- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Red Apple General Trading Fze v. Jinbhuvish Power Generations Pvt. Ltd.
Factual and Procedural Background
The Petitioners filed a Company Petition invoking the jurisdiction under section 237(b) of the Companies Act seeking an investigation into the affairs of Respondent No. 1 Company (R1) and related entities. The Petitioners allege that they invested substantial sums in the Respondent Companies based on representations of high returns, but did not receive share certificates as promised. They discovered that shares were allotted at a premium without their consent and were subsequently fraudulently transferred to third parties without their knowledge or authorization. The Petitioners lodged FIRs and filed a winding up petition against one of the group companies, alleging fraud, cheating, and misappropriation of funds. They further alleged violations of various provisions of the Companies Act by the Respondents and sought directions for investigation under section 237(b) of the Act.
The Respondents filed joint and separate replies denying the allegations, raising preliminary objections on maintainability, locus standi, mis-joinder of parties, and asserting that the Petitioners have suppressed material facts. They denied the existence of MOUs and claimed the shares were allotted lawfully and the Petitioners were aware of the allotment at a premium. Some Respondents asserted that the Petitioners had disclaimed interest in the shares in a civil suit, thus lacking locus standi. Certain Respondents also denied involvement and claimed to be unnecessary parties. The Petitioners filed rejoinders reiterating their claims and denying the Respondents' contentions.
The matter proceeded to hearing where the Court examined the pleadings, submissions, and cited precedents to determine the maintainability of the petition, locus standi of Petitioners, and whether the facts disclosed a case warranting investigation under section 237(b) of the Companies Act.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Petitioners have a cause of action and locus standi to file a petition under section 237(b) of the Companies Act for investigation into the affairs of the Respondent Company.
- Whether the allegations of fraudulent allotment and transfer of shares, mismanagement, and violation of statutory provisions disclose circumstances warranting an investigation under section 237(b).
- Whether the petition is maintainable despite the existence of civil and criminal proceedings involving the parties.
- Whether the Petitioners have suppressed material facts or approached the forum with unclean hands, disentitling them from relief.
- Whether there is mis-joinder or non-joinder of necessary parties affecting the maintainability of the petition.
- Whether Respondent No. 9 (Company Secretary) is liable in the petition or should be discharged.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- They invested large sums relying on Respondents' representations and were assured issuance of equity shares at face value but shares were allotted at a premium without their consent.
- They never received physical share certificates despite repeated demands.
- The shares allotted to them were fraudulently transferred to third parties without their knowledge or authorization.
- The Respondents committed fraud, misfeasance, and violated Companies Act provisions relating to filings and disclosures.
- The Respondents incorporated companies with similar names to mislead and defraud investors and statutory authorities.
- The Petitioners are entitled to invoke section 237(b) for investigation regardless of pending civil or criminal proceedings.
- They denied executing any MOUs relied upon by Respondents and alleged these were fabricated to mislead the Court.
- Respondent No. 9 acted under instructions and is not liable; hence, petition should be dismissed against her.
Respondents' Arguments
- The petition is not maintainable as it does not disclose a cause of action and Petitioners lack locus standi.
- The Petitioners have approached the forum with unclean hands and suppressed material facts including insolvency and criminal convictions of Petitioner No. 2.
- The shares were lawfully allotted pursuant to board resolution and share application, and Petitioners were aware of allotment at premium.
- The Petitioners have disclaimed interest in the shares in a civil suit, thus lacking legal standing to file this petition.
- Several third parties alleged to be involved are not impleaded, leading to mis-joinder and non-joinder of necessary parties.
- The MOUs relied upon by Petitioners are denied and claimed to be fabricated; the persons who purportedly represented Petitioners had no authority.
- Respondents other than R1 are unnecessary parties and have no direct relation to the allegations.
- Respondent No. 9 (Company Secretary) acted in good faith, based on information provided and is not colluding with Petitioners or other Respondents.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Kumaranunni v. Mathrubhumi Printing & Publishing Co. Ltd., (1983) 54 Com Cases 370 (Ker) | Maintainability and cause of action under Companies Act petitions | The Court distinguished the facts of this case from the precedent, holding that the present petition disclosed sufficient cause of action. |
| Kamal K. Dutta v. Ruby General Hospital Ltd., (2005) 124 Com Cases 441 (CLB Delhi) | Maintainability and scope of investigation under section 237(b) | The Court found this precedent inapplicable due to differing facts and upheld the petition's maintainability. |
| Sumathy (U.A) v. Dig Vijay Chit Fund (P.) Ltd., (1983) 53 Com Cases 493 (Ker) | Conditions for ordering investigation under Companies Act | The Court held that the facts here warranted investigation unlike in Sumathy. |
| Rohtas Industries Ltd. v. S.D Agarwal, (1969) 1 SCC 325 : AIR 1969 SC 707 | Investigation under section 237(b) should not be ordered lightly and requires proper grounds | The Court acknowledged this principle but found proper grounds existed in the present case. |
| V.V Purie v. M/S. E.M.C Steel Ltd. & Others, [1980] 50 Com Cas 127 (Del) | Locus standi of Petitioners under section 237(b) | The Court held that Petitioners had locus standi as investors with stake in the company. |
| Sofia Busman v. Union of India, (2002) 110 Comp Cas 710 | Company Law Board's jurisdiction to entertain petitions under section 237(b) | Supported the jurisdiction and discretionary powers of the Board to order investigation. |
| HSBC Private Equity India Ltd. v. Shree Ram Multi Tech Ltd., (2004) 53 SCL 449 (CLB) | Maintainability of petition based on information from interested parties | Confirmed that information from investors entitled the Board to entertain the petition. |
| The Barium Chemicals Ltd. v. Company Law Board, 1966 Supp. SCR P. 311 | Interpretation of section 237(b) and conditions for investigation | Guided the Court in applying the criteria for ordering investigation based on circumstances suggesting fraud or misconduct. |
| Binod Kumar Kasera v. Nandlall And Sons Tea Industries P. Ltd., [2010] 153 Comp Cas 184 (CLB) | Requirement of prima facie evidence for investigation under section 237 | The Court held that sufficient prima facie evidence existed to justify investigation in the present case. |
| Modi Industries Ltd. v. Union of India, (1982) 52 Comp Case 589 (Del) | Grounds for ordering investigation including fraud, misfeasance, and breach of trust | Supported the Court's finding that circumstances justified investigation despite pending litigations. |
| Delhi Flour Mills Co. Ltd., (1975) 45 Company Case 33 (Del) | Investigation warranted if malpractices raise inference of dishonesty or mismanagement | Reinforced the Court's conclusion that malpractices existed warranting inquiry. |
| Rajasthan Ltd. v. Rajasthan Breweries Ltd., (2007) 80 CLA 128 (CLB) | Nature of investigation under section 237 as administrative and fact-finding | Clarified that investigation orders do not prejudice respondents and are administrative in nature. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the pleadings, evidence, and submissions of both parties. It found that the Petitioners had disclosed a cause of action and had locus standi as investors with a stake in the Respondent Company. The Court rejected the Respondents' contention that the Petitioners' knowledge of share allotment at a premium was longstanding and that the petition was filed with ulterior motives.
The Court noted that the Petitioners never received physical share certificates and that shares were transferred without their authorization, supported by documentary evidence including annual returns and share transfer records. It found the Respondents' explanations for share transfers and filing of revised returns to be unconvincing and suspicious.
The Court held that the Respondents' failure to obtain prior permissions for foreign investments and the rotation of invested funds among group companies for personal gains indicated fraudulent and unlawful conduct. The involvement of persons without authority in executing MOUs and share applications further raised doubts about the Respondents' bona fides.
The Court referred to the legal principles under section 237(b) of the Companies Act and relevant precedents, emphasizing that investigation orders require circumstances suggesting fraud, misconduct, or withholding of information. It found that such circumstances were present on the facts of the case, justifying an investigation.
