- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Hari Shanker Pal And Others Revisionists v. Mangal Singh And Others Opp. Parties.
Arun Kumar Bit, Member:— This is a revision under section 219 U.P Land Revenue Act filed by Shri Hari Shanker Pal, Ram Shanker Pal and Hargovind Pal s/o Gaya Prasad residents of village Vijankhera Tahsil and Pargana Ghatampur District Kanpur Nagar against the order dated 24.2.2009 passed by Tahsildar (Judicial), Ghatampur in mutation suit No. 400/100, Hari Shanker v. Mangal Singh, 34/35 L.R Act.
2. The contention of the revisionists that they had purchased the disputed land from the original tenure holder Mangal Singh through two registered sale-deeds executed on 4.6.2001 and 7.7.2005 respectively and thereafter had submitted the mutation applications in the Court of Tahsildar. Since no objection was received, the mutation was allowed by the Tahsildar through his judgment dated 8.5.2008
3. However, subsequently a time-barred application was filed by the respondents on 20.12.2008 for restoration and the same was allowed by the Tahsildar on 24.2.2009 The present revision has been filed by the revisionist against this order for restoration with the contention that it was non-speaking and against the basic tenets of justice as no opportunity of hearing was allowed to him.
4. The revision was admitted on 12.9.2011 and notices were issued. In response, the respondents had filed their written objection on 20.1.2012 The Lower Court records were also duly requisitioned.
5. I have heard the arguments put forwarded by the learned Counsels of both the parties as well as have perused the lower Court records.
6. The very basis on which the mutation was requested was two registered sale-deeds executed by Mangal Singh on 4.6.2001 and 7.7.2005 in the presence of various witnesses. The text of these registered document is unequivocal in its expression:—
7. Therefore, the contention of the respondents that the disputed plots were only leased out for a limited period and that he had been hoodwinked by the revisionists in signing these registered documents against his wishes, does not cut any ice and cannot at all be relied upon. The mutation proceedings are summary proceedings and there is no justification for a revenue Court to disbelieve such registered sale-deeds, duly proved by their witnesses. As it stands today the Civil Court has not passed any order declaring anything illegal in these sale-deeds. Therefore the order of Tahsildar (Judicial) dated 8.5.2008 was justified on valid ground.
8. The other legal point raised by the respondent was about the maintain-ability of the proceeding in the Court of Tahsildar it has been argued that since both the sale-deeds were executed during the period of consolidation in the village, the mutation application should have been submitted in the consolidation Court and once the notification of 52 CH. Act was issued, they were barred under section 49 CH. Act. This is a myopic view. In the instant case, there were two sale-deeds, separated by a gap of four years. If applied separately, the problem of fragmentation would have arisen. It was therefore natural that the revisionists had applied for mutation on 21.9.2005, immediately after the second sale-deed. The fact that consolidation was going on, was apparent from the text of the second sale-deed itself. In order to facilitate the proceeding, the CH. 41 was submitted alongwith the mutation application. In any case, the aims of consolidation Court end revenue Court are the same i.e updation of land record. One is complementary to the other. It is only during consolidation operation, revenue Court stops interfering till the operation is over. Thereafter it takes over again. Thus there is no dichotomy in their functioning. Therefore, the fact that the mutation was not completed during the consolidation operation, does not act as a legal barrier so as to deny a valid transaction. The contention of the respondent is not tenable.
9. In the light of the above, the order of mutation dated 8.5.2008 was justified. The subsequent order of cancellation and restoration of proceeding dated 24.2.2009 was uncalled for, as it would lead to unnecessary litigation by opening a Pandora's box in a revenue Court, not entitled to look into the voidability of legally registered sale-deeds.
10. The revision is allowed as above.
11. Revision Allowed.
Alert