Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

DARSHANA & ORS v. GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS

Delhi High Court
Feb 21, 2017
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

These matters are a batch of writ petitions (led by W.P.(C) No.5395/2015 Jai Kishan & Anr.) filed by persons whose lands were subject to acquisition proceedings initiated under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. Notifications under Section 4 were issued in 2005 (for various villages), declarations under Section 6 were made in 2006 and an award (No.3/2008-09) relevant to some petitioners was passed on 26.05.2008. The award stated that physical possession would be taken after announcement of the award. The respondents contend physical possession was taken (in some cases on 29.07.2008) and compensation paid; the petitioners dispute actual physical possession and assert they remained in continuous physical possession, alleging only paper possession was taken.

During pendency of references under Section 18 of the 1894 Act challenging compensation, the Government of NCT of Delhi issued (01.10.2008) a Special Rehabilitation Package (SRP) applicable to awards not announced till 18.12.2007, providing enhanced compensation terms and requiring acceptance of the package and withdrawal of challenges to avail the benefit. The petitioners accepted the SRP and executed undertakings stating they had accepted compensation including SRP and that no cause of action would arise to agitate the matter further — undertakings given prior to commencement of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (the 2013 Act, commenced 01.01.2014).

The petitioners sought declarations under Section 24(2) of the 2013 Act — i.e., that acquisition proceedings in respect of their lands be deemed to have lapsed and they be entitled to benefits under Section 24(2) — on the basis that even though awards were made more than five years before commencement of the 2013 Act, either compensation had not been paid or physical possession had not been taken. These petitions were heard together and disposed of by a common judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether petitioners who had accepted the Government's Special Rehabilitation Package (SRP) and executed undertakings prior to 01.01.2014 retained any right, title or interest in the subject lands so as to claim relief under Section 24(2) of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013.
  2. Whether an undertaking given in terms of the SRP (leading to acceptance of compensation and withdrawal of challenges) can defeat or preclude a landowner from claiming statutory benefits conferred by the 2013 Act, including under Section 24(2), where the landowner contends physical possession was not actually taken.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The undertakings executed to accept the SRP could not divest or "snatch away" statutory rights that accrued under the 2013 Act; those undertakings only related to withdrawal of Section 18 proceedings for enhancement of compensation under the 1894 Act.
  • Without actual physical possession by the acquiring authority, the land remained with the landowners; Section 16 of the 1894 Act (providing that upon taking possession the land vests absolutely in the Government) presupposes actual physical possession and that onus of taking possession is on the acquiring authority.
  • Because acquisition and vesting are expropriatory, the provisions of the 1894 Act and constitutional protections (Article 300-A referenced) require strict compliance; the petitioners therefore argued they remained entitled to the remedial provisions of Section 24(2) of the 2013 Act which reliefs owners whose lands remain uncompensated or where possession is not taken.

Respondents' Contentions

  • The respondents contended physical possession of the subject lands was taken (in some instances on 29.07.2008) and compensation was paid to the petitioners.
  • The respondents relied on the fact that petitioners had accepted the SRP and executed undertakings stating that they had accepted the compensation including SRP and that this amounted to surrender of all rights in the subject lands prior to the commencement of the 2013 Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
W.P.(C) 9101/2014: Bhim Singh & Ors. vs. Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors. (judgment dated 20.12.2016) Held that landowners who accepted the SRP and gave undertakings surrendering rights had divested themselves of all rights, title and interest in the acquired land prior to commencement of the 2013 Act; consequently they could not claim benefits under Section 24(2) of the 2013 Act. The court applied this precedent directly to the instant batch of cases, finding the facts virtually identical and holding that petitioners who had accepted SRP and executed undertakings had no rights left on the date the 2013 Act commenced and therefore could not claim Section 24(2) relief.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analysed the matter primarily by comparing the factual matrix of these writ petitions with the earlier decision in Bhim Singh (W.P.(C) 9101/2014). The steps in the court's reasoning were:

