Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Naveen Bhatnagar v. Sudarshan Consolidated Limited

Company Law Board
Aug 6, 2013
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Petitioner, Mr. Naveen Bhatnagar, initially an employee and later a Director of the Respondent Company incorporated on 16 September 2008, resigned from the Company through a resignation letter dated 17 September 2010. The resignation was acknowledged and accepted by the Company via a letter dated 21 September 2010. Despite this, the Company failed to file Form 32 with the Registrar of Companies (ROC), Jammu, reflecting the cessation of the Petitioner’s directorship, thereby continuing to show him as a Director on the MCA portal. The Petitioner made several requests and reminders to the Company for filing the requisite Form 32, but to no avail.

The ROC issued multiple communications directing the Company to comply with statutory requirements under Sections 303(2) and 234(1) of the Companies Act, 1956, but the Company did not respond. The Petitioner further alleged that the Respondent Company and its Directors fabricated a forged resignation letter dated 28 November 2012, with a scanned signature of the Petitioner, and filed Form 32 in ‘STP mode’ reflecting cessation of directorship from that date. The Petitioner lodged a criminal complaint regarding forgery and sought intervention from the Ministry of Corporate Affairs and the Regional Director for statutory action.

The Respondent contended that resignation of a Director must be accepted by the Board as per the Articles of Association, and no Board meeting was held on 21 September 2010 to accept the Petitioner’s resignation. They asserted that the Petitioner continued as a Director until 28 November 2012 when his resignation was accepted. The Petitioner’s absence from Board meetings after 17 September 2010 was also noted.

After considering pleadings, replies, rejoinders, and arguments, the Court found that although the resignation letter dated 17 September 2010 was acknowledged, it was not accepted in a Board meeting as required by Article 95 of the Articles of Association. However, under Section 283(1)(g) of the Companies Act, 1956, the Petitioner’s office as Director automatically vacated due to non-attendance at Board meetings for three consecutive quarters after 17 September 2010.

The Court directed the Respondent Company to file Form 32 reflecting the cessation of the Petitioner’s directorship effective from 1 July 2011, within 30 days, and to correct statutory records accordingly. The Company Petition and Company Application were disposed of, with no order as to costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the resignation of the Petitioner as Director was valid and effective given the Articles of Association requirement of Board acceptance?
  2. Whether the Respondent Company’s failure to file Form 32 for cessation of directorship violated statutory provisions under the Companies Act, 1956?
  3. Whether the Petitioner’s directorship automatically vacated under Section 283(1)(g) of the Companies Act, 1956 due to non-attendance at Board meetings?
  4. Whether the Respondent Company’s filing of a purported resignation dated 28 November 2012 with a forged signature was lawful or constituted misconduct?
  5. What is the appropriate date for cessation of the Petitioner’s directorship for filing Form 32?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The Petitioner resigned on 17 September 2010, and the resignation was accepted by the Company on 21 September 2010.
  • The Company failed to file Form 32 with the ROC despite repeated requests, causing the Petitioner to be shown as a Director unlawfully.
  • The Respondent Company and its Directors fabricated a forged resignation letter dated 28 November 2012 with the Petitioner’s scanned signature to shift liabilities onto the Petitioner.
  • The Petitioner lodged a criminal complaint for forgery and sought statutory action against the Company and delinquent officers.
  • Reliance on the Doctrine of Indoor Management, asserting that outsiders can presume compliance with the Company’s Articles and procedures.
  • Under Section 283(1)(g) of the Companies Act, 1956, the Petitioner’s directorship automatically vacated due to non-attendance at Board meetings after 17 September 2010.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • There is no provision in the Companies Act regarding resignation of a Director; resignation must be governed by the Articles of Association.
  • The Articles require Board acceptance of resignation; no Board meeting was held on 21 September 2010 to accept the Petitioner’s resignation.
  • The Petitioner continued as Director until 28 November 2012 when his resignation was accepted.
  • The letter dated 21 September 2010 acknowledging resignation is an interpolation and invalid as no Board meeting occurred that day.
  • The Petitioner was initially an Executive employee, then elevated to Whole Time Director without his consent but resigned after seven months due to dissatisfaction.
  • Filing of Form 32 based on the ‘alleged’ resignation letter of 17 September 2010 was not mandatory within 30 days as per Articles and law.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the facts and submissions and found that the Petitioner’s resignation letter dated 17 September 2010 was acknowledged but not accepted in a Board meeting as required by Article 95 of the Articles of Association. The Respondent Company’s failure to produce the original resignation letter dated 28 November 2012, which was accepted on the same day it was submitted, raised suspicion about the genuineness of the resignation and conduct of the Company.

