Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Roopendra Singh v. State Of Tripura And Another

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 11, 2017
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

SLP (Crl.) No. 7014 of 2012: The appellant-accused was acquitted by the Additional Sessions Judge, Khowai, West Tripura of charges under Sections 342, 376(2)(b) and 506 IPC. The victim (Respondent 2) filed Criminal Appeal No. 23 of 2011 before the Gauhati High Court under Section 372 CrPC. The High Court ruled that, as a “victim,” she could appeal without obtaining leave under Section 378(3) CrPC. The accused challenged that finding before the Supreme Court.

SLP (Crl.) Nos. 8316-17 of 2012: The Extra Joint Ad-hoc Additional Sessions Judge, Kelapur acquitted the accused of offences under Sections 302 and 201 read with Section 34 IPC. The State’s application for leave to appeal was rejected by the Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench). Relying on that rejection, the High Court also dismissed the widow-informant’s appeal filed under Section 372 CrPC. She approached the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a victim’s statutory right of appeal conferred by the proviso to Section 372 CrPC can be exercised without obtaining leave of the High Court under Section 378(3) CrPC.
  2. Whether the dismissal of a victim’s appeal can be sustained solely because the High Court has refused leave to the State to appeal against the same acquittal.

Arguments of the Parties

Amicus Curiae’s Submissions

  • The proviso to Section 372 is an independent substantive provision giving an unfettered right to victims to appeal against acquittal, conviction for a lesser offence, or inadequate compensation.
  • Appeals under Sections 373, 374, 377, 379 and 380 CrPC can be filed without leave; appeals under Section 378 require leave. A victim’s appeal under the proviso to Section 372 belongs to the first category.
  • The legislative history—from the 1955 amendment to Section 417 of the 1898 Code, through the 154th Law Commission Report and the Malimath Committee—shows Parliament’s intention to strengthen victims’ rights and avoid the “distortion” of the criminal-justice system.
  • The decision of this Court in Satya Pal Singh v. State of M.P. was said to create anomalies, especially where appeals would lie to a Sessions Court (no leave contemplated) yet require leave if filed by a victim.
  • Accordingly, the Amicus sought reference to a larger Bench for reconsideration of Satya Pal Singh.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Satya Pal Singh v. State of M.P., (2015) 15 SCC 613 A victim may appeal under the proviso to Section 372 CrPC, but only after obtaining leave of the High Court under Section 378(3) CrPC. The Supreme Court treated this decision as binding and declined to refer the matter to a larger Bench; it applied the requirement of leave to the present cases.
Ram Phal v. State & Ors., 2015 SCC OnLine Del 9802; (2015) 221 DLT 1 (Full Bench, Delhi HC) Held that a victim’s appeal under Section 372 is an independent right not requiring leave. Cited only to note that it was disapproved in Satya Pal Singh; the Court did not follow it.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. The Court noted that Satya Pal Singh directly settled the legal question and therefore controlled the outcome. Although extensive submissions were made for reconsideration, the Bench found no justification to depart from or refer the matter against that precedent, especially given the pendency of these cases for more than five years.

2. In SLP 7014/2012, the victim had already filed an application requesting that her appeal be treated as one under Section 372 read with Section 378. Applying Satya Pal Singh, the Court held that leave under Section 378(3) CrPC was indeed necessary but deemed it appropriate to grant such leave itself so that the High Court could consider the appeal on merits.

3. In SLP 8316-17/2012, the Court emphasized that the right of a “victim” (as defined in Section 2(wa)) to maintain an appeal is substantive and independent. The High Court erred in dismissing the widow-informant’s appeal merely because the State’s application for leave had been refused. The correct course was for the High Court to consider whether leave should be granted to the victim, in line with paragraphs 17 and 18 of Satya Pal Singh.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF / ALLOWED.

• In SLP (Crl.) 7014/2012, the Supreme Court granted the requisite leave under Section 378(3) CrPC and remitted the victim’s appeal to the Gauhati High Court for decision on merits.

• In SLP (Crl.) 8316-17/2012, the orders of the Bombay High Court dismissing the widow-informant’s appeal were set aside. The matter was remitted for fresh consideration, including the question of leave in light of Satya Pal Singh.

Implications are confined to directing High Courts to apply the rule in Satya Pal Singh; no new precedent was set, but clarity was provided on the procedural handling of victim appeals pending before High Courts.

Show all summary ...

Uday U. Lalit, J.— Leave granted in both the matters.

