Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Smt. B.Leela Rani v. M/s. Sri Adithya Homes Pvt. Ltd.,

State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Apr 25, 2017

STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL FORUM

Telangana

Complaint Case No. CC/288/2014

1. Smt. B.Leela Rani W/o.B. Rajasekhar Reddy, Aged about 52 years, Occupation House Wife, R/o.H.No. 12-13- 677/96/B, Keemthi Colony, Tarnaka, Secunderabad.

Secunderabad

Telangana ...........Complainant(s)

Versus

1. M/s. Sri Adithya Homes Pvt. Ltd., W/o.B. Rajasekhar Reddy, Aged about 52 years, Occupation House Wife, R/o.H.No. 12-13- 677/96/B, Keemthi Colony, Tarnaka, Secunderabad.

Secunderabad

Telangana ............Opp.Party(s)

BEFORE:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B. N. RAO NALLA PRESIDENT HON'BLE MR. Sri. PATIL VITHAL RAO JUDICIAL MEMBER For the Complainant:

For the Opp. Party:

Dated : 25 Apr 2017

Final Order / Judgement

STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION

OF TELANGANA : AT HYDERABAD

CC NO.288 OF 2014

Between :

B.Leela Rani W/o B.Rajasekhar Reddy, Aged about 52 years, Occ: Housewife, R/o H.No.12-13-677/96/B,

Keemthi Colony, Tarnaka, Secunderabad.

1

Complainant And

M/s Sri Adithya Homes Pvt., Ltd., Rep. by its M.D. Sri V.Kota Reddy S/o V.Shiva Kota Reddy, aged about 58 years, # 8-2-323/8/A, Adithya House,

Road No.3, Banjara Hills,

Hyderabad - 500 034.

Opposite party

Counsel for the Complainant : M/s B.Ratnakar Rao Counsel for the Opposite party : Sri G.Ramachandra Rao

Coram :

Hon'ble Sri Justice B.N.Rao Nalla, President &

Sri Patil Vithal Rao, Member

Tuesday, the Twenty Fifth day of April Two thousand Seventeen

Oral Order : (per Hon'ble Sri Justice B.N.Rao Nalla, President)

2

*** This is a complaint filed by the Complainant seeking direction to the Opposite party to pay an amount of Rs.38,96,100/- towards damages to the complainant which she is legally entitled to @ Rs.15/- per sft per month as per clause-7 of the Development Agreement dated 06.03.2007 for 5772 sft., for the delayed period of 45 months i.e., 01.02.2010 to 17.10.2013; to pay interest @ 18% on the said amount of Rs.38,96,100/- from filing of the complaint till realization; to pay an amount of Rs.5,00,000/- towards damages/ compensation towards the mental agony suffered by the complainant and to pay costs of Rs.20,000/-.

2. It is the case of complainant that she is the absolute owner and possessor of plot bearing No.4, admeasuring 508.33 sq. yards in Sy.No.20, situated at Kothaguda village, Serilingampally mandal, Ranga Reddy district, vide document No.7612/1994, registered before the District Registrar Office, Ranga Reddy district, had offered to give the said plot on development along with other neighbouring plot owners to the Opposite party on the basis of 47:53 ratio, to develop the same by constructing multi-storied residential complex on land admeasuring Ac.6-00 on par with international standards, for which the developer has come forward to develop the land by constructing multi-storied building by taking necessary approvals from the concerned authorities on the above said land.

3. Accordingly, a development agreement was executed between the (28) plot owners and the developer i.e., Opposite party on 06.03.2007 registered as document No.6652/2007 on 27.04.2007. As per clause (3) of the development agreement, dt.06.03.2007 the Opposite party shall have to complete the construction of flats in all respects by providing all amenities as mentioned in the development agreement and deliver the possession of respective flats to its owners within two years from the date of sanction plan. The OP had obtained the sanction plan from the GHMC vide proceedings No.G-280/BP/WZ/237/ 2007, dt.30.01.2008. As per said condition, the OP shall have to complete the construction of flats in all respects and deliver the possession within 24 months i.e., by 01.02.2010.