The Court also considered and rejected the Respondents' objections regarding mis-joinder and non-joinder of parties, holding that only the company and its board of directors are necessary parties under section 237(b).
Respondent No. 9, the Company Secretary, was discharged as she acted in good faith under instructions and was not implicated in the alleged fraud.
Holding and Implications
The Court allowed the petition and exercised its powers under section 237(b) of the Companies Act to direct the Central Government to order an investigation into the affairs of Respondent No. 1 Company. The parties were directed to cooperate and furnish all information during the investigation.
Respondent No. 9 was discharged from the petition. The parties were directed to bear their own costs. All pending appeals and interim orders were disposed of or vacated.
The decision directly affects the parties by authorizing a formal investigation into the company's affairs to uncover fraud and malpractice. No new legal precedent was established beyond the application of existing statutory provisions and judicial principles to the facts of this case.
1. The above Company Petition has been filed by the Petitioners invoking the jurisdiction of this bench conferred upon it by virtue of the provisions contained in section 237(b) of the Companies Act. The Petitioners have sought the following reliefs:
a) To direct Respondent No. 10 to seize and take into custody all books and records of the Respondent Companies to prevent the books and records from being destroyed, altered etc.
b) To restrain the Respondent Companies from creating any third party rights of the properties belonging to the Respondent Companies and also restrain the merger/amalgamation of the Respondent Companies with any other Company.
c) To direct the Registrar of Companies, Mumbai not to take on record any of the documents pertaining to change in shareholding pattern of the Respondent Companies.
d) To direct the Respondent No. 1 Company to maintain the status quo with respect to the shareholding of Respondent No. 1 Company as per the Annual Return filed on 22/10/2010.
Case of the Petitioner
2. In brief, the facts of the case as set out in the petition are as follows:—
2.1 The Petitioner No. 2 is a British citizen of Indian origin residing in U.K and he is the owner and manager of Petitioner No. 1.
2.2 The R2 approached the Petitioner No. 2 through one Mr. Sreenath Dwarkanath who was working with the Petitioner No. 1 alongwith his friend Mr. K.V.B Vishwanathan and represented an investment opportunity in one of his Group Company namely Parshwa Agrico Pvt. Ltd. which was engaged in wheat trade business. They represented that if the Petitioner No. 2 make investment in the said company, he would get 30% to 40% profits per year on his investment. Accordingly, the Petitioner No. 1 remitted US $ 9,99,950 to Parshwa Agrico Pvt. Ltd. from its bank accounts.
2.3 After few months of making the said investment, the R2 and his said associates came up with a new idea of setting up a power generating plant in India instead of doing business of wheat and assured that Petitioners may get 10 to 12 times return on their investments. Relying upon their representations to be true the Petitioners further invested an amount of US $ 24,24,200 plus GBP 1,85,000 towards investment in the shape of equity.
2.4 However, the power project did not come into existence for a long time and whenever the Petitioners enquired from the R2 and his Associates Mr. Shreenath and Mr. Vishwanathan with respect to progress of the power generating plant, they kept on pacifying the petitioner No. 2 by giving false promises. Their answers were vague and finally upon the insistence of the Petitioners they informed that setting up a power project is highly time consuming and expensive and therefore the funds invested by the Petitioners have been put in his existing company namely Jinbhuish Power Generations Pvt. Ltd. the R1 Company herein. They further requested the Petitioners to extend further financial assistance in the said R1 Company against the equity shares. The Petitioners having trust upon them made further payments of US $ 8,50,000/- on 5/08/2007; US $ 3,74,200/- on 29/10/2007; and GBP 1,85,000/- on 13/11/2007 respectively.
2.5 Despite assurances to issue the equity shares of R1 Company in favour of the Petitioners, the Petitioners never received any Share Certificates in respect of any of their investments made from time to time. The Petitioners smelt foul play and mind, therefore suspicion arose in their mind. The Petitioners out of abundant caution made enquiries from the Ministry of Corporate Affairs. After making persistent efforts in the month of July, 2010 the Petitioners came to know that 10,07,089 equity shares of R1 Company were allotted to Petitioner No. 1 at a premium of Rs. 105/- per equity share whereas the face value of the share was Rs. 10/- each. The Petitioners were completely taken aback and shocked with the said disclosure as they were never informed about such allotment on a premium of Rs. 105/- per share and this was against their representation and assurances to allot the shares @ Rs. 10/- per share. At no point of time the Petitioner had agreed to pay premium of per equity share and the R2 in fact allotted the shares of R1 Company to Petitioner No. 1 at a premium of Rs. 105/- per equity share.
2.6 Immediately after coming to know the aforesaid facts the Petitioner No. 2 requested R2 to hand over the physical possession of share certificates. Despite assurances, R2 did not deliver the said share certificates. The Petitioners once again met R2 and enquired about the status of allotment of shares against the entire investments made by him and also requested the R2 amongst other to hand over the share certificates. R2 assured the Petitioners that once the Annual Report of R1 company is filed, he would hand over the share certificates allotted to the Petitioner No. 1 and shall also issue additional share of R1 Company against the balance amount for which shares were yet to be issued. However, the Petitioners never received physical possession of shares inspite of the repeated requests and demands of the Petitioners.
2.7 Thereafter, in the month of February, 2011 the Petitioner sought the inspection of R1 company on the portal of the Ministry of Corporate Affairs and were shocked to learn from the Annual Return filed on 22/10/2010 that the said R2 had resigned on 29/11/2008 and was no more a Director of R1 company and that the said shares which were allotted to the Petitioner No. 1 had been fraudulently transferred on 5/02/2010 to Mr. Vishwanathan. It was further revealed that on 25/02/2010 the said shares were transferred by Mr. Vishwanathan to Mr. Nilesh Mehta, R3 herein. Further, the said shares were thereafter transferred by R3 on 10/03/2010 to Aarya Powertech Pvt. Ltd. whose name was subsequently changed to Jinbhuvish Powertech Pvt. Ltd. (R8). Again on 3/06/2010 R8 transferred 24,79,338 equity shares of R1 company to only Gayatri Energy Ventures Pvt. Ltd. which is 100% subsidiary of Gayatri Projects Ltd. a public limited company, equity shares of which are listed on Bombay Stock Exchange. The interest of Gayatri Energy Ventures Pvt. Ltd. in the affairs of R1 Company is represented by one Mr. T.V Sandeep Kumar Reddy who was also a Director of R1 Company since 3/06/2010 till 2/12/2011. It was further revealed that, a Share Purchase Agreement has been executed between Gayatri Energy Ventures Pvt. Ltd. and R1 Company for acquiring approximately 50% of stake of R1 Company by Gayatri Energy Ventures Pvt. Ltd.
2.8 In fact, the Petitioners never signed any Transfer Deeds for transferring any shares from the Petitioner No. 1 to any third person including Mr. Vishwanathan. It is alleged that the R2 amongst the others without the Petitioners' knowledge, deliberately and fraudulently transferred the said shares of Petitioner No. 1 to Mr. K.V Vishwanathan, who subsequently transferred the said shares to different persons and entities of whom all the Respondents directly or indirectly are beneficiaries.
2.9 Having come to know all this fraud played upon the Petitioners, the Petitioners approached the Economic Offences Wing, Crime Branch, Mumbai and lodged FIR against R2 and his associates. The Petitioners have also filed a winding up petition against Parshwa Agrico Pvt. Ltd. During the investigation of the criminal cases, the Petitioners who came to know that the Respondents after receiving the amount did not invest the same in any project. Instead the amount was rotated among the group companies for personal gains of the Respondents. It was also transpired that there were many transactions among the three companies namely [1] Jinbhuvish Power Generation Pvt. Ltd. A/c No. 3095 with National Co-operative Bank [2] Aarya Powertech Pvt. Ltd. A/c No. 3094 with same National Co-operative Bank and [3] Aamrupa Engineering & Mining Pvt. Ltd. A/c No. 3093 with same National Co-operative Bank. It is alleged that the Respondents have thus committed acts of fraud, cheating, misfeasance and the funds which were invested by the Petitioners have been utilized for personal gains of the Chairman and Board of Directors of Respondent Companies and business of the Company has been conducted with intent to defraud the Petitioner No. 2, creditors, members or any other person or otherwise to cause gross loss and injury to the Petitioner No. 2 and others. It is further alleged that the R2 amongst the others have incorporated various companies with similar names and business activities so as to defraud the Petitioners and the statutory bodies like Income-tax Department etc. The Mehta group of Companies consists of around 17 companies and R2 was Director at some point of time or the other in about 36 companies.