  1. Recital of procedural and factual history: acquisition commenced under the 1894 Act (notifications 2005, declaration 2006, awards in 2008); award stated possession to be taken after announcement; petitioners had challenged compensation via references under Section 18; Government issued SRP on 01.10.2008 applicable to awards not announced till 18.12.2007.
  2. Detailed reference to terms of SRP, including enhanced compensation effective from 18.12.2007, allowance of solatium and interest, requirement that beneficiaries accept the package and not mount challenges to avail it, and that petitioners executed undertakings accepting the SRP and stating full and final settlement.
  3. Recognition that undertakings were executed prior to commencement of the 2013 Act (01.01.2014).
  4. Consideration of the petitioners' core contention that their undertakings could not defeat statutory rights under the 2013 Act because physical possession had not been actually taken. The petitioners relied on Section 16 of the 1894 Act and principles of eminent domain/Article 300-A and strict construction of expropriatory provisions.
  5. The court noted the earlier decision in Bhim Singh which held that acceptance of SRP and the undertaking resulted in divestment of rights before the commencement of the 2013 Act. The court accepted that precedent and observed that the facts in the present batch were virtually identical and therefore covered by that judgment.
  6. On that basis the court concluded it could not accede to the petitioners' submission: notwithstanding arguments about physical possession, the undertakings and acceptance of SRP operated to deprive petitioners of any right, title or interest in the lands on the date the 2013 Act came into force; therefore the petitioners could not claim benefit under Section 24(2) of the 2013 Act.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petitions are dismissed. It is held that the petitioners cannot claim any benefit under Section 24(2) of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013.

Direct consequences and orders made by the court:

  • The writ petitions were dismissed accordingly but without any costs.
  • All pending applications arising in these petitions were disposed of.
  • Interim orders, if any, were vacated.

The opinion applies and follows the prior decision in Bhim Singh & Ors. vs. Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors.; the judgment does not articulate any new broader legal principle beyond applying that precedent to the present, factually similar cases. The direct effect is that petitioners who accepted the SRP and gave undertakings prior to commencement of the 2013 Act are not entitled to Section 24(2) relief.

Show all summary ...

Judgment delivered on: 21.02.2017 + W.P.(C) 5395/2015 & CM No.9724/2015 JAI KISHAN & ANR ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 5399/2015 & CM 9733/2015 RANVIR SINGH & ORS ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 5406/2015 & CM 9742/2015 SAMUNDER SINGH & ORS ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 5430/2015 & CM 9783/2015 ANAND KUMAR & ANR ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 5431/2015 & CM 9784/2015 HARI SINGH & ORS ..... Petitioners W.P.(C) 5395/2015 & Ors. Page 2 of 14 versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 5432/2015 & CM 9785/2015 JAI PRAKASH AND ORS. ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 5433/2015 & CM 9786/2015 KRISHAN SINGH ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 5436/2015 & CM 97872015 RAJENDER SINGH ..... Petitioner versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 5437/2015 & CM 9788/2015 RAM CHANDER & ANR ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 5448/2015 & CM 9803/2015 PREM SINGH & ORS ..... Petitioners versus W.P.(C) 5395/2015 & Ors. Page 3 of 14 GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 5449/2015 & CM 9804/2015 RAMPHAL AND ORS. ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 5452/2015 & CM 9808/2015 RAM KANWAR & ORS. ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 5460/2015 & CM 9830/2015 DHANPATI & ORS. ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 5473/2015 & CM 9843/2015 CHARAN SINGH & ORS. ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 7138/2015 & CM 13100/2015 RANBIR SINGH AND ORS. ..... Petitioners versus W.P.(C) 5395/2015 & Ors. Page 4 of 14 GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 7142/2015 & CM 13106/2015 DHARAMVIR SINGH & ORS. ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 7149/2015 & CM 13114/2015 SUKHBIR SINGH & ORS ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 7153/2015 & CM 13118/2015 SURAJ SINGH AND ORS. ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 7154/2015 & CM 13119/2015 RAJ KARAN & ORS ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 7155/2015 & CM 13120/2015 KARTAR SINGH & ORS ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents W.P.(C) 5395/2015 & Ors. Page 5 of 14 + W.P.(C) 7179/2015 & CM 13200/2015 JAI KISHAN AND ORS. ..... Petitioners versus GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 7181/2015 & CM 13203/2015 HAR PRATAP SINGH & ANR ..... Petitioners versus GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 7183/2015 & CM 13204/2015 OM PRAKASH & ORS ..... Petitioners versus GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 7185/2015 & CM 13206/2015 KHEM RAJ & ORS. ..... Petitioners versus GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 7187/2015 & CM 13208/2015 DAYANAND & ORS ..... Petitioners versus GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 7189/2015 & CM 13210/2015 W.P.(C) 5395/2015 & Ors. Page 6 of 14 NARAYAN SINGH & ANR. ..... Petitioners versus GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 7190/2015 & CM 13211/2015 ROHTASH SINGH & ORS ..... Petitioners versus GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 7194/2015 & CM 13216/2015 KARTAR SINGH & ORS ..... Petitioners versus GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents + W.P.(C) 7196/2015 & CM 13218/2015 DARSHANA & ORS ..... Petitioners versus GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS ..... Respondents Advocates who appeared in this case:- For the Petitioners: Mr Sanjay Parikh with Mr Aagney Sail & Ms Nimi Susan Thomas. For the Respondent L&B/LAC: Mr Yeeshu Jain, Standing counsel with Ms Jyoti Tyagi. For the Respondent L&B/LAC: Mr Siddharth Panda. For the Respondent DSIIDC: Ms Renuka Arora with Ms Anusuya Salwan & Mr Kunal Kohli. W.P.(C) 5395/2015 & Ors. Page 7 of 14 CORAM:- HONBLE MR JUSTICE BADAR DURREZ AHMED HONBLE MR JUSTICE ASHUTOSH KUMAR JUDGMENT ASHUTOSH KUMAR, J

