Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Chairman-Cum-Managing Director v. Consumer Education Research Society Suraksha Sankul

National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Mar 20, 2014
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission Order

Factual and Procedural Background

This matter involves a series of identical revision petitions (Revision Petition Nos. 3382 to 3389 of 2013) filed in the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) against the Order dated 17/06/2013 of the Gujarat State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in various appeals (Appeal Nos. 872/2010 to 879/2010). The petitioners are identified as the Chairman-cum-Managing Director of ONGC Ltd. & others (including the Executive Officer, ONGC Ltd. and the Chief Manager (F&A), ONGC). The respondents include the Consumer Education Research Society & others and various individual complainants; Life Insurance Corporation (LIC) also appears in the record. The petitions challenge the concurrent findings of the District Forum and the Gujarat State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission relating to pension-related claims.

Bench: Hon'ble Mr. Justice J.M. Malik (Presiding Member) and Hon'ble Dr. S.M. Kantikar (Member). Date of judgment: 20 March 2014.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether consumer fora (District Forum and State Commission) have jurisdiction to adjudicate disputes concerning pension and other retiral benefits.
  2. Whether persons who are beneficiaries of pension schemes or similar retiral benefits (including those working in semi-government institutions) fall within the definition of "consumer" under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, and thus can invoke consumer fora for redressal.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners (ONGC and its officers) argued that the consumer fora have no power to decide pension-related matters and have arrogated to themselves jurisdiction they do not possess.
  • To support this contention counsel for the petitioners relied on the Supreme Court decision in Dr. Jagmittar Sain Bhagat vs. Director, Health Services, Haryana & Ors. (decided 11.7.2013, Civil Appeal No. 5476 of 2013), which, as cited by petitioners' counsel, contains observations that a government servant cannot raise disputes regarding service conditions or payment of gratuity/GPF or other retiral benefits before a Forum under the Act and that a government servant does not fall under the definition of "consumer" under the Act.
  • Learned counsel for the petitioners therefore urged that the consumer fora have exceeded their jurisdiction by entertaining these pension claims.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' separate legal arguments in opposition to the petitions beyond the general record of appearances.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dr. Jagmittar Sain Bhagat vs. Director, Health Services, Haryana & Ors. (Supreme Court, decided 11.7.2013, Civil Appeal No. 5476 of 2013) Contains the observation (as cited by petitioners) that a government servant cannot raise disputes regarding service conditions or payment of gratuity/GPF or other retiral benefits before a Forum under the Consumer Protection Act; a government servant does not fall within the statutory definition of "consumer" under Section 2(1)(d)(ii) for such matters. The petitioners relied on this decision to argue lack of jurisdiction of consumer fora. The NCDRC observed that this judgment must be read holistically and should not be taken in isolation to defeat the position of complainants in the present cases (noting that para 15 of that judgment discusses earlier precedents recognizing beneficiaries as consumers).
Regional Provident Fund Commissioner v. Bhavani, AIR 2008 SC 2957 Held that a person who was a member of the Employees' Family Pension Scheme and contributing to it was availing services rendered by the appellant for implementation of the Scheme and therefore came within the definition of "consumer" under Section 2(1)(d)(ii). The NCDRC relied on the passage quoted in para 15 of Dr. Jagmittar Sain Bhagat to support the proposition that beneficiaries under pension schemes can fall within the definition of "consumer" and thus can approach consumer fora for redressal.
Regional Provident Fund Commissioner vs. Shiv Kumar Joshi, 2000 SCC 98 Holds that the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, though discharging statutory functions, renders "services" under the Act for running the Scheme; beneficiaries of the Scheme are to be treated as "consumer" within the meaning of the Act, including where the Central Government pays administrative charges for the Scheme. The NCDRC cited this decision to reinforce that entities administering pension or provident schemes can be treated as service providers and beneficiaries as consumers, supporting jurisdiction of consumer fora in appropriate cases.
Spring Meadows Hospital v. Harjot Ahluwalia, (1998) 4 SCC 7 (JT 1998 2 SC 620) Held that "consumer" includes a person who hires or avails services and also includes beneficiaries of such services who may be different from the person who directly availed the services. The NCDRC cited this authority to support the broader statutory definition of "consumer" that embraces beneficiaries of services (thereby supporting consumer fora jurisdiction where beneficiaries complain).
Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner, Raichur vs. Vasant Madhav Kerur (RP No. 765 of 2013) and connected petitions (NCDRC, decided 9.4.2013) NCDRC's own earlier view addressing similar issues relating to provident fund/pension beneficiaries and their status under the Act. The Bench recorded that its own earlier view in these connected matters supported the conclusion reached in the present set of revision petitions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by noting the sensitive nature of pension disputes and the difficulty pensioners face from delays. The petitioners challenged the concurrent findings of the District Forum and the State Commission, contending that consumer fora lacked jurisdiction over pension matters. The petitioners primarily relied on the recent Supreme Court decision in Dr. Jagmittar Sain Bhagat to support the proposition that government servants cannot raise service-related or retiral benefit disputes before consumer fora.

