Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Satellite Developers Limited v. State Of Maharashtra And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 27, 2017
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute concerns land bearing C.S. No. 1/255 at Foras Road, Tardeo Division, Mumbai, measuring 10,394 sq m. Under a Draft Development Plan (DDP) prepared in 1991 by the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (MCGM) pursuant to the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (MRTP Act), portions of the land were reserved for a recreation ground, a maternity home and housing for the dis-housed. Section 127 of the MRTP Act stipulates that such reservations lapse if acquisition is not completed within ten years of the plan coming into force and the owner serves a purchase notice.

On 6 February 2003 the appellant served a purchase notice under Section 127. Although acquisition steps were initiated—including a Section 6 notification under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (27 February 2004) and a signed award dated 31 October 2011—compensation was not paid within the time-frames repeatedly fixed by the Bombay High Court in Writ Petition No. 1148 of 2010 (orders dated 21 July 2010 and 25 October 2010). The appellant filed a second writ petition (No. 1600 of 2012) challenging the award and seeking dereservation or, in the alternative, compensation.

By judgment dated 8 May 2013, the High Court declined to declare lapsing under Section 127, observing that the appellant had waived reliance on the notice by continually pursuing acquisition and compensation. The present civil appeal challenges that judgment. During Supreme Court proceedings, both parties expressed willingness to settle on the basis of a Government of Maharashtra notification dated 10 May 2016 that permits an owner to develop 30 % of reserved land (so-called “70/30 policy”). The appellant counter-proposed a “60/40” split in its favour (letter dated 26 December 2016).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the reservation over the appellant’s land had lapsed under Section 127 of the MRTP Act owing to the failure of the authorities to complete acquisition within the statutory time-frame.
  2. Whether the acquisition award dated 31 October 2011 was valid in light of alleged procedural irregularities and non-payment of compensation.
  3. What equitable resolution should be fashioned, given both parties’ willingness to compromise by reference to the State Government’s 10 May 2016 policy.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • The DDP reservation had lapsed under Section 127 because acquisition proceedings were not completed within the statutory period after service of the purchase notice.
  • Nevertheless, the appellant was prepared to settle by developing 60 % of the land and dedicating the remaining 40 % as a recreation garden, provided it could utilise 100 % of the plot’s FSI on the 60 % portion and obtain condonation of open-space deficiency without premium.

Municipal Corporation’s Arguments

  • The dispute should be resolved strictly in terms of the Government notification dated 10 May 2016, allowing the owner to develop only 30 % while handing over 70 % free of cost.
  • The Corporation accepted that some default had occurred but maintained that settlement must mirror the State policy.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted that the 10 May 2016 policy technically did not apply to the case but recognised that both parties wished to use it as a framework for settlement. The appellant, by not pressing its Section 127 claim, demonstrated willingness to resolve the matter through compromise. Conversely, MCGM’s repeated defaults in paying compensation warranted a sympathetic adjustment in the appellant’s favour.

Invoking its equitable powers under Article 142 of the Constitution, the Court considered it just to invert the policy ratio to a “60/40” split: the appellant must hand over 60 % of the land to the planning authority free of cost for reservation purposes and may develop the remaining 40 % in accordance with adjoining land-use regulations, subject to all other conditions contained in the Government policy (e.g., FSI/TDR provisions). The Court stressed that no penalties would be levied on the appellant and that the existing award would not impede implementation of this arrangement.

Holding and Implications

The civil appeal is DISPOSED OF.

Under Article 142, the Court directs that 60 % of the plot be surrendered to the planning authority and permits the appellant to develop the remaining 40 % with the benefits and conditions set out in the State’s 2-May-2016 policy. No penalties are payable, and the previous acquisition award is rendered ineffectual for this settlement. The order is expressly non-precedential, confined to the unique facts and the parties’ consent. Its immediate effect is to conclude all pending disputes between the parties; it sets no binding rule for future cases.

Show all summary ...

Dr A.K Sikri, J.— This appeal has a chequered history with many rounds of litigations. At the same time, it may not be necessary to take a detailed stock of various litigations. It is simply because of the reason that the controversy is substantially narrowed down, which we are called upon to decide in these proceedings. However, a glimpse of the events that have taken place since the start of the dispute may be spelled out in order to have an idea of the nature of the dispute that had initially arisen and how the controversy has remarkably shrunk and stands before us in a totally truncated form. The shortlist of dates and event, therefore, would suffice, which we reproduce below.

