Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/S Sat Guru Sai Cable Network v. Media Pro Enterprise India Pvt. Ltd. .

Telecom Disputes Settlement And Appellate Tribunal
Jan 6, 2014
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The counsel for the parties were heard. The sole matter in dispute identified by the court is the fair subscriber base (SLR) in the area of operation proposed by the petitioner. Both parties agreed the dispute could be referred to the Tribunal's mediation centre to reconcile a fair SLR, taking into account the respondent's existing SLR with another MSO in the same area and the expectation that a new MSO will take time to establish and obtain only a certain percentage of market share in the first year. The matter was listed before the learned Mediator for 17.01.2014. The respondent was directed to have responsible officers present with documents pertaining to the SLR with the other MSO; those documents are confidential and to be shared only with the Mediator. The Mediator was requested to facilitate reconciliation of a fair SLR on which the respondent can supply signals to the petitioner. The court expressed hope the parties would resolve their disputes before the next date.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a fair subscriber base (SLR) can be determined for the petitioner's proposed area of operation and, if so, what that fair SLR should be, taking into account the respondent's existing SLR with another MSO and the realistic first-year market share for a new MSO.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court identified the dispute as limited to the fair SLR and accepted the parties' mutual agreement to attempt reconciliation via mediation. The analysis focused on practical factors to be used in mediation: the respondent's existing SLR with another MSO in the same area and the realistic expectation that a new MSO can secure only a limited percentage of market share in its first year. Because the respondent's comparative SLR documents are confidential, the court limited their disclosure to the Mediator. On this basis, the court directed listing before the Mediator and tasked the Mediator with facilitating a negotiated reconciliation of a fair SLR to govern the supply of signals.

Holding and Implications

The matter is referred to the Tribunal's Mediation Centre and listed before the learned Mediator on 17.01.2014.

Implications: The Mediator is to reconcile a fair SLR based on the respondent's existing SLR with the other MSO and an assessment of the petitioner's likely first-year market share. The respondent must bring confidential SLR documents to the Mediator only. The direct effect is referral to mediation with the expectation of resolution; the opinion does not establish any new legal precedent.

Show all summary ...

Heard the counsel for the parties at some length.

On hearing the counsel the only issue that appears to be the matter of dispute, is fair subscriber base in the area of operation proposed by the petitioner.

Both the parties agree that this matter can be referred to the mediation centre of the Tribunal on the specific point of reconciling a fair SLR based on the existing SLR of the respondent with the other MSO in the same area and taking into consideration that a new MSO would require some time to establish and, therefore, can hope to get certain percentage of the market share only in the first year.

Let the matter be listed before the learned Mediator on 17.01.2014 where responsible and concerned officers of both the parties will be present. The representative of the respondent will have necessary documents pertaining to the SLR with other MSO in the same area. These being of confidential nature, he may share the same only with the Mediator. Based on the SLR and the reasonable percentage of the same that the petitioner can be expected to achieve in the first year, the learned Mediator is requested to facilitate the reconciliation of a fair SLR on which the signals can be supplied by the respondent to the petitioner.

It is hoped and expected that the parties would be able to resolve their disputes before the learned Mediator on the next date.