Despite the procedural non-compliance, the Petitioner had not attended any Board meetings for three consecutive quarters following 17 September 2010, which under Section 283(1)(g) of the Companies Act, 1956, results in automatic vacation of the office of Director. The Court noted that the Company is required to hold at least one Board meeting every three calendar months under Section 285 of the Companies Act, 1956, and the Petitioner’s absence without leave supported the automatic vacation.

Balancing the equities and in view of the Petitioner’s repeated requests to file Form 32, the Court held that the Petitioner ceased to be a Director effectively from 1 July 2011, the date marking three consecutive quarters of non-attendance. The Court directed the Respondent Company to file Form 32 accordingly and update statutory records.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF

The Court directed the Respondent Company to file Form 32 for cessation of the Petitioner’s directorship with effect from 1 July 2011 within 30 days and to make necessary corrections in statutory records. The decision effectively recognizes the automatic vacation of the Petitioner’s directorship under Section 283(1)(g) of the Companies Act, 1956 due to non-attendance at Board meetings, despite procedural irregularities in acceptance of resignation. No broader precedent was established beyond the direct effect on the parties.

Show all summary ...

1. In this case, the Petition has been filed under Section 614 of the Companies Act, 1956 by the Petitioner with the prayer to direct the Company to file Form 32 of the Petitioner w.e.f 17 September, 2010. Precisely speaking, the Respondent Company was incorporated on 16.09.2008 and is maintaining its Registered Office at Industrial Growth Centre (ISG), Phase Samba J&K-184121. Against the authorised share capital of Rs. 5 crores, the paid up capital the Company amounted to Rs. 4.62 crores. Initially, the Company was incorporated by the Subscribers to the Memorandum viz. Mr. Joy Prokash Banerjee, Mr. Neeraj Kumar Mehta, Ms. Bhumika Wadhwa, Mr. Lokesh Chandra Rohela, Mr. P. Vishnu, Mr. Naveen Bhatanagar and Mr. M.V Sadanandan with an initial paid up capital of Rs. 5 lakhs. In fact, the Petitioner was working as an employee of the Respondent Company and getting monthly salary for his employment & he was elevated to the position of Director. However, as stated in the Petition, without the permission, consent and knowledge of the Petitioner, the Respondent Company filed Form 32 with the ROC for change in designation of the Petitioner from merely a ‘Director’ to ‘Whole Time Director’ of the Respondent Company w.e.f 16.02.2010 At this stage, the Petitioner, i.e Mr. Naveen Bhatnagar, resigned from he Company vide his resignation letter dated 17 September, 2010 duly received and acknowledged by Shri S.M.Z Naqvi, Director of the Company. Further, the Company duly accepted the resignation letter of the Petitioner vide its acceptance letter dated 21 September, 2010. However, as alleged in the Petition, till date the Company has not filed the requisite Form 32 with Registrar of Companies, Jammu, as required under the provisions of Companies Act, 1956, in spite of several requests and reminders of the Petitioner through letters dated 8 December, 2010, 20 December, 2010, 19 January, 2011 and 19 November, 2011 and thereby, the Petitioner is still shown as a Director on the MCA portal.

2. It has also been mentioned in the Petition that ROC (J&K) vide letter dated 31 March, 2011, directed the Company to comply with Section 303(2) of the Companies Act, 1956. As the Company failed to do so, vide letter dated 3 June, 2011, ROC (J&K) served a notice under Section 303(2) of the Companies Act, 1956 to the Respondent Company. Further, ROC (J&K) vide letter dated 25 October 2011, directed the Respondent Company under Section 234(1) of the Companies Act, 1956, to furnish certified true copy of Register of Directors under Section 303 of the Companies Act, 1956, Board Meetings and Minutes and attendance register. As the Respondent Company was not replying to any of the letters sent by ROC (J&K), ROC (J&K) vide Setter dated 1 November, 2011 requested the Regional Director to take prompt action against the Respondent Company and its officers. The Petitioner also served tetter dated 25 April, 2012 and requested the Regional Director (NR) to take prompt action and to initiate stringent action against the Company. Lastly, the Petitioner sent notice dated 12 June, 2010, through his Counsel to the Regional Director (NR), requesting him to take prompt action and to initiate stringent action against the Company or direct the ROC (J&K) to take statutory action against the Company and its delinquent directors and officers for non compliance in filing of Form 32 and intentionally violating the various provisions of the Companies act, 1956.