The NCDRC rejected the petitioners' arguments on the following grounds, as explained in the opinion:

  1. The Court emphasized that the Supreme Court authority relied upon must be read as a whole and not selectively. In particular, para 15 of Dr. Jagmittar Sain Bhagat quotes and discusses the earlier decision in Regional Provident Fund Commissioner v. Bhavani, which recognized that beneficiaries of pension schemes could be consumers within the meaning of the Act.
  2. The NCDRC highlighted that the complainants in the present cases are not government servants but work in a semi-government institution; accordingly, they do not have access to a State Administrative Tribunal and approaching civil courts would be time-consuming. Under Section 3 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, the consumer fora provide a statutory remedy for redressal.
  3. The Court relied on established Supreme Court authority (Regional Provident Fund Commissioner vs. Shiv Kumar Joshi and Spring Meadows Hospital v. Harjot Ahluwalia) to demonstrate that (i) administrators of pension/provident schemes can be treated as rendering "service" under the Act and (ii) beneficiaries of such services fall within the definition of "consumer".
  4. The Bench further noted that it had adopted a similar view in its earlier decision (Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner, Raichur vs. Vasant Madhav Kerur and connected petitions) decided on 9.4.2013.
  5. On the basis of the foregoing authorities and factual distinction (complainants not being government servants but beneficiaries), the Court concluded that the consumer fora were competent to adjudicate these pension-related complaints and that the revision petitions lacked merit.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court dismissed all the revision petitions as lacking merit. The core ruling is summarized as:

ALL REVISION PETITIONS DISMISSED

Direct consequences imposed by the Court:

  • Each revision petition was dismissed with costs of Rs. 5,000/- (Rupees five thousand) payable to each of the complainants.
  • Payment of the costs is to be made within three months; failure to do so will attract interest @ 10% per annum until realization.

Implications beyond the parties: The opinion applies and relies upon existing Supreme Court authorities and the Bench's earlier decision to uphold the proposition that beneficiaries of pension or provident schemes can, in appropriate circumstances, be considered "consumers" and may seek redressal in consumer fora. The text of the opinion does not state that it is establishing a new legal precedent beyond applying and reaffirming these authorities; its immediate effect is the dismissal of the petitions and the imposition of costs as recorded above.

Signed: Justice J.M. Malik, Presiding Member; Dr. S.M. Kantikar, Member. Order dated 20 March 2014.

Show all summary ...

NATIONAL CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION

NEW DELHI

REVISION PETITION NO. 3382 OF 2013

(Against the Order dated 17/06/2013 in Appeal No. 872/2010 of the State Commission Gujarat)

1. CHAIRMAN-CUM-MANAGING DIRECTOR OF ONGC LTD. & 2 ORS.

JIVAN PRABHAT TOWER,11TH FLOOR, 124

CANNOUGHT PLACE,

NEW DELHI-110001

2. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, ONGC LTD ,

PRBS SECTION GROUND FLOOR, OLD SECRETARIAT

BUILDING, TEL BHAWAN,

DEHRADUN

UTTRAKHAND

3. THE CHIEF MANAGER (F&A), ONGC,

5TH FLOOR, CHANDKHEDA,

AHMEDABAD - 380005 GUJARAT ...........Petitioner(s) Versus

1. CONSUMER EDUCATION RESEARCH SOCIETY & 2

ORS.

