- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kavita Choudhary v. Registrar (Examination)
Factual and Procedural Background
An advertisement was issued on 18.02.2017 inviting applications for the post of Lower Division Clerk (LDC) in various District Judgeships and the District Legal Services Authority. The advertisement cautioned applicants to carefully and correctly fill out the online application form. The appellant, claiming to be a member of an Other Backward Class (OBC), mistakenly selected the option “OBC Creamy Layer” on the form, which disqualified her from receiving the reservation benefits available to OBC candidates who are not in the creamy layer. After the results were declared, the appellant scored 158 marks, one mark higher than the last selected female OBC candidate who scored 157 marks. Upon realizing her mistake, the appellant challenged the decision of the learned Single Judge dated 27.10.2017, which held that as an educated person, she should have been careful while filling the form.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a bonafide mistake made by an applicant in selecting the “OBC Creamy Layer” category, which results in denial of reservation benefits, can be rectified after the declaration of results.
- Whether such a mistake, which does not prejudice the rights of any third party, should be allowed to be cured.
- The extent to which the principle of fairness applies in correcting clerical or procedural errors in reservation category claims in recruitment processes.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant claimed to be a member of the OBC category but inadvertently selected “OBC Creamy Layer” on the online form, which disqualified her from reservation benefits.
- She argued that this was a bonafide mistake and sought rectification to be treated as an OBC Non-Creamy Layer candidate, as she scored higher than the last selected female OBC candidate.
- The appellant sought permission to participate further in the selection process based on her correct category.
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents contended that the appellant, being educated, ought to have been careful while filling the online form.
- They relied on the impugned decision dated 27.10.2017 which rejected the appellant's claim on the ground of negligence in submission of the application.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| State Of Rajasthan & Anr. v. Datar Singh (D.B.S.A.W No. 875/2012, dated 31.07.2013) | Recognition of bonafide mistakes and their rectification where no third party is prejudiced. | The court relied on this precedent to support allowing correction of the appellant’s mistake as it did not affect any third party rights. |
| Dinesh Kumar Mahawar v. RPSC (S.B.C.W.P No. 7159/2017, dated 11.10.2017) | Principle that bonafide mistakes that do not prejudice others should be allowed to be cured. | Applied to justify permitting the appellant to rectify her category mistake and continue in the recruitment process. |
| Shimala Jat v. State of Rajasthan (S.B.C.W.P No. 906/2017, dated 27.01.2017) | Support for rectification of errors in reservation claims when no third party is affected. | Used to affirm that the appellant’s error could be remedied without injustice. |
| Sapana Kumari v. State of Rajasthan (S.B.C.W.P No. 15654/2016, dated 24.11.2016) | Same principle regarding bonafide mistakes and non-prejudice to third parties. | Reinforced the court’s view to allow correction of the appellant’s category status. |
| Arkshit Kapoor v. Union of India (W.P(Civil) No. 3721/2017, dated 31.07.2017) | Consistent approach on bonafide mistakes and their correction. | Supported the decision to enable the appellant’s participation as OBC Non-Creamy Layer. |
| AJAY KUMAR MISHRA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. (W.P (Civil) No. 11642/2016, dated 31.07.2017) | Affirmed the principle allowing rectification of bonafide mistakes not affecting third parties. | Applied by the court to permit the appellant’s claim correction. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court distinguished between two types of mistakes: those that affect no third party and those that do. It reasoned that rectifying a mistake that harms no third party causes no prejudice and is therefore permissible. The appellant’s incorrect selection of “OBC Creamy Layer” was a bonafide mistake that did not prejudice any other candidate’s rights. The court relied on a consistent line of precedents from this Court and the Delhi High Court holding that such mistakes should be allowed to be cured. The court emphasized fairness and the principle that “to err is human,” implicitly endorsing remedial action to correct the appellant’s error. Consequently, the court directed treating the appellant as an OBC Non-Creamy Layer candidate and allowed her to participate in the further selection process, subject to verification of her certificate by the respondents.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is allowed and the impugned order dated 27.10.2017 is set aside. The appellant is to be treated as an OBC Non-Creamy Layer candidate and permitted to participate in the ongoing recruitment process, including the scheduled type test. The respondents retain the right to verify the appellant’s certificate.
The decision directly benefits the appellant by allowing correction of her application error without causing prejudice to others. No new legal precedent is established; rather, the ruling follows established principles permitting rectification of bonafide mistakes that do not affect third parties.
1. For the reasons stated in the application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC, the same is allowed.
D.B Civil Special Appeal(W) No. 1700/2017:
2. Learned counsel for the respondents appears on advance copy of the writ-appeal being served.
3. Heard learned counsel for the parties.
4. On 18.02.2017 an advertisement was issued inviting applications for the post of LDC in different District Judgeships and District Legal Services Authority. The advertisement cautioned the applicants to be careful while submitting their applications on-line and ensure that the form was correctly filled up.
5. The appellant claims to be a member of an Other Backward Class and while filling up the on-line form she wrongly clicked at the option “OBC Creamy Layer”. This made her disentitled to the benefit of being treated as a candidate in the OBC category, for the reason a member of an Other Backward Class, if falling within creamy layer, would not entitle her to the benefit of reservation.
6. When the result was declared the appellant found that she had secured 158 marks in the written examination and the last female OBC candidate selected had secured 157 marks. She then realised her mistake.
7. Vide impugned decision dated 27.10.2017 the view taken by the learned Single Judge is that being an educated person, the appellant ought to have been careful.
8. To err is human. We do not note the second part: To forgive is divine.
9. Mistakes can be of two kinds. First kind would be where nobody is affected by a mistake. The second is where a third party is affected by a mistake.
10. The difference in the two mistakes would be that whereas rectification of the first would cause no prejudice, rectification of the second would cause a prejudice.
11. We find in the decisions dated 31.07.2013 in D.B.S.A.W No. 875/2012, State Of Rajasthan & Anr. v. Datar Singh, dated 11.10.2017 in S.B.C.W.P No. 7159/2017, Dinesh Kumar Mahawar v. RPSC, dated 27.01.2017 in S.B.C.W.P No. 906/2017, Shimala Jat v. State of Rajasthan, dated 24.11.2016 in S.B.C.W.P No. 15654/2016, Sapana Kumari v. State of Rajasthan, dated 31.07.2017 in W.P(Civil) No. 3721/2017, Arkshit Kapoor v. Union of India, dated 31.07.2017 in W.P (Civil) No. 11642/2016, AJAY KUMAR MISHRA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS., passed by this Court and the Delhi High Court, the consistent view taken is that a bonafide mistake which does not affect a third party right should be allowed to be cured.
12. We dispose of the appeal directing that the appellant be treated as an OBC Non-Creamy Layer candidate and we permit her to participate in the further selection process. Needless to state the respondents would be entitled to verify the certificate submitted by the appellant.
13. Being informed that the type test is scheduled for 02.11.2017 we direct that the appellant be issued an Admit Card entitling her to take the type test tomorrow i.e 02.11.2017 The Admit Card be issued today itself.
14. The appeal is disposed of setting aside the impugned order dated 27.10.2017 and allowing the writ petition filed by the appellant.
Alert