3. The Petitioners have also pleaded various violations of the provisions of the Companies Act committed by the R1 Company such as non filing of E Form, Form 23 AC, 23ACA, E Form 66, E-Form 20B, E Form 2 for allotment of shares, E-Form 23 and E-Form 5 as required within the prescribed time limit and has also pleaded that the Respondents have violated the provisions contained in Sections 94, 139 of the Act.
4. It is alleged by the Petitioners that they through their Advocate wrote several letters to the Registrar of Companies, Mumbai requesting for probe in the affairs of R1 Company but no heed was paid to their requests. Hence this petition for direction to the Central Government of India to carry out the investigation in terms of the provisions contained in Section 237(b) of the Act.
Reply of R1 to R3 anri R6 and R7
5. The aforesaid Respondents appeared and filed a joint reply. They have taken common stand and therefore for the sake of brevity, I am describing the pleas taken by them in their defence in short.
6.1 At the outset, the Respondents have raised a preliminary objection to the effect that the petition is not maintainable and liable to be dismissed interalia on the following preliminary objections:—
a. Firstly, because the Petition does not disclose any cause of action;
b. Secondly, the Petitioners have no locus standi to file the present petition;
c. Thirdly, the Petitioners have approached this Forum with unclean hands and have suppressed material and vital facts;
d. Fourthly, the Respondents other than R1 are not necessary and proper parties. Hence the petition is bad for mis-joinder of parties;
e. Fifthly, the Petition is bad due to non joinder of necessary parties namely Parshwa Agrico Pvt. Ltd. Mr. K.V Vishwanathan etc.
6.2 Further, the Respondents have denied all the allegations made by the Petitioners saying that the Respondents made false representation an induced them to part with the amount for investment with 10 times return thereon.
6.3 According to the Answering Respondents, sometime in April, 2006 Mr. K.V Vishwanathan who claimed to be the representative of the Petitioners (Investor Group) approached the R2 and represented to him that one of his close friend is carrying on business of manufacturing, trading, import and export etc. of wheat and wheat products through a company known as Gulf Agro Food Industries India Ltd. He further informed that the said company was facing financial crunch. Consequently, its account had been declared NPA by its Bankers. Since the R2 was also dealing in the same kind of business and he was looking for an opportunity to expand its business, it was therefore decided that Gulf Agro Food Industries India Ltd. would process wheat for the R2's company namely Parshwa Agrico Pvt. Ltd. After some negotiations a MOU dated 8/05/2006 between the two companies was executed. According to the said MOU, Parshwa agreed to supply the raw material to Agro Food Industries India Ltd. for processing and also extended a sum of Rs. 4 crores as financial assistance to Gulf Agro Food Industries India Ltd. Further, on 24/05/2006, another MOU came to be executed between his company on one hand and Mr. K.V Vishwanathan, Mr. Faisal Aftab, Mrs. Chhaya Sreenath (wife of Sreenath Dwarkanath) and Mrs. Rehana Hanif Manjra (Wife of Petitioner No. 2) on the other side by which it was agreed that they would invest Rs. 4.5 crores in Parshwa Agrico Pvt. Ltd. to meet its expenses of supplying wheat to Agro Food Industries India Ltd. under the earlier MOU dated 8/05/2006.
6.4 It is alleged that Mr. Faisal Aftab backed out from the MOU dated 24/05/2006. Therefore, on 27/05/2006 another MOU with identical terms and conditions was executed in between Parshwa Agrico Pvt. Ltd. and Mr. K.V Vishwanathan, Mrs. Chhaya Sreenath and Mrs. Rehana Hanif Manjra. It is averred that though the Petitioner No. 2 was not a party in both the MOU, the remittance of an amount of US $ 9,99,950 to Parshwa Agrico Pvt. Ltd. was made through his companies namely Red Apple General Trading Ltd. and Red Apple General trading GZE Untied States in order to fulfill the obligations of the Investor Group under the said MOU executed in June and August, 2006, The R2 has categorically denied the suggestion of Petitioner No. 2 as pleaded in the petition that in lieu of their investment any shares of the R1 Company were to be issued to the Petitioner No. 1.
6.5 It is further pleaded by the Respondents that the Answering Respondents were inclined to enter into Dower sector in India and therefore in September, 2006 they took steps to change the name and object of one of its Group Companies from Jinbhuvish Engineering Pvt. Ltd. to Jinbhuvish Power Generations Pvt. Ltd. and also incorporated a new company, namely Jinbhuvish Powertech Pvt. Ltd. (R8).
6.6 According to the Respondents, after coming to know their plan of entering into power project, the Petitioner No. 2 mooted a proposal for making investment in the Power Sector. Accordingly, a fresh MOU 24/02/2007 was executed between the NRI Group of investors by Mr. K.V Vishwanathan and Indian Group of Investors represented by the R2 for the purpose of establishing 200 MW project in India. It was interalia agreed in the said MOU that a new company would be incorporated in which both the parties would invest Rs. 82.50 crores each. It is further averred that to finalise the arrangement between the Petitioner No. 2 and the Respondents in respect of their respective participation in the power project a meeting was held on 1/03/2007 between the Petitioner No. 2, Mr. K.V Vishwanathan and Mr. Sreenath Dwarkananth in Dubai. The agenda of the meeting was as to what compensation Mr. K.V Vishwanathan and Sreenath Dwarkanath would be entitled to for their involvement and participation in the said project. In the said meeting, it was also decided that Mr. K.V Vishwanathan and Mr. Sreenath Dwarkanath would represent Petitioner No. 2 and would take all decisions on its behalf in dealing with the Respondents.
6.7 It is next averred that to fulfill its obligation under clause 6(c) of MOU dated 24/02/2007, the Petitioner No. 2 remitted an amount of US $ 12,00,000 through Petitioner No. 1 to the account of P.V Page & Company on 19/03/2007 towards expenses of incorporation of new company and for partial contribution towards its share in equity in the proposed company. However, the said amount could not be credited to the account of P.V Page & Company due to some technical issues. It is stated that since the delay occurred in the incorporation of new company in terms of MOU dated 24/02/2007, the Petitioner No. 2 through Mr. K.V Vishwanathan requested through R2 to adjust the remittance made by him as equity investment in the R1 Company. The R2 agreed to do so but asked the Petitioner No. 2 to pay premium of Rs. 105 per share to which the Petitioner No. 2 agreed. Accordingly, the amounts remitted by Petitioner No. 1 on 19/03/2007, 5/08/2007, 29/10/2007, 13/11/2007 were credited in the account of R1 Company treating as share application money.
6.8 It is the case of R1 and R2 on 12/03/2008 that the Petitioner No. 1 through Mr. K.V Vishwanathan and Mr. Sreenath Dwarkanath submitted an application to R1 for allotment of 10,07,089 equity shares covering the entire investment of Rs. 11,58,15,235/- made by the Petitioner in R1 company. The Board of Directors of R1 Company passed a resolution dated 25/03/2008 and allotted the shares in its favour and also allotted 89,82,911 equity shares in Araya Power Tech Pvt. Ltd. (now known as Jinbhuvish Power Tech Pvt. Ltd. (R8) at a premium of Rs. 105,116 per shares.
6.9 According to the Respondents, pursuant to the above allotment Shares Certificate No. 000005 dated 11/04/2008 was issued in favour of Petitioner No. 1 and same was kept with R1 Company on the request of Mr. K. Vishwanathan as they were the three beneficiaries of the said shares.
