Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Nuclear Power Corporation Of India Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Ce & St (Ltu), Mumbai .

CESTAT
Feb 15, 2017

M.V Ravindran, Member (Judicial):— This appeal is directed against order-in-original No. 20.Commr (KAP)/LTU-M ST/2011 dated 10.02.2012

2. Heard both sides and perused the records.

3. The issue that falls for consideration in this case is whether the appellant herein is required to discharge the service tax on the amount received by them under the category of ‘Management, Maintenance or Repair Services’ or otherwise.

4. The relevant facts that arise for consideration, after filtering out unnecessary details are the appellant entered into an agreement with M/s Rajasthan Atomic Power Station (RAPS) for management and operation of the said Unit on behalf of Department of Atomic Energy (DAE). The agreement entered indicated that appellant has to manage and operate the plant, machinery and other assets, to manage all contracts, transactions and capital works, to provide material accounting reports to DAE in regard to fuel & heavy water at periodic intervals and to manage stores inventory identified for RAPS. The adjudicating authority after following due process of law has come to a conclusion that the appellant had rendered the services of management, maintenance or repair services as they had maintained the plant, machinery and other assets despite the fact that these assets are the property of DAE.

5. On careful consideration of submissions made and perusal of records, we find that the demands confirmed by the adjudicating authority are not correct and against the law settled by various decisions of the Tribunal. On perusal of the definition of ‘Management, Maintenance or Repair Services’ for the period involved, we find that the said definition will not cover the activity undertaken by appellant as the said activities were in the nature of managing the power plant and not providing services under the category of ‘Management, Maintenance or Repair Services’. We find that the adjudicating authority has considered the agreement entered by appellant with RAPS on behalf of DAE, but has misdirected the findings based only on the clause of the agreement which entitled to the appellant to claim reimbursement from DAE regarding the expenditure attributable to RAPS and also other common expenditures. We find that an identical issue came up before this very same Bench in the case of CST v. Polydrill Engineers Pvt. Ltd. - 2016-TIOL-927-CESTAT-MUM, the respondent therein were given a contract for operation for the bulk handling plant of ONGC on a consideration and this activity of bulk handling plant was sought to be taxed under ‘Management, Maintenance or Repair Services’. The period involved in Polydrill Engineers Pvt. Ltd. case was also pre and post 01.05.2006 This Bench after reproducing the definition of ‘Management, Maintenance or Repair Services’, following the judgement of the Tribunal in the case of CMS (I) Operations & Maintenance Co. P. Ltd. - 2007 (7) STR 369 (Tri. Chennai), held that maintenance and operations of bulk handling plant will not be covered under the category of Management, Maintenance or Repair Services'. In our considered view the issue is no more res integra. Accordingly, following the ratio of the judgement of the Tribunal in the case of Polydrill Engineers P. Ltd. (supra) and Evonik Energy Services - 2016-TIOL-1073 (CESTAT-Mum) we hold that impugned order is unsustainable.

6. The impugned order is set aside and appeal is allowed.