4. As per clause-7 of the development agreement, in case of failure, the OP shall have to pay Rs.15/- per month per sft, from 01.02.2010 till delivery of possession to the plot owners towards damages. As per the ratio of 47:53, the complainant is entitled an area of 5772 sft and

(6) car parking lots towards her share. Subsequently, a supplementary development agreement was registered between the plot owners in the year 2010 wherein the flats have been allotted to the plot owners. As per the said agreement, the complainant had been allotted flats bearing No.A-405, D-608 & E-505, admeasuring 1955 each towards her share. The said residential complex has been given name as "Adithya Sunshine".

3

5. After several oral requests and remainder, the OP had completed the construction of the complex and handed over the possession of the flats i.e., A-405, D-608 and E-505 on 18.10.2013 i.e., after 45 months of delay to the complainant, which amounts to deficiency of service on its part. As such, the complainant is entitled to claim damages @ Rs.15/- per sft per month on 5772 sft., for 45 months from 01.02.2010 to 17.10.2013 which comes to Rs.38,96,100/-. Complainant got issued a notice on 26.09.2014 to pay the damages, which the Opposite party received but failed to comply. For not delivering the possession in time, complainant lost rental income for the said period. Hence the complaint with the reliefs, stated at paragraph no.1, supra.

6. The Opposite party resisted the claim by way of written statement contending that complainant is not a "consumer" of any service and the OP is not "provider of any service"

within the meaning of Section 2(1)(d) and 2(1)(o) of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 and there exists no consumer dispute and hence the above complaint is not maintainable. The grievance, if any, of the complainant falls outside the scope of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 and outside the jurisdiction of the consumer fora to be agitated before a civil court. The main issues are whether the developments and circumstances at the material time had such an impact in the Sunshine project as to derail it whether the three Development Agreements had to be merged and integrated into a single project and whether the interpretation and enforcement of consideration of the Development Agreement as modified is a matter to be adjudicated as a consumer dispute, in view of the observation of the Full Bench of High Court of Calcutta in Ashok Kumar Jaiswal Vs. Ashim Kumar Kar, AIR 2014 Calcutta 92 wherein it is observed that

"the development agreement is also an agreement for sale subject to certain conditions", so also the matters relating to disputes with regard to settlement of accounts and validity of GHMC sanction order. Further, in pursuance of Judgment reported in (2008) 7 SCC 166, the question of jurisdiction has to be considered as a preliminary issue.

7. That the matter involves complicated questions of fact involving evidence and not a summary trial envisaged before the Consumer Fora and requires to be relegated to the civil court. It admitted the ownership of complainant to the extent of 508.33 square yards and giving it for development by an agreement dated 06.03.2007 and entering into supplementary agreement and allotment of flats No.A-405, D-608 and E-505. However, it denied to have not constructed the flat within time with all the amenities.

8. With intention to belittle the excellent execution of work rendered by Opposite party in spite of all odds, the complainant filed the complaint with malafide intention. That the genesis of the Sunshine project started in the year 2006. Sri V.Sitharama Reddy was the owner and possessor of an extent of land admeasuring Ac.12-39 gts in Sy.Nos.12, 13 and 14 situated at Izzathnagar of Hyderabad of which he laid out plots in an area of Ac.3-00 guntas in Sy.No.14 (part) without any sanction of the layout and sold the plots. He came with the proposal to pool

4

together all these plots and go for development. The location was in the neighbourhood of Hi- tech city and expected demand was from software industry. As a large number of owners of small plots are involved, the effort demanded considerable liaison work. After bringing together the several owners of individual plots, the OP entered into development agreement- cum-GPA on 15.05.2006 with land owners christening the venture as "Aditya Exclusive" for sharing of built-up area mentioning the value as Rs.2,000/- per sft. for purpose of adjustment.

9. The above development agreement dt.15.05.2006 generated interest and enthusiasm in various plot owners in the adjacent land admeasuring Ac.3-00 guntas comprising of Ac.1-00 guntas in Sy.No.57 (part) of Kondapur village and Ac.2-00 guntas in Sy.No.20 (part) of Kothaguda village. In this case also, it was not an approved layout. The owners of individual plots, including complainant approached the OP to develop their land as part of the same venture. The OP took initiative to bring together all these owners of bits of plots which aggregated to Ac.3-00 guntas entered into Development Agreement-cum-GPA on 06.03.2007 with 28 plot owners registered as document No.6652/2007 rechristening the venture as "Aditya Sunshine" providing for sharing of built-up area in the ratio of 47% to land owners and 53% to the developer including undivided interest in the land. The value of the built-up area allotted to the land owner is mentioned as Rs.3,600/- per sft. The complainant appears at serial number 5 of the above agreement.

