Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Tulsa Devi Nirola v. Radha Nirola

Sikkim High Court
May 29, 2017
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This Appeal challenges the Order dated 22.12.2015 passed by the District Judge, East Sikkim, in Succession Case No. 88 of 2015 (Smt. Tulsa Devi Nirola v. Radha Devi Nirola), wherein the Petitioners were denied a Succession Certificate and their Petition was dismissed.

The Petitioners claimed that late Ram Chandra Nirola, who died on 13.4.2015, was the husband of Petitioner No. 1 and father of Petitioners No. 2 and 3. The deceased married Opposite Party No. 1 on 9.5.1987, and Opposite Parties No. 2, 3, and 4 are children from this second marriage. The Petitioners reside separately from the Opposite Parties, who live in a four-storied building at 5 Mile, Tadong, where the deceased also resided until his death.

The Petitioners sought a Succession Certificate for debts, securities, and pension benefits left by the deceased, including Rs. 9,00,000/- in Post Office deposits, other bank deposits, and life insurance. The deceased's monthly pension was not in the name of Petitioner No. 1, and she claimed entitlement as the legally wedded wife without any divorce decree granted against her. The Petitioners requested that the pension be granted in the name of Petitioner No. 1 and that Opposite Party No. 1 be directed to produce relevant documents.

The Opposite Parties admitted the familial relations but denied the claims of the Petitioners. They relied on a "Banda Patra" (Partition Deed) dated 30.6.2008, executed between the Petitioners and Opposite Party No. 1 and the deceased, which settled division of movable and immovable properties. According to the Opposite Parties, the Petitioners received land and Rs. 4,00,000/- as full and final settlement and had no further claims. They also contended that the deceased had nominated Opposite Party No. 1 as his wife and family for pension benefits in official forms in accordance with Sikkim Services (Pension) Rules.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Petitioners, as the first wife and children from the first marriage, are entitled to a Succession Certificate including pension benefits of the deceased.
  2. Whether the prior family settlement ("Banda Patra") executed between the parties bars the Petitioners from claiming further rights over the deceased's movable and immovable properties.
  3. Whether the nomination and family details provided by the deceased under the Sikkim Services (Pension) Rules determine the rightful recipient(s) of the family pension.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The first wife (Petitioner No. 1) was legally married to the deceased and entitled to monthly pension as no divorce decree exists.
  • Pension nominations do not apply to family pension; Rule 40(6) of Sikkim Services (Pension) Rules, 1990 mandates equal shares if payable to more than one widow.
  • The bigger share of immovable property was given to the second wife, while the first wife only received some land and Rs. 4,00,000/-.
  • The Petitioners requested production of relevant documents and family pension be granted in the name of Petitioner No. 1 only.

Opposite Parties' Arguments

  • A Partition Deed ("Banda Patra") dated 30.6.2008 settled all claims of the Petitioners by allotting them land and cash, constituting full and final settlement.
  • The deceased nominated Opposite Party No. 1 as his wife and family for pension benefits in official forms as per Sikkim Services (Pension) Rules.
  • The Petitioners No. 2 and 3 are employed and above 25 years, thus do not fall within the definition of family eligible for pension under Rule 40(1)(b).
  • Rule 38 and Rule 40(12) of the Sikkim Services (Pension) Rules govern nomination and family details, which were complied with by the deceased indicating Opposite Party No. 1 as wife.
  • The Petitioners did not contribute to the deceased's medical expenses and pension benefits were expended by the Opposite Parties.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Pushpa Bai v. Aasbati Laleshwar Naag, AIR 2008 Chhattisgarh 53 Entitlement of second wife and children as legitimate heirs and share in death benefits Distinguished on facts; no prior family settlement in cited case, whereas here a Partition Deed existed settling all claims by Petitioners.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court acknowledged the undisputed fact that the deceased married Opposite Party No. 1 in 1987 and resided with her. The Petitioners lived separately and had accepted the division of property under the "Banda Patra" dated 30.6.2008, which allotted them land and cash as full and final settlement. The Court noted that the Petitioners did not assert claims during the deceased's lifetime and that the Opposite Parties had borne medical expenses and taken care of the deceased.

The Court examined the provisions of the Sikkim Services (Pension) Rules, including Rule 40(1)(b), Rule 40(6), Rule 40(12), Rule 38, and Rule 43(c)(1), which govern family pension nominations and definitions of family. It found that the deceased had nominated Opposite Party No. 1 as his wife and family member for pension benefits, complying with procedural requirements.

