- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Maninder Singh Petitioner v. State Of Punjab And Ors. S
Structured Summary of the Opinion — CWP No.67 of 2012 (O&M)
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, belonging to the Balmiki/Mazbi Sikh category, applied for the post of Assistant Professor/Lecturer (Mechanical Engineering) advertised by Malout Institute of Management and Information Technology (respondent No.5) by advertisement dated 25.02.2011. The advertisement provided six posts in the Mechanical Engineering branch with the category breakup: General 03, ESM 01, SC 01, BC 01 (Total 06). The petitioner applied under the SC category.
The petitioner sought, by a writ petition (seeking certiorari), to quash a reply dated 19.12.2011 (P.13) that had been sent in response to a legal notice dated 02.12.2011 (P.12). He contended that, under Government Instructions dated 05.05.1975 (P.1), Clarifications dated 08.04.1980 (P.2), and Section 4(5) of the Punjab Scheduled Castes and Backward Classes (Reservation in Services) Act, 2006, the post should be filled from the sub-category of Balmiki/Mazbi Sikh.
Respondent No.5 (the Institute) replied that the post was advertised as SC category, the Selection Committee considered the petitioner but found him not suitable, and respondent No.6 was selected. The Institute further explained that reservation provisions of the 2006 Act need to be incorporated in its bye-laws and that a future vacant SC post would be advertised specifically for Balmiki/Mazbi Sikh after obtaining government sanction and incorporation in the bye-laws. The Government of Punjab (Department of Technical Education & Industrial Training) similarly communicated on 08.09.2011 that the vacant post may be advertised for Balmiki/Mazbi Sikh in future after necessary approval and incorporation in the institute's bye-laws; the petitioner was informed of this position by letter dated 08.09.2011 (R.5/25).
The court noted that the institute had considered the petitioner at interview but did not find him suitable and that selection was made on merit-cum-performance. The court observed that the reply to the legal notice could not be treated as an adverse order subject to judicial review under Article 226. The advertisement posts were contractual for three years; more than five years had elapsed, and thus the court considered the petition an academic exercise. The writ petition was dismissed on 1 May 2017.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner is entitled, under Section 4(5) of the Punjab Scheduled Castes and Backward Classes (Reservation in Services) Act, 2006 and relevant Government instructions, to have the advertised SC post filled specifically from the Balmiki/Mazbi Sikh sub-category.
- Whether the reply dated 19.12.2011 to the legal notice (P.13) constitutes an impugnable adverse order subject to judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution.
- Whether the petition retains any live cause of action given that the advertised posts were contractual (initially for three years) and more than five years have elapsed since advertisement.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner relied on Government Instructions dated 05.05.1975 and Clarifications dated 08.04.1980, and specifically on Section 4(5) of the Punjab Scheduled Castes and Backward Classes (Reservation in Services) Act, 2006, to claim that the post must be filled from the Balmiki/Mazbi Sikh sub-category.
- The petitioner served a legal notice dated 02.12.2011 seeking compliance, and sought quashing of the reply dated 19.12.2011 (P.13) that responded to that notice.
Respondents' Arguments
- Respondent No.5 submitted that the post was advertised for the SC category and that both the petitioner and respondent No.6 were considered by the Selection Committee; the petitioner was not found suitable while respondent No.6 was selected on merit-cum-performance.
- The institute contended that provisions of the 2006 Act regarding reservation need to be incorporated into its bye-laws before they can be applied; the institute is a society registered under the Societies Registration Act and no bye-laws had been placed on record by either side.
- Respondent No.5 and the Government of Punjab communicated that a future vacant SC post would be advertised specifically as for Balmiki/Mazbi Sikh only after obtaining government approval and incorporating the same in the institute's bye-laws; the petitioner was informed of this position.
- The respondents implied that the reply to the legal notice is not an adjudicatory order and therefore not subject to judicial review under Article 226.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded in a sequential manner based strictly on the material on record:
- Examination of the advertisement and application: The court noted the Institute's advertisement dated 25.02.2011 and that the petitioner applied for the sole SC-category Assistant Professor/Lecturer post in the Mechanical Engineering department.