2. On 16-9-1991, the appellant claimed rights over the property being CS No. 1/255 on Foras Road, Tardeo Division, Mumbai, admeasuring 10,394 sq m. Under the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (hereinafter referred to as “the MRTP Act”), Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay can requisition the land for development for the purposes specified under the said Act. In respect of the aforesaid land, a Draft Development Plan (DDP) was prepared by the Municipal Corporation in the year 1991. Under the said Plan, 3548.52 sq m of land was reserved for recreation ground, 1355 sq m for maternity home and 5491.4 sq m for housing the dishoused. However, later the reservation for recreation ground was reduced to 2000 sq m. The MRTP Act further provides for acquisition of such land, by agreement or under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 in order to enable the Municipal Corporation to develop the land as per the DDP. If the steps in this behalf are not taken within the stipulated period, it results into lapsing of the land reserved for development. This was so provided under Section 127 of the MRTP Act, which reads as under:

“127. Lapsing of reservations.—If any land reserved, allotted or designated for any purpose specified in any plan under this Act is not acquired by agreement within ten years from the date on which a final regional plan, or final development plan comes into force or if proceedings for the acquisition of such land under this Act or under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (1 of 1894), are not commenced within such period, the owner or any person interested in the land may serve notice on the Planning Authority, Development Authority or as the case may be, appropriate authority to that effect; and if within six months from the date of the service of such notice, the land is not acquired or no steps as aforesaid are commenced for its acquisition, the reservation, allotment or designation shall be deemed to have lapsed, and thereupon, the land shall be deemed to be released from such reservation, allotment or designation and shall become available to the owner for the purpose of development as otherwise, permissible in the case of adjacent land under the relevant plan.”

3. On 6-2-2003, the appellant served upon the respondent Corporation a purchase notice under Section 127 of the MRTP Act and called upon the Corporation to initiate acquisition proceedings in respect of land reserved for recreational ground. On 27-2-2004, Notification under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, read with Section 126 of the MRTP Act was issued by Respondent 1. On 21-6-2006, by notice under Sections 9 and 10 of the Land Acquisition Act, Respondent 4 called upon the appellant to furnish details required as per the notice issued and also to record objections in respect of measurement of the subject land. On 22-9-2006, the appellants gave their no-objection for handing over the subject land against monetary compensation. On 22-4-2010, the appellant filed Writ Petition No. 1148 of 2010 wherein a prayer was made for a declaration of lapsing of the reservation. The appellant, however, also prayed for an alternative order in the nature of a direction to the respondents to acquire the land.

4. On 21-7-2010 2010 SCC OnLine Bom 2184, the High Court disposed of the writ petition directing Respondent 4 to pass the final award within a month and granted liberty to the appellant to revive the writ petition in case of non-compliance by Respondent 4. It may be mentioned herein that the appellant had made a statement that it will not press Prayer (a) in the writ petition for dereservation of the subject land. The operative portion of the order of the High Court in this behalf reads as under: (Satellite Developers Ltd. case 2010 SCC OnLine Bom 2184, SCC OnLine Bom paras 4-5)

“4. We, therefore, dispose of the petition with a direction that Respondent 4 shall pass the award on or before 31-10-2010 and make payment of compensation in accordance with the award within a month thereafter.
5. In case Respondent 4 does not comply with the aforesaid time-limit, the petitioners will be at liberty to move this Court for appropriate directions. Liberty is also granted to the petitioner to revive the petition. This direction is given in view of the assurance from the petitioner's counsel that petitioners will furnish the required documents to the authorities within reasonable time-limit.”

5. Thereafter, on 25-10-2010 2010 SCC OnLine Bom 2185, the High Court extended the time for passing of the award by Respondent 4 till 31-12-2010 and further extended the time to pay the compensation to 31-1-2011. On 31-3-2011, the Municipal Corporation sought further three months' time to comply with the abovementioned order dated 21-7-2010 2010 SCC OnLine Bom 2184. The High Court directed that 50% of the award amount be deposited in the Court. Respondent 3 had signed an award on 31-10-2011 for 2000.25 sq m of land to be acquired. The final compensation as per the award was Rs 14,48,19,014 and proper documents were required to be submitted.

6. On 17-7-2012, the appellant filed another writ petition bearing No. 1600 of 2012 with a prayer to quash the award dated 31-10-2011 passed by Respondent 4 on the ground that the appellant was never called on before signing of the award and neither was the compensation amount paid by the Municipal Corporation to Respondent 3 as per the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act. Significantly, the appellant, apart from seeking orders of quashing of the award and dereservation of the subject land, again sought to be compensated in terms of the award. In spite of repeated extensions sought by the Municipal Corporation, it failed to pay the compensation to the appellant, as directed by the High Court by its order dated 21-7-2010 2010 SCC OnLine Bom 2184.