1. In all these writ petitions, the petitioners have prayed for the benefit of Section 24(2) of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (hereinafter referred to as the 2013 Act), i.e., a declaration to the effect that the land acquisition proceedings in respect of their lands be deemed to have lapsed in view of the provisions of Section 24(2) of the 2013 Act. The aforesaid prayers have been made in the background of the fact that the petitioners have received compensation but they remained in continuous physical possession of the land in question even though the award was made more than 5 (five) years prior to the commencement of the 2013 Act (i.e. on 01.01.2014). All the writ petitions are based on almost identical facts except the description of lands and some dates. The facts of the case of the petitioners in W.P.(C) No.5395/2015 Jai Kishan & Anr. is taken as the reference case.

2. Hence, all the writ petitions are being disposed of by this common W.P.(C) 5395/2015 & Ors. Page 8 of 14 judgment.

3. The land acquisition proceedings in the aforesaid batch of cases commenced under the old Land Acquisition Act of 1894. The notification under section 4 of the 1894 act was issued on 25.08.2005 for the acquisition of land for public purpose viz. for development of New Industrial Area admeasuring 1343 bighas and 03 biswas of land in village Kanjhawala; 1774 bighas and 09 biswas of land in village Sultanpur Dabas; 1905 bighas and 05 biswas of land in village Karala; and 30 bighas and 09 biswas of land in village Pooth Khurd. Thereafter declaration under section 6 of the 1894 act was made on 10.07.2006 and ultimately award no.3/2008-09 dated 26.05.2008 was passed for the lands in village Karala which included the land of the petitioners in W.P.(C) 5395/2015 (Jai Kishan and Anr.). Separate awards were passed for lands acquired in other villages.

4. The award clearly indicated that the physical possession of the land under acquisition would be taken after the announcement of the award.

5. The respondents have contended that the physical possession of the subject lands was taken on 29.07.2008 and the compensation to the petitioners was also paid. In some of the cases, the subject land was W.P.(C) 5395/2015 & Ors. Page 9 of 14 taken on different dates. The aforesaid facts have been disputed by the petitioners and they asserted that the physical possession was still with them and that only paper possession was taken.

6. The petitioners in this batch of cases had challenged the compensation which was determined by the Collector by moving reference under section 18 of the 1894 act. During the pendency of such reference petitions, Government floated a Special Rehabilitation Package (SRP) wherein taking into consideration the general increase in the prices of the land and the inequity of giving compensation based on the procedure followed under the 1894 Act, it was decided that with respect to the land for which the awards were not announced till December, 2007, a special benefit would be given to the people affected.

7. The Special Rehabilitation Package read as under: GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI LAND & BUILDING DEPARTMENT B-BLOCK: VIKAS BHAWAN: NEW DELHI. No.F.9(20)/80/L&B/LA/Vol.II/8226-44 Dated: 01-10-2008 ORDER The government of the NCT of Delhi have taken into consideration the general increase in prices of land and the inequity of giving compensation based on the procedure W.P.(C) 5395/2015 & Ors. Page 10 of 14 followed under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. Therefore, the government have decided to give a Special Rehabilitation Package for the people affected by land acquisition in respect of the cases in which the land acquisition awards have not been announced till December 18, 2007, details of which are:-

1. The amount of compensation effective from December 18, 2007 would be discounted by Rupees 11.80 lakhs per acre per year for those lands which were notified under section 4 for acquisition in 2006 and 2005.

2. Though this Special Rehabilitation Package would involved additional funds for making payment of compensation to the farmers, the amount would be recovered while determining the cost of land allotted to other government agencies.