3. The Petitioner has also filed Company Application No. 84/2013 in Company Petition No. 1/614/12 stating therein that the Respondent Company and its Directors/Officers drafted a fake resignation letter dated 28 November, 2012 of the Petitioner and affixed scanned image of the Petitioner's signature in conspiracy with a practicing Company secretary and illegally filed Form 32 in ‘STP mode’ for cessation of the directorship of the Petitioner. However, the Petitioner resigned from the Company w.e.f 17 September, 2010, which was duly acknowledged and accepted by the Respondent Company, but to shift the unseen liabilities of the Respondent Company on the Petitioner, the Respondent created the foul play and frivolously filed fake and forged resignation of the Petitioner and filed Form 32 from current date i.e 28 November, 2012. Further, it has been stated that the Petitioner lodged a criminal complaint dated 26 December, 2012 against the present directors and others for the forgery of documents and signature etc. before the concerned police station and also, sent a letter dated 31 December, 2012 to Joint Secretary, Ministry of Corporate Affairs, and concerned Registrar of Companies and requested them to direct the Respondent Company to file correct Form 32 of the Petitioner for cessation of his directorship w.e.f 17.09.2010

4. In the reply, the Respondent Advocate has stated that there is no provision in the Companies Act about the resignation of a director and, therefore this aspect has to be considered with reference to the Articles of Assocation of the company. Since the Articles of Assocation of the Company provided for tendering resignation, but the person ceasing to be a director only on acceptance by the Board of Directors of such resignations. The Petitioner cannot be said to have ceased to have any concern in the Company immediately on tendering his alleged resignation. The Respondent Advocate has pointed out that it is wrong to state that the Petitioner had resigned from the Company on 17 September, 2010. In fact, there does not seem to be a due acceptance of the said letter of 17 September, 2010 on 21 September, 2010 as alleged. The Articlesx of Association of the Company clearly mentions that the resignation of the Director (s) have to be approved by the Board, and on 21 September, 2010, no Board meeting took place. Hence, the Petitioner continued to be a Director on the date of filing this present petition. However, on 28 November, 2012, when it became known that Shri S.M.Z Naqvi was resigning from the Directorship of the Company, the Petitioner expressed his desire to resign and thus, on 28 November, 2012, the Petitioner was allowed to resign and the resignation of Shri S.M.Z Naqvi was deferred to 29 November, 2012. The Respondent Advocate has mentioned that the Petitioner was initially an Executive employee and then a Director with the Company by law. His competence results in his elevation to Whole Time Director w.e.f 16 February, 2010. However, after a gap of seven months of such appointment, he chose to resign from the Directorship on the ground that he was unhappy to have been appointed as an Executive Director without his permission/consent.

5. In the Rejoinder, the Petitioner advocate has submitted that the Petitioner, i.e Mr. Naveen Bhatnagar, Ex-Director of the Respondent Company, resigned from the Company vide his resignation letter dated 17 September, 2010 and the Company duly accepted the resignation of the Petitioner vide its acceptance letter dated 21 Septmber 2010, duly signed by Mr. S.M.Z Naqvi, Director a, that time. After his resignation, the Petitioner was neither a Director of the Company nor associated with the Company directly or indirectly and hence, the burden to follow the provisions contained in the Articles of Association of the Company is with the Company and its Directors/Officers. The Petitioner Advocate has also cited the settled principle of ‘Doctrine of Indoor Management’ that an outsider cannot be considered to of the fact that the Company has duly complied with all the necessary procedures/provisions as contained in its Articles of Association. The Petitioner Advocate has also pointed out the Petitioner after receipt of the acceptance of his resignation from the Company has served several letters dated 8 December, 2010, 20 December, 2010, 19 January, 2011 and 19 November, 2011, to the Company for filing Form 32 with the ROC but has not received any replies thereto. The Petitioner Advocate has highlighted that after service of present Petition the Respondent Company and its Directors/Officers drafted a fake resignation letter dated 28 November, 2012 of the Petitioner and affixed scanned image of the Petitioner's signature and filed Form 32 for cessation of the Directorship of the Petitioner.