6.10 Lastly, it is averred that the Answering Respondents later on came to know that Petitioner No. 2 had been declared bankrupt by Preston Country Court in case No. 0000302 of 2008 though this fact was not however informed by Petitioner No. 2 to the Respondents at any point of time. Certain other allegations have been made regarding the alleged criminal antecedents of the Petitioner No. 2. The Respondents have also referred to a civil suit filed by one against the Petitioners for specific performance of an agreement by which the Petitioners allegedly agreed to sell the impugned shares to the said party.
6.11 The Petitioners filed their Rejoinder in which they have reiterated the allegations and further denied having executed any MOU and alleged that they are all fabricated and got up documents prepared by the R2 in collusion with Mr. Vishwanathan etc.
Reply of R4, R5 and R9
7. The Respondent Nos. 4, 5 and 9 have filed their respective replies denying all the allegations made in the petition against them. The gist of the reply filed by R4 and R5 is that the Petitioner has not made any direct allegations in its company petition against them. It is further stated that the R4 and R5 are not having any personal relations with the R1 or its Promoters. According to them, they were looking for investors in their project and had approached the Respondents with a proposal for investment into R1 Company. It is further stated that during the year 2010, many companies have initiated to develop Thermal Power Projects when Government itself is encouraging the industry by providing necessary infrastructure for the upcoming projects by giving coal linkages etc. When power sector was in the boom in 2010, GEVPL which is a subsidiary of Gayatri Projects Ltd. attracted towards the Coal Linkage obtained by the Promoters of JPGPL from Ministry of Coal and when approached by Mr. Manish Mehta (R2) GEVPL had shown interest to invest in the upcoming Power Project and entered into agreement on May 31, 2010 to develop a 500 MW Coal Based Thermal Power Project at Yavatmal District, Maharashtra. It is further stated that Gayatri Energy ventures Pvt. Ltd. (GEVPL) is a subsidiary of Gayatri Projects Ltd. (GPL) through which the investment in JPGPL (Jinbhuvish Power Generations Pvt. Ltd.) was done in the year 2010 pursuant to the agreement entered into JPGPL, its Promoters and GEVPL to jointly develop 500MW Coal Based Thermal Power Project at Yavatmal District, Maharashtra. It is if further stated that the representations given by the JPGPL and promotes from time to time were specifically made as part of the agreement. Further the investment in JPGPL was done by strictly complying with the provisions of law. GEVPL has acted within its powers given in the Memorandum of Association of the Company. It is further stated that at present the investment in JPGPL by GEVPL was done to the extent of 10% of paid-up of the Company pursuant to Share holder's agreement executed between the “Aarya Powertech Pvt. Ltd. and Gayatri Energy Ventures Pvt. Ltd. and Jinbhuvish Power Generations Pvt. Ltd”. But the agreement was executed to acquire 50% stake in the company as and when required by the project. Lastly, it is submitted that R4 and R5 have not signed any annual return or revised returns filed by the R1 Company nor such returns filed by the R1 are not in their knowledge. It is stated that the allegations made by the Petitioner are baseless and unconnected with the grievance against the Promoters of the R1 Company and therefore they are unnecessary parties and hence the petition is liable to be dismissed qua them.
8. Respondent No. 9 has filed a separate reply in which she sought dismissal of the petition against her interalia stating that she is a Practicing Company Secretary; that according to Company Law once the paid-up capital of the company crosses an outer limit of 5 crores the company is obliged to appoint a full time company secretary on its role; that the R1 company having paid up capital around Rs. 23 cores had an in-house company secretary and it was its responsibility to provide R9 the correct datas; that the R9 has acted upon the data received in bonafide belief; that based on the board resolution she received Form 20(B) relating to transfer of shares as correct she appended her physical signature and uploaded the same; that emphasis by the Petitioner on a printed format Form 20(B) regarding the certification is completely misplaced and malicious; that the R9 has no collusion with the company as alleged and the Petitioners only to settled their dispute with the other Respondents have chosen to make wild and baseless allegations and thus liable to be dismissed.
9. R8 and RIO have not filed their written statement.
10. The Petitioners have filed their rejoinder.
Contentions and Findings
11. I have heard the Ld. Counsel appearing for the Parties and perused the records.
12. Firstly, I propose to deal with the preliminary objections raised by the Respondents. It is contended by the Ld. Counsel for the Respondents that the petition is not maintainable as it fails to disclose any cause of action against the Respondent No. 1. It is submitted that the entire petition is based on allegations in relation to impugned shares of R1 Company allotted to Petitioner No. 1 and its alleged transfer. According to the Ld. Counsel, barring the said instance, all other allegations are bald and baseless. It is submitted that from the reading of pleadings of the petition, it may be noted that all the amounts invested by the Petitioners from time to time were allegedly received by third parties namely Mr. K.V Vishwanath, Mr. Sreenath Dwarkanath etc. towards the alleged allotment of shares in R1 Company. Moreover, the Petitioner has not filed even a single document to support their allegations. It is submitted that the alleged MOUs entered into between the Petitioners and R1 and R2 have been denied by the Petitioners in their rejoinder and further affidavits. It is, therefore, contented that mere allegations are not sufficient to invoke the discretionary powers of this board for the investigation under Section 237(b). The Ld. Counsel has relied upon the following decisions in support of his contentions:
i. Kumaranunni v. Mathrubhumi Printing & Publishing Co. Ltd., (1983) 54 Com Cases 370 (Ker);
ii. Kamal K. Dutta v. Ruby General Hospital Ltd., (2005) 124 Com Cases 441 (CLB) Delhi;
iii. Sumathy (U.A) v. Dig Vijay Chit Fund (P.) Ltd., (1983) 53 Com Cases 493 (Ker).
13. It is further contended by the Ld. Counsel for the Respondents that the Petitioners have even denied the existence of the application dated 8/3/2008 for allotment of shares in their favour pursuant to which 10,07,089 shares of the R1 company were allotted to the Petitioner No. 1. The Ld. Counsel for Respondents has taken me through the record and submitted that the said equity shares aggregating to 10,07,089 were allotted/issued pursuant to a board resolution dated 25/03/2008 in the name of PI at a premium of Rs. 105/- per share as mentioned in the share application form. According to the Ld. Counsel for the Respondent, the Petitioner No. 2 was fully aware of this allotment which is evident from their communication dated 8/10/2010 addressed by the Petitioner No. 1 to R2. It is the contention of the Ld. Counsel for the Respondents that the Petitioners despite being aware of allotment of shares at a premium of Rs. 105/- in the year 2008 have wrongly alleged that they came to know about the allotment in the year 2011 upon making a search of the Website of ROC. It is therefore contended that the Petitioner's alleged knowledge that they came to know in the year 2011 about the allotment of shares at a premium of Rs. 105/- per share is a mere a feeble attempt to explain the delay in filing the present petition with ulterior motives.
14. Further, these Petitioners have failed to produce any evidence to justify their claim for allotment of more shares than already allotted to the Petitioner No. 1. It is alleged by the Ld. Counsel for the Respondents that the intention of the Petitioners in fact is to harass the respondents and extract more money from them than what is legally due to them by using the threat of investigation under Section 237(b) in the affairs of R1 Company. It is therefore, contended that looking to the conduct of the Petitioners, the Petition is liable to be dismissed. In this regard the Respondents have relied upon the case of Rohtas Industries Ltd. v. S.D Agarwal, (1969) 1 SCC 325 : AIR 1969 SC Page 707 whereby it has been held by the Hon'ble Apex Court that unless proper ground exists for investigation of the affairs of a company, such investigation will not be lightly undertaken, since an investigation may seriously damage a company and should not be ordered without proper material gathered.
