- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M/S. Himachal Futuristic Petitioner v. I.T.I Ltd.
Judicial Opinion Summary — I.A. No. 1105/2017 (Jayant Nath, J., Oral)
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner filed objections under section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act to an arbitral award dated 07.07.2012. This application (I.A. No. 1105/2017) seeks condonation under Section 5 of the Limitation Act for a delay of 40 days in re-filing those objections.
A Single Judge of this court had earlier, on 09.01.2015, allowed an application noting a genuine issue regarding registry objections about court fees payable on the award; the Single Judge concluded sufficient cause existed to condone delay and allowed re-filing. That order was challenged before a Division Bench, which on 07.04.2015 observed that the Single Judge had not considered the specific period from 09.10.2012 to 27.11.2012 and remitted the matter for fresh consideration of the explanation for delay during that period, permitting the petitioner to file an additional affidavit.
In compliance with that direction, the petitioner filed an additional affidavit explaining the reasons for the delay during 09.10.2012 to 27.11.2012. The present hearing is confined to considering whether the delay in re-filing for that period should be condoned.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner has shown sufficient cause to condone a 40-day delay in re-filing objections under section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act by invoking Section 5 of the Limitation Act, specifically for the period 09.10.2012 to 27.11.2012.
- Whether the explanations offered (ambiguity due to a newly introduced filing format, festive-season vacations and office closures, accidental misplacement of papers, and absence of the counsel's clerk) amount to "sufficient cause" and demonstrate due diligence so as to justify condonation of the delay.
- How the established legal principles and precedents on condonation of delay in re-filing under section 34 (as explained by the Division Bench in relevant authorities) apply to the facts of this case.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The Registry raised objections on 09.10.2012 primarily about a newly introduced filing "new format" for petitions/objections; there was ambiguity among practitioners as to the correct procedure/format, necessitating inquiries and reformatting of the petition.
- During the period 09.10.2012 to 27.11.2012 there were multiple festivals (Dussehra, Eid, Diwali, Moharram, Guru Nanak’s Birthday) and associated vacations/closures; the court and the counsel's office remained closed during Dussehra and Diwali vacations.
- Documents pertaining to the case were accidentally misplaced during this period.
- The counsel's clerk went to his hometown (Uttarakhand) to celebrate Diwali and returned only after the festival period, contributing to the delay.
- Time was consumed in attempting to remove or address the objections raised by the Registry.
Respondent's Arguments
- The learned senior counsel for the respondent vehemently opposed condonation of the delay in re-filing the objections.
- The respondent relied on multiple judgments of this court (and other authorities) to oppose condonation; the opinion specifically lists the cases relied upon by the respondent (see the precedents table below for the list).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Gautam Associates v. Food Corporation Of India, 2009 (111) DRJ 274 | Relied upon by the respondent in opposing condonation of delay. | The court records that the respondent relied on this judgment; the opinion does not spell out the specific principle drawn from it beyond its use in opposition. |
| Prakash Atlanta JV v. National Highways Authority of India, EFA (OS) No. 4 of 2013 dated 12.02.2013 | Relied upon by the respondent in opposing condonation of delay. | Noted as one of several authorities the respondent cited; the opinion does not extract a specific rule from it for separate application. |
| NTPC Limited v. Gannon Dunkerley & Co. Ltd., FAO (OS) No. 89 of 2013 dated 12.02.2013 | Relied upon by the respondent in opposing condonation of delay. | Cited by the respondent; the court's opinion records the reliance but does not elaborate a distinct application from this case. |
| Union Of India v. Popular Construction Co., AIR 2001 SC 4010 | Relied upon by the respondent in opposing condonation of delay. | Included in the respondent's list of authorities; the opinion does not state the specific principle taken from this Supreme Court decision beyond its citation in opposition. |
| Delhi Transco Ltd. & Anr. v. Hythro Engineers Pvt. Ltd., 2012 (3) ARBLR 349 (Delhi) | Relied upon by the respondent in opposing condonation of delay. | Recorded among the respondent's cited authorities; the court does not detail a discrete application from this judgment in the opinion text. |