7. Writ Petition No. 1148 of 2010 was finally heard and decided on 8-5-2013 2013 SCC OnLine Bom 1892. The High Court, after narrating the aforesaid events, found that the respondents did not act with due diligence, even after service of notice upon them under Section 127 of the Act. At the same time, the High Court was of the view that since the remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution of India was in the nature of prerogative remedy and the extraordinary jurisdiction of the High Court was purely discretionary, in the facts of the present case, it was not necessary to exercise the jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution. The High Court, therefore, refused to grant Prayer (a) based on the notice dated 6-2-2003 given by the appellant to the respondents under Section 127 of the MRTP Act. In the process, the High Court observed that the appellant had waived the effect of its notice under Section 127 inasmuch as it was regularly following up with the respondents to complete the acquisition proceedings and claim compensation against the same. The High Court has also held that as Writ Petition No. 1600 of 2012 was pending, the question regarding validity of the award can be argued therein.

8. The present appeals were filed questioning the validity of the aforesaid judgment dated 8-5-2013 2013 SCC OnLine Bom 1892 passed by the High Court. The matter was taken up from time to time. As pointed out in the beginning, since the controversy has been narrowed down, because of the positive attitude shown by both the parties, it is not necessary to discuss the legal nuances.

9. The Municipal Corporation has placed on record the Notification dated 10-5-2016 issued by the Urban Development Department of the Government of Maharashtra. It has offered to settle the matter on the terms contained in the said notification. This notification provides for a 70/30 policy whereby the Chief Officer may allow the owner to develop the reservation on 70% of the land and after handing over it to the Planning Authority free of cost then remaining 30% land may be allowed to be developed as per adjoining use, subject to the following terms/conditions:

(a) The owner shall be entitled to develop remaining 30% land for the uses permissible in the adjoining zone with full permissible FSI of the entire plot and permissible TDR potential of the entire plot.
(b) The Municipal Chief Officer, if required, shall allow the TDR for the unutilised FSI if any [after deducting in situ FSI as mentioned in Sr. No. (i) above] which shall be utilised as per the TDR utilisation regulations.
(c) No reservation shall allow to be developed partly.

10. Time was given to the appellant to respond to the said suggestion. The appellant, while maintaining that the DDP had lapsed in view of the provisions contained in Section 127 of the Act, responded to the aforesaid proposal of the Municipal Corporation vide its letter dated 26-12-2016 by stating that the appellant was ready to consider developing 40% of the plot as a recreation garden for the city at their own cost if 60% of the balance plot is available to it for development, subject to two conditions viz. (i) as per MCGM policy, 100% of FSI/development potential of the entire plot is allowed to be constructed on the 60%; and (ii) any open space deficiency in the planning of the building thereon be condoned without payment of any premium therefor.

11. When the matter was heard, both the parties were agreeable to resolve the dispute, but pressed their respective stance. The appellant submitted that the proposal quoted in its letter dated 26-12-2016 be accepted, whereas the Municipal Corporation impressed upon this Court to dispose of the matter in terms of the Notification dated 10-5-2016. While taking their respective positions in the manner aforesaid, Mr Sidharth Luthra, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant, and Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General appearing for the Municipal Corporation, agreed that they would leave it to the Court to take any appropriate and suitable decision in the matter.

12. We have considered the matter. Strictly speaking, the Policy is not applicable in the instant case. However, both the parties want that to be the basis for resolving the controversy. For this reason, the appellant is not pressing its challenge predicated on Section 127 of the MRTP Act. However, at the same time, it wants some modification of the policy terms in its favour. This constructive approach of both the parties commends to us. Having regard to the peculiar facts of this case and that the Municipal Corporation has defaulted in certain respects, we are of the view that ends of justice would be subserved if we allow the owner/appellant to develop the reservation of 60% of land and after handing over it to the Planning Authority free of cost, then remaining 40% land is allowed to be developed as per the adjoining use, subject to the conditions that are mentioned in the Policy dated 2-5-2016.

13. This order is passed in exercise of our powers under Article 142 of the Constitution and without treating this as a precedent. It may not be considered as tweaking with the Policy as the same is, otherwise, not applicable. That is taken as a yardstick for resolving the dispute as both the parties agreed for it. We also make it clear that the appellant would not be called upon to pay any penalties and the award passed in the case would not come in the way of the parties.

14. The civil appeal is disposed of in the aforesaid terms. No costs.