10. The above development agreement was followed by Supplementary agreement dated 12.05.2008 registered as document No.7762/2008, in terms of which, the complainant was allotted a total extent of 5865 sft as against her entitlement at 6140 sft built-up area. As per clause-3 of the agreement, the developer shall stand discharged on construction and delivery of the flats to the owners as per the terms of the principal agreement. So, the OP is discharged from term which requires him to deliver the flat within two years from the date of obtaining permission from GHMC.

11. In this background, adjacent land had to be included in the project to make it viable for the benefit of all. Six land owners adjacent to and abutting Aditya Sunshine venture approached the OP for development of an extent of land measuring 3193 sq.yds in Sy.No.20 (part) on agreeable terms which ipso facto patently reflects the crisis in the economy. Under the impact of recessionary trends, the land owners agreed for only 35% of built-up area towards owners share apart from giving up a built-up area of 100 sft. for each flat to access amenities. In the context of recessionary circumstances and with a view to save the project for successful completion, the OP entered into another agreement on 30.10.2010 registered as document No.10822/2010.

12. Because of the three development agreements, the OP had to integrate all the three plans and obtain a single sanction permit No.9427/HO/WZ/Cir-11/ 2011, dt.20.03.2012. So, two

5

years period started from 20.03.2012 and not from 31.01.2010 as claimed by complainant. On account of global recession, the software industry suffered the worst set back with consequent negative impact on the real estate projects. The vigorous agitation for splitting Andhra Pradesh had the effect of postponement of investment decisions by the prospective purchasers had a devastating impact. On account of fall in market demand due to recession and proposed division of the State of Andhra Pradesh, the consideration mentioned in the Development Agreement could not be sustained and had to be renegotiated between the land owners and the developer. A meeting of the land owners held on 13.12.2009 at the residence of B.Rajasekhara Reddy, husband of complainant, unanimously decided, inter-alia, that all the owners shall reduce their eligible area by 6% on the actual eligibility. As per development agreement, complainant is entitled to the built-up area of 6140 sft and the reduction of 6% on eligible built- up area worked out to 5772 sft. However, under supplementary agreement dt.12.05.2008, the complainant was allotted three flats E-505, D-608 and A-405 aggregating to 5865 sft as against 5772 sft.

13. In terms of clause-12 of the agreement, the complainant was required to purchase the excess built-up area of 93 sft @ Rs.2,900/- per sft by paying Rs.2,69,700/- as the original rate of Rs.3,600/- was reduced as per the minutes of renegotiation between landowners and builder held on 13.12.2009 to Rs.3,300/- and again to Rs.2,900/- in the meeting held on 17.04.2011. The complainant did not pay this amount to the OP towards the excess area of 93 sft till date. She is also liable to pay interest of the amounts due. There was no cause of action which had arisen in favour of complainant to allege delay in delivery of possession, as such, delay did not constitute any deficiency of service. The OP trusted the assurances of complainant that all dues will be cleared as expeditiously, particularly, keeping in view her husband's assurances in the meeting held on 17.04.2011 to pay dues by end of August 2011 itself. The complainant is liable to pay interior costs and amenities amounting to Rs.23,69,700/- as below:

(i) Cost of excess built-in area of 93 sft. Rs. 2,69,700-00

(ii) Cost of interiors @ Rs.6 lakhs per flat Rs.18,00,000-00

(iii) Amenities charges @ Rs.1 lakh per flat Rs. 3,00,000-00

14. As per the value stipulated in the development agreement, the sale consideration works out to 6140 sft x Rs.3600/- (vide clause-12) = Rs.2,21,04,000/-. As per renegotiated price, the revised sale consideration, the cost per sft of built-up area was revised to Rs.3,300/- in the first instance and further revised to Rs.2,900/-, thus, the sale consideration works-out to : 5772 sft x Rs.2,900/- = Rs.1,67,38,800/-. The complainant raised an artificial claim for damages amounting to Rs.38,96,100/- on hypothetical basis. The complainant accepted three flats with total built-up area of 5865 sft but restricted her claim for damages to the extent of 5772 sft when she actually received and retained the remaining extent under her possession expressly admitted that she has not paid the cost of 93 sft to the OP. Thus, the complainant is a defaulter

6

not entitled to any claims.