| Executive Engineer (Irrigation & Flood Control) v. Shree Ram Construction Co., 2010 (10) AD Delhi 180 | Relied upon by the respondent in opposing condonation of delay. | Listed by the respondent; the opinion notes the citation but does not elaborate further in the reasoning section. |
| Union Of India v. M/s Harbhagwan Harbhajan Lal, O.M.P No. 30 of 2010, dated 11.03.2010 | Relied upon by the respondent in opposing condonation of delay. | Included in the respondent's reliance list; the opinion does not specify a distinct principle used from this case. |
| Delhi Development Authority v. Durga Construction Co., ILR (2014) 1 Delhi 153 | Sets out the Division Bench's settled legal position regarding condonation of delay in re-filing under section 34 — courts have jurisdiction to condone delay in re-filing but must test applicant's conduct for due diligence; condonation jurisdiction is not to be exercised liberally. | The court relies on this Division Bench decision as the settled legal framework for considering condonation of delay in re-filing. The opinion quotes and applies the principles from this authority when assessing whether the petitioner acted with due diligence and whether the reasons for delay qualify as beyond the applicant's control. |
| Competent Placement Services (through its Director/Partner) v. Delhi Transport Corporation through its Chairman, 2011 (2) R.A.J. 347 (Del) | Cited within the quoted passage in the Division Bench reasoning (as authority on limits of condonation and that re-filing cannot be permitted indefinitely without explanation). | Referenced in the DDA v. Durga Construction Co. exposition quoted by the court; used to underline that condonation of re-filing delay is subject to strict scrutiny and is not to allow indefinite unexplained delays. |
| Northern Railway v. Pioneer Publicity Corp. Pvt. Ltd., Civil Appeal No. 10340 of 2016 (Supreme Court) | Addressed condonation of 65 days in re-filing under section 34; contains analysis that Section 34(3) applies to initial filing and may have no direct application to re-filing; shows Supreme Court's approach to refiling and condonation in the particular facts considered. | The court referred to this Supreme Court decision and reproduced parts of its reasoning. The opinion treats it as persuasive in considering whether Section 34(3) is applicable to re-filing and in assessing explanations tendered for delay; the decision supported the view that re-filing may be treated differently from initial filing depending on circumstances and explanations offered. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in the following analytical steps (as set out in the opinion):
- Scope limited by Division Bench: The only matter for fresh consideration was the petitioner's explanation for the period 09.10.2012 to 27.11.2012, as remitted by the Division Bench on 07.04.2015. The court confined its assessment to that period and to the additional affidavit filed pursuant to the Division Bench's direction.
- Examination of the petitioner's additional affidavit: The affidavit explained the delay by reference to (a) confusion and reformatting required by a newly introduced filing format or procedure, (b) multiple festivals and attendant closures (Dussehra, Eid, Diwali, Moharram, Guru Nanak’s Birthday), (c) accidental misplacement of papers, (d) the counsel's clerk being away in his hometown during Diwali, and (e) time consumed in attempting to remove registry objections.
- Consideration of respondent's opposition and authorities: The respondent strongly opposed condonation and relied on a number of judgments. The court recorded those authorities and considered the established line of reasoning from the Division Bench decision in Delhi Development Authority v. Durga Construction Co., which articulates the legal framework for condoning delay in re-filing under section 34.
- Application of the legal framework from DDA v. Durga Construction Co.: The court applied the Division Bench's guidance that while courts retain jurisdiction to condone delay in re-filing, that jurisdiction should not be exercised liberally; the applicant must show due diligence and that the delay was due to reasons beyond the applicant's control and could not have been avoided despite all possible efforts. The court expressly referred to and relied upon those paragraphs from the DDA decision.
- Consideration of Supreme Court guidance in Northern Railway: The court also referred to the Supreme Court's treatment of re-filing in Northern Railway v. Pioneer Publicity, which dealt with a 65-day delay and observed that Section 34(3) applies to initial filing of an application under section 34 and may not have direct application to re-filing. The opinion reproduces and treats that reasoning as relevant context in assessing whether the explanation suffices in the circumstances.