- Assessment of statutory and administrative reliance: The petitioner relied on Government instructions (1975 and 1980) and Section 4(5) of the 2006 Act. The court observed these claims but examined whether they could be operationalized given the Institute's regulatory structure.
- Bye-laws and institutional competence: The court highlighted respondent No.5's submission that reservation provisions under the 2006 Act must be incorporated into the Institute's bye-laws before being applied. Neither party produced the bye-laws; consequently the precise procedure for selection and appointment within the Institute could not be delineated from the record.
- Selection committee's treatment: The court relied on respondent No.5's un-replicated statement (para 17 of its written statement and a letter dated 17.08.2011) that the petitioner was considered by the Selection Committee but did not perform satisfactorily; the selected candidate stood higher on merit. The court noted there was no replication filed by the petitioner against these submissions.
- Communications with government and petitioner: The court recorded that the Government of Punjab (TE&IT) advised on 08.09.2011 that the vacant SC post may be advertised in future specifically indicating Balmiki/Mazbi Sikh after obtaining sanction and incorporation in the bye-laws, and that the petitioner was informed accordingly by letter dated 08.09.2011 from the Institute.
- Nature of the impugned document: The court analyzed the reply dated 19.12.2011 to the legal notice and held that this reply could not be treated as an "impugned order" passed by a competent authority that would attract judicial review under Article 226. In other words, a response to a legal notice was not equivalent to an adverse administrative order amenable to certiorari in this context.
- Temporal and practical considerations: The court observed that the posts were advertised on a contractual basis for an initial three-year period and that more than five years had elapsed since advertisement; therefore, any claim regarding the particular contractual appointment was rendered academic and there was no live cause of action justifying relief.
- Impleading of respondent No.6: The court found respondent No.6 to have been unnecessarily impleaded because his selection related to an earlier advertisement dated 30.10.2010 in which the petitioner had also participated and been unsuccessful; the court regarded this impleading as unnecessary and prejudicial to respondent No.6.
- Conclusion from the above: Combining the procedural posture (reply to legal notice not an impugned order), the institutional requirement to incorporate reservation in bye-laws, the selection committee's assessment on merit, and the lapse of time rendering the dispute academic, the court concluded the petition had no merit.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The writ petition was DISMISSED.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The petitioner's challenge seeking to quash the reply dated 19.12.2011 and to compel application of a Balmiki/Mazbi Sikh sub-category appointment in respect of the advertised post was rejected; no relief was granted to the petitioner.
- The court treated the reply to the legal notice as not constituting an adverse order amenable to judicial review under Article 226, and emphasized the requirement that reservation provisions be incorporated into the institute's bye-laws before being enforced.
- Because the advertised posts were contractual and more than five years had elapsed, the court considered the petition to be an academic exercise and therefore not maintainable in the circumstances recorded.
- No new precedent was announced; the decision applies to the facts and record before the court and the opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal rule beyond its application to these facts.
Order dated: 1 May 2017. Bench: Jaswant Singh, J.
Present: Mr. Gurbachan Singh, Advocate for the petitioner. Mz. Sudeepti Sharma, D.A.G, Punjab for respondent Nos.1 to 4. Mr. Balwinder Singh, Advocate for respondent No.5. Mr. Ashok Bhardwaj, Advocate for respondent No.6. Jaswant Singh, J
1. The petitioner, who belongs to Balmiki/Mazbi Sikh and was aspirant for the post of Assistant Lecturer, has preferred this writ petition seeking a writ of Certiorari for quashing the reply dated 19.12.2011 (P.13) in response to the legal notice dated 02.12.2011 sent on behalf of the petitioner whereby it has been intimated that no interview for the post in question could be held until and unless the same is properly advertised.
2. Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that in view of the Government Instructions dated 05.05.1975 (P.1) and Clarifications of Instruction dated 08.4.1980 (P.2) issued by the Punjab Government and in view of mandate of Section 4 (5) of the Punjab Schedule Castes and Backward Classes (Reservation in Services) Act, 2006 (for short the Act), the claim of the petitioner for filling up the post from the sub-category of Balmiki/bazbi Sikh
1 of 7 CWP No.67 of 2012 (O&M) #2# is liable to be accepted.
