- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
STATE BANK OF BIKANER & JAIPUR v. K.K. KACHER
IN THE STATE COMMISSION: DELHI
(Constituted under Section 9 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986)
Date of Decision: 28.3.2017
First Appeal- 609/2013
(Arising out of the order dated 22.04.2013 passed in Complainant Case No. 231/06 by the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum (VI), Vikas Bhawan, New Delhi)
State Bank of Bikaner & Jaipur,
27, Barakhamba Road,
Connaught Place,
New Delhi-1.
…..Appellant
Versus
K.K. Kochar, Sole Prop. Mithasu Export India, G-479, Sushant Lok-II,
Sector-57, Gurgaon, Haryana. .….Respondent
CORAM
1
Justice Veena Birbal, President Salma Noor, Member
1. Whether reporters of local newspaper be allowed to see the judgment?
2. To be referred to the reporter or not?
Justice Veena Birbal, President
This is an appeal under Section 15 of the Consumer Protection Act (in short, 'the Act') wherein challenge is made to order dated 22.04.2013 passed by the District Consumer Dispute Redressal Forum-VI, District New Delhi (in short, the District Forum) in CC No. 231/06 whereby the aforesaid complaint case has been allowed .
1.
Briefly the facts relevant for the disposal of the present appeal are as under:2. The respondent herein i.e. complainant before the District Forum had filed a complaint under section 12 of the Act alleging deficiency in service on the part of appellant/OP Bank in withholding material information with respect to delay in payment of his consignment. It was alleged that the respondent/complainant was the sole proprietor of M/s. Mitashu Exports India, Delhi. The respondent/complainant had entered into a contract with M/s. K.M. Wholesalers for export from India to Namibia of consignment of general household goods like pressure cookers, wall clocks, televisions and casseroles etc. The agreed value of contract was US $ 28816.70 which amount was to fall as due and payable on expiry of 60 days as evidenced by bill of lading. It was alleged that respondent/complainant arranged for the goods under the contract and handed over the same to Shipping Co. (AMI India Logistics Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai) on 23.06.2000. It was alleged that on 24.06.2000, respondent/complainant availed the services of the appellant/OP Bank to forward the documents of the said consignment to the foreign bank of the buyer at Namibia and to collect payment from them upon release by the buyer. It was alleged that the said title documents were received by the foreign bank and accepted by the buyer but this information was not conveyed to the respondent/complainant by the appellant/OP. It was alleged that on 23.08.2000 i.e. a day before the due date of payment, the foreign bank intimated the appellant/OP that the buyer was not having sufficient funds in his account and also sought further instructions from the respondent/complainant but the same were never conveyed by the appellant/OP to respondent/complainant. It was alleged that on 18.09.2000, the respondent/complainant had issued another letter in writing calling upon the respondent/complainant to ask for return of original documents from the foreign bankers. However, no reply was given. The appellant/OP was not taking any action in the matter. It was alleged that the respondent/complainant informed the appellant/OP that on 11.12.2000, the buyer had met with an accident and succumbed to injuries. It was alleged that even after the said incident, several requests were made to secure the payment but appellant/OP did not take any action. It was alleged that a further request was sent by the respondent/complainant on 29.01.2001 requesting the appellant/OP to recover the payment of the consignment with interest from foreign bank and credit the same to respondent/complainant's account within 15
2
days. It was alleged that as many months had elapsed since the death of buyer and his taking custody of the goods and documents, the respondent/complainant requested the appellant/OP only for the payment of money and not for return of documents. It was alleged that the appellant/OP failed to take any action and remained completely silent throughout. It was alleged that the respondent/complainant having come to know that the foreign bank had taken over the properties and assets of the deceased buyer, requested the appellant/OP to press the foreign bank for remitting the due amount to respondent/complainant from the properties of buyer then available with foreign bank. It was alleged that the appellant/OP failed to acknowledge or respond to any of the aforesaid requests of the respondent/complainant due to which effective recourse
for
securing the payment were lost. It was alleged that on 28.01.2005, a legal notice was also served. On being aggrieved with the attitude of the appellant/OP, the respondent/complainant preferred a complaint before the Ld. District Forum and prayed for the award of compensation of Rs. 40 Lacs along with interest @18% p.a. and also litigation costs. The complaint was contested by the appellant/OP by filing written statement wherein it was denied that there was any deficiency in service on their part and prayer was made for the dismissal of complaint. It was alleged that the respondent/complainant was not a 'consumer' within the meaning of the Act. It was alleged that the respondent/complainant had secured the services of appellant/OP bank only on collection basis i.e. for the purpose of forwarding the export bills from India to the designated bank of foreign buyer and collecting the remittance; however no consideration as agreed was ever received for the said work. It was alleged that the appellant/OP had promptly delivered all the communications received from the foreign bank. It was alleged that the appellant/OP forwarded the documents of goods to the foreign bank of the buyer only on the instructions of the respondent/complainant on collection basis only and not on negotiation basis. It was alleged that the messages received from the foreign bank being SWIFT messages were secured and privileged communications and not available to anybody else except the addressee to whom they were sent. It was alleged that as no one except the appellant/OP had access to these messages, they could not be provided to the respondent/complainant by anyone except the appellant/OP. It was alleged that the respondent/complainant was wrong in saying that copies of the SWIFT messages were provided by the Embassy of Namibia as their access was limited to the appellant/OP who received them from the foreign bank.
3.
Both the parties had filed their evidence in the form of affidavits. After hearing the arguments and considering the material on record, the Ld. District Forum held the appellant/OP responsible for its deficiency to respondent/complainant and directed it to pay Rs. 13, 82,400/- being the value of goods and a compensation of Rs. 2 Lacs for travelling expenses and harassment.
