Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Information Filed By:- v. M/S. Rohit Medical Store Informant

Competition Commission Of India
Apr 11, 2013
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Informant, proprietor of M/s. Rohit Medical Store, filed information on 20.12.2012 under Section 19(1) of the Competition Act, 2002 against Macleods Pharmaceutical Ltd, FDC Limited, Cipla Limited, Sh. Sanjeev Pandit (President of Himachal Pradesh Society of Chemist & Druggist Alliance), and the Himachal Pradesh Society of Chemist & Druggist Alliance. The Informant alleged that the Opposite Parties engaged in anti-competitive practices by requiring a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from the Society before granting stockist-ship in Himachal Pradesh.

Previously, the Himachal Pradesh State Chemists & Druggists Association (HPSCDA) was subject to MRTPC orders in 2009 directing that NOCs were not necessary for stockist appointments. Despite these directions, the Association allegedly changed its name to Himachal Pradesh Society of Chemists & Druggists Alliance and continued insisting on NOCs.

The Informant completed formalities to become a stockist for Opposite Party No. 1 but was denied delivery of ordered products due to lack of NOC from Opposite Party No. 5. Similar refusals were reported from Opposite Parties No. 2 and 3, attributed to pressure from Opposite Party No. 5. The Informant submitted evidence including a recorded conversation and letters showing the demand for NOCs.

The Commission considered the matter in meetings held on 02.01.2013, 13.02.2013, and 13.03.2013, reviewed the facts, allegations, and documents submitted.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conduct of Opposite Party No. 5 in making it compulsory to obtain a No Objection Certificate before appointment as stockist amounts to anti-competitive practice under Section 3(3)(b) read with Section 3(1) of the Competition Act, 2002?
  2. Whether there exists a prima facie case to direct an investigation into the alleged anti-competitive conduct of Opposite Parties?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Commission analyzed the factual matrix and documents submitted by the Informant, noting that Opposite Party No. 5 effectively controls and regulates stockist appointments for all pharmaceutical companies in Himachal Pradesh by making NOC compulsory. This conduct was seen as restricting the supply of medicines by pharmaceutical companies, thereby violating Sections 3(1) and 3(3)(b) of the Competition Act, 2002. Given the prima facie evidence of anti-competitive behavior, the Commission found it appropriate to direct an investigation by the Director General to examine these allegations further. The Commission clarified that its observations were not final and would not prejudice the investigation, which would also consider the responsibility of persons in charge under Section 48 of the Act.

Holding and Implications

The Commission directed the Director General under Section 26(1) of the Competition Act, 2002 to conduct an investigation into the matter within 60 days of communication of the order.

The direct effect of this decision is the initiation of a formal investigation into the alleged anti-competitive practices involving the compulsory demand of NOCs by the Himachal Pradesh Society of Chemists & Druggists Alliance and the pharmaceutical companies. The order does not constitute a final determination on the merits but sets the procedural stage for further inquiry. No new precedent was established by this order.

Show all summary ...

The information in the instant case was filed on 20.12.2012 under Section 19(1) of the Competition Act, 2002 (‘Act’) by the proprietor of M/s. Rohit Medical Store (‘Informant’) against Macleods Pharmaceutical Ltd (‘Opposite Party No. 1’), FDC Limited (‘Opposite Party No. 2’), Cipla Limited (‘Opposite Party No. 3’), Sh. Sanjeev Pandit, President, Himachal Pradesh Society of Chemist & Druggist Alliance (‘Opposite Party No. 4 ‘) and Himachal Pradesh Society of Chemist & Druggist Alliance (‘Opposite Party No. 5’) alleging that Opposite Parties were engaged in anti-competitive practices.

2. The factual matrix of the case is as under:—

2.1 The Informant has alleged that Opposite Party No. 4 being President of Opposite Party No. 5 compelled the pharmaceutical companies to grant stockist-ship in the territory of Himachal Pradesh only to those persons who had obtained No Objection Certificate from Opposite Party No. 5. It is submitted that earlier Opposite Party No. 5 was known as Himachal Pradesh State Chemists & Druggists Association (‘HPSCDA’). A complaint was filed against HPSCDA being Case No. UTPE/174/2008 before the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Commission(‘MRTPC’) and the MRTPC vide its order dated 18 May, 2009 gave following directions:—

“Respondent No. 1 is directed to give wide publicity among members and other concerned interests that its No Objection Certificate would not be necessary for appointment of stockists. Respondent No. 1 would file Affidavit of compliance within six weeks.”

2.2 As per the Informant, a similar order was also passed on 20 May, 2009 against HPSCDA on complaint of the present Informant in case No. UTPE 188/2008 and again direction was given and the pharmaceutical company was directed that it would not insist upon NOC for affecting supplies to the Informant if Informant was otherwise eligible to get supplies. HPSCDA was also directed to give wide publicity among its members and other concerned that ‘No Objection Certificate’ would not be necessary for appointment of a dealer or stockist by pharmaceutical companies. An affidavit of compliance was to be filed by Association. In order to evade these directions of MRTP Commission, it is alleged that the association changed its name from Himachal Pradesh State Chemists & Druggists Association to Himachal Pradesh Society of Chemists & Druggists Alliance and again started following the same practice of granting No Objection Certificate and insisting for NOCs.

