Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

R. Retheesh v. Union Of India

Central Administrative Tribunal
Jun 17, 2014

George Paracken, Judicial Member:— This application having been heard on 17th June 2014 this Tribunal on the same day delivered the following:—

The applicant has filed this Original Application seeking the following reliefs:—

1. Call for the records leading to the issue of A-1 and consequential orders issued thereon and quash the same in so far as it relates to the transfer and appointment of the 5th respondent, in preference to the applicant.

2. Declare that the applicant is entitled to be considered and transferred as Assistant Loco Pilot in the Trivandrum Division of Southern Railway, in preference to the 5th respondent, and direct the respondents accordingly.

3. Direct the respondents to consider and transfer the applicant to, and against a vacancy of Assistant Loco Pilot, in the Thiruvananthapuram Division of Southern Railway in terms of Annexure A-8 orders of the first respondent, and direct further to grant all the consequential benefits with effect from the date from which the 5th respondent joined the Trivandrum Division of Southern Railway.

4. Award costs of and incidental to this application.

5. Pass such other orders or directions as deemed just fit and necessary in the facts and circumstances of the case.

2. The brief facts of the case are that the applicant and the 5th respondent were working under the Madras Division of the Southern Railway. Both of them have registered their names for inter-divisional transfer on spouse ground permissible in terms of Railway Board Order RBE No. 23/2010 dated 2.2.2010 The said order was issued on the basis of the DoP&T instructions on the issue of posting of husband and wife at the same station. The Railway Board has adopted the guidelines prescribed by the DoP&T which reads as under:—

a. Where both the spouses are railway employees and belong to the same seniority units.

The husband & wife, if working in the same Department and if the required level of post is available, should invariably be posted together in order to enable them to lead a normal family life and look after the welfare of their children especially till the children attain 18 years of age. This will not apply on appointment under the Central Staffing Scheme. Where only wife is a Government servant, the above concessions shall be applicable to the Govt. servant. Hence both the railway servants may be posted at the same station/place ensuring that one of them does not work as subordinate to the other.

b. Where both the spouses are railway servants but belong to different seniority units.

Efforts may be made to post both the railway servants at the station where posts at appropriate level exist in the respective seniority units failing which requests for change of the category may be considered sympathetically keeping in view all other relevant rules in the matter.

c. Where one of the spouses is a railway servant and the other belongs to All India Service or another Central Service.

The Railway servant should be posted at station/place in the Railway/Division/PU in whose territorial jurisdiction the place/state of posting of his/her spouse falls or as close to it as possible if there is no Railway Organization/post at the place/state of posting of the spouse.

d. Where one of the spouses is a railway servant and the other belongs to a state service.

The Railway servant should be posted at the station/place in the Railway/Division/PU in whose territorial jurisdiction the place/state of posting of his/her spouse falls. If it is not possible, if a request from the railway servant to the Controlling Authority of the spouse for his/her posting at the place of posting of the railway servant is received the same may be forwarded to the concerned authority for sympathetic consideration.

e. Where one of the spouses is a railway servant (all India service) and the other is working in a central/state/Public Sector Undertaking/Autonomous Body/Private Sector.

The railway servant may apply to the controlling Authority for a posting at the place of posting of his/her spouse which may be considered favorably by the competent authority.

If no post is available for posting of the railway servant at the place of posting of the spouse he/she may be posted to a place closer to the ‘place of posting of the spouse. If this also is not possible application from the railway servant for posting of the spouse who is working in the Central/State/Public Sector Undertaking may be forwarded to the controlling authority of the spouse of his/her posting at or near the place of the railway servant.

3. Thereafter under the powers conferred upon him by the Railway Board, the General Manager has issued further instructions vide letter No. P(R)676.P/Vo.III dated 25.2.2013 According to the said instructions, the request for inter divisional transfer on spouse ground as well as on normal ground is to be treated in the ratio of 1:3.