- Assessment and conclusion: Having regard to the petitioner's explanation (new format ambiguity and associated reformatting, festivals and office closures, misplacement of papers, absence of clerk, time spent addressing registry objections) and the legal standards from the cited authorities, the court concluded that sufficient reasons were furnished to condone the delay for the period in question. The court also noted that the award is in favour of the petitioner and that the respondent's objections under section 34 remain pending, a fact bearing on the interest of justice in allowing the re-filing.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The application is allowed and the delay in re-filing the objections under section 34 is condoned for the period in question.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The petitioner is permitted to re-file its objections; the 40-day delay in re-filing for the period 09.10.2012 to 27.11.2012 is formally condoned by the court. The respondent's objections under section 34 remain pending and the matter proceeds accordingly.
- Broader precedent: The opinion applies and relies upon existing authorities (notably Delhi Development Authority v. Durga Construction Co. and the Supreme Court's reasoning in Northern Railway) in reaching its conclusion. The court did not purport to lay down a new legal principle or overrule existing authorities; rather it applied the settled principles to the facts of this case. Therefore, no new precedent is articulated beyond the application of established law to these facts.
Administrative note in the file: OMP 54/2013 — case to be listed on 21.08.2017.
Jayant Nath, J. (Oral)
I.A No. 1105/2017
1. This is an application filed under Section 5 of the Limitation Act seeking condonation of delay of 40 days in re-filing of the objections under section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act.
2. The petitioner has filed objections to the award dated 07.07.2012 The dispute centres around the delay in re-filing of the objections. This court on 09.01.2015 allowed this application noting that there was a genuine issue regarding objections raised by the Registry about the court fees that was required to be paid on the amount awarded by the arbitrator. The court concluded that sufficient cause has been shown by the petitioner to condone the delay in re-filing the objections and allowed the application.
3. The above order of this court was impugned before the Division Bench. The Division Bench on 07.04.2015 concluded that the delay in refiling for the period between 09.10.2012 to 27.11.2012 has not been considered by the learned Single Judge. Hence, the matter was remitted back to consider the application a fresh regarding delay in re-filing of the objections for the said period in question. The petitioner was permitted to file an additional affidavit giving explanation for the period in question.
4. Hence, the present arguments are confined only to the directions of the Division Bench dated 07.04.2015 whereby the explanation of the petitioner for the period from 09.10.2012 to 27.11.2012 for condonation of delay in re-filing the objections has to be considered.
5. In compliance with the directions of the Division Bench dated 07.04.2015, the petitioner has filed an additional affidavit. The additional affidavit states that in terms of the objections raised by the Registry on 09.10.2012, the main objection raised was regarding the ‘new format’ which was recently introduced for the purpose of filing of the petition. It is urged that there was some ambiguity among lawyers regarding the new procedure/format for filing. Inquiry was made and the petition was reformatted in terms of the ‘new format’. It is further stated that during this period from 09.10.2012 to 27.11.2012, there were vacations due to festive seasons, i.e Dussehra on 24.10.2012, Eid on 27.10.2012, Diwali on 13.11.2012, Moharram on 25.11.2012 and Guru Nanak Birthday on 28.11.2012 It is urged that the court and the office of the lawyer remain closed during Dussehra and Diwali vacations. The papers of the present case were also accidentally misplaced. The clerk of the counsel also went to his hometown Uttarakhand during Diwali and returned after celebrating Diwali. It is also urged that during this period, time was spent in attempting to remove the objections, which were raised by the Registry.
6. I have heard the learned senior counsel for the parties.
7. The learned senior counsel for the respondent has vehemently opposed the condonation of delay in re-filing the objections relying upon the various judgments of this court, which are as follows:
i. Gautam Associates v. Food Corporation Of India., 2009 (111) DRJ 274;
ii. Prakash Atlanta JV v. National Highways Authority of India, EFA (OS) No. 4 of 2013 dated 12.02.2013;
iii. NTPC Limited v. Gannon Dunkerley & Co. Ltd., FAO (OS) No. 89 of 2013 dated 12.02.2013;
iv. Union Of India v. Popular Construction Co.., AIR 2001 SC 4010;
Delhi Transco Ltd. & Anr…. v. Hythro Engineers Pvt. Ltd…. 2012 (3) ARBLR 349 (Delhi);
vi. The Executive Engineer (Irrigation & Flood Control) v. Shree Ram Construction Co., 2010 (10) AD Delhi 180;
vii. Union Of India v. M/S Harbhagwan Harbhajan Lal…., O.M.P No. 30 of 2010, dated 11.03.2010 and
viii. Delhi Development Authority v. Durga Construction Co., ILR (2014) 1 Delhi 153.”