15. The Opposite party committed a gross clerical mistake and by oversight came to the erroneous conclusion that there are no dues from the complainant though an amount of Rs.23,69,700/- is actually due and outstanding and thus, gave delivery of possession of the three flats namely A-405, D-608 and E-505 to the complainant on 18.10.2013 does not liquidate or discharge the outstanding debt due from the complainant. When there is such a categorical admission on the part of complainant that she remained a defaulter even as on the date of lodging the present complaint, the inference is obvious that OP was not bound to deliver possession but the delivery was only as of grace in view of the oversight.

16. Sharing of built-up area between the landowner and the developer does not involve service within the meaning of the Act, the value of the share of built-up area falling to the share of complainant i.e., the consideration for the development agreement is one of the principal inputs which enters the cost of project and forms part of the pricing of the apartments. The question of jurisdiction should first be decided as a preliminary issue before going into the merits of the case as laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in K.Sagar, Managing Director, Kiran Chit Fund, Musheerabad Vs. A.Bal Reddy and another (2008) 7 SCC 166. Hence, prayed to dismiss the complaint with costs.

17. In order to prove her claim, the Complainant filed her evidence affidavit and the documents Ex.A1 to A5. On behalf of the Opposite party, one B.Sudheer Reddy, its Director, filed his evidence affidavit and the documents Ex.B1 to B9.

18. Ex.A1 is the certified copy of the Development Agreement-cum-General Power of Attorney dated 06.03.2007 registered as document No.6652/2007 on 27.04.2007. Ex.A2 is the copy of no-dues-cum-letter of handover dated 18.10.2013. Ex.A3 is the copy of legal notice dated 26.09.2014 got issued by the complainant to the Opposite party. Ex.A4 is the postal receipt of Ex.A3 notice and Ex.A5 is the postal acknowledgement. On the other hand, Ex.B1 is the copy of Development Agreement-cum-General Power of Attorney dated 15.05.2006 registered as document No.2377 of 2006. Ex.B2 is the copy of Development Agreement-cum-General Power of Attorney, dated 06.03.2007 registered as document No.6652/2007 on 27.04.2007 (replica of Ex.A1). Ex.B3 is the copy of Development Agreement-cum-General Power of Attorney dated 30.10.2010 registered as document No. 10822/2010 on 08.12.2010. Ex.B4 is the copy of calculation after reduction of 6% area, in respect of the complainant's share. Ex.B5 is the copy of Supplementary Agreement dated 12.05.2008 registered as document No.7762 of 2008 on 04.09.2008. Ex.B6 is the copy of proceedings dated 30.01.2008 of the Zonal Commissioner, GHMC according permission for

7

construction of 2 cellar + ground + 7 upper floors in Sy.No.14(P) of Izzatnagar (Vg) and Sy.No.20(P) of Kothaguda village. Ex.B7 is the copy of the proceedings dated 20.03.2012 of the Commissioner, GHMC according permission for construction of Cellar for parking, Ground + Upper (7) floors for residential flats in Sy.No.14(P) of Izzatnagar (v), Sy.No.20(p) of Kothaguda villages & Sy.No.57(p) of Kondapur village.

19. The points that arise for consideration are :

i) Whether there is any deficiency of service on the part of the Opposite party and whether the Complainant is entitled for the reliefs, as prayed for?

ii) To what relief ?

20. POINT No.1: It is not in dispute that the Complainant is the owner of the land to the extent of 508.33 square yards in Sy.No.20 situated at Kothaguda village, Serilingampally mandal, Ranga Reddy district, and she along with other adjoining owners of the land, given their plots to the Opposite party for development under Ex.A1 agreement (Ex.B2). It is also not in dispute that the Opposite party agreed to deliver the possession of respective flats to its owners within two years from the date of sanction plan. Further, it is not in dispute that parties hereto entered into another agreement under Ex.B5.