SURAKSHA SANKUL, AHMEDABAD-GANDHINAGAR

HIGHWAY, THALTEJ,

AHMEDABAD - 380054

GUJARAT

2. SHRI SUVINDER SINGH,

A/191 ,SARVOTTAM NAGAR, NEAR P.O RAILWAY

COLONY,

AHMEDABAD - 380019

GUJARAT

3. MANAGER, (P&GS), LIFE INSURENCE

CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.

G-701, 3RD FLOOR, JIVAN PRAKASH , TILAK ROAD, AHMEDABAD - 380001

GUJARAT ...........Respondent(s)

REVISION PETITION NO. 3383 OF 2013

(Against the Order dated 17/06/2013 in Appeal No. 873/2010 of the State Commission Gujarat)

1. CHAIRMAN-CUM-MANAGING DIRECTOR OF ONGC LTD. & 2 ORS.

JIVAN PRABHAT TOWER,11TH FLOOR, 124

CANNOUGHT PLACE,

NEW DELHI-110001

2. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, ONGC LTD ,

PRBS SECTION GROUND FLOOR, OLD SECRETARIAT

BUILDING, TEL BHAWAN, ...........Petitioner(s)

1

DEHRADUN

UTTRAKHAND

3. THE CHIEF MANAGER (F&A), ONGC,

5TH FLOOR, CHANDKHEDA,

AHMEDABAD - 380005

GUJARAT

Versus

1. CONSUMER EDUCATION RESEARCH SOCIETY & 2

ORS.

SURAKHSHA SANKUL, AHMEDABAD-GANDHINAGAR

HIGHWAY, THALTEJ,

AHMEDABAD - 380054

GUJARAT

2. SHRI RAMESHCHANDRA INDRELAL,

A/6 DASHMETH NAGAR, BEHIND JANTA NAGAR,

CHANDKHEDA ,

GANDHINAGAR - 382424

GUJARAT

3. MANAGER, (P&GS), LIFE INSURENCE

CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.

G-701, 3RD FLOOR, JIVAN PRAKASH , TILAK ROAD, AHMEDABAD - 380001

GUJARAT ...........Respondent(s)

REVISION PETITION NO. 3384 OF 2013

(Against the Order dated 17/06/2013 in Appeal No. 874/2010 of the State Commission Gujarat)

1. CHAIRMAN-CUM-MANAGING DIRECTOR OF ONGC LTD. & 2 ORS.

JIVAN PRABHAT TOWER,11TH FLOOR, 124

CANNOUGHT PLACE,

NEW DELHI-110001

2. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, ONGC LTD ,

PRBS SECTION GROUND FLOOR, OLD SECRETARIAT

BUILDING, TEL BHAWAN,

DEHRADUN

UTTRAKHAND

3. THE CHIEF MANAGER (F&A), ONGC,

5TH FLOOR, CHANDKHEDA,

AHMEDABAD - 380005 GUJARAT ...........Petitioner(s) Versus

1. CONSUMER EDUCATION RESEARCH SOCIETY & 2

ORS.

SURAKHSHA SANKUL, AHMEDABAD-GANDHINAGAR

HIGHWAY, THALTEJ,

AHMEDABAD - 380054 GUJARAT ...........Respondent(s)

2

2. SMT NIRMALADEVI,

B-19, BALAKRISHNA NAGAR, COOP.SOCIETY, BEHIND

JANTA NAGAR,

GANDHINAGAR - 382424

GUJARAT

3. MANAGER, (P&GS), LIFE INSURENCE

CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.

G-701, 3RD FLOOR, JIVAN PRAKASH , TILAK ROAD, AHMEDABAD - 380001

GUJARAT

REVISION PETITION NO. 3385 OF 2013

(Against the Order dated 17/06/2013 in Appeal No. 875/2010 of the State Commission Gujarat)

1. CHAIRMAN-CUM-MANAGING DIRECTOR OF ONGC LTD. & 2 ORS.

JIVAN PRABHAT TOWER,11TH FLOOR, 124

CANNOUGHT PLACE,

NEW DELHI - 110001

2. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICE, ONGC LTD

PRBS SECTION GROUND FLOOR, OLD SECRETARIAT

BUILDING, TEL BHAWAN,

DEHRADUN

UTTRAKHAND

3. THE CHIEF MANAGER (F&A), ONGC,

5TH FLOOR, CHANDKHEDA,

AHMEDABAD - 380005 GUJARAT ...........Petitioner(s) Versus

1. CONSUMER EDUCATION RESEARCH SOCIETY & 2

ORS.

