Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ram Bahal v. Mst. Chhohari Devi Opp. Party.

Board of Revenue
Feb 22, 1993

A.U Khan, M.:— The facts as set forth are: On 20.7.1979 Ram Bahal and Ram Achal institute a declaratory lawsuit in the Court of Sub-Divisional Officer, Basti. The pleading has set forth that Sheo Harak had three sons and two daughters. The sons expired issueless; the last of the sons to die was Kalpnath on his death in the year 1965 the interest in holding devolved on his two sisters; Smt. Kalp Devi and Smt. Pran Devi. The names of two sisters, each entitled to equal share, are recorded in. Then Smt. Kalp Devi expired in the year 1972 and plaintiffs, her two, sons, are successors-in-interest. The last sister Smt. Pran Devi also expired in the year 1974 without a male lineal descendant. She has only a daughter Smt. Chowara Devi, defendant here, who is a widow. On such a denonuement plaintiffs became successors-in-interest of tenure of Smt. Pran Devi. Also they came to possession. It is given out that Ram Bahal was far away in service; so taking advantage of his absence from village Ram Lochan, husband of Smt. Pran Devi, had his name, by skilful manoeurve, recorded in. Ram Lochan, then, executes a sale-deed on 10.10.1974 favouring his daughter Smt. Chowara Devi. Her application for mutation of name is going apace. It is claimed that sale-deed is void as vendor Ram Lochan has no transferable interest. Ram Lochan is dead. Nevertheless his action casts a cloud of suspicion on their title to land. The relief to declare them bhumidhar tenant in possession is prayed for.

2. On 4.10.1979 Smt. Chowara Devi D/1 files her written statement. The case put forth is that on death of Smt. Kalpa Devi her interest in holding has devolved on her mother Smt. Pran Devi. Plaintiffs came to her mother beseeching that share of their mother be restored. On their submissions an oral family settlment was reached in 1972. The terms agreed upon are: Plaintiffs shall have ½ share of their, mother. However, if Smt. Pran Devi were to die first, her husband Ram Lochan shall inherit her interest in the tenure. In the event Ram Lochan were to die first, she shall be successor of her mother's tenure. Also Sec. 174 Z.A Act will govern succession in future. Such are the conditions of agreement. In due time Smt. Pran Devi dies first, and name of Ram Lochan is recorded in. In turn he executes a sale-deed on 10.10.1974 to her. Now she is bhumidhar tenant in possession. The relief to dismiss the suit is prayed for. On pleadings of the parties issues were formulated on 20.3.1980 Parties are given chance to lead their evidence; documental and oral. They have made their representation. On 31.12.1981 Sri S.N Prasad, Asstt. Collector First Class, enters an order dismissing the suit. Plaintiff Ram Bahal's appeal. On 16.5.1983 Sri Bhuinya Din, learned Addl. Commissioner (Executive) enters an order dismissing the appeal. The second appeal is carried by plaintiffs.

3. Heard the counsel for the parties and perused the record.

4. To make intelligible the relationship between the contestants the following pedigree is given:

5. The pedigree is not in controversy.

6. It admits of no dispute that among the brothers Kalpnath was the last to die. On his death the interest in holding devolved, in equal measure, on his two sisters: on death of Smt. Kalp Devi in the year 1972, her interest is inherited by sons: plaintiffs: Ram Banal and Ram Achal: the two brothers. Subsequently Smt. Pran Devi also dies in the year 1974. Who will inherit her individed co-tenureship? The case of plaintiff Ram Bahal's is that they are lawful successors: Smt. Chowara Devi D/1 asserts she is legal heir by reason of a family settlement reached in 1972. The rival claims need a neat and fuller exposition.

7. Let us imagine how the family settlement was arrived at Smt. Pran Devi's sketched so graphically by her daughter Smt. Chowara Devi in paragraph 3 of her pleading:

Ram Bahal. P/1: Auntie dear, we are your sister's sons — say your own, favour us with our mother's share of Inheritance, gone to you in devolution.

Smt. Pran Devi: My sons you come so soon after your mother's death — my sister too, I grant what you ask for; nevertheless I am to set, a few conditions you have to earneratly live by.

Ram Achal P/2: Anutie mine, spell out the terms for what they are; We hope to honour our commitments.

