- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Manohar Lal Etc./Gopi Chand Revisionists v. Collector, Jhansi Etc. Opposite Parties.
Factual and Procedural Background
Two revision petitioners under section 333 of the UPZA and LR Act challenged the judgment and order dated 6.10.2003 passed by the Collector/District Magistrate, Jhansi in Miscellaneous Case Nos. 1 and 2 of 2002-03. The Collector's orders had set aside the order dated 22.8.2002 passed by the Deputy Collector in Case Nos. 3 and 5 of 1999-2000 under section 212 of the Act. The revisionists contended that the matter had been decided in their favour by the Board of Revenue and that the Collector erred in overriding that decision. The respondent (through the learned DGC(R)) replied that the Board's order dated 24.9.2001 was contrary to a Supreme Court judgment and a Board circular not placed before the Board, and that the Collector was therefore justified in setting aside the Deputy Collector's orders.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Collector was justified in setting aside the Deputy Collector's order dated 22.8.2002 despite an earlier order of the Board of Revenue in favour of the revisionists.
- Whether the Board of Revenue's order dated 24.9.2001 was contrary to the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court and to the Board's Circular No. C-865/5-9-R-2001, and whether non-placement of those authorities before the Board vitiated the Board's order.
Arguments of the Parties
Revisionists' Arguments
- The dispute was conclusively decided in their favour by the Board of Revenue and that decision was never challenged in any competent court.
- The Trial Court (Deputy Collector) was justified in ordering in accordance with the Board's decision, and the Collector erred in overriding that decision.
Respondent's Arguments (Learned DGC(R))
- The Board's order dated 24.9.2001 was passed contrary to the law declared by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. 4787 of 2001, Hindi Lal Tewari v. Kamla Devi etc. (decided 25.7.2001).
- The Board's Circular No. C-865/5-9-R-2001 dated 24.1.2001 (guidelines regarding ponds/tanks) was not brought to the Board's notice when it passed its order.
- Because the Board's order was opposed to the law and the circular was not considered, the Collector was justified in setting aside the Deputy Collector's orders.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Civil Appeal No. 4787 of 2001, Hindi Lal Tewari v. Kamla Devi etc., decided on 25.7.2001 | That ponds/tanks are valuable social assets and should not be settled with or allotted to any particular person to maintain environmental balance, preserve water and avoid acute drinking water problems. | The court treated this decision as the law of the land and held that orders contrary to it (and to the Board's circular) were inadvertent; this justified the Collector's action in setting aside the Deputy Collector's orders. |
| Board's Circular No. C-865/5-9-R-2001, dated 24.1.2001 | Guidelines consistent with the Supreme Court's direction regarding ponds/tanks as social assets (as noted in the opinion). | The court relied on the circular together with the Supreme Court decision to conclude the Board's order was passed without considering these authorities and was therefore inadvertent; the Collector correctly applied these guidelines. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court accepted the respondent's contention that the Supreme Court in Hindi Lal Tewari v. Kamla Devi etc. had directed that ponds/tanks are valuable social assets and should not be settled or allotted to individuals to protect environmental balance and water resources. The Board's Circular dated 24.1.2001 contains guidelines aligned with that direction. Because those authorities were not brought to the notice of the Second Appellate Court, the Board's order dated 24.9.2001 was held to be inadvertently passed. The Deputy Collector's order dated 22.8.2002, which followed the Board's order, was therefore set aside by the Collector who applied the Supreme Court's decision and the Board's circular. On this basis the court concluded the Collector was justified and the revision petitions lacked merit.
Holding and Implications
REVISION PETITIONS DISMISSED IN LIMINE.
Direct effect: The impugned orders dated 6.10.2003 passed by the Collector, Jhansi, are confirmed and maintained; the revision petitions are dismissed. The opinion does not purport to lay down any new precedent beyond applying the Supreme Court judgment and the Board's circular to the facts of this case.
S.P Pandey, Member:— These are two revision petitioners under section 333 of the UPZA and LR Act (hereinafter referred to as the Act), preferred against the judgment and order, dated 6.10.2003, passed by the learned Collector/District Magistrate, Jhansi in Miscellaneous Case Nos. 1 and 2 of 2002-03, setting aside the order, dated 22.8.2002, passed by the learned Deputy Collector, Jhansi, in Case Nos. 3 and 5 of 1999-2000, under section 212 of the Act.
2. I have heard the learned Counsel for the revisionists as well as the learned DGC (R) and have also scanned the relevant papers on file. The bone of contentions of the learned Counsel for the revisionists, inter-alia, in a nut-shell, is that since the case, in question, was fought between the parties, concerned upto the Board of Revenue, resulting in the decision in favour of the revisionists, which was never challenged before any Court of competent jurisdiction, the learned Trial Court was perfectly justified in ordering, accordingly and the learned Collector, concerned, has grossly erred in over-riding the decision, rendered by the Board and therefore, his impugned order cannot, at any stretch of imagination, be allowed to sustain.
3. The learned DGC (R), in reply, urged that since the Board's order, dated 24.9.2001 was passed against the spirits of the law of the land, enunciated by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. 4787 of 2001, Hindi Lal Tewari v. Kamla Devi etc., decided on 25.7.2001 as well as the Board's Circular No. C-865/5-9-R-2001, dated 24.1.2001, as the same was not brought to the notice of the Board, the learned Collector, concerned was perfectly justified in rendering the impugned order as per the aforesaid case law and therefore, these revision petitions having no force, very richly deserve dismissal outright, in limine.
4. Having given my thoughtful consideration to the matter, in question, I do notice that as a matter of fact, by the aforesaid case law, relied upon by the learned DCG(R), the Hon'ble Apex Court has, in fact, directed vide order, dated 25.7.2001, that ponds/tanks, being valuable social assets, should not be settled with nor the same be allotted to any particular person, in order to maintain environmental balance, water preservation and conservation as well as to avoid acute drinking water problems to the general public as well as animals, which has now, in fact, become the law of the land. Vide the aforesaid Board's circular, dated 24.1.2001 guidelines have been laid down, accordingly. Since the same has not been brought to the notice of the learned Second Appellate Court the order, dated 24.9.2001 was, in fact, passed inadvertently by it and accordingly, the learned Trial Court passed the order, dated 22.8.2002 To the contrary, the learned Collector, concerned, has dealt with the matter, in question in depth analytically and logically and has set aside the orders passed by the learned Deputy Collector, concerned in this connection, rightly ob serving the law of the land enunciated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India as well as the Board's Circular, dated 24.1.2001 and therefore, I in the facts and circum stances of the instant case as well as the aforesaid law of the land and the Board's circular in this respect, am of the considered opinion that he was perfectly justified in rendering the impugned order and as such, these revision petitions, being not fit for admission, very richly deserve dis missal outright, in limine.
5. In view of the above, these revision petitions, being not fit for admission, are accordingly, dismissed as such in limine and the impugned orders, dated 6.10.2003, passed by the learned Collector, concerned, are hereby, confirmed and maintained.
6. This order shall govern Revision Petition Nos. 47 and 46 of 2004-05.Jhahsi.
7. Revision Petitions Dismissed.
Alert