15. It is further argued by the Ld. Counsel for the Respondents that from the reading of the petition it may be seen that it contains various allegations involving the third parties who are not impleaded in the present petition. According to the Ld. Counsel in the absence of such parties namely Parshwa Agro, Mr. Vishwanathan, Mr. Sreenath Dwarkanath, P.V Page & Co., etc. the petition cannot be decided and therefore the petition is liable to be dismissed as it does not disclose proper cause of action against the Respondents.
16. In reply, it has been submitted by the Ld. Counsel for the Petitioners, that the investment of the amount disclosed by the Petitioners has not been denied by the Respondents. According to him admittedly, no share certificates pertaining to R1 have been issued. It is argued by the Ld. Counsel for the Petitioner, that they never agreed to pay Rs. 105/- per share as premium. According to the Ld. Counsel for the Petitioners upon the representation being made by the R2 to give a handsome returns on the investments the Petitioners; they agreed to advance the amount in lieu of the security in the shape of equity. It is therefore, contended that the Petitioners have made out a case and cause of action has arisen in favour of the Petitioners to invoke the jurisdiction of this Bench conferred upon it by virtue of Section 237(b) of the Act and therefore the petition is maintainable.
17. I have considered the submissions advanced by the Ld. Counsel for both the sides and perused the citations referred to by the Ld. Counsel in support of their arguments, In my opinion, having regard to the pleadings of the petition a cause of action has arisen in favour of the Petitioners for filing the petition under Section 237(b) of the Act. I am not inclined to accept the contention of the Ld. Counsel of the Respondents that the allegations are in the nature of personal character against the R1 Company and have been directed to malign its image or extract more amounts by exerting pressure. There is ample documentary evidence referred to and relied upon by the Petitioners which I shall discuss hereinafter which gives rise to cause of action in favour of the Petitioners.
18. I have gone through the cases of Kumaranunni v. Mathrubhumi Printing & Publishing Co. Ltd., (1983) 54 Com Cases 370 (Ker); Kamal K. Dutta v. Ruby General Hospital Ltd., (2005) 124 Com Cases 441 (CLB) Delhi; Sumathy (U.A) v. Dig Vijay Chit Fund (P.) Ltd., (1983) 53 Com Cases 493 (Ker). I am of the view that the facts of the case referred to above and the facts of the case are different and they do not apply in the present case.
19. The next point argued by the Ld. Counsel for the Respondents challenging the maintainability of the petition is that since the Petitioners have no locus standi to file this petition, the petition is liable to be dismissed. It is contended by the Ld. Counsel that according to the case of the Petitioners the Respondents have allegedly committed fraud upon them. Pointing out the documents available on records, it is submitted that the impugned shares were allotted to the Petitioner No. 1 in April, 2008 and in December, 2010 a suit came to be filed in High court Bombay by one Mr. Iqbal Bux being Suit No. 72 of 2011 for specific performance of MOU dated 30/10/2009 by which the Petitioner No. 1 had agreed to sell the said shares to them. According to the Ld. Counsel for the Respondents, in the said suit, the petitioners have made a statement before the Bombay High Court that they had nothing to do with the said shares. The said statement was accepted as an undertaking to the court as recorded in its order dated 31/10/2012. Furthermore, the said undertaking as recorded in the order of the High Court is final and binding on the Petitioners. Thus, the petitioners as per their own admission do not have any right or title or interest in the said equity shares which are now the subject matter of the petition and therefore, the Petitioners have no locus standi to file this petition. It is therefore, contended, that the petition is liable to be dismissed since the allegations contained in the petition are in relation to these equity shares and if once the petitioners themselves denied their title to the impugned shares, then nothing survives in the petition to be decided.
20. In support the Ld. Counsel for the Respondents has relied upon decision V.V Purie…Petitioner v. M/S.E.M.C Steel Ltd. & Others…S, [1980] 50 Com Cas 127 (Del) and submitted that the petition is liable to be dismissed and the Petitioners have no locus standi to apply to the Court for an order under Section 237(b) of the Act.
21. Replying to the above submissions, the Ld. Counsel appearing for the Petitioners contends that CLB has been conferred powers to deal with the affairs of the Company falling under section 237(b) of the Companies Act. It is further contended that under the said provision Company Law Board could take information from any source including members and creditors or otherwise as if the person providing information has a stake or is an interested party in the Company. It is further submitted that the said civil suit filed by Mr. Iqbal Bux is a got up suit based on the forged MOU which is sub-judice and it has no bearing on this case. Moreover, the Answering Respondents have themselves admitted that the Petitioner No. 1 is a shareholder/Investor. The Ld. Counsel thereby contends that the Petitioner being interested as investor in the company is entitled to file the application and therefore, the plea taken by the Respondents that the Petitioner has no locus is baseless, frivolous and liable to be dismissed.
22. I have considered the rival submissions. In my opinion, the language of section 237(b) of the Companies Act, categorically provides that the CLB may pass an order to the Central Government to appoint inspectors to investigate the affairs of the company and to report thereon to the Central Government. Undisputedly, the Petitioner had invested funds according to the own admission made by the Respondents. Therefore it does not lie in the mouth of the Respondents that the Petitioner has no locus to file the petition. I would like to cite few decisions in support of my aforesaid view:
1. Sofia Busman v. Union of India, (2002) 110 Comp Cas 710: [1999] wherein it is held that the Company Law Board has been specifically constituted to deal with the affairs of the Company falling under section 237(b) of the Companies Act, 1956 and it is only appropriate that such body consider the matter in preference to the discretionary remedy vested in the Court.
2. HSBC Private Equity India Ltd. v. Shree Ram Multi Tech Ltd. (2004) 53 SCL 449 (CLB) (PB) wherein it is held that “the Company Law Board could take information from any source including members and creditors or otherwise as if the person providing information has a stake or is an interested party in the Company”. It was further held that “the Petition was maintainable under Section 237(b) as information was being provided by the interested party to the Company Law Board”.
23. Based on the above, I hereby hold that the Petitioners have locus to file the petition.
24. Next point raised by the Ld. Counsel for the Respondents the Petitioners is that since the Petitioners have approached this Forum with unclean hands and have suppressed the material and vital facts and hence they have disentitled themselves to any equitable reliefs. The Respondents have given the following illustrations to show that the Petitioners have suppressed the following information from the Hon'ble Board:
a. Petitioner No. 2 has been declared insolvent by a competent court in the UK on May 10, 2011. While this fact has been brought to record of this Hon'ble Board, the same has not been refuted and is therefore deemed to have been accepted by the Petitioners.
b. Petitioner No. 2 was also convicted by a court in Dubai and he was sentenced for 3 years of imprisonment. However, since Petitioner No. 2 was absconding, a red corner notice was issued against Petitioner No. 2 by the Interpol, Abu Dhabi and thereby requesting Interpol, New Delhi (by way of a letter dated July 8, 2012).
c. Pursuant to an extensive search carried out by various police authorities (across the world), Petitioner No. 2 was finally arrested by the Police in Abu Dhabi and he is now languishing in the jail.
d. Further, the said Mr. Iqbal Vali Bux has also filed a criminal complaint against the Petitioner No. 2 before the Court of the Metropolitan Magistrate pursuant to which an FIR has been registered by the Agripada, Police Station under sections 406, 420, 465, 467 and 471 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. In this matter, Agirpada Police Station has filed a charge sheet against the Petitioner No. 2 before the Court of Metropolitan Magistrate having found the Petitioner No. 2 has committed offences under the said sections of IPC.
25. Answering the above said charges, the Ld. Counsel for the Petitioners submitted that the jurisdiction of this Bench to pass an order for investigation into the affairs of the Company is independent of any civil or criminal disputes between the Parties and therefore, the pendency of criminal cases or civil cases shall have no effect or bearing on the powers of this Bench to pass an order for investigation into the affairs of the Company. Moreover, the Petitioners have also brought to the knowledge of the Bench that the R2 and R3 through its Group Companies are involved in various malpractices, misdoings and fraudulent activities. According to him, in the year 2004 a CBI Wing raided the premises of Respondent Group and several criminal matters are pending against them.
