- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Deepak v. Union Of India
Factual and Procedural Background
The applicant applied for a post under Northern Railway Recruitment Board (RRC) pursuant to an advertisement dated 30.08.2012 for 7368 posts in Pay Band-1. The eligibility required a minimum qualification of 10th pass or ITI or equivalent, with age limits specified. The applicant, eligible under the OBC category, appeared and cleared the written examination held on 08.12.2013 and the Physical Examination Test on 27.03.2014. Subsequently, the applicant attended document verification on 04.06.2014 with all required documents. However, the candidature was rejected by the respondents on the ground of mismatch in handwriting/signature detected by a Forensic Document Expert appointed by the Ministry of Railway/Government of India. The applicant sought reasons under the RTI Act and representation for explanation and opportunity of hearing, which were not granted. The rejection was communicated via the official website and no inquiry involving the applicant was conducted. The applicant filed this Original Application (OA) under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 challenging the rejection.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the rejection of the applicant's candidature on the basis of expert opinion regarding mismatch of handwriting/signature without providing an opportunity of hearing violates principles of natural justice.
- Whether the expert opinion on handwriting mismatch is sufficient ground for rejection of candidature in the recruitment process.
- Whether the applicant had any right to appointment by virtue of clearing the written exam and physical test and attending document verification.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments
- The rejection of candidature was made without giving any opportunity of hearing, violating principles of natural justice.
- No inquiry was conducted or the applicant was not associated with any inquiry, rendering the rejection arbitrary.
- Relied on the judgement in Sandeep Kumar v. UOI where similar orders by RRB were set aside.
Respondents' Arguments
- Fact of rejection on handwriting/signature mismatch was not disputed.
- Clearing document verification does not confer any right to appointment.
- The Screening Committee observed mismatch and referred the case to a Government Examiner of Questioned Documents (GEQD) nominated by Ministry of Railway/Govt. of India.
- Based on expert report certifying mismatch in handwriting/signature on application form, OMR, and document verification papers, candidature was rejected by competent authority (Chairman/RRC).
- Recruitment Notice explicitly required candidates to fill application forms in their own handwriting and with consistent signatures, non-compliance with which leads to invalidation.
- Similar cases were dismissed by CAT Chandigarh Bench and Principal Bench (citing Deepak v. UOI, Devendra Kumar v. General Manager/Northern Railway, and Apex Court judgement in UOI v. Sarwan Ram).
- Argued that the judgement in Sandeep Kumar v. UOI relied upon by the applicant was per incuriam and not a binding precedent.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Deepak v. UOI, OA No. 1355/HR/2013 (CAT Chandigarh Bench) | Rejection of candidature on expert opinion of handwriting mismatch without hearing is valid. | Held that similar pleas were rejected, supporting the respondents' action. |
| Devendra Kumar v. General Manager/Northern Railway, OA No. 2356/2014 (CAT Principal Bench) | Expert opinion on handwriting/signature mismatch is sufficient ground for rejection. | Applied as binding precedent to uphold rejection of candidature. |
| UOI v. Sarwan Ram, SLP(C) No. 706/2014 (Apex Court) | Endorsed the principle that expert opinion on handwriting mismatch can justify rejection. | Supported the respondents’ reliance on expert report. |
| Sandeep Kumar v. UOI, OA No. 060/00574/2015 | Orders passed by RRB in similar matters were set aside. | Applicant relied on this judgement; however, it was held per incuriam and not binding. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court carefully examined the Recruitment Notice which mandated that candidates must fill application forms in their own handwriting and with consistent signatures to prevent impersonation. The court noted that a mismatch in handwriting/signatures among the application form, OMR, and document verification papers, when certified by a qualified Government Examiner of Questioned Documents, provides reasonable ground to presume that the applicant and the person appearing in the examination may not be the same. The court found that the rejection was based on such an expert opinion and that similar cases have been consistently upheld by CAT benches and the Apex Court. The court also observed that the applicant had no automatic right to appointment merely by clearing earlier stages of recruitment. The court rejected the applicant’s contention that lack of hearing violated natural justice, implicitly accepting that expert opinion in such cases suffices without a show cause notice or hearing. The court distinguished the applicant’s reliance on the Sandeep Kumar judgement, holding it to be per incuriam and not applicable.
Holding and Implications
The Original Application is rejected.
The direct effect of this decision is the dismissal of the applicant's challenge to the rejection of his candidature based on handwriting/signature mismatch. No costs were awarded. The court reaffirmed existing precedents that expert opinion on handwriting mismatch is a valid ground for rejection without requiring a hearing or inquiry involving the candidate. No new legal principles or precedents were established by this decision.
Rajwant Sandhu, Member Accountant:— This OA has been filed under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 impugning the action of the respondents whereby the candidature of the applicant has been rejected on the ground that “Case rejected by the expert i.e. mismatch in handwriting/signature on application form, OMR & Document verification papers etc. has been reported by Forensic Document Expert duly nominated by Ministry of Railway/Govt. of India and based on this advice, candidature rejected by Chairman/RRC” (Annexure A-11).