Smt. Pran Devi: Right. It is apt to make clear. Suppose, I were to die earlier then, my interest in holding shall go to my husband Ram Lochan. In case he dies first - God forbid — it shall be inherited by dear daughter Smt. Chowara Devi: widow's lot has befallen her. Mind you I am absolute owner and Sec. 174 Z.A and L.R Act shall determine future succession.

Ram Bahal P/1: We cannot but deeply thank for restoration of our mother's interest inhering in you; also for the line future devolution of interest shall take. We assure of our loyalty and beg you to let us go.

8. Ram Bahal's is emphatic denial. The contention is: no family settlement; all this is impulse of sheer subjective fantasy. Shall we go to beg for our mother's interest came to us as of legal right? Shall be bargain out our patrimony for nothing in return? Shall we go to Smt. Pran Devi, the craftiest or to her husband Ram Lochan, wickedest of man — paragraph 8 uses a word “Mutfanni” to describe him. We had no reason to hammer out a settlement. On the contrary, on Smt. Pran Devi's death, her interest has devolved on us. That is that.

9. Having heard their pleas and advocacy, I am to go by my faith in my refrain from the Biblical Prophet Isaiah: “Come now and let us reason together”. On death of Smt. Kalp Devi in 1972, her sons: Plaintiff's had become co-tenant's with aunt Smt. Pran Devi. She, in her life time, could have transferred her undivided interest in holding to her husband or to her daughter. When she did not what she could easily have, I see she had no overriding concern for settling a future course of devolution? When I have a power to do a thing here and now but shall not have there and then (or when I shall be no more) I will surely do that presently. By happenstance, Smt. Pran Devi did not effect a disposal of her interest in her life time. And did not because she was quite unaware that succession shall devolve to the nearest heir of brother Kalpnath. This is the crux. And also the tormentina dilemma upon which Smt. Chowara Devi is impaled. She invents. But a few savoury red herrings have been drawn across her path. Ram Lochan is not in the table of succession: here, there or anywhere. A rank outsider: A stranger. So transfer of title to land can only be by a registered instrument. She invents an oral compromise — not reuqiring registration - and projects it in the past; 1972, when Smt. Pran Devi had, as demonstrated to prove, an absolute power of disposition with the scorn of a support in a compromise.

10. Smt. Pran Devi cannot orally bequeath or convey or in any manner whatsoever relinquish or release her interest in the holding to her husband Ram Lochan. At that crucial moment Ram Bahal's had no stakes in her tenure. What the settlement was all about? As noticed, Ram Lochan is not a descendant from a common ancestor or had no antecedent claim to land. So not in a position to proffer an adjustment in a compromise, a subject without a theme. To be sure, the facts set forth do create a permanent tenurial interest in Ram Lochan. It is creation of a title and is compulsorily registerable. A sale of land orally conceived and executed is beside the point: is inadmissible. A transfer of an interest cannot be a settlement. A compromise is not valid unless the same is bona fide; in the same way as no human conception is divine unless it is sublime. Is the family compromie lawful? No — Certainly no. Is this beguilement — Yes, truly and deeply so. Such a method is ‘finding’ and its practitioner Smt. Chowarwa Devi is a ‘courthouse Mrs. Machiavelli’.

11. On death of their mother Smt. Kalp Devi, Ram Bahal and Ram Achal had become co-tenants with Smt. Pran Devi. When she also died in the year 1974 the co-tenurial relationship of two years ended. On death of Smt. Pran Devi succession to her interest is thrown open. Who will? The answer is straight-forward. On death of last brother Kalpnath two sisters have succeeded in equal measure. The interest was inherited in the tenure as sisters under Sec. 172 Z.A and L.R Act. On sister's death, the interest shall devolve upon the nearest surviving heir (such heir being ascertained in accordance with the provisions of Sec. 171) of the last male bhumidhar. And Kalonath was the last male bhumidhar. His nearest heirs are sister's sons: plaintiff's Ram Bahal and Ram Achal: two brothers: On death of Smt. Pran Devi the interest in holding devloves on Ram Bahal's. The entry of Ram Lochan's name was erroneous; no saleable interest he had. Manifestly the sale-deed dated 10.10.74 transfers no title to Smt. Chowara Devi as no one can transfer an interest one does not have. Sale is void. The two courts below have not set a proper perspective; have not brought sense, wit and imagination to bear in description, analysis and conclusion. The second appeal is allowed. The orders of courts below are set aside. The suit of plaintiff Ram Bahal's is decreed with costs throughout. Their names be mutated in records as bhumidhars. Order accordingly.

12. Appeal Allowed.