3. The other elements of the award namely solatium and interest would be allowed as per rules.

4. The Special Rehabilitation Package would not be treated as precedent for the future.

5. The payment of compensation should be done in a time bound manner.

6. The package would apply to all agricultural lands.

7. The Special Rehabilitation Package should be accepted by individual farmers and made applicable in each case only, if they do not mount a challenge to the award already announced by the LAC. If they have challenged the award they must withdraw the petition to avail of the benefit of the Special Rehabilitation Package. Sd/- ( G.S. MEENA ) Addl. Secretary (L&B)

8. The petitioners accepted such package (SRP) and gave an W.P.(C) 5395/2015 & Ors. Page 11 of 14 undertaking, in accordance with the terms of the package, of their having accepted the compensation including SRP, leading to cessation of all their rights qua the acquired land. In the undertaking given by the petitioners, it was categorically stated that no cause of action would arise for agitating the matter in any courts of law or authority or authorities and that it was towards full and final settlement in respect of the acquired land.

9. Be it noted that these undertakings of the petitioners were made prior to the commencement of 2013 Act i.e. on 01.01.2014.

10. A bench of this Court in W.P.(C) 9101/2014: Bhim Singh & Ors. vs. Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors. and other batch cases held, without going into the question and distinction of the physical possession or the paper possession that the land owners, after having accepted the SRP and having given their undertaking in that regard, had actually surrendered their rights in the subject lands.

11. Since it was held in the aforesaid cases that the land owners, by accepting the SRP and giving an undertaking referred to above, had divested themselves of all their rights with respect of the subject acquired land prior to the commencement of 2013 Act, they could not have W.P.(C) 5395/2015 & Ors. Page 12 of 14 claimed any benefit under Section 24(2) of the 2013 Act.

12. The facts of these batch of cases are virtually identical and are covered by the aforesaid judgment delivered on 20.12.2016 in Bhim Singh & Ors. vs. Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors.

13. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners however contended that an undertaking given by the petitioners as ordained in the Special Rehabilitation Package could not have snatched away the statutory rights of the petitioners under the New Act and that the undertaking merely was with respect to their rights for continuing with the proceedings under Section 18 i.e. for enhancement of compensation, under the 1894 Act. The aforesaid submission was based on the premise that without taking the actual possession of the land acquired by the Government, the land remained with the land owners and therefore they would definitely be entitled to the benefit of Section 24(2) of the New Act of 2013 which provides succour to such land owners with respect to whose lands, even after passing of the award, awarded compensation is not paid or possession is not taken. Thus, it was argued that despite the undertaking given by the petitioners as contemplated in the SRP, the rights under Section 24(2) of the New Act could not be denied to them. It W.P.(C) 5395/2015 & Ors. Page 13 of 14 was contended that the acquisition proceedings would not be deemed to have been completed till possession is taken. Section 16 of the Land Acquisition Act 1894 provides that collector may take possession of land, which shall thereupon vest absolutely in the government, free of all encumbrances. It was further argued that the power of acquisition and possession of property falls within the power of eminent domain, and therefore strict compliance with the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 and Article 300-A of the Constitution is a must. Vesting of land under Section 16 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 pre-supposes actual physical possession and the onus of taking possession is on the acquiring authority. Since the land acquisition proceedings are expropriatory in nature, the provisions of the Act has to be construed strictly. The new rights under the new Act of 2013, therefore, cannot be denied, notwithstanding the acceptance of SRP and the undertaking of giving up of rights qua the acquired land.

14. There is no gainsaying that the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 have to be strictly complied with but we are afraid, we cannot accede to the submissions of the petitioners as it has been clearly laid down in W.P.(C) 9101/2014 (Bhim Singh Vs. Government of NCT of W.P.(C) 5395/2015 & Ors. Page 14 of 14 Delhi & Anr.) that no right, title or interest of the petitioners is left in the subject lands after the land owners accepted the Special Rehabilitation Package and compensation and gave a clear undertaking that they shall not pursue their rights in the subject lands. The aforesaid judgment is absolutely clear and unambiguous that in the absence of any right, title or interest in the subject land on the date of coming into force of the New Act, such benefit thereunder cannot be extended to the petitioners/ land owners.

15. The case of the petitioners are squarely covered by the judgment delivered in Bhim Singh & Ors. vs. Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors.

16. Accordingly, it is held that the petitioners cannot claim any benefit under Section 24(2) of the 2013 Act.

17. These writ petitions are dismissed accordingly but without any costs and all the pending applications stand disposed of.

18. Interim orders, if any, stand vacated. ASHUTOSH KUMAR, J BADAR DURREZ AHMED, J FEBRUARY 21, 2017/ab