2. It is stated in the OA that Northern Railway, Board of Railway Recruitment had issued advertisement dated 30.08.2012 (Annexure A-1) inviting applications to fill 7368 posts in Pay Band-1 in the pay scale of Rs. 5200-20200 with Grade Pay of Rs. 1800/-. The eligibility criteria for the post was 10 pass or ITI or equivalent. Age limit for the recruitment is 18-33 years reckoned as on 01.01.2013, while the upper age limit of the specified categories was relaxed. The applicant being eligible applied under OBC Category. He was issued Roll No. 50067971. As per the schedule, the applicant appeared in the written examination conducted by the respondents on 08.12.2013 and cleared the same. Applicant was called for Physical Examination Test (PET) which was scheduled for 27.03.2014 and he cleared this also. Thereafter, the applicant was called for document verification on 04.06.2014 (Annexure A-5) as per the procedure of selection and pursuant to that, the applicant went to the venue with all the required documents for their verification before the authorities. The applicant came to know from the official website that his documents had been sent to the technical experts for further detailed examination as evident from the copy of webpage obtained from the website of the respondents (Annexure A-6). The respondents again updated the official website with the status that the case of the applicant had been rejected by the experts (Annexure A-7). Thereafter, the applicant sought information under RTI Act as to the ground on which his candidature had been rejected by the authorities (Annexure A-8). The respondents vide letter/reply dated 05.01.2015 (Annexure A-9) informed the applicant that information is available on website of RRC.
3. The applicant then made a representation dated 06.02.2015 (Annexure A-10) to the respondent department requesting that the reason for the rejection of his candidature be explained and why he had not been given any opportunity of hearing before deciding his case. Instead of considering his representation, the respondents informed the applicant through the official website that his candidature had been rejected (Annexure A-11).
4. In the grounds for relief, it has, interalia, been stated that while rejecting the candidature of the applicant, the respondents did not give any opportunity of hearing to the applicant. This action of the respondents was against the principles of natural justice and the impugned order passed by the respondents was liable to be quashed. It has also been stated that no inquiry was conducted by the respondents and even if inquiry had been conducted, the applicant had not been associated with the same. Hence this OA.
5. In the written statement filed on behalf of the respondents, the facts of the matter have not been disputed. It has further been stated that calling the applicant for document verification did not automatically confer any right upon candidate for his appointment on any post of Northern Railway. The Screening Committee nominated by Railway Administration for the verification of the documents observed that there was mismatch in handwriting/signatures and recommended the case for further examination by expert. On the basis of the Committee's observations, the case was sent for detailed examination of the candidate's handwriting by an expert appointed/nominated by Ministry of Railway/Govt. of India. On receipt of the expert's report certifying that on cross verification of original OMR, application and document verification data handwriting/signature do not match with each other, the case was rejected by competent authority i.e. Chairman/RRC. Accordingly, the status of the candidate was uploaded on the RRC Website.
6. It is also stated that the issue involved in this OA is no more res integra in view of the decision dated 2/9.7.2014 of CAT Chandigarh Bench in Deepak v. UOI in OA No. 1355/HR/2013, CAT Principal Bench, New Delhi in Devendra Kumar v. General Manager/Northern Railway, New Delhi in OA No. 2356 of 2014 and Apex Court judgement in SLP(C) No. 706/2014 UOI v. Sarwan Ram Annexed as Annexures R-1, R-2 and R-3.
7. No rejoinder has been filed on behalf of the applicant.
8. Arguments advanced by learned counsel for the parties were heard when learned counsel for the applicant reiterated the content of the OA and stated that he was relying on the judgement dated 4.11.2015 in OA No. 060/00574/2015 titled Sandeep Kumar v. UOI where in a similar matter, the orders passed by the RRB had been set aside.
9. Learned counsel for the respondents drew attention to paras 5.1.2 and 10.10.8 of the Recruitment Notice dated 30.8.2012 (Annexure A-1) that read as follows:—
How to apply:
“5(1.2). Candidates should fill up the application form in his/her own handwriting either in Hindi or in English with blue or black ball point pen only.
Invalid applications:
5(10.8) Applications without signature or with signatures in capital letters or with different signatures at different places.”
Learned counsel stated that as per the expert opinion, the handwriting on the relevant papers submitted by the applicant at the time of document verification did not match and the applicant's case was sent for detailed examination by Government Examiner Questioned Documents (GEQD), nominated by Government of India, Ministry of Railway. On receipt of expert's report regarding mismatch of his handwriting/signatures, the applicant's case was rejected by the competent authority and the status was uploaded on the RRC website. Learned counsel further stated that a similar case had been rejected by the Principal Bench on 27.7.2015 in OA No. 2356/2014 titled Devendra Kumar v. UOI (Annexure R-1). Learned counsel also drew attention to judgement in OA No. 4143/2013 alongwith six other OAs dismissed on 22.12.2015 wherein para 16 reads as follows:—
“16. It is clear that the Chandigarh Bench of the Tribunal in Deepak (supra) and the Principal Bench of the Tribunal in Devendra Kumar (supra) have rejected similar pleas in those cases and, therefore, to the extent that Chandigarh Bench has not taken note of these orders while passing order in Sandeep Kumar (supra), clearly renders that order per incuriam. Thus, the order in Sandeep Kumar (supra) will not act as a precedent and the orders in Deepak (supra) and Sh. Devendra Kumar (supra) will hold the field.”
10. In all these cases, no show cause notice was issued to the concerned applicants, but the expert opinion regarding mismatch of handwriting had been relied upon.
11. We have given our careful consideration to the matter. The Recruitment Notice dated 30.8.2012 requires candidate/applicant to fill the application form in his/her own handwriting in Hindi or in English. A possible reason for this requirement is to facilitate comparison of handwriting on the application form, signature on the OMR sheet and other documents to ensure that no impersonation takes place. In the normal course, signatures and handwriting should match. However, if significant difference is detected by an expert, such as the Government Examiner of Questioned Documents, there is reasonable ground to presume that the applicant and the person who appeared in the examination may not be the same. The candidature of the applicant has been rejected on account of mismatch in handwriting/signatures on application form/OMR and document verification papers. Hence, we are of the view that Devendra Kumar (supra) is applicable to the present OA also.
12. In view of the discussion above, the OA is rejected. No costs.
Alert