21. There is no dispute as regards allotment of flats by the developer in favour of the complainant. The only dispute is that the developer failed to complete the construction of the flats within the time stipulated i.e., 24 months with a grace period of three months. In case of failure on the part of the Developer to complete and deliver possession of the respective flats to the owners 1 to 28 within the period of time stipulated, the Developer agreed to pay the damages at the rate of RS.15/- per sft per month or such portion thereof which remained uncompleted and the same is evident from the agreement under Ex.A1 at clause No.7.

22. Admittedly, the developer obtained permission for construction of the subject flats only on 30.01.2008, as is evident from the document Ex.B6. For the delay in delivery of the flats, the developer would resort to global recession and the agitation for bifurcation of State of Andhra Pradesh. Further, the counsel for the Opposite party contend that the question of jurisdiction has to be considered as a preliminary issue while going into the merits of the case. In this regard, we may state that the present complaint is filed claiming damages for delay in delivery of possession @ Rs.15/- per sft for 5772 sft, for a period of 45 months from 01.02.2010 to 17.10.2013.

8

23. For the purpose of computation of pecuniary jurisdiction, the value of the goods or services, as the case may be, and not the value or cost of removing the deficiency in service is to be considered for the purpose of determining pecuniary jurisdiction. Even interest has to be taken into account for the purpose of determining the pecuniary jurisdiction. The pecuniary jurisdiction is to be determined on the basis of aggregate of value of goods purchased or the services hired or availed. In the instant case, the complainant had been allotted three flats total admeasuring 5865 sft i.e., A-405 measuring 1955 sft, D-608 measuring 1955 sft and E-505 measuring 1955 sft. However, for the reasons best known, the complainant claimed the compensation on the built-up area of 5772 square feets only. Initially, it was agreed between the parties that the value of the built-up area would be Rs.3600/- per sft., and later-on, the same is reduced to Rs.3300/- per sft and to Rs.2900/- per sft., as is evident from the documents Ex.B2, B4 and B9. In such a circumstance, the value of the goods or services shall be the same. If the value of goods or services is to be taken as

i) Rs.3600/- per square feet of built-up area, the value for 5772 sft., would come to Rs.2,07,79,200/-.

ii) Rs.3300/- per square feet of built-up area, the value for 5772 sft., would come to Rs.1,90,47,600/-.

iii) Rs.2900/- per square feet of built-up area, the value for 5772 sft., would come to Rs.1,67,38,800/-.

In this regard, we are fortified with the Judgment rendered by the Hon'ble National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, New Delhi in the matter of Ambrish Kumar Shukla & 21 others Vs. Ferrous Infrastructure Pvt., Ltd., decided on 07.10.2016, reported in I (2017) CPJ 1 (NC). Basing on the above, the value of the goods or services along with compensation and interest is considered, the value would exceed the amount shown above. Viewed in any way, the value of the built-up area fell to the share of the complainant would oust the pecuniary jurisdiction of this Commission. Even in the case of Gurdeep Singh H.Puruswani Vs. Runwal Constructions, decided on 10.09.2015, took the same view.

24. Coming to the terms of contract, the same are binding on each of the parties. Clause-3 of Ex.B2 shows that the builder shall complete the construction of the complex within 24 months from the date of release of the permission by the competent authorities. Clause-5 contemplates that the owners shall contribute Rs.1,00,000/- in total, for each apartment, towards all the provisions and amenities like BPCL gas connection, club house and its equipment, cable connections, solar equipments, water softeners, swimming pool, conference hall, library room, reception room with furniture, water, drainage, etc., Further, the owners shall contribute corpus fund @ Rs.20/- per sft., at the time of handing over the possession of flats. Though these contentions were raised by the developer in the written statement, nothing is whispered by the complainant. Clause-13 provides for division of property for which a committee consisting of 5 members was formed including the husband of the complainant herein.

9

25. Clause-22 of the agreement provides for appointment of an arbitrator in case of any disputes. In this regard, we may state that remedy before the Consumer Fora is in addition to and not in derogation of any other Act and reply upon judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court 2012(2) SCC 506 M/s National Seeds Corporation Ltd., M.Madhusudan Reddy". However, there is no quarrel at all on this issue.