The Court distinguished the precedent relied upon by the Petitioners, emphasizing the presence of a prior family settlement in the instant matter, which was absent in that case. It observed that the Petitioners had no further claims to the deceased’s properties or pension after the settlement.

Accordingly, the Court found the impugned order to be a reasoned decision and saw no grounds to interfere with the Trial Court’s dismissal of the Petitioners’ claim for a Succession Certificate.

Holding and Implications

The Appeal is dismissed and disposed of accordingly.

The direct effect of this decision is that the Petitioners are denied a Succession Certificate and any claim to the deceased's pension or properties beyond the prior family settlement. No new legal precedent is established by this ruling.

Show all summary ...

Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.:— This Appeal assails the Order dated 22.12.2015, passed by the learned District Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok in Succession Case No. 88 of 2015, Smt. Tulsa Devi Nirola v. Radha Devi Nirola, vide which the Petitioners were denied Succession Certificate and their Petition dismissed.

2. The parties herein shall be referred to in terms of their appearance before the learned Trial Court.

3. The Petitioners averred that late Ram Chandra Nirola, retired as Divisional Forest Officer, Forest Department, Government of Sikkim, on 30.6.2009 and passed away on 13.4.2015 He was the husband of Petitioner No. 1 and the father of the Petitioners No. 2 and 3. On 9.5.1987, he married the Opposite Party No. 1 and Opposite Parties No. 2, 3 and 4 are children from the second wedlock. The Petitioners are residents of Kaputhang, Upper Taza, Pakyong, East Sikkim while the Opposite Parties reside in 5 Mile, Tadong, East Sikkim, in a four storeyed building, where the deceased had also resided with them till his demise on 13.4.2015, at the Central Referral Hospital, Tadong. On his death, the Panchayat Members of Taza issued a “No Objection Certificate” to the Petitioners to obtain the Succession Certificate for the debts and securities left behind by the deceased, which include Rs. 9,00,000/- (Rupees nine lakhs) only, in the Post Office, other bank deposits and Life Insurance. The deceased also left behind a four storied building at 5 Mile, Tadong, from where the Opposite Parties are now drawing a rent of Rs. 20,000/- (Rupees twenty thousand) only, per month. As all relevant documents are lying with the Opposite Party No. 1, the Petitioner No. 1 obtained information through RTI and came to learn that her name is not mentioned in the Family Pension Order while the name of the Opposite Party No. 1 is entered. As no decree of divorce has been granted to her by any Court, she continues to be the legally wedded wife of the deceased and therefore, entitled to monthly pension as per norms, hence, the prayer for granting of Succession Certificate to the Petitioners and Opposite Parties pertaining to the amount specified in the Schedule to the Petition. That, monthly pension be granted in the name of the Petitioner No. 1 only, and the Opposite Party be directed to produce all relevant documents pertaining to bank deposits of the deceased and original Sikkim Subject Certificate of the deceased.

4. The Opposite Parties filed their written statement and while admitting the relation between the deceased and the Petitioners, denied and disputed the other claims of the Petitioners. According to the Opposite Parties, on 30.6.2008, a “Banda Patra” (Partition Deed) was executed between the Petitioners No. 1, 2 and 3 and the Opposite Party No. 1 and the deceased, duly scribed by one Dilli Ram Nirola, the surviving uncle of the deceased. The said document pertained to the division of movable and immovable properties between the Petitioners No. 1, 2 and 3 on the one hand and the Opposite Party No. 1 and the deceased on the other. The Opposite Parties No. 2, 3, and 4 were minors and thus represented by the Opposite Party No. 1. The Petitioners were fully satisfied by the division made and reflected in the Partition Deed and took over the plots of land located at Kabuthang, measuring 2.2240 hectares and cash amount of Rs. 4,00,000/- (Rupees four lakhs) only, as full and final settlement of their share of movable and immovable properties with the understanding that there would be no claim of any nature whatsoever by them in future. Till the time the deceased was alive i.e 13.4.2015, the Petitioners staked no claims for any pension or retirement benefits. That, the Opposite Parties incurred huge medical expenses on account of the treatment of the deceased and his retirement benefits were expended there. That during his life time, the deceased had personally entered in “APPENDIX 8 FORM 3” the details of his family by indicating the names of the Opposite Parties in terms of the Form mentioned in Appendix 5 of Rule 40(12) of the Sikkim Services (Pension) Rules, 1990 read with Sikkim Services (Commutation of Pension) Rules, 1985. The Petitioners No. 2 and 3 are teachers employed in the Government but failed to contribute towards the treatment of the deceased. That, in all the service documents of the deceased, he had mentioned the names of the Opposite Parties as his family under Rule 40(1)(b) of Sikkim Pension Rules, 1990. The term family includes only widow and children, sons who have not attained the age of 25 years, similarly unmarried daughters who have not attained the age of 25 years. That, in the first instance, as the Petitioners No. 2 and 3 are employed and aged above 25 years, they do not fall within the meaning of family, therefore, the findings of the learned Trial Court ought not to be disturbed.