2.3 The Informant has informed that Opposite Party No. 1, M/s Macleods Pharmaceutical Ltd. is one of the leading companies having presence in Himachal Pradesh. Employees of Opposite Party No. 1 came to Informant and offered stockist-ship of the company. All formalities for appointing Informant as stockist were completed, except obtaining of No Objection Certificate from Opposite Party No. 5. The Informant told Opposite Party No. 1 that NOC was not required for dealership/stockist-ship in view of the order of MRTPC as well as Competition Commission of India. A demand draft of Rs. 4 lakhs in favour of Opposite Party No. 1 and an order for purchase of medicines was placed on Opposite Party No. 1 by Informant. On 8 October, 2012, representative of Opposite Party No. 1 sent a list of ordered products amounting to Rs. 1,56,731/-. However, these products/goods were not delivered to Informant and Informant was told that unless a ‘No Objection Certificate’ was granted by Opposite Party No. 5, the ordered products would not be delivered. The Informant has stated that Opposite Party No. 4 had personal antagonism with Informant and wanted to create obstruction in the business of Informant and therefore, was not prepared to grant ‘NOC’ in favour of the Informant. Despite the fact that there was no other stockists in the area of Bilaspur, where Informantwas having its business and the stockists of Mandi and Hamirpur districts (HP) were giving supplies to Bilaspur, ‘No Objection Certificate’ was refused. Similar averments have also been made by Informant in respect of Opposite Party No. 2. Informant has stated that despite informing Opposite Party No. 2 that no ‘No Objection Certificate’ was required from Opposite Party No. 5 for being appointed as stockist, Opposite Party No. 2 also insisted on ‘NOC’ in favour of Informant for appointing him as stockist for district Bilaspur.

2.4 As per the Informant, there are about eight stockists of Opposite Party No. 3 in the State of Himachal Pradesh. The Opposite Party No. 3 is selling about 500 products grouped into 22 divisions and it supplies all of its products to the stockists of Una, Hamirpur, Kangra, Mandi, Shimla and Solan etc. but, at Bilaspur district, it has made Informant as its stockist only for one division (for some products). The Informant has alleged that the products of other divisions (total ethical products) were not supplied to him due to the pressure exerted by the President of Opposite Party No. 5.

2.5 The Informant has stated that he was not being granted stockist-ship of Opposite Party No. 1, 2 and 3 because of the condition imposed by Opposite Party No. 5 to obtain NOC from it before being appointed as a dealer/stockist. In support of this contention, Informant has placed on record a CD containing conversation of Opposite Party No. 4 with the employees of Opposite Party No. 1, wherein Opposite Party No. 4 was emphasizing that obtaining of NOC was must. The Informant has also placed on record the letter showing that NOC was being demanded for appointing him as stockist.

2.6 The Informant has also submitted that he had earlier also moved the Commission about this practice of NOC being demanded by pharmaceutical companies but he did not pursue his earlier complaint because the pharmaceutical firm Novartis India Pvt. Ltd. agreed to restore supplies.

3. The Commission considered the matter in its meeting held on 02.01.2013, 13.02.2013 and 13.03.2013 and has carefully gone through all the facts and allegations raised by the Informant in the information and the documents annexed with the information.

4. On thorough examination of the facts and circumstances of the matter and the documents annexed with the information, the Commission observes that the Opposite Party No. 5 appears to be controlling and regulating the appointment of stockist-ship of each and every pharmaceutical company in the State of Himachal Pradesh. The evidence placed on record by the Informant shows that no one can be appointed as the stockist of any pharmaceutical company in the State of Himachal Pradesh without the NOC of Opposite Party No. 5 association. The conduct of Opposite Party No. 5 of making it compulsory for the Informant to obtain NOC before appointment as stockist of Opposite Party No. 1 and 2 and 3 appears to be in violation of Section 3(3)(b) read with Section 3(1) of the Act as through the said conduct of Opposite Party No. 5, it appears to have restricted the supplies of medicines of Opposite Party No. 1 and 2 in the State of Himachal Pradesh.

5. After giving our thoughtful consideration on the matter, the Commission is of the opinion that there exists a, prima facie, case to direct the Director General to cause an investigation into the matter.

6. Accordingly, the Commission directs under Section 26(1) of the Act to the Director General to conduct an investigation into the matter and to submit his report within a period of 60 days from the communication of this order. The Commission, however, makes it clear that the observations made in this order are not final and shall not, in any manner, influence the investigation proceedings. However, in case the DG finds any of the Opposite Party is in violation of the provisions of the Act, it shall also investigate the role of the persons, who at the time of such contravention, were in-charge of and responsible for the conduct of the business of such Opposite Party so as to fix responsibility of such persons under Section 48 of the Act. DG shall also give opportunity of hearing to such persons in terms of Section 48 of the Act.

7. The Secretary is directed to send a copy of the information to the Office of the Director General in terms of the relevant provisions of the Act and the Regulations made there under.