4. Before the aforesaid orders were issued the applicant had applied for inter divisional transfer on 27.1.2009 and his name was registered at Sl. No. 78 whereas 5th respondent had applied for such inter divisional transfer earlier than the applicant on 7.6.2008 and his name was registered at Sl. No. 46. However, after the aforesaid orders with regard to request for inter divisional transfer on spouse ground, the applicant has applied on 14.6.2011 and the 5th respondent has applied on 4.7.2011 But the respondents have issued the impugned Annexure A-1 order dated 31.8.2013 granting inter divisional transfer to the 5th respondent on spouse ground whereas the applicant was not transferred. He has, therefore, filed this OA seeking the aforesaid reliefs.

5. The official respondents have filed their reply stating that the 5th respondent has got the priority in transfer because of the mistake committed by the Madras Division. They have stated that while issuing Annexure A-5, an error had happened inadvertently in showing the date of registration of one Shri. K. Rathish Kumar as 3.11.2011 against Shri. R. Ratheesh whose date of actual registration was on 14.6.2011 and he stands senior in the order of registration to Shri. S. Anoop. Later on, it was corrected by the Madras Division vide Annexure R-3 letter dated 5.9.2013

6. 5th respondent has also filed the reply. Shri. Martin G Thottan who appeared for the 5th respondent argued that in spite of the fact that the applicant had registered for inter divisional transfer prior to the 5th respondent, the 5th respondent had the right of priority over applicant for inter divisional transfer on the ground that in terms of R.B.E No. 23/2010 dated 2.2.2010, if both the spouses are working in the same Government Department they have priority in the matter of transfer. In the case of the 5th respondent, his spouse is also working in the Railways in Trivandrum Division. Secondly, he has argued that before the issuance of the instructions regarding transfer on spouse ground by the respondents, the 5th respondent had registered his name for inter divisional transfer on 7.6.2008 and his name was registered at Sl. No. 46 in the list. The applicant had also registered his name for inter divisional transfer on 27.1.2009 and his name was registered at Sl. No. 78 in the list. Thirdly, his wife being an athlete representing Southern Railway, the respondents' consideration was heavily in favour of the 5th respondent for inter divisional transfer rather than the applicant.

7. I have heard learned counsel for the parties. It is seen that by virtue of the earlier application for inter divisional transfer, neither the applicant nor the 5th respondent reached their turn for transfer. It is only by virtue of the policy of transfer on spouse ground that both the applicant has got an early opportunity to get inter divisional transfer. Therefore, the earlier registration for inter divisional transfer made by both the applicant and the 5th respondent is not relevant in this case at all. Secondly, in my considered opinion, the 5th respondent cannot claim any preference over the applicant on the ground that his spouse is working in the Railways because there cannot be a further classification in the matter of transfer on spouse ground. Just because the wife of 5th respondent is working in the Railways and the applicant's wife is working in the private sector, as submitted by the learned counsel, the 5th respondent cannot claim any priority over the applicant. Thirdly, the fact that the 5th respondent's wife is an athlete is also not a valid consideration for inter divisional transfer. The fact remains that the applicant is the early registrant for inter divisional transfer on spouse ground. Admittedly, it is by an inadvertent mistake that the applicant's name was not recorded in the register and the respondents Railways themselves have corrected it later on. At the same time, 5th respondent's transfer also cannot be faulted. He has not misrepresented any fact before the official respondent for getting his transfer on spouse ground prior to the transfer of the applicant.

8. In the above facts and circumstances of the case and in the interest of justice, I dispose of this OA with a direction to the official respondents to transfer the applicant to the Trivandrum Division on inter divisional transfer basis on spouse ground against the next available vacancy under the quota fixed for the same. However, since posting and transfer on inter divisional transfer has an impact on the future of the employees, the applicant being the earlier registrant for the inter divisional transfer on spouse ground, while posting him in Trivandrum Division he shall have priority over the 5th respondent in all matters including seniority.

9. The OA is disposed of accordingly. There shall be no order as to costs.