3. On the contrary, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents have opposed the prayer of the petitioner in view of the fact that the post in question against which the petitioner is claiming the relief was advertised for SC Category and both the candidates i.e the petitioner as well as respondent No.6 were duly considered by the Selection Committee wherein the petitioner was not found suitable whereas respondent No.6 stood selected.
4. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the paper book with their able assistance.
5. It is not in dispute that the Principal, Malout Institute of Management and Information Technology-respondent No.5 issued an advertisement dated 25.2.2011 (P.11) for Teaching and non- Teaching posts, including six posts of Assistant Professor/Lecturers in the Mechanical Engineering Branch in the pay scale of Rs.15600-39100/- (revised) with GP Rs.6000/- per month and break up of the same is as under: "General ESM SC BC Total
03 01 01 01 06" In response to the aforesaid Advertisement, the petitioner applied for the post of Assistant Professor/Lecturer Mechanical Engineering in SC Category. Thereafter, vide letter dated 05.4.2011 (R.5/14), the petitioner made a request to respondent No.5 that in view of Section 4 (5) of the Act of 2006, the post of Scheduled Caste be amended/re-published after the same is categorised. It is also necessary to mention here that certain other applications including under RTI Act were also made by the
2 of 7 CWP No.67 of 2012 (O&M) #3# petitioner and his father; but this Court does not deem it proper to go into the details of the same being similar to the application dated 05.4.2011.
6. In paragraph 17 of Preliminary Submissions in the written statement of respondent No.5, it has been submitted that the provisions of Act of 2006, regarding reservation policy are required to be incorporated in the Bye-laws of the Institute. It is clarified that Malout Institute of Engineering and Technology is a Society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 as amended by Punjab Act of 1957 and the same was registered on 11.8.1998 by the Registrar of Firms & Societies, Punjab,Chandigarh (R.5/1). Neither the petitioner nor respondent No.5 has placed on record the Bye-laws of the Institute to delineate the procedure of regulations of making selection and appointment to the post of Assistant Professor/Lecturer. In para 17, it has further been submitted that one post of Assistant Professor/Lecturer in SC Category is lying vacant in the Department of Mechanical Engineering of the Department of the Institute and the same shall be advertised by the Institute against the particular category i.e SC (Balmiki/Mazbi Sikh) subject to the approval of their office to incorporate the said Notification in the Bye-laws of the Institute and a communication dated 13.7.2011 was also sent to respondent No.1-Principal Secretary, Department of Technical Education and Industrial Training, Punjab (R.5/21). Still further, there is another letter dated 17.8.2011 (R.5/23) addressed to respondent No.4, which clearly depicts that the candidature of the petitioner was duly considered by the Selection Committee but
3 of 7 CWP No.67 of 2012 (O&M) #4# he was not found suitable for the post and thus he could not be selected and the selected persons stood higher in merit than the petitioner and thus selection has been made purely on merit-cum- performance basis, on the recommendation of the Selection Committee and a reference of this letter finds mention in para 19 of the Preliminary Submission and relevant part of the same reads as under: " 19. That the answering respondent sent a detailed reply vide its letter No.1882-83-84-85 dated 17.08.2011. In this reply the answering-respondent had clarified that the Institute had called all thefive candidates including the petitioner for the interview and had not ignored has candidature at anylevel. He was considered by the Selection Committee butdid not find him suitable for teaching job as he failed to perform before the Selection Committee when he was asked to speak/deliver lecture on the given topic. It was further clarified that the candidate who had been selected stood higher in themerit than the petitioner and the selection had been made purely on merit cum performance basis on the recommendations of the Selection Committee. Finally, it had been submitted that in future the vacant post of SC category will be filled by the Institute from the particular category i.e Balmikis and Mazhabi Sikhs for which the case had already been sent to the Govt of Punjab. A copy of this letter had also been endorsed to the Secretary, Govt of Punjab, Deptt of Welfare (Reservation Cell), Chandigarh, the Director, Technical Education and Industrial Training, Punjab, Chandigarh and the District Welfare Officer, Muktsar."