26. It is further submitted that the suit No. 72 of 2011 is a conspiracy and orchestrated effort by the Respondents in collusion with one Mr. Iqbal Ali Bux to mislead the Court. It is further submitted that in fact Mr. K.V Vishwanathan and Mr. Sreenath Dwarkanath had no rule in the management of the Company and therefore they have not been impleaded. Further, the said persons are co-accused in the criminal complaint filed by the Petitioners as Respondents in the array of the Parties and they are facing criminal investigation alongwith the Answering Respondents against them. According to the Petitioners, in fact all the MOUs agreement which have been relied upon by the Respondents is only an eye wash and an attempt in order to mislead this Bench. He added that the said agreements and forms have not been signed by the Petitioners nor the Respondents have produced any POA to prove that the Petitioners have ever authorised the said persons. He adds that the Petitioners are in no way concerned with Gulf Agro Foods (I) Ltd. It is, therefore, submitted that the allegations made by the Respondents against the Petitioner No. 2 do not have bearing on the merits of the case and on this ground the petition cannot be dismissed.
27. I have considered the submissions advanced by both the Parties. I am of the opinion that the criminal proceedings pending against either of the Parties do not have relevancy in the petition filed under Section 237(b) of the Act. I agree with the view expressed by the Ld. Counsel for the Petitioner that in a petition under Section 237(b) the CLB has to take decision in the facts and circumstances of the given case. For the reasons stated above, I reject the contention of the Ld. Counsel for the Respondents that the petition is liable to be dismissed for the reason that the Petitioner No. 2 has not disclosed material and vital facts in the petition relating to his criminal antecedent and the cases pending against him.
28. The Respondents have also taken objection in relation to mis-joinder of parties. According to the Respondents Parshwa Agro, Mr. K.V Vishwanathan, Mr. Sreenath Dwarkanath, P.V Page & Co., etc. are the necessary parties who have not been impleaded by the Petitioners and in whose absence the petition cannot be decided completely. Similarly it is contended that the R2 to R9 have been unnecessarily impleaded, therefore the petition is liable to be dismissed for non joinder and mis-joinder of parties.
29. I have considered the rival submissions. In my view, in a petition under section 237(b) of the Companies Act, only the company and its board of directors are the necessary parties. Since, there are allegations against R2 to R9 for committing fraud the particulars whereof, are described in the petition, therefore they have been impleaded being proper party Mr. K.V Vishwanathan, Mr. Sreenath Dwarkanath, Parshwa Agrico Ltd., etc. have no connection with the R1 Company. They have never authorised them to have negotiations on behalf of the Petitioners with the Respondents. The Petitioners have denied any association with them. They have also denied having executed any MOU. Therefore, in my opinion, they are not necessary parties. In so far as question of mis-joinder of parties are concerned, the R9 has been arrayed being Company Secretary of R1 Company who had signed certain Forms on its behalf and field the same in the ROC. The Petitioners have made allegations against her, therefore, she is a proper party. I, therefore, hold that the petition is not liable to be dismissed on the said grounds.
30. Now I proceed to deal with the contentious issue in this case as to whether the Petitioners have successfully made out a case for investigation under Section 237(b) of the Act. However, before I proceed, I may like to mention here that in the course of submissions, it was vehemently argued by the Ld. Counsel for the Respondents, that the Petitioner No. 2 is a habitual offender and he has several litigations pending against him. According to him, he was wanted by Inter pole also. On the other side, the Respondents have placed plenty of material on record showing that the R2 was involved in various Economic offences and numerous litigations are pending against him for committing cheating, forgery and misappropriation of funds in respect of which CBI raided his premises.
31. In so far as the Petitioners are concerned, there are only two matters regarding which the documents have been produced to show that he was party in a insolvency petition pending in U.K and the other is the civil suit filed by Mr. Iqbal Vali Bux for specific performance of an agreement in respect of the impugned shares in India. Be that as it may, while adjudicating this petition I am not impressed by the said factors and independent of all the civil and criminal litigations against both the Parties. I propose to proceed to examine the facts and circumstances of this case and decide as to whether is this a fit case for making an order of investigation into the affairs of R1 Company under Section 237(b) of the Act.
32. Before dealing with this issue I would like to reproduce the provision contained in section 237(b) of the Companies Act here as under:—
Section 237: Without prejudice to its powers under section 235, the Central Government—
(b) may do so if, [in its opinion or in the opinion of the Tribunal] there are circumstances suggesting:—
i. That the business of the company is being conducted with intend to defraud its creditors, members or any other persons or otherwise for a fraudulent or unlawful purpose, or in a manner oppressive of any of its members, or that the company was formed for fraudulent or unlawful purpose.
ii. that persons concerned in the formation of the company or the management of its affairs have in connection therewith been guilty of fraud, misfeasance or other misconduct towards the company or towards any of its members; or
iii. that the members of the company have not been given all the information with respect to its affairs which they might reasonably expect, including information relating to the calculation of the commission payable to a managing or other director or the manager of the company.
33. From the plain reading of the aforesaid provision it is thus clear that if in the opinion of the Tribunal there are circumstances suggesting that the business of company is being conducted with intend to defraud its creditors, members or any other persons or otherwise for a fraudulent or unlawful purpose, or in a manner oppressive of any of its members, or that the company was formed for fraudulent or unlawful purpose, the Central Government may order for investigation of the records of the Company.
34. In the present case from the perusal of the material available on record it is clearly proved that the Respondents have allegedly issued at the instance of Mr. Vishwanathan 10,07,089 equity shares of R1 Company at a premium of Rs. 105/- without following the due procedure of law. It is also proved that the inspite of allotment of alleged shares to the Petitioners they did not handover the physical share certificate to the Petitioners till date. It is also clearly proved that the Respondents have transferred the said alleged shares without any intimation to the Petitioners firstly to Mr. K.V Vishwanathan then to R3 and thereafter to R8 without any proper authority or proper documents. From the perusal of the documents available on record, it may be noted that the transfer of the shares are reflected in the returns that are filed with the ROC with the digital signatures of directors. It is difficult to believe the case of the Respondents that the said mistake occurred due to some communication gap, with its Company Secretary. In my view, this explanation offered by them is patently false. It is noted that the two directors of the company have also signed both the revised annual returns. I further find force in the submission of the Petitioners that the Respondents have failed to justify till date the transfer of shares between Ms. Neeta Manish Mehta and Aarya Powertech Pvt. Ltd. (now Jinbhuvish Pvt. Ltd.) and transfer of shares between Aarya Infratech to Aarya Powertech Pvt. Ltd. (now Jinbhuvish Pvt. Ltd.) which took place on 10/03/2010. The Company has rectified this also in the 3 Revised Annual Return dated 10/12/2011 to 3/06/2010 only.
35. Furthermore, the explanation offered by the Answering Respondents that the filing of both the Revised Annual Returns were a mistake in by the Company Secretary in view of the fact that amended Article of Association read with Shareholders Agreement dated 30/05/2010 executed by and between Gayatri Energy Ventures Pvt. Ltd. and R1, R2 and R8 clearly shows that Petitioner No. 1 was not a shareholder on the date of signing of the said agreement. The distinctive number of shares which alleged to be standing in the name of the Petitioner No. 1 is actually standing in the name of Aarya Powertech Pvt. Ltd. (now known as Jinbhuvish Powertech Pvt. Ltd.) i.e R8. Also the said Shareholders Agreement clearly shows that the share holding pattern at the time of execution of Share Holders Agreement, as per Annexure-1 of the said agreement, the share holding pattern upon acquisition of the First Tranche Purchase of Shares as per Annexure-7 of the said agreement and share holding pattern upon acquisition of 50% shareholding by Gayatri Energy Ventures Pvt. Ltd. as per Annexure-8 of the Agreement. All these documents clearly mention that the shares and the corresponding distinctive numbers are held by Aarya Powertech Pvt. Ltd. (now known as jinbhuvish Powertech Pvt. Ltd.) Also at numerous other places in the Share Holders Agreement, Petitioner No. 1 has not been mentioned as the shareholder.
