Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/S Hindustan Coca Cola Beverages P. Ltd (S) v. Cce, Ahmedabad (S).

CESTAT
Mar 24, 2017

Dr. D.M Misra, Judicial Member:— This is an appeal filed against OIA No. 135-136/2012(Ahd-III)/SKS/Commr. (A)/Ahd dated 10.10.2012 passed by the Commissioner (Appeals) of Central Excise and Customs-Ahmedabad.

2. Briefly stated the facts of the case are that the appellant was issued with the SCN dated 05.05.2011 alleging wrong availment of CENVAT credit of Rs. 17,32,270/- on various counts. It was alleged that they had availed credit of Rs. 1,02,132/- on inputs/capital goods, which were used for erection of transmission line in bringing electricity from outside, to the factory premises, Rs. 4,93,821/- availed on M.S Channels, Angles, Beams etc, which were used as supporting structure to various capital goods viz. steam line, water line, stair case etc, in their factory premises” “Rs. 37,389/- availed on input services, namely, Engineering & Construction Service, which were used in the installation and erection of transmission line, tower, shed etc” Rs. 10,98,928/- availed as credit on service tax paid in respect of Security Services, Courier Services, Maintenance & Repair Services on invoices, which were in the name of their sales offices which was not registered as Input Service Distributor. On adjudication, CENVAT credit of Rs. 1,02,132/- availed on electric transmission lines and input services used for erection commissioning of such transmission line was allowed by the Adjudicating Authority, but, the balance credit availed i.e on M.S Channels, Angles, Beams etc., and on other input services totally amounting of Rs. 15,92,749/- was confirmed alongwith interest and equal amount of penalty. Aggrieved by the said order, the assessee as well as Revenue filed appeal before the Ld. Commissioner (Appeals), who allowed the appeal filed by the revenue and enhanced the demand to Rs. 17,32,270/- alongwith interest and equal amount of penalty. Hence, the present appeal.

3. Ld. Advocate Shri Hardik Modh for the appellant submits that for the transfer of electricity from outside to the factory grid by using cables and other capital goods eligible to credit in view of the decisions of this Tribunal in the case of Shri Shyam Iron Udyog Pvt. Ltd. v. C.C.E & S.T Bhubaneswar-II, 2010 (25) ELT 545 (Tri-Kolkata), Synthetic Packers Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, (Appeals-I), Bangalore, 2009 (240) ELT 235 (Tri.-Bang.). In relation to credit availed on use of M.S Angles, Channels, Beams etc., in fabrication of supporting structures inside the factory premises, the Ld. Advocate submitted that the same is covered by the decision of the Principal Bench in the case of Singhal Enterprises Pvt. Ltd v. Commissioner of Central Excise & Customs, Raipur, 2016 (341) ELT 372 (Tri.-Del.). On the issue of utilization of input services for installation, and maintenance of transmission line, towers etc., outside the factory premises, ld. advocate has referred to the judgement of the Larger Bench of this Tribunal in the case of Parry Engg. & Electronics P. Ltd v. C.C.E & S.T - Ahmedabad-I, II, III, 2015 (40) STR 243 (Tri.-LB). On the issue of eligibility of CENVAT credit on the service tax paid on various input services against invoices issued by their sales offices which were not registered as Input Services Distributor, the Ld. Advocate submitted that the issue is covered by the Judgement of the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court in the case of C.C.E v. Dashion Ltd., 2016 (41) ELT 884 (Guj.).

4. The Ld. AR for the Revenue reiterated the findings of the Ld Commissioner (Appeals).

5. Heard both sides and perused the records. I find that in bringing power from the outside to the factory premises by laying down cables to be used in or in relation to the manufactured of final product, covered by the decision of this Tribunal in Shri Shyam Iron Udyog Pvt. Ltd's case (supra). On the issue of eligibility of CENVAT credit on M.S Angles, Channels, Beams etc, it is covered by the judgement of the Principal Bench of this Tribunal in Singhal Enterprises Pvt Ltd's case (supra). Wherein the lordship observed as follows:—

“13. Now we turn to the question, whether credit is admissible on various structural steel items, such as, MS Angles, Sections, Channels, TMT Bar, etc., which have been used by the appellants in the fabrication of support structures on which various capital goods are placed? The same stands denied by the lower authority. The learned DR has sought disallowance of the same by citing the decision of the Larger Bench in the case of Vandana Global Ltd. (supra) and other judgments. Further, he has brought to our notice and emphasized the amendment carried out in Explanation-II to Rule 2(a) which defines the term “Input” w.e.f 7-7-2009. It has further been pleaded that the Cenvat credit claimed for the period prior to this will be covered within the decision of the Larger Bench in the case of Vandana Global Ltd. (supra).

14. The Larger Bench decision in Vandana Global Ltd.'s case (supra) laid down that even if the iron and articles were used as supporting structures, they would not be eligible for the credit. Considering the amendment made w.e.f 7-7-2009 as a clarification amendment and hence to be considered retrospectively. However, we find that the said decision of the Larger Bench was considered by the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court in the case of Mundra Ports & Special Economic Zone Ltd., 2015 (04) LCX 0197 : 2015 (39) S.T.R 726 (Guj.), wherein it was observed that the amendment made on 7-7-2009 cannot be held to be clarificatory and as such would be applicable only prospectively.

15. We find that the controversy can be laid to rest by making a reference to the decision of the Apex Court in the case of CCE, Jaipur v. Rajasthan Spinning & Weaving Mills Ltd., 2010 (255) E.L.T 481 (S.C), wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court has considered an identical issue of steel plates and MS channels used in the fabrication of chimney for diesel generating set. The credit stands allowed in the light of Rule 57Q of the erstwhile Central Excise Rules, 1944. In the said judgment, the Apex Court has referred to the “user test” evolved by the Apex Court in the case of CCE, Coimbatore v. Jawahar Mills Ltd., 2001 (132) E.L.T 3 (S.C), which is required to be satisfied to find out whether or not particular goods could be said to be capital goods. When we apply the “user test” to the case in hand, we find that the structural steel items have been used for the fabrication of support structures for capital goods. The appellants have argued that the various capital goods, such as, kiln, material handling conveyor system, furnace, etc. cannot be suspended in mid-air. They will need to be suitably supported to facilitate smooth functioning of such machines. It is obvious that the structural items have been suitably worked upon for this purpose. Accordingly, the goods fabricated, using such structurals, will have to be considered as parts of the relevant machines. The definition of ‘Capital Goods’ includes, components, spares and accessories of such capital goods. Accordingly, applying the “User Test” to the facts in hand, we have no hesitation in holding that the structural items used in the fabrication of support structures would fall within the ambit of ‘Capital Goods’ as contemplated under Rule 2(a) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, hence will be entitled to the Cenvat credit”.

6. On the issue of availing of CENVAT credit on input services used for erection of transmission lines, towers, etc., for bringing electricity from outside the factory premises, the issue is covered by the Larger Bench decision of Tribunal in Parry Engineering & Electronics Pvt. Ltd's case (supra). With regard to the credit availed on invoices, issued by their sales office, which was denied to them on the ground that sales office is not registered as the input service distributor during the relevant period, the issue is covered by the judgment of the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court in Dashion Ltd's case (supra).

6. In view of the aforesaid judgements, in my opinion, CENVAT credit is admissible to the appellant. The impugned order is set-aside and the appeal is allowed with consequential relief, if any, as per law.