7. It is relevant to mention here that there is no replication
4 of 7 CWP No.67 of 2012 (O&M) #5# filed by the petitioner against the submissions made in this paragraph of the written statement. Again, the Government of Punjab in the Department of Technical Education and Industrial Training vide letter dated 08.9.2011 (R.5/24) has intimated to respondent No.5 that one post of Assistant Professor/Lecturer, which is lying vacant, may be advertised in future for SC Category by clearly specifying that the post is meant for Balmiki/Mazbi Sikh and the same shall be notified in the Bye-laws of the Institute after obtaining sanction from the Government. It was further stipulated that this intimation may be sent to the petitioner also by the College and consequently, vide letter dated 08.9.2011 (R.5/25), the petitioner was intimated in the following terms: " This has reference to memo no.02/09/2011- 2TE2/3541 dated 09.08.2011 received from Govt of Punjab, Deptt of TE&IT on the aforesaid subject (copy enclosed). In this regards, the Institute wish to inform you that in future the vacant post of SC catgory in the department of Mechanical Engineering will be advertised and filled from this particular category of post i.e Balmikiand Mazbi Sikh after taking necessary approval from the Govt of Punjab and incorporating the same in the Institute's bye-laws. This is for your information please."
8. In view of the above, it is apparently clear that respondent No.5 has in no uncertain terms, intimated to the petitioner that there is one post of Assistant Professor/Lecturer lying vacant in the Mechanical Department of the College and as and when the same is advertised in future, the same shall be clearly categorised in SC
5 of 7 CWP No.67 of 2012 (O&M) #6# (Balmiki/ Mazbi Sikh) in the light of provisions of Section 4 (5) of the Act of 2006 as well as reservation Policy applicable in the State of Punjab and the same will be duly incorporated in the Bye-laws of the Institute. In view of the above, no cause of action survives in favour of the petitioner for issuance of any direction against the respondent-College regarding the post of Assistant Professor/Lecturer.
9. Despite the aforesaid factual position, the petitioner had got served a legal notice dated 02.12.2011 (P.12) through his counsel and the same was duly replied by respondent No.5 on 19.12.2011 (P.13), which, in the opinion of this Court, does not give any cause of action to the petitioner, as the reply sent by respondent No.5 to the Advocate of the petitioner cannot be termed as an impugned order and the same is not liable to be treated as an adverse order passed by the Compatent Authority for the purpose of judicial review of this Court while exercising powers under Article 226 of the Constitution.
10. There is another aspect of the matter for dismissal of this writ petition, in view of the fact that the perusal of Advertisement dated 25.2.2011 (P.11) makes it clear that the posts in question were on contractual basis, initially for a period of three years and thereafter the contract was to be renewed subject to the requirement of the Institute and performance of the individual(s). In the present case, we are concerned with the sole post of Assistant Professor/Lecturer in SC Category against which the petitioner had applied and it is not clear as to who has been
6 of 7 CWP No.67 of 2012 (O&M) #7# appointed against the sole post.
11. Be that as it may, it is clear that the post in question was advertised on contractual basis for a period of three years and by now a period of more than five years has already lapsed and that being the position, the petitioner has no cause of action at this juncture and the present writ petition is only an academic exercise.
12. Before parting with the order, it is relevant to observe here that respondent No.6 has unnecessary been impleaded as a party respondent as he has no concern with the Advertisement dated 25.2.2011 (P.11) and was selected and appointed on the basis of earlier Advertisement dated 30.10.2010 (P.6) in which the petitioner was also a contender, but remained unsuccessful. Thus, it is not understandable as to what prompted the petitioner to implead respondent No.6 as a party in the present writ petition without any cause or basis. The only inference, which can be drawn is that it is only the incorrigibility of the petitioner, which has resulted into the impleadment of respondent No.6 as a party respondent just to face the harassment while defending the present lis, which could have been avoided by the petitioner. In view of the aforesaid, this Court finds that the present petition is devoid of any merit and the same is dismissed. May 1st , 2017 ( JASWANT SINGH ) manoj JUDGE
7 of 7
Alert