26. The agreement under Ex.B5 was entered with respect of allotment of share of the owners in the proposed complex specifying the built-up areas of flats terming the earlier agreement as 'principal agreement'. In support of her allegation that the developer failed to complete the construction of the flats and deliver the possession, the complainant relied on Ex.A1 document. However, this was disputed by the developer contending that as there was another agreement entered into with the landowners under Ex.B3, there occasioned delay and further submitted the delay on account of global recession and agitation for separate statehood of Telangana.

27. Though the complainant would contend that there is delay on the part of the developer in completing the construction and handing over the flats, no piece of evidence is brought on record to vouchsafe the same except the notice under Ex.A3 stating to have served on the developer vide Ex.A6. A perusal of Ex.A6 does not show the seal and stamp of the developer. As per complainant, the stipulated time expired on 30.01.2010. There from, till handing over possession as on 18.10.2013 Ex.A2, no correspondence is made complaining deficiency in service on the part of the Opposite party. Nothing prevented the complainant from making any complaint or addressing the opposite party.

28. On other hand, the developer would contend that the complainant failed to make amount in respect of the excess built-up area of 93 sft, interiors @ Rs.6 lakhs per flat and amenities @ Rs.1 lakh per flat, total amounting to Rs.23,69,700/-. Even then, it had given the possession by oversight as of grace. There is no denial of this aspect by the complainant. However, in the arguments, the complainant contends that as per the minutes of the meeting held on 13.12.2009, the opposite party had failed to complete the project by the end of June 2011, as such, the conditions mentioned in the original development agreement dated 06.03.2007 are applicable and hence, she is entitled an area of 6140 sft., but not 5772 sft. If this is taken to be true, the value of the goods and services would exceed rupees two crores. Further, it is contended by the complainant that instead of paying the costs of excess area of 275 sft., @ Rs.3,300/- which comes to Rs.9,07,500/-, the opposite party had provided the wood work with sub-standard material which is not even the worth of Rs.9 lakhs and that she paid the amount of Rs.3,00,000/- towards amenities. Surprisingly, these facts did not find place in the complaint for the reasons best known. Except making bald and vague assertion that she had paid the amount of Rs.3,00,000/- towards amenities, no particulars of date, year and month are furnished, even otherwise, any piece of evidence to that effect. Further, the complainant failed to respond to the averment that the complainant is due an amount of Rs.18,00,000/- towards interiors.

10

29. A keen perusal of Ex.B8 minutes of meeting held on 13.12.2009, it is crystal clear that the owners were due and payable to the developer the cost of excess area beyond their actual eligibility @ Rs.3,300/- per sft and the owners have agreed to reduce their eligible area @ 6% on the actual eligibility as also agreed to pay the amount of Rs.1,00,000/- by June 2010. From the perusal of Ex.B9 minutes of meeting held on 17.04.2011, it is crystal clear that the owners agreed for compulsory package of flush tanks, AC unit provision and geyser in each flat @ Rs.60,000/- per flat. They further agreed for interior packages of Rs.6 lakhs and Rs.9.5 lakhs including compulsory package of Rs.6 lakhs. And this amount was required to be paid before 15thMay, otherwise, the construction shall be carried-out as per standard specification. Further, the amenities charges are to be paid before 31stMay 2011. Both these minutes of meeting were held at the premises of the complainant's husband at Tarnaka and the signature of B.Raja Shekar Reddy is subscribed on these two documents. Even there is no denial of these documents by the complainant. Ex.A8 and A9 are nothing but they imposed fresh terms upon the contract of delivery of possession between the complainant and the developer, to which they have been assented. Hence, the allegation of delay in delivery of possession on the part of the complainant against the opposite party falls to ground. In the face of an express provision like this, it is not open to the Complainant to contend that the other terms of the agreement are binding on the opponent and is governed by the same. We find ourselves in complete agreement with the view endorsed by the Opposite party that this Commission has no jurisdiction for the reasons already stated. Admittedly, from the inception of Ex.A1, the complainant is represented by her husband in each and every meeting including Ex.B8 and B9. Her husband is a lawman and not a layman and nothing prevented her to address the deficiencies to the developer.

