- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M/S. Diamond Overseas Complainant v. M/S. All Cargo Movers (India) Pvt. Ltd. Opposite Party.
Factual and Procedural Background
The complainant, an export-oriented company, engaged the services of the opposite party, a carrier, to send a consignment to the Republic of Armenia. The invoice value of the goods was US $36,029.40, dated 7.3.2001. The complaint arose from an alleged deficiency in service by the carrier, specifically that although the carrier stated the goods were delivered on 28.5.2001, it failed to satisfy to whom the goods were delivered, and there was no endorsement on the original multimodal transport documents. The documents were issued in New Delhi on 23.3.2001 and contained certain conditions under the Multimodal Transportation of Goods Act, 1993 (MTOG Act). The complainant sought relief including compensation of Rs. 39,14,600.10 for losses suffered and costs of the petition.
A preliminary objection was raised challenging the maintainability of the complaint on the ground that the MTOG Act bars the jurisdiction of the Consumer Protection Forum under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 (CP Act), as the MTOG Act overrides the CP Act.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Multimodal Transportation of Goods Act, 1993 bars the jurisdiction of the Consumer Protection Forum under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 in respect of complaints against multimodal transport operators.
- Whether the arbitration clause contained in the multimodal transport documents constitutes a valid arbitration agreement barring the complaint before the Consumer Protection Forum.
- The applicability of limitation and jurisdiction provisions under the MTOG Act vis-à-vis the Consumer Protection Act.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the provisions of the MTOG Act, particularly Sections 24, 25, 26, and 29, and compared them with the Consumer Protection Act. Section 29 of the MTOG Act states that its provisions prevail over any inconsistent law. Section 24 prescribes a nine-month limitation period for actions against multimodal transport operators, differing from that under the CP Act. Section 25 provides jurisdictional venues for filing suits, and Section 26 allows for arbitration if provided in the contract.
The court analyzed the arbitration clause (Clause 25) in the multimodal transport documents, which stated that disputes could be settled by arbitration in India or any mutually agreed place with each party appointing an arbitrator. The court held that this clause does not amount to a binding arbitration agreement.
Given these findings, the court concluded that the MTOG Act does not bar the jurisdiction of the Consumer Protection Forum. The complaint is maintainable under the CP Act, and the provisions of the MTOG Act do not override the consumer forum's jurisdiction in this matter.
Holding and Implications
The complaint filed under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 is maintainable, and the Multimodal Transportation of Goods Act, 1993 does not bar the jurisdiction of the Consumer Protection Forum.
The direct effect of this decision is that the complainant may proceed with the complaint before the Consumer Protection Forum. The court did not set any new precedent beyond affirming the forum's jurisdiction in such cases involving multimodal transport operators. The matter was directed to be listed for further proceedings.
D.P Wadhwa, J. (President):— Alleging deficiency in service on the part of the opposite party-a carrier, complainant has sought the following reliefs;
“It is, therefore, MOST RESPECTFULLY prayed that your lordship may graciously be pleased”—
1. To direct the respondent/opposite party to pay a sum of Rs. 39,14,600.10 (Rs. Thirty Nine Lacs Fourteen Thousand Six Hundred Ten Paise only) to the petitioner/complainant on account of losses suffered by them as on 24.9.2001
2. Entire cost of the petition may also be awarded in favour of petitioner/complainant and against the respondent/opposite party.
3. Any other relief which the Hon'ble Commission thinks fit in the facts and circumstances of the case in favour of the petitioner/complainant.
When we issued notice in the complaint a preliminary objection which went to the root of the very maintainability of the complaint was raised and that was to the effect that the Multimodal Transportation of Goods Act, 1993 (‘MTOG Act’ for short) bar the jurisdiction of a Forum under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 (‘CP Act’ for short) as the former Act overrides the later Act.
We have examined the matter. Complainant an export oriented company sent a consignment to the Republic of Armenia and for that it engaged services of the opposite party. The invoice value of the goods was US $ 36029.40 and the invoice is dated 7.3.2001 Complaint, in fact, is that though the opposite party said that the goods had been delivered on 28.5.2001 yet it had not satisfied whom these were delivered and there was no endorsement in all the three original multimodal transport documents. In these documents place of issue is mentioned at New Delhi, and date is 23.3.2001 With these documents there are certain conditions stated to have been issued in accordance with the MTOG Act. Clause 25 under the heading ‘Arbitration’ reads as under:
“25. Arbitration:
The contract evidenced hereby or contained herein shall be governed by and construed according to Indian laws. Any difference of opinion or dispute thereunder can be settled by arbitration in India or a place mutually agreed with each party appointing an arbitrator.”
MTOG Act, is later Act than the Consumer Protection Act, 1986. Section 29 of MTOG Act provides that “The provisions of this Act shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent herewith contained in any other law for the time being in force or in any instrument having effect by virtue of any law other than this Act.” Sections 24, 26 and 26 of MTOG Act would also be relevant and we quote:
“24. Limitation on action.— The multimodal transport operator shall not be liable under any of the provisions of this Act unless action against him is brought within nine months of —
(a) the date of delivery of the goods, or
(b) the date when the goods should have been delivered, or
(c) the date on and from which the party entitled to receive delivery of the goods has the right to treat the goods as lost under sub-section (2) of section 13.
25. Jurisdiction for instituting action.— Any party to the multimodal transport contract may institute an action in a court which is competent and within the jurisdiction of which is situated one of the following places, namely —
(a) the principal place of business, or in the absence thereof, the habitual residence, of the defendant; or
(b) the place where the multimodal transport contract was made, provided that the defendant has a place of business branch or agency at such place; or
(c) the place of taking charge of the goods for multimodal transportation or the place of delivery thereof; or
(d) any other place specified in the multimodal transport contract and evidenced in the multimodal transport document.
26. Arbitration.- (1) The parties to a multimodal transport contract may provide therein that any dispute which may arise in relation to multimodal transportation under the provisions of this Act shall be referred to arbitration.
(2) The arbitration proceeding may be instituted at such place or in accordance with such procedure as may be specified in the multimodal transport document.
MTOG Act will nullify those provisions of CP Act which are inconsistent with the provisions of MTOG Act. That would be the effect of Section 29 of MTOG Act. Section 24 of MTOG Act provides different period of limitation than that under the CP Act. If complaint is filed under CP Act which is in contravention of Section 24 of MTOG Act then a Forum under CPA will have no jurisdiction to try the complaint. Section 25 entitles a party to file a civil suit. Section 26 also entitles a party to go for arbitration. There is nothing in the provision of Section 25 and 26 which can be said to inconsistent with Section 3 of CP Act under which Section the provisions of CPA shall be in addition and not in derogation of any other law for the time being in force.
We have quoted clause 25 of the terms and conditions of the Multimodal Transportation of Document. It only provides that when there is an arbitration agreement then it shall be considered according to Indian laws and that when there is any difference of opinion or dispute under the contract that can be settled by arbitration in India or a place mutually agreed with each party appointing an arbitrator. This clause cannot be held to be an arbitration agreement.
We are, therefore, of the view that present complaint is certainly maintainable and the Multimodal Transportation of Goods Act, 1993 does not bar jurisdiction of a Forum under the Consumer Protection Act. Copy of this order shall be sent to both the parties and the matter to be listed on 11 July, 2002 for further direction and proceedings.
Alert