6. The Petitioner Advocate argued that the Respondent Company was incorporated on 16 September, 2008, and since the very inception of the Company, it was remotely controlled and run by Mr. Sanjeev Malhotra, who owned 99.91% shares of the Company. The Petitioner, i.e Mr. Naveen Bhatnagar, belongs to a middle class family and was working as an employee in the Company on monthly salary. The Petitioner was appointed as Director of the Company and without realizing the legal jugglery and in sheer innocence, the petitioner accepted this fancy tag. However, on 17 September, 2010, the Petitioner gave his resignation from the Company and the Company duly accepted the resignation of the Petitioner vide its acceptance letter dated 21 September, 2010. However, the Company did not file Form 32 in spite of several written requests and reminders vide letters dated 8 December, 2010, 20 December, 2010, 19 January, 2011 and 19 November, 2011. The Petitioner also complained to the Registrar of Companies, J&K to take appropriate actions against the Respondent Company in order to place his resignation on record for proper compliance of law. However, the Respondent Company drafted a fake resignation letter dated 28 November, 2012 of the Petitioner and affixed scanned image of the Petitioner's signature and illegally filed Form 32 in ‘STP mode’ for cessation of the Directorship of the Petitioner w.e.f 28 November, 2012. In support of this, the Respondent Company failed to produce the original letter/document for such resignation. Lastly, it has been contended that as per Section 283(1)(g) of the Companies Act, 1956, the directorship of Petitioner automatically vacated as he has not attended any Board meeting after 17 September, 2010.

7. The Respondent Advocate has extended the arguments that the Petitioner was initially an Executive employee and then, a Director with the Company for long. His Thereafter, his salary, perks and privileges all increased as per the Company policy. However, after a gap of over seven months of such appointment, he chose to resign from the Directorship on the ground that he was unhappy to have been appointed as an Executive Director without his permission/consent. It is thus wrong to state that the Petitioner can be said to have resigned immediately on 17 September, 2010. On the other hand, he very well knew the status he enjoyed, and continued to do so for the over next seven months or so. It is only thereafter he started losing interest in the affairs of the Company, but at no point of time did he propose to resign from the Board. The Respondent Advocate stated that there is no provision in the Companies Act about the resignation of a Director and therefore, as per the well settled law, this aspect has to be considered with reference to the Articles of Association of the Company. Since the Articles of Association of the Company provided for tendering resignation, but the person ceasing to be a Director only on acceptance by the Board of Directors of such resignations. Thus, the Petitioner cannot be said to have ceased to have any concern in the Company immediately on tendering his alleged resignation. The Respondent Advocate further stated that the Articles of Association specifically dealt and prescribed the manner in which the Director's resignation could be accepted and in the absence of specific provision to that effect in the Companies Act, 1956, it is the Articles of Association which prevails as per the extant laws of the land. Thus, filing of the ‘alleged’ resignation cannot be said to be mandatory within 30 days of the ‘alleged’ tendering of the said letter. It is wrong to state that the Petitioner had resigned from the Company on 17 September, 2010. There does not seem to be a due acceptance of the said letter of 17 September, 2010 on 21 September, 2010 as alleged. However, there are numerous anomalies viz:—

(a) That the letter is also dated 21 September, 2010 i.e the same day on which the said Director, Shri S.M.Z Naqvi is said to have received the resignation letter.

(b) In the said alleged letter, the said Director, Shri S.M.Z Naqvi, informs that the resignation has been noted in the records of the Company and you are relieved w.e.f from 21 September, 2010. Your Form 32 will be filed with ROC accordingly.’

(c) That, from the above, it becomes amply clear that the said letter is nothing but an interpolation as-the Articles of Association of the Company clearly mentions that the resignation of the Director (s) have to be approved by the Board, and on 21 September, 2010 there took place no such Board Meeting.

In light of same, there cannot be a ROC notification vide Form 32 for non existent resignations. The Respondent Advocate argued that the Petitioner continued to be a Director on the date of filing this present Petition and only on 28 November, 2012, did he approach the Company and his resignation accepted.