36. In addition to what has been stated above, the Respondents reliance is mainly upon the share application form filed as Exhibit R2/6 alongwith their reply based on which the Respondents have purportedly issued the share certificate. From the perusal of the said application and alleged share certificate the case of the Petitioners appears correct that the said documents have been cooked up in haste to defend the criminal prosecution. This is further corroborated from the facts that the amended AOA which clearly defines the Promoters and the Shareholders does not have the name of the Petitioner No. 1. The Respondents have failed to convince as to why the letter dated 8/10/2010 of the Petitioners by which they demanded share certificate was not responded to them. I also find force in the submission of the Petitioners that serious irregularities and manipulations have been made by the Answering Respondents in the affairs of the Company. The alleged sequence of events relating to transfer of shares pointed out hereinabove does not seem bonafide act. Further, there is nothing on record to show that the Petitioners have given any authority to Mr. K.V Vishwanathan to apply for allotment of shares and/or to sign or deal with any documents in relation to the shares.
37. On behalf of the Answering Respondents it was strenuously argued that before invoking the provisions of Section 237(b) it is necessary for the Board that business of the R1 Company is being conducted with intend to defraud any of its members, creditors or any other person and there are circumstances which justify an order directing investigation into the affairs of the Company. The Ld. Counsel submitted that the provision under section 237 has been interpreted by Hon'ble Supreme in The Barium Chemicals Ltd. v. Company Law Board, 1966 Supp. SCR P. 311 and Hon'ble Supreme Court has held as follows:—
“Para 27 … The next requirement is that “there are circumstances suggesting etc”. These words indicate that before the Central Government forms its opinion it must have before it circumstances suggesting certain inferences. These inferences are of many kinds and it will be useful to make a mention of them here in a tabular form:
(a) That the business is being conducted with intent to defraud—
(i) Creditors of the company or
(ii) Members or
(iii) Any other person;
(b) That the business is being conducted
(i) For a fraudulent purpose or
(ii) For an unlawful purpose;
(c) That persons who formed the company or manage its affairs have been guilty of—
(i) Fraud or
(ii) Misfeasance or other misconduct—
Towards the company or towards any of its members.
(d) That information has been withheld from the members about its affairs which might reasonably be expected including calculation of commission payable to—
(i) Managing or other director
(ii) Managing agent
(iii) The secretaries and treasurers
(iv) The managers
28. These grounds limit the jurisdiction of the Central Government. No jurisdiction, outside the section which empowers the initiation of investigation, can be exercised. An action, not based on circumstances suggesting an inference of the enumerated kind will not be valid. In other words, the enumeration of the inferences which may be drawn from the circumstances, postulates the absence of a general discretion to go on a fishing expedition to find evidence.”
38. Referring the above law, it has been submitted that before making an order the judicial conscience of the Board must be satisfied that there is malpractices in the affairs of the R1 Company according to the Ld. Counsel from the facts of the present case the requirement of clause (b) and (c) of Section 237 of the Act are not attracted. Further, in so far as sub-clause (d) is concerned, the Petitioner has not placed even a single document to show that they had asked R1 Company for certain information but the same has been denied to them. Further, according to the Ld. Counsel the equity shares have been allotted to PI against its investment and the said shares stands in its name, hence the question of defrauding him does not arise. It is, therefore, contended that there are no circumstances which would justify an order directing into the affairs of the company.
39. The Ld. Counsel has further submitted that in the case of Binod Kumar Kasera v. Nandlall And Sons Tea Industries P. Ltd., [2010] 153 Comp Cas 184 (CLB) the then Ld. Member CLB has held as follows:
“The object of an investigation under section 235(2) is to discover something which is not apparently visible to the naked eye. Where a petition discloses merely facts which are apparent from the balance-sheet of the company, an investigation will not be ordered. At least prima facie evidence should exist that the business of a company is being carried on in fraud of its creditors or of persons dealing with the company or otherwise for a fraudulent or unlawful purpose which would lead to the conclusion that an investigation is necessary. There also must be circumstances before the court, which lead to an inference that there has been the type of malpractices by the respondent-company or its directors, which would justify an investigation of its affairs. No jurisdiction, outside the section which empowers the initiation of investigation, can be exercised. An action, not based on circumstances suggesting an inference of the enumerated kind will not be valid. In other words, the enumeration of the inferences which may be drawn from the circumstances, postulates the absence of a general discretion to go on a fishing expedition to find evidence. No doubt the formation of opinion is subjective but the existence of the sine qua non for action must be demonstrable. If the action is questioned on the ground that no circumstances leading to an inference of the kind contemplated by the section exists, the action might be exposed to interference unless the existence of the circumstances is made out. The conclusions must relate to intend to defraud, a fraudulent or unlawful purpose, fraud or misconduct or the withholding of information of a particular kind. In the present case, there is no hint even in this affidavit that the circumstances were such as to suggest fraud, intent to defraud or misconduct, this is to say circumstances under which investigation can be ordered. A court can act only on the materials placed before it; and those materials should at least be such as to satisfy the court that a deeper probe into the company's affairs is desirable in the interests of the company itself. The materials should be such as would result in proceedings being taken under sections 242 to 244; no investigation could be ordered merely because a shareholder feels aggrieved about the manner in which the company's business is being carried on.”
40. The Ld. Counsel has further submitted that Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Rohtas Industries Ltd. (Supra) has observed that “in interpreting Section 237(b), we cannot ignore the adverse effect of the investigation on the company”. He therefore, submitted that the petition deserves to be dismissed.
41. On the other side, the Ld. Counsel appearing for the Petitioners has submitted that the shares have been issued just to avoid the criminal liability by the Respondents in the year 2011. According to him, issuance of shares does not absolve the Answering Respondents from an order of investigation who has committed fraud and fabricated the documents and managed the litigations against the Petitioners to misappropriate of the amount of their investment. Therefore, a case under Section 237(b) of the Act is made out. According to the Ld. Counsel in the present case the Petitioners are the shareholders and they have placed material before this Bench to its satisfaction that a deeper probe into the affairs of the company is desirable in the interest of the company itself. Further, the decisions referred to by the Respondents are not applicable having regard to the facts of the present case. All the above said judgments are rendered in different context and different situation and it is settled law that the law laid down by the superior Court on the basis of facts and circumstance accompanying a particular case, cannot be straight away lifted and imported in a case of different facts and circumstances. Therefore, these judgments do not come to the rescue of the Respondents.
42. I have considered the rival submissions and perused the record in my opinion, the following circumstances clearly suggests that the business of the company is being conducted with intend to defraud its creditors and members and that the persons concerned in the formation of the company have been guilty of fraud, towards the company. It is a fit case for directing an inquiry in the exercise of rights and powers conferred upon me by virtue of Section 237(b) of the Act.
i. The Answering Respondents were fully aware of the fact that the petitioner No. 2 was facing insolvency proceedings in the court of U.K Despite having the knowledge of the fact, the Answering Respondents to protect the Petitioner No. 2 from the process of law allowed him to invest the amount in India as admitted by them in their own Reply Affidavit filed in para No. 30. The relevant extract thereof is being reproduced here as under:—
“Sometime in Docker 2009, Mr. K.A Vishwanathan approached R2 and represented to him that Were were insolvency proceedings filed in the United Kingdom against the Petitioner No. 2 and to safeguard his investment in me R1 Company, it would be approbate if the shares held by him in Respondent No. 1 through the Petitioner No. 1 be transferred in favour of someone trusty to avoid attachment and these shares could be re-transferred in favour of the Petitioner No. 1 after the said insolvency proceedings were over. Believing the said representation to be true and only with an intention of helping the Petitioner No. 2 to protect his investment, the Board of Directors of R1 Company passed a resolution dated 1/02/2010 to seek legal opinion on the issue of transfer of shares held by the Petitioner No. 2 to Mr. K.V Vishwanathan and from him to R2 and from R2 to the R8. It was also decided that the Company secretary of the R1 Company would be requested to file appropriate return of share transfer. For the reasons obvious, this fact and all these documents have also been disclosed by the Petitioners in the present company petition.”
