- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ram Krishna v. Ram Dulare .
P.P Bhatnagar, J.M:— This is a Defendant's second appeal arising from a suit under Section 229-B of the Z.A and L.R Act.
2. The above suit was filed on October 3, 1958 by Ram Charan and Ram Dularey against Prem Narain and others including the Gaon Sabha and the State for the declaration of rights of one or the other over the land in suit. It was decreed in favour of Ram Dularey Plaintiff No. 2 only declaring him to be the Bhu-midhar by Sri D.D Singh, AC Pratapgarh district, on June 24, 1960. The Defendant's appeal was dismissed by the learned Additional Commissioner, Sri R.K Garg, who upheld the decree by his order dated February 26, 1969. The Defendants have now come up in second Appeal before the Board. During the pendency of this Appeal Ram Gharan Respondent No. 2 died. His son Chiranji Lal shall be substituted in his place.
3. The holding belonged to one Kallu and was inherited by his widow Smt. Sheoraja. On her death her mar-ried daughter Smt. Chandra Kali entered into possession and was held to have acquired Sirdari rights by prescription. She was a patient of T.B On March 17, 1958, when her husband Ram Dularey was in Jail and she was in an advanced stage of the diseases, she was taken to the Tahsil by the Defendants where she obtained a Bhumidhari certificate by depositing 10 times the annual revenue and executed a sale deed of ⅞ths of her interest in favour of the Defendants without any consideration. Next day she expired. The Trial court held the sale deed to be fictitious Having been obtain-ed by fraud, and rejected it. It also held that the Defendants had not been able to, obtain possession.
4. Ram Charan Plaintiff No. 1's claim was discarded as he was not able to prove that he was the brother's son of the last male tenant Kallu. Smt. Chan-dra Kali's husband Ram Dularey Plains-tiff No. 2 was held to be her heir under Section 174 Z.A and L.R Act and the suit was decreed in his favour. Ram Charan Plaintiff No. 1 submitted to the decree which was subsequently confirmed by the Lower Appellate Court.
5. I have heard the learned counsels for both sides and have also perused the records. The learned counsel for the Defendants-Appellants urged that the suit was really for the cancellation of the sale deed and should have been instituted in Civil Court. He cited a decision of the Hon'ble Court reported in 1966 R.D 392 in support of his contention. It was held that where the cause of action disclosed that the relief could not be granted by a Revenue Court then the suit would lie in the Civil Court. In that case the suit was filed for the can cellation of the sale deed and was held to be cognizable by the Civil Court. In the instant case the relief claimed was the declaration Of tenure-holder's rights which could be granted only be a Reve-nue Court and the discarding of the sale deed was a mere ancillary matter. The question of conflict of jurisdiction has been set at rest by a Full Bench decision of the Hon'ble High Court in Ram Awalamb v. Jata Shanker ( . 1968 R.D 470) in which it has been held that a suit would be cognizable by the Court which can grant the main relief if the main relief is cognizable by a Revenue Court the suit would be cognizable by it only, the fact that the ancillary relief is cognizable by the Civil Court would be immaterial for determining the proper forum of the suit. As already noted above the main relief in the instant case was cognizable by the Revenue Court. The learned counsel's plea that the Revenue Court had no jurisdiction is not tenable.
6. The learned counsel also argued that the Courts below arrived at a wrong conclusion about the sale deed. I do not agree. Their conclusion is based on the appreciation of evidence and on the circumstances of the case. The appreciation of evidence cannot be questioned and the finding of fact cannot be reopened and reversed in Second Appeal.
7. Lastly, the learned counsel argued that it had not been established as to when Smt. Sheoraja died and consequently it could not be determined whether Smt. Chandra Kali inherited as a married daughter or took possession without title acquiring rights later on by prescription. This point was not raised by the Defendants-Appellants in their pleadings and no issue on this point was requested. It was not taken up in the First Appeal and no mention even in the memo of Second Appeal. The learned counsel for the Respondent rightly objected that it could not be taken in argument in the Second Appeal. However, I have gone into the evidence. P.Ws 1.3 examined on August 1, 1958 stated that she died 11-12 years ago. D.W 1 in his first statement of May 19, 1968 (back of W.S) denied knowledge and in his second statement recorded on September 5, 1959 he said that she died about 7 years ago. D.W 2 said that he died 10 years ago. Jagmohan father of Defendants-Appellants, deposed that she died 15 years ago. The evidence on record shows that the death took place about 1948. At that time a married daughter was not an heir according to Sections 35/36 U.P.T.A Therefore, Smt. Chandra Kali took possession without title, and nobody challenging it she prescribed her rights and became a Sirdar by the operation of the law. She then acquired Bhumidhari rights under Sections 134/139 Z.A and L.R Act. Being a female tenureholder other than one mentioned in Sections 171/172 Z.A and L.R Act her interest devolved in accordance with Section 174 of the Act. Since she had no children, it devolved on her husband Ram Dularey Plaintiff No. 2.
8. In the result, the Appeal is dismissed with cost and counsel's fee of Rs. 20/-. The records of the courts below shall be returned as early as possible.
9. C.C.O No. 2238 for R.D
Alert