4.
Aggrieved with the aforesaid order, the appellant/OP filed the present appeal before us.5. The Learned Counsel for the appellant/OP has contended that entire transaction was for business purposes and thus the respondent/complainant was not a 'consumer' under the Act. On merits it is contended that the entire correspondence with the foreign bank was duly divulged to the respondent/complainant. It is contended that the respondent/complainant has failed to inform the appellant/OP about the delay in delivery of consignment and novation of contract by the buyer which information was received from the Embassy of Namibia vide letter dated 01.01.2001. It is contended that the respondent/complainant concealed this material information in the complaint filed before the Ld. District Forum. It is contended that since the above date, the respondent/complainant had been trying to secure his payment directly without involving the bank. It is further contended that the appellant/OP bank was merely engaged as a collecting bank to act as an agent of the sender and is not liable for negotiating any documents. Accordingly, it is prayed that the impugned order be set aside and the appeal be allowed.
6.
No one has appeared on behalf of respondent/complainant despite awaiting. Perusal of order sheet shows that for the past three dates also no one had appeared for respondent/complainant.
7.
In reply to the appeal, the respondent/complainant has contended that appellant/OP was grossly negligent in not following his specific instructions as well as in failing to intimate the
8.
3
respondent/complainant about the insufficiency of funds in the account of buyer. We have heard the counsel for the appellant/OP and have considered the material on record.9. The foremost question which arises for consideration is as to whether the respondent/complainant is a 'consumer' within the meaning of the Act. In order to answer the aforesaid question, the relevant sub- clause of section 2 (1) of the Act is reproduced as under:
10.
"(d) "consumer" means any person who— buys any goods for a consideration which has been paid or promised or partly paid and partly promised, or under any system of deferred payment and includes any user of such goods other than the person who buys such goods for consideration paid or promised or partly paid or partly promised, or under any system of deferred payment when such use is made with the approval of such person, but does not include a person who obtains such goods for resale or for any commercial purpose; or i.
hires or avails of any services for a consideration which has been paid or promised or partly paid and partly promised, or under any system of deferred payment and includes any beneficiary of such services other than the person who hires or avails of the services for consideration paid or promised, or partly paid and partly promised, or under any system of deferred payment, when such services are availed of with the approval of the first mentioned person but does not include a person who avails of such services for any commercial purposes;
ii.
Explanation—For the purposes of this clause, "commercial purpose" does not include use by a person of goods bought and used by him and services availed by him exclusively for the purposes of earning his livelihood by means of self-employment."
On a bare perusal of the above definition, it is clear that though consumer means any person who hires or avails of any services for a consideration, it does not include a person who avails of such services for any commercial purpose. The explanation attached below the aforesaid clause stipulates that commercial purpose does not include use by a person, of the services availed by him, exclusively for the purpose of earning his livelihood by means of self-employment. It would thus be seen that emphasis is on the purpose for which the goods are purchased or the services are hired or availed.
A similar question has come up before the National Commission in a consumer complaint between the same parties in respect of a different transaction i.e. Kishore Kumar Kochhar v. State Bank of Bikaner & Jaipur IV (2015) CPJ 649 (NC). In the aforesaid case complainant had procured export consignment of food grains from India to South Africa for USD 900 million vide contract dated 08.07.2002. The complainant also received irrevocable Letter of Credit backed specific part consignment. Order was received for USD 2.6 million from M/s Tanaka Resources Ltd. The Letter of Credit was given by ABSA Bank Ltd. The complainant approached the OP bank for obtaining loan facility against the Letter of Credit backed export order. The duration of Letter of Credit was only 45 days and the OP despite being aware of the said fact made the complainant to wait indefinitely for grant of credit in the form of Letter of Credit discounting limit to the tune of about 75% of the irrevocable LC. The complainant had alleged deficiency in service on the part of bank as the OP did not discount the document despite several visits and requests. The National Commission observed that the case was involving a commercial transaction. It was further observed that the complainant himself had admitted in the complaint that he was engaged in the business of international trade of food grains etc. as such the complainant was not a 'consumer'. The complaint was dismissed for want of jurisdiction. In coming to aforesaid conclusion, the National Commission had relied upon its earlier judgments on the subject i.e. Subhash Motilal Shah (HUF) & Ors. v. Malegaon Merchants Co-op. Bank Ltd., I (2013) CPJ 34A (NC), Monstera Estate Pvt. Ltd. v. Ardee Infrastructre Pvt. Ltd, IV (2010) CPJ299 (NC), Pharos Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. Tata Motors Ltd. & Ors., IV (2014) CPJ 525
(NC).
11.
The present case is fully covered by the aforesaid decision of National Commission wherein the parties are same. The respondent/complainant had entered into a commercial transaction with M/s
12.
4
K.M. Wholesalers for exporting from India to Namibia for sale of some household goods. As per the case set up, transaction was for international trade. The services of appellant/OP were taken for commercial purposes. The respondent/complainant has not adduced any evidence to prove that he is a 'consumer' within the meaning of the Act. It is not the case of respondent/complainant that the case falls within the purview of Explanation to Section 2 (1) (d) (ii) so as to bring the respondent/complainant within the meaning of the term 'consumer'.
The Learned District Forum had no jurisdiction to deal with the complaint. We hereby allow the appeal and set aside the impugned order and consequently dismiss the CC No. 231/06.
13.
A copy of this order as per the statutory requirement be forwarded to the parties free of charge and also to the concerned District Forum. Thereafter, the file be consigned to Record Room.
14.
(Justice Veena Birbal) President
(Salma Noor)
Member
5
Alert