From the contents of the above para, the aforesaid fact that the Respondents had knew the antecedents of the Petitioner No. 2 is established. In my view, no prudent businessman will allow such investment to be made in his company inviting the possibility of criminal prosecution and/or other litigation involving the interest of the Company and its shareholders. It is, therefore, presumed that intention and conduct of the answering respondents were malafide and dishonest since beginning.
ii. Further, entering into alleged MOUs with Mr. K.V Vishwanathan and/or Mr. Sreenath Dwarkanath who claimed themselves to be the authorsied representatives of the Petitioners is a notable question mark. Admittedly, Mr. Vishwanathan and Mr. Sreenath Dwarkanath had no written authority thereby authorizing them to execute the purported MOUs on behalf of the Petitioners. Moreover, the MOUs have been denied by the Petitioners. The petitioners have further denied any kind of association with the said persons. It is further noted that the notary who attested the said MOUs Mr. Maroo has clearly denied the attestation of the MOUs. It is presumed that any prudent businessman before executing such MOUs would definitely exercise due diligence and affirm the background of the investors and check the authority of the person(s) signing such MOUs. Admittedly, no such efforts were made by the R2. This fact further raises strong suspicion and doubt on the conduct of the Answering Respondents.
iii. The transactions made by the Petitioners in favour of the Respondents through the Banks are extremely suspicious and doubtful. It is seen from the perusal of the documents that the amount received from Petitioner No. 1 to tune of Rs. 11,58,15,250 was got transferred in the account of R1 from 30/03/2007 to 20/11/2007. Thereafter, the said funds were transferred in the account of Aamrupa Engineering & Mining Pvt. Ltd. and various group companies of R2. It is further revealed that this amount was not spent in the project of R1 and amounts were rotated amongst group companies for their benefit. It appears that there were many such transaction amoung three companies namely [1] Jinbhuvish Power Generation Pvt. Ltd. A/c No. 3095 with National Co-operative Bank [2] Aarya Powertech Pvt. Ltd. A/c No. 3094 with same National Co-operative Bank and [3] Aamrupa Engineering & Mining Pvt. Ltd. A/c No. 3093 with same National Co-operative Bank. The Respondents have failed to submit any cogent explanation in this regard.
iv. In the disclosure made relating to shareholding pattern of the R1 Company, the petitioner's shareholding has not been reflected leading to conclusion that the intention of the Respondents were not bonafide throughout. Further, acting upon an application signed by Mr. K.V Vishwanathan and Mr. Sreenath Dwarkanath for issuance of the share certificate under their signatures, on the basis of which share certificate has been issued in the year 2011 is also another suspicious circumstance which need to be probed deeply.
v. The explanation in respect of the alleged error committed by the Company Secretary (R9) in filing of Form which according to them occurred due to communication gap does not seem convincing. The gist of the explanation of the R1 Company as it appears from the material available on record is that on 12/10/2010, the company filed annual returns with ROC showing the original position of the shareholders and it was also showing Red Apple as the shareholder. The compliance certificate given by the company secretary and filed with ROC also mentioned very clearly that there was no transfer of shares during the year 2009/2010. In the said returns, there was mistake in the age of directors and hence, two revised returns were filed with ROC on 22 and 26/10/2010 respectively to correct the age of the directors. However, while filing it, the company officials upon noticing above referred resolution of board of directors misconstrued it as if the shares were really transferred and therefore, a chart on plain paper was enclosed showing transfer of said shares from Red Apple to Mr. Vishwanathan on 5/02/2010 and then to others on 25/02/2010 and 10/03/2010. This was done though no shares were actually transferred and even in the share register maintained with the company, there was same position about holding of 10,07,089 shares being held in the name of Red Apple. This was done inadvertently by the company officials. The compliance certificate filed mentioned about dates of board meetings and there were no board meetings at all on the dates on which said transfers were shown. If, the uploading of the revised returns, which was a bonafide mistake on the part of company officials, would have been a deliberate attempt as contended by the Petitioner, then, in that case, the compliance certificate would also have been revised and uploaded. However, since it was never done, it proves that it was a bonafide mistake. This said explanation in my view does not inspire confidence.
vi. The investments made by a Foreign Investor into an Indian Company (the Petitioners being British Citizen) require prior permission and sanction from the Competent Authorities in terms of guidelines of Government of India. However, nothing has been produced by the Parties that they had obtained any prior permission or sanction as required under law for the investments to be made in the R1 Company. In fact this was the duty of the Respondents but by not doing so it can be inferred that they deliberately ignored the law for their ulterior motive.
vii. R2 incorporated various companies with similar names and same business activities. The R2 has been director in about 36 companies. The balance sheet of Parshwa Agrico Pvt. Ltd., which is other group companies of R1 Company if looked into item wise, raise many questions to be answered.
viii. Admittedly, the Respondent Company did not file any annual returns of Form 23 AC, 23 ACA, E Form 66, E-Form 20B, E Form 2 for allotment of shares, E-Form 23 and E-Form 5 required to be filed within the prescribed time limit. The Respondents failed to place any convincing reasons. Therefore, the allegations of the Petitioners that the same were filed with malafide intentions cannot be out rightly rejected.
43. Thus, from the perusal of all the sequence of circumstances narrated hereinabove, it is established that the business of the R1 Company is being conducted with intend to defraud the Petitioner and its members and therefore in my opinion, this is a fit case in which an order should be made for investigation into the affairs of the R1 Company.
44. It may be mentioned here that while dealing similar issues, this Bench in the case Incab Industries Ltd., (1997) 1 Comp LJ 156 (CLB) has laid down that if it is established that the funds have not been properly managed then the matter to be investigated whether the above deeds in particular diversion of funds and wasteful expenditure was intentional and was to benefit to any particular person or persons concerned with the management of the company. It is further laid down by the Hon ble Delhi High Court in the case of Modi Industries Ltd. v. Union of India, (1982) 52 Comp Case 589 (Del) that if the circumstances led to inference that there has been some fraud, misfeasance, breach of trust or misconduct which requires investigation it is not necessary that person concerned should be actually guilty but at least there should seem to be some circumstances which could lead to the inference. It was held in Delhi Flour Mills C. Ltd., (1975) 45 Company Case 33 (Del.) that if the Petitioner will prove some instance of malpractice which would raise an inference of dishonesty or malfeasance or misappropriation or some such similar ground which lead to an inference of mismanagement or oppression then the Court might consider an order for making an investigation. A beneficial reference is also drawn in the matter of Rajasthan Ltd. v. Rajasthan Breveries Ltd. reported in (2007) 80 CLA Page 128 CLB, this Bench is of the view that “An order directing investigation cannot prejudice the Respondents and such order is only analogous to the issue of a fact finding commission. This particular power of CLB is not of judicial or quasi judicial nature but of administrative in nature and initiative to exercise this power may even be taken suo moto or on the application of or information supplied by any shareholder or other person”.
45. In so far as the Respondent No. 9 is concerned, in my opinion, she deserves to be discharged. Lastly, the purpose of filing the petition is liable to be dismissed against R9. She is a practicing company secretary and whatever she did, she has done under instructions of her clients. Therefore the petition is liable to be dismissed against her. Petition is thus allowed in terms of the following order:—
i. in the exercise of the powers conferred upon me by virtue of Section 237(b) of the Act, direct the Central Government to pass an order for investigation into the affairs of the Company and take appropriate action, if warranted, on receipt of the investigation report. The Parties are hereby directed to cooperate and furnish all the information, as they possess, to the Authorities concerned during investigation.
ii. Respondent No. 9 is discharged.
iii. Parties shall bear their own costs.
iv. All the pending C.As stand disposed off. Interim order, if any stands vacated.
v. Let copy of the order be circulated to all concerned.
Alert