8. The legal position regarding condonation of delay in re-filing of objections under section 34 of the Act were considered and settled by the Division Bench of this court in the case of Delhi Development Authority v. Durga Construction Co. (supra). Relevant paras are as follows:
“19. It follows from the above that once an application or an appeal has been filed within the time prescribed, the question of condoning any delay in re-filing would have to be considered by the Court in the context of the explanation given for such delay. In absence of any specific statute that bars the jurisdiction of the Court in considering the question of delay in re-filing, it cannot be accepted that the courts are powerless to entertain an application where the delay in its re-filing crosses the time limit specified for filing the application.
20. Although, the courts would have the jurisdiction to condone the delay, the approach in exercising such jurisdiction cannot be liberal and the conduct of the applicant will have to be tested on the anvil of whether the applicant acted with due diligence and dispatch. The applicant would have to show that the delay was on account of reasons beyond the control of the applicant and could not be avoided despite all possible efforts by the applicant. The purpose of specifying an inelastic period of limitation under section 34(3) of the Act would also have to be borne in mind and the Courts would consider the question whether to condone the delay in re-filing in the context of the statute. A Division Bench of this High Court in Competent Placement Services through its Director/Partner v. Delhi Transport Corporation through its Chairman: 2011 (2) R.A.J 347 (Del) has held as under:—
“9. In the light of these provisions and decisions rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, it is thus clear that no petition under section 34 of the a&c act can be entertained after a period of three months plus a further period of 30 days, subject to showing sufficient cause, beyond which no institution is permissible. However, the rigors of condonation of delay in re-filing are not as strict as condonation of delay of filing under Section 34(3). But that does not mean that a party can be permitted an indefinite and unexplainable period for refilling the petition.”
9. The twin arguments were raised by the petitioner for condonation of delay. Firstly, about the ‘new format’ having been introduced. Hence, it took some time to re-format the objections after having obtained the correct format. Secondly, the fact that it was festive seasons which resulted in repeated holidays when the lawyers office was closed. Connected with this plea is the fact that the clerk of the counsel for the petitioner had also gone to his hometown for celebration of Diwali.
10. In this context reference may be had to the judgment of the Supreme Court in Northern Railway v. Pioneer Publicity Corp. Pvt. Ltd. being Civil Appeal No. 10340 of 2016. In that case the Supreme Court was dealing with an issue of condonation of delay of 65 days in re-filing the objections under section 34 of the Act. The Supreme Court held as follows:—
“Mr. Amarjeet Singh Chandiok, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Respondent submitted that Section 34(3) of the Act bars re-filing beyond the period stipulated therein. The said sub-section reads as follows:
“34. (3) An application for setting aside may not be made after three months have elapsed from the date on which the party making that Application had received the Arbitral Award or, if a request had been made Under Section 33, from the date on which that request had been disposed of by the Arbitral Tribunal:
Provided that if the Court is satisfied that the Applicant was prevented by sufficient cause from making the Application within the said period of three months it may entertain the Application within a further period of thirty days, but not thereafter.
We find that said Section has no Application in refiling the Petition but only applies to the initial filing of the objections Under Section 34 of the Act. It was submitted on behalf of the Respondent that Rule 5(3) of the Delhi High Court Rules states that if the Memorandum of Appeal is filed and particular time is granted by the Deputy Registrar, it shall be considered as fresh institution. If this Rule is strictly applied in this case, it would mean that any re-filing beyond 7 days would be a fresh institution. However, it is a matter of record that 5 extensions were given beyond 7 days. Undoubtedly, at the end of the extensions, it would amount to re-filing.
We are not inclined to accept this contention particularly since the Petitioner has offered an explanation for the delay for the period after the extensions.
Having regard to the overall circumstances of the case, we consider it appropriate in the interest of justice to set aside the impugned Order.”
11. Keeping in view the legal position and the facts above, in my opinion, there are sufficient reasons given for the condonation of the delay which occurred. I may also note that the Award is against the respondent and in favour of the petitioner. The respondent has also filed objections under section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act which are pending. In view of the above, I allow the present application and condone the delay in re-filing the objections.
OMP 54/2013
12. List on 21.08.2017
Alert