8. Having gone through the averments made in the Company Petition and Company Application, replies, rejoinder and arguments (oral and written), it is quite clear that the Petitioner, i.e Naveen Bhatnagar, was the subscriber of the Memorandum of Association of the Company. Initially, the Petitioner was working as an employee of the Respondent Company and getting monthly salary for his employment & he was elevated to the position of Director. However, as stated in the Petition, without the permission, consent and knowledge of the Petitioner, the Respondent Company filed Form 32 with the ROC for change in designation of the Petitioner from merely a ‘Director’ to ‘Whole Time Director’ of the Respondent Company w.e.f 16.02.2010 Therefore, Mr. Naveen Bhatnagar resigned from the Company vide his resignation letter dated 17 September, 2010, duly received and acknowledged by Shri S.M.Z Naqvi on 21 September, 2010. Further, the Company duly accepted the resignation letter of the Petitioner vide its acceptance letter dated 21 September, 2010 also. However, The Respondent Company did not file the requisite Form 32 with the Registrar of Companies (J&K), as required under the provisions of Section 303(2) of Companies Act, 1956, despite several requests and reminders of the Petitioner through letters dated 8 December, 2010, 20 December, 2010, 19 January, 2011 and 10 November 2011. The Respondent Company failed to do so in spite of the letters dated 31 March, 2011 and 3 June, 2011, sent by ROC, J&K also. On the other side, through Company Application No. 84/2013, it has been submitted that the Respondent Company and its Directors/Officers drafted a fake resignation letter dated 28 November, 2012 of the Petitioner and affixed scanned image of the Petitioner's signature in conspiracy with a practicing Company secretary and illegally filed Form 32 in ‘STP mode’ for cessation of the directorship of the Petitioner. The Petitioner has alleged that the Respondent created the foul play and frivolously filed fake and forged resignation of the Petitioner and filed Form 32 from current date i.e 28 November, 2012, for which the Petitioner lodged a criminal complaint dated 26 December, 2012 against the present directors and others for the forgery of documents and signature etc. before the concerned police station. The allegation levelled by the Petitioner has reasonable force, in view of the submissions made by the Petitioner that the Respondent Company failed to produce the original letter/document for such resignation. Further to this, it has been stated that as per Section 283(1)(g) of the Companies Act, 1956, the office of Petitioner automatically vacated as he has not attended any Board meeting after 17 September, 2010. This implies that the Petitioner has also not sought ‘leave of absence’ for attending the Board meetings held subsequent to 17 September, 2010, in the Company.

It is also correct that the Article 95 of Articles of Association of the Company provides that the office of a Director shall become vacant on resignation of his office by notice in writing and its acceptance by the Board. Therefore, there are two requirements for the vacation of the office of a Director and this includes letter of resignation and acceptance of the said resignation by the Board of Directors. In the instant case, the Respondent Advocate has pointed out that it is wrong to state that the Petitioner has resigned from the Company on 17 September, 2010. In fact, as stated in the reply, there does not seem to be a due acceptance of the said letter of 17 September, 2010 on 21 September, 2010, as no Board Meeting took place on 21 September, 2010. However, despite the submission of the/petitioner that the Respondent Company failed to produce the original letter dated 28 November, 2012 for such resignation, the Respondent Company has filed Form 32 in ‘STP mode’ for cessation of the Directorship of the Petitioner w.e.f 28 November, 2012, itself. This shows suspicion to the conduct of the Respondent Company as to why the resignation letter dated 17 September, 2010, was not accepted and resignation letter dated 28 November 2012, the genuineness of which is doubted by the Petitioner himself, has been accepted on the same day of submission of the said letter dated 28 November, 2012. Therefore, the technical compliance of Article 95 of the Articles of Association was not done by the Respondent Company by accepting the resignation letter dated 17 September, 2010 in the Board Meeting. Yet, it is also correct that the Petitioner has not attended the Board Meetings subsequent to 17 September, 2010 and thus, he remained absent without asking ‘leave of absence’ from the Board of Directors during the Board meetings held for the quarters ending December 2010, March 2011 and June 2011. Thus, the argument of the Petitioner Advocate that as per Section 283(1)(g) of the Companies Act, 1956, the office of Petitioner automatically vacated as he has not attended any Board meeting after 17 September 2010, holds good. In terms of the requirement of 614 of the Companies Act, 1956, the Petitioner has made several requests through letters dated 801 December 2010, 20 December, 2010, 19 January, 2011 and 19 November, 2011, to file necessary Form 32 for the cessation of the Directorship of the Board as Director. In view of this, the balance of justice goes in favour of the Petitioner and hence, he ceases to be Director in terms of Section 283(1)(g) of the Companies Act, 1956, as he has not attended Board Meetings subsequent to 17 September, 2010. In the absence of the specific dates of Board Meetings held subsequent to 17 September, 2010, the next three quarters are taken as the base for calculating three Board Meetings as the Company is required to hold at least one Board Meeting in every three calendar months in compliance of the requirements of section 285 of the Companies Act, 1956. Consequently, the Petitioner automatically ceases to be Director in terms of Section 283(1)(g) on and from 1 July, 2011.

9. Under the aforesaid facts and circumstances, I am of the considered view that the Company should file Form 32 in respect of cessation of Petitioner w.e.f 1 July, 2011 and hence the Company is directed to file Form 32 for the cessation of Directorship of Shri Naveen Bhatnagar, the Petitioner, w.e.f 1 July, 2011, within 30 days and make necessary corrections in the statutory records.

10. The CP No. 1/614/2012 & CA No. 84/2013 are disposed of accordingly.

11. No Order as to cost.