SURAKHSHA SANKUL, AHMEDABAD-GANDHINAGAR

HIGHWAY, THALTEJ,

AHMEDABAD - 380054

GUJARAT

2. SMT. KAILASHBEN PRAJAPATI ,

AT & POST UVARSAD, ADALAJ, WATER TANK,

GANDHINAGAR

GUJARAT

3. MANAGER, (P&GS), LIFE INSURENCE

CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.

G-701, 3RD FLOOR, JIVAN PRAKASH , TILAK ROAD, AHMEDABAD - 380001

GUJARAT ...........Respondent(s)

REVISION PETITION NO. 3386 OF 2013

(Against the Order dated 17/06/2013 in Appeal No. 876/2010 of the State Commission Gujarat)

1. CHAIRMAN-CUM-MANAGING DIRECTOR OF ONGC ...........Petitioner(s)

3

LTD. & 2 ORS.

JIVAN PRABHAT TOWER,11TH FLOOR, 124

CANNOUGHT PLACE,

NEW DELHI - 110001

2. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, ONGC LTD ,

PRBS SECTION GROUND FLOOR, OLD SECRETARIAT

BUILDING, TEL BHAWAN,

DEHRADUN

UTTRAKHAND

3. THE CHIEF MANAGER (F&A), ONGC,

5TH FLOOR, CHANDKHEDA,

AHMEDABAD - 380005

GUJARAT

Versus

1. CONSUMER EDUCATION RESEARCH SOCIETY & 2

ORS.

SURAKHSHA SANKUL, AHMEDABAD-GANDHINAGAR

HIGHWAY, THALTEJ,

AHMEDABAD - 380054

GUJARAT

2. SMT.KAVITAVBEN T. THAKORE,

TRILOK BHAVAN, BHARWAD VAS, NEAR SOMNATH

MANDIR, SARKHEJ ,

AHMEDABAD - 382210

GUJARAT

3. MANAGER, (P&GS), LIFE INSURENCE

CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.

G-701, 3RD FLOOR, JIVAN PRAKASH , TILAK ROAD, AHMEDABAD - 380001

GUJARAT ...........Respondent(s)

REVISION PETITION NO. 3387 OF 2013

(Against the Order dated 17/06/2013 in Appeal No. 877/2010 of the State Commission Gujarat)

1. CHAIRMAN-CUM-MANAGING DIRECTOR OF ONGC LTD. & 2 ORS.

JIVAN PRABHAT TOWER,11TH FLOOR, 124

CANNOUGHT PLACE,

NEW DELHI - 110001

2. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, ONGC LTD

PRBS SECTION GROUND FLOOR, OLD SECRETARIAT

BUILDING, TEL BHAWAN,

DEHRADUN

UTTRAKHAND

3. THE CHIEF MANAGER (F&A), ONGC,

5TH FLOOR, CHANDKHEDA,

AHMEDABAD - 380005 GUJARAT ...........Petitioner(s)

4

Versus

1. CONSUMER EDUCATION RESEARCH SOCIETY & 2

ORS.

SURAKHSHA SANKUL, AHMEDABAD-GANDHINAGAR

HIGHWAY, THALTEJ,

AHMEDABAD - 380054

GUJARAT

2. SMT.HELEN S, WALLACE ,

440/2612, SHUBH LAXMI NAGAR, G.H.B.

CHANDKHEDA,

GHANDINAGAR - 372424

GUJARAT

3. MANAGER, (P&GS), LIFE INSURENCE

CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.

G-701, 3RD FLOOR, JIVAN PRAKASH , TILAK ROAD, AHMEDABAD - 380001

GUJARAT ...........Respondent(s)

REVISION PETITION NO. 3388 OF 2013

(Against the Order dated 17/06/2013 in Appeal No. 878/2010 of the State Commission Gujarat)

1. CHAIRMAN-CUM-MANAGING DIRECTOR OF ONGC LTD. & 2 ORS.

JIVAN PRABHAT TOWER,11TH FLOOR, 124

CANNOUGHT PLACE,

NEW DELHI-110001

2. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, ONGC LTD ,

PRBS SECTION GROUND FLOOR, OLD SECRETARIAT

BUILDING, TEL BHAWAN,

DEHRADUN

UTTRAKHAND

3. THE CHIEF MANAGER (F&A), ONGC,

5TH FLOOR, CHANDKHEDA,

AHMEDABAD - 380005 GUJARAT ...........Petitioner(s) Versus

1. CONSUMER EDUCATION RESEARCH SOCIETY & 2

ORS.