30. Further, a keen perusal of Ex.A6 goes to show that the possession of the flats fell to the share of complainant were handed over on 18.10.2013 after making payment of total dues including charges for amenities and car parking. From the recitals of this document, it can be safely inferred that the complainant made payment of amounts fell due and payable to the Opposite party only by 18.10.2013, which resulted in delay in delivery of possession. Had really there been any delay on the part of the Opposite party in delivery of possession, nothing prevented the complainant from addressing a notice in the interregnum, which she failed to. To decide all these facts as to the entitlement of shares in the property, dues payable by each other and other disputed facts require elaborate and lengthy trial since no evidence is placed on record by the complainant. On the other hand, the Opposite party claims that the complainant failed to make payment of Rs.23,69,700/- which she is liable to which the complainant disputes. To decide all these issues, it is, therefore, in any event, not an appropriate case to be heard and disposed of in a summary fashion. This is an appropriate claim for a Civil Court to decide and obviously was not filed before a Civil Court to start with because, before the Consumer Forum, any figure in damages can be claimed without having to pay the Court-fees. This in that sense is an abuse of the process of the Consumer Forum. In this regard, we place our reliance on the decision rendered by the Hon'ble National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, New Delhi in the matter of Vishamber Sunderdas Badlani and others Vs. Indian Bank and three others, decided on 28.09.2007, reported in I (2008) CPJ 76 NC. For the aforesaid reasons, we answer the point No.1 framed for consideration at paragraph No.18, supra, against the Complainant and in favour of the Opposite party.

11

31. POINT No.2 : In the result, the complaint fails and is accordingly dismissed but in the circumstances, no costs.

PRESIDENT MEMBER

Dated: 25.04.2017

APPENDIX OF EVIDENCE

WITNESSES EXAMINED

For Complainant : For Opposite party :

Affidavit evidence of B.Leela Rani, Affidavit evidence of B.Sudheer Complainant as PW1. Reddy, Director of OP as RW1.

EXHIBITS MARKED

For Complainant :

12

Ex.A1 is the certified copy of the Development Agreement-cum-General Power of Attorney, dated 06.03.2007 registered as document No.6652/2007 on 27.04.2007 executed in between the Complainant and 27 other land owners and the Opposite party. Ex.A2 is the copy of No Dues-cum-letter of handover, dated 18.10.2013 issued by the Opposite party.

Ex.A3 is the carbon copy of legal notice dated 26.09.2014 got issued by the complainant to the Opposite party.

Ex.A4 is the original postal receipt bearing dated 26.09.2014. Ex.A5 is the original postal acknowledgement.

For Opposite party :

Ex.B1 is the photocopy of Development Agreement-cum-General Power of Attorney, dated 15.05.2016 registered as document No.2377/2006 on 15.07.2006 executed in between Vuyyuru Seetharama Reddy and 27 other land owners with the Opposite party. Ex.B2 is the photocopy of Development Agreement-cum-General Power of Attorney, dated 06.03.2007 registered as document No.6652/2007 on 27.04.2007 executed in between the Complainant and 27 other land owners and the Opposite party. Ex.B3 is the photocopy of Development Agreement-cum-General Power of Attorney, dated 30.10.2010 registered as document No.10822/2010 on 08.12.2010 in between Harmeet Singh and other land owners and the Opposite party. Ex.B4 is the Photostat copy of statement of calculation after reduction of 6%, pertain to the complainant.

Ex.B5 is Photostat copy of the Supplementary Agreement, dated 12.05.2008 executed in between the complainant and other 27 land owners and the Opposite party. Ex.B6 is photocopy of proceedings bearing No.G/280/BP/WZ/237/2007, dated 30.01.2008 issued by the Zonal Commissioner, GHMC in favour of M/s Aditya Homes Pvt., Ltd.,

Ex.B7 is photocopy of building permit order bearing No.9427/HO/WZ/Cir-11/2011, dated 20.03.2012 issued by the Commissioner, GHMC in favour of M/s Sri Aditya Homes Pvt., Ltd.,

Ex.B8 is photocopy of the minutes of the meeting held on 13.12.2009 at the residence of

13

B.Rajashekar Reddy, the husband of complainant at Tarnaka. Ex.B9 is photocopy of the minutes of the meeting held on 17.04.2011 at the residence of Sri B.Rajashekar Reddy, husband of the complainant at Tarnaka.

PRESIDENT MEMBER

Dated: 25.04.2017

[HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B. N. RAO NALLA]

PRESIDENT

[HON'BLE MR. Sri. PATIL VITHAL RAO]

JUDICIAL MEMBER

14