- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ram Bilash v. Ram Rekha Opp. Party.
A.U Khan, M.:— This reference has been decided on 9.11.1992 by my predecessor Hon'ble Member Sri V.S Pandey since transferred. An application for restoration has been granted on 2.12.1992 The reference for the second time comes under consideration.
2. The facts are: Ram Bilash's institute a lawsuit under Sec. 229-B Z.A and L.R Act in the court of Asstt. Collector First Class. The pleading is to declare them bhumidhar tenant in possession of the land.
3. On 6.1.1989 Gaon Sabha D/1 files an lqbal dawa. On 6.4.1989 Rekha D/2 also files an Iqbaldawa. On 4.5.1989 Asstt. Collector enters an order decreeing the suit on the sole basis of admission of claim.
4. Aggrieved by this order Suresh Singh's 4 men move an application in restoration. Their contention is that land in suit has been transferred to them by a sale deed dated 16.12.1988 That their interest in land is involved. The application avers that suit has been decreed on basis of a pretended Iqbaldawa. In this manner the court had been deceived. The relief to set aside the decree dated 4.5.1989 is prayed for. An affidavit is enclosed in support.
5. On 13.7.1989 defendant Rekha also moves an application in restoration. He says that he has filed no Iqbaldawa and the same filed on his behalf is an act of fraud; that he was never served. Also he admits that he has transferred the land in suit on 16.12.1988 to Suresh Singh's. Also the vendee is in possession. The relief to set aside the decree dated 4.5.1989 is prayed for. Parties are given chance to lead their evidence. On 19.7.1989 Asstt. Collector enters an order granting restoration. The infected decree dated 4.5.1989 goes down. On 28.12.1989 Addl. Commissioner submits a reference with his recommendation to set aside the order of the court below and to remand the case for re-disposal after giving an opportunity to Ram Bilash's to set forth their claim, the reference is docketed here for a definitive decision.
6. Heard the counsel for the parties and perused the record.
7. I am of certain opinion that the decree dated 4.5.1989 is infected. No suit can in law be decreed only on basis of admission. The Chairman Gaon Sabh a has no authority to file an Iqbaldawa, in absence of prior permission from the Tahsildar.
8. In his restoration application Rekha D/1 has challenged that he has not filed an Iqbaldawa. In that position the burden is of Ram Bilahs's to examine the Advocate who has identified the thumb impression of Rekha over Iqbaldawa. In the grounds of revision before Addl. Commissioner Ram Bilash's has not stated that he is ready and willing to examine the said Advocate, to attest that Ram Rekha has filed an Iqbaldawa. Moreover, even on an Iqbaldawa a suit cannot be decreed. Plaintiff has to prove his case against the State. The decree dated 4.5.1989 is not based on a legal consideration which should and must. The trial court has not examined to satisfy himself whether plaintiff can in law be declared bhumidhar tenant in possession. In such a situation the duty is court's to set aside such a decree - 1978 R.D 16.
9. Also no copy of notice under Sec. 80 C.P.C has been filed to show that it is satisfying the requirement of Sec. 80 C.P.C There is no proof that the original of the notice has been sent and served on Collector or left in his office. In absence thereof the suit is not maintainable.
10. The suit has been instituted on 13.3.1989 The land in suit had been transferred to Suresh Singh's on 16.12.1988 by defendant Rekha. In this circumstances the restoration application by Suresh Singh's is supportable in fact and at law. So is the application by defendant Rekha.
11. The counsel for revisionist submits that he was given no opportunity of hearing as is mandatory in the circumstances of the case. In a situation where the decree is infected and is unsupportable in law the grant of a chance to set forth a case in S.D.O's shall only be an exercise in abstraction. Decree-holder has been heard in this court. It has not been shown that a potential case in support of decree is in hand. My predecessor have rightly noted that where a person has secured a decree by means of fraud he is not to be given a right of hearing in view of (1990) 4 SCC 633 : AIR 1991 SC 909. Counsel for revisionist have argued all the points listed in the grounds of revision before the Commissioner's.
12. For the reasons foregone the reference is rejected. The order of Sub-Divisional Officer granting restoration application shall stand. The suit comes under consideration. The same be decided on merits according to law.
Alert