5. It was vehemently, contended by learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners before this Court that the bigger share of the immovable property was given to the second wife which included a building, while the first wife received some land and Rs. 4,00,000/- (Rupees four lakhs) only. That, for pension, there can be no nomination and nominations are only for the purposes of savings in General Provident Fund and Gratuity. That, in terms of Rule 40(6) of the Sikkim Services (Pension) Rules, 1990, it is laid down that where the family pension is payable to more widows than one, it shall be paid in equal shares. Therefore, the question of nomination for family pension does not arise and hence, the Petitioner No. 1 is entitled to an equal share of the pension.

6. Resisting the arguments of the Petitioners, it was contended by learned Counsel for the Opposite Parties that Rule 38 of the Sikkim Service Pension Rules, 1990, provides for nomination for the purposes of pension. Reliance was also placed on Rule 40(12) of the Sikkim Services (Pension) Rules, 1990, wherein it is prescribed that as soon as the Government Servant enters service, he shall give details of the family in the prescribed form (Appendix 5) to the Head of the Department, in terms of which the nomination had been made. That, Appendix 5 deals with proforma for details of the family. This has been duly entered by the deceased in Form 3, Appendix 8 in terms of Rule 43(c)(1), which prescribes that six months prior to the date of retirement of the Government servant, the Head of Office shall obtain particulars from the retiring government servant. This was complied by the deceased indicating the Opposite Party No. 1 as his wife and therefore, in view of the condition of the ‘Banda Patra’ and the arguments placed hereinabove, it is clear that the Petitioners have no right to the pension.

7. I have heard learned Counsel for the parties at length and considered their submissions. I have also carefully perused the records of the Case.

8. Undisputedly, the deceased was married to the Opposite Party No. 1 on 9.5.1987 and started residing with her at 5 Mile, Tadong. For all purposes, this was accepted by the Petitioner No. 1 as she continued to live alone with her children devoid of the company of the deceased, although allegedly the deceased used to come and visit her. The ‘Banda Patra’ dated 30.6.2008 reveals that a cash amount of Rs. 4,00,000/- (Rupees four lakhs) only, and land measuring 2.2240 hectares at Kabuthang had been made over to the three of them. Thereafter, it was agreed that no further claims to any other property of the deceased would be made by them.

9. In the Judgment relied on by learned Senior Counsel for the Appellants/Petitioners, being AIR 2008 Chhattisgarh 53: Smt. Pushpa Bai v. Aasbati Laleshwar Naag, the facts therein were that the deceased had nominated his mother and not his second wife, the Applicant No. 1 for receiving the death benefits. The Court held that although Applicants 3 to 5 were children borne by his second wife, the Applicant No. 1, whom he had married during the subsistence of his first marriage, they are his legitimate children and Class 1 heirs along with the mother of the deceased. It was ordered that besides the first wife of the deceased, the Applicant No. 2, his second wife and Applicants No. 3, 4 and 5 were also entitled to 1/5 share each in the death benefits of the deceased. The facts therein are distinguishable from the Case at hand. There appears to be no prior family settlement between the parties with regard to any property of the deceased, whereas in the instant matter vide the ‘Banda Patra’, it was agreed between the Petitioners and the Opposite Parties that as the Petitioners had received their share of movable and immovable properties from the deceased, they were satisfied and would have no grievances whatsoever in future. Apart from which, it is an admitted fact that the Opposite Party No. 1 and the deceased were married as far back in 9.5.1987 and had been living together, while the Petitioners had nothing to do with the Opposite Parties, herein. Therefore, as pointed out by the learned Trial Court, the deceased was taken care of throughout by the Opposite Parties and therefore, it would not be proper to permit the Petitioners to suddenly appear after the death of Ram Chandra Nirola and stake a claim over his properties/securities and pension. The deceased was not found mentally infirm when he made the nomination and no suspicion should rear its head on this count.

10. Hence, in consideration of the entirety of the facts and circumstances hereinabove, I find that the impugned Order of the learned Trial Court is a reasoned Order and therefore, brooks no interference.

11. Appeal dismissed and disposed of accordingly.

12. No order as to costs.

13. Records of the learned Trial Court be returned forthwith.