SURAKHSHA SANKUL, AHMEDABAD-GANDHINAGAR

HIGHWAY, THALTEJ,

AHMEDABAD - 380054

GUJARAT

2. SMT.BHANUBEN P SONI,

C/6, SHUKAN APARTMENTS NEAR NIRNAY NAGAR,

RANIP ROAD, RANIP

AHMEDABAD

GUJARAT

3. MANAGER, (P&GS), LIFE INSURENCE ...........Respondent(s)

5

CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.

G-701, 3RD FLOOR, JIVAN PRAKASH , TILAK ROAD, AHMEDABAD - 380001

GUJARAT

REVISION PETITION NO. 3389 OF 2013

(Against the Order dated 17/06/2013 in Appeal No. 879/2010 of the State Commission Gujarat)

1. CHAIRMAN-CUM-MANAGING DIRECTOR OF ONGC LTD. & 2 ORS.

JIVAN PRABHAT TOWER,11TH FLOOR, 124

CANNOUGHT PLACE,

NEW DELHI-110001

2. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, ONGC LTD ,

PRBS SECTION GROUND FLOOR, OLD SECRETARIAT

BUILDING, TEL BHAWAN,

DEHRADUN

UTTRAKHAND

3. THE CHIEF MANAGER (F&A), ONGC,

5TH FLOOR, CHANDKHEDA,

AHMEDABAD - 380005 GUJARAT ...........Petitioner(s) Versus

1. CONSUMER EDUCATION RESEARCH SOCIETY & 2

ORS.

SURAKHSHA SANKUL, AHMEDABAD-GANDHINAGAR

HIGHWAY, THALTEJ,

AHMEDABAD - 380054

GUJARAT

2. SHRI.M.T MAKWANA,

A/96 BHAGWATI SOCIETY, BEHIND JANTA NAGAR,

CHANDKHEDA,

GANDHINAGAR - 382424

GUJARAT

3. MANAGER, (P&GS), LIFE INSURENCE

CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.

G-701, 3RD FLOOR, JIVAN PRAKASH , TILAK ROAD, AHMEDABAD - 380001

GUJARAT ...........Respondent(s)

BEFORE:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE J.M. MALIK, PRESIDING MEMBER HON'BLE MR. DR. S.M. KANTIKAR, MEMBER For the Petitioner : Mr. Shivendu Singh , Advocate For the LIC : Mr. Rajesh K. Gupta, Advocate For the Respondents 1& 2 : Mr. Amjid Maqbool, Advocate with For the Respondent :

6

Mr. Siddharth Kaushik, Advocate Dated : 20 Mar 2014

ORDER

JUSTICE J. M. MALIK, PRESIDING MEMBER

1. The parties are up in arms over the question of pension. It is always desirable that the pensioners should be treated with kid gloves but it is unfortunate that in our times, they are exasperated by senseless delay. The Department is always interested in wasting more money and their time, than it is involved in such like frivolous litigations.

2. The Chairman-cum-Managing Director, ONGC Ltd. and their Executive Officer and the Chief Manager(F& A) have called into question the orders rendered by the District Forum and Gujarat State Consumer

-9-

Disputes Redressal Commission, Ahmedabad. Both the fora below have given the concurrent findings.

3. All the revision petitions are identical and the same will be decided through this common judgment.

4. This is an indisputable fact that all these cases pertain to the pension. The main grievance of the opposite parties/petitioners is that the consumer fora are not armed with the power to adjudicate the pension matters. The counsel for the petitioners did not raise any other point. In order to buttress his arguments, he has cited an authority of the Supreme Court reported in Dr. Jagmittar Sain Bhagat vs. Dir. Health Services, Haryana & Ors. decided on 11.7.2013 in civil appeal No. 5476 of 2013 wherein the Supreme Court was pleased to observe:

"In view of the above, it is evident that by no stretch of imagination a government servant can raise any dispute regarding his service conditions or for payment of gratuity or GPF or any of his retiral

7

benefits before any of the Forum under the Act. The government servant does not fall under the definition of a "consumer" as defined under Section 2(i)(d)(ii) of the Act. Such government servant is entitled to claim his retiral benefits strictly in accordance with his service -10-

conditions and regulations or statutory rules framed for that purpose. The appropriate forum, for redressal of any his grievance, may be the State Administrative Tribunal, if any, or Civil Court but certainly not a Forum under The Act."

5. Learned counsel for the petitioner vehemently argued that the consumer fora have arrogated to themselves those powers which they do not possess.

6. We clap no value with these arguments. The judgment of Dr. Jagmittar Sain Bhagat vs. Dir. Health Services, Haryana & Ors. (supra) must be read holistically. The same cannot be read in vacua to the detriment of one party and to the benefit of another party. Para 15 of the same judgment runs as follows:

"In Regional Provident Fund Commissioner v. Bhavani . AIR 2008 SC 2957, this court dealt with the issue as to whether Dr. Padia's submissions regarding the non-applicability of the Act to the case of Regional Provident Fund Commissioner - the person responsible for the working of a Pension Scheme, could be held to be a 'service giver' within the meaning of Section 2(1)(o) of the Act, as it was neither a case of rendering of free service nor rendering of

-11-

service under a contract of personal service so as to bring the relationship between the parties within the concept of 'master and servant'. The court held:

"In our view, the respondent comes squarely within the definition of 'consumer' within the meaning of Section 2(1)(d)(ii), inasmuch as, by becoming a member of the

8

Employees' Family Pension Scheme, 1971, and contributing to the same, she was availing of the services rendered by the appellant for implementation of the Scheme. The same is the case in the other appeals as well."

7. It must be borne in mind that the complainants in the instant case are not the government servants. They work in a semi government institution. They cannot approach the State Administrative Tribunal or civil court. The civil court will entail a lot of time. By virtue of Section 3 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, they have got the remedy of redressal of their grievances in the consumer fora itself.

8. Moreover, in Regional Provident Fund Commissioner vs. Shiv Kumar Joshi, 2000 SCC 98, it was held:

"We cannot accept the argument that the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, being Central

-12-

Government, cannot be held to be rendering "service" within the meaning and scheme of the Act. The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, under the Act and the Scheme discharges statutory functions for running the Scheme. It has not, in any way, been delegated with the sovereign powers of the State so as to hold it as a Central Government, being not the authority rendering the "service" under the Act. The Commissioner is a separate and distinct entity. It cannot legally claim that the facilities provided by the "Scheme" were not "service" or that the benefits under the Scheme being provided were free of charge. The definition of "consumer" under the Act includes not only the person who hires the "services" for consideration but also the beneficiary, for whose benefit such services are hired. Even if it is held that administrative charges are paid by the Central Government and no part of it is paid by the employee, the

9

services of the Provident Fund Commissioner in running the Scheme shall be deemed to have been availed of for consideration by -13-

the Central Government for the benefit of employees who would be treated as beneficiaries within the meaning of that word used in the definition of "consumer". This court in Spring Meadows Hospital V. Harjot Ahluwalia, 7 (1998) 4 SCC: JT (1998) 2 SC 620, to which one of us (Saghir Ahmad, J) was a party has already held that the

"consumer" means a person who hires or avails of any services and includes any beneficiary of such service other than the person who hires or avails the services. The Act gives a comprehensive definition of

"consumer" who is the principal beneficiary of the legislation but at the same time in view of the comprehensive definition of the term

"consumer" even a member of the family of such "consumer" was held to be having the status of 'consumer' ".

9. This view was taken by our Bench in Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner, Raichur vs. Vasant Madhav Kerur (RP No. 765 of 2013) and other connected 27 revision petitions decided on 9.4.2013.

-14-

10. Consequently, all the revision petitions are meritless and the same are dismissed with costs of Rs.5000/- each payable to each of the complainants, which shall be paid within three months, otherwise, it will carry interest @10% per annum till realisation.

......................J

J.M. MALIK

PRESIDING MEMBER

......................

10

DR. S.M. KANTIKAR

MEMBER

11