I. Criminal appeal arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 7014 of 2012

2. The appellant was tried in Sessions Trial No. 22 (WT/K) 2010 in the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Khowai, West Tripura for having committed the offences punishable under Sections 342, 376(2)(b) and 506 IPC and was acquitted of all the charges levelled against him vide judgment of the trial court dated 28-4-2011. Respondent 2 i.e the victim challenged the acquittal by filing Criminal Appeal No. 23 of 2011 in the Gauhati High Court, Agartala Bench. This appeal was filed under Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (“CrPC”, for short). When the appeal was listed for admission, an objection was taken that unless “leave” was granted under Section 378(4) CrPC, the appeal could not be admitted. At this juncture, a petition under Section 482 CrPC was filed by Respondent 2 for treating the said criminal appeal under Section 372 read with Section 378 CrPC.

3. The matter was contested. The High Court by its judgment and order dated 6-6-2012 Cri MA No. 253 of 2011 concluded that there was an unfettered right conferred upon the victim by Section 372 CrPC and that no leave was required for the victim to file such appeal. Consequently, the High Court observed that there was no necessity for converting the appeal to one under Section 372 read with Section 378 CrPC. The following observations are noteworthy:

“The proviso to Section 372 has created a right to appeal unfettered of any leave or sanction and it shall automatically lie to the forum where an appeal ordinarily lies against the order of conviction of such court if the said appeal against the judgment and order of acquittal is filed by the victim as defined in Section 2(wa) CrPC.
For the reasons as stated above, this Court is of the view that even though the right to appeal for the victim has been created by the proviso to Section 372 CrPC, the said proviso itself is a comprehensive provision, not fettered by any leave or sanction as required for the categories of appeals as depicted in Sections 378(1), 378(2) and 378(4) CrPC. No leave is required for the victim to file an appeal as against the order of acquittal under the proviso to Section 372 CrPC.”

4. The correctness of the decision of the High Court is questioned by the appellant-accused. By order dated 13-8-2014 SLP (Cri) No. 7014 of 2012, Mr Shekhar Naphade, learned Senior Advocate was requested to assist the Court as Amicus Curiae and the matter was directed to be listed for final hearing. In the meantime, a decision was rendered by this Court on 6-10-2015 in Satya Pal Singh v. State of M.P (2015) 15 SCC 613 Paras 14, 15, 17 and 18 of the decision are as under:( & 621)

“14. Thus, from a reading of the abovesaid legal position laid down by this Court in the cases referred to supra, it is abundantly clear that the proviso to Section 372 CrPC must be read along with its main enactment i.e Section 372 itself and together with sub-section (3) of Section 378 CrPC, otherwise the substantive provision of Section 372 CrPC will be rendered nugatory, as it clearly states that no appeal shall lie from any judgment or order of a criminal court except as provided by CrPC.
15. Thus, to conclude on the legal issue:
‘Whether the appellant herein, being the father of the deceased, has statutory right to prefer an appeal to the High Court against the order of acquittal under the proviso to Section 372 CrPC without obtaining the leave of the High Court as required under sub-section (3) of Section 378 CrPC?’
This Court is of the view that the right of questioning the correctness of the judgment and order of acquittal by preferring an appeal to the High Court is conferred upon the victim including the legal heir and others, as defined under Section 2(wa) CrPC, under the proviso to Section 372, but only after obtaining the leave of the High Court as required under sub-section (3) of Section 378 CrPC. The High Court of M.P has failed to deal with this important legal aspect of the matter while passing the impugned judgment and order.
***
17. Hence, the impugned judgment and order of the High Court is not sustainable in law and the same is liable to be set aside by this Court and the case is required to be remanded to the High Court to consider for grant of leave to file an appeal by the appellant as required under sub-section (3) of Section 378 CrPC and thereafter proceed in the matter.
18. For the reasons stated supra, this appeal is allowed by setting aside the impugned judgment and order of the High Court. The case is remanded to the High Court to hear the appellant with regard to grant of leave to file an appeal as the appellant is legal heir of the victim as defined under Section 2(wa) CrPC and dispose of the appeal in accordance with law in the light of observations made in this order as expeditiously as possible.”

5. The decision in Satya Pal Singh (2015) 15 SCC 613 shows that reliance was placed on a Full Bench decision of the High Court of Delhi in Ram Phal v. State 2015 SCC OnLine Del 9802, (2015) 221 DLT 1, according to which the right to prefer an appeal conferred upon a victim by virtue of the proviso to Section 372 CrPC is an independent statutory right and there is no need for the victim to seek leave of the High Court. The said decision of the Full Bench of the High Court of Delhi was not found to be legally correct by this Court in Satya Pal Singh (2015) 15 SCC 613.

6. When this matter came up for final hearing, the learned Amicus Curiae submitted that the decision of this Court in Satya Pal Singh (2015) 15 SCC 613 required reconsideration. It was submitted that the proviso to Section 372 CrPC is an independent provision conferring a substantive right on the victim to prefer an appeal against the judgment of acquittal, conviction for lesser offence or inadequate compensation. It was further submitted that appeals under Sections 373, 374, 377, 379 and 380 in Chapter XXIX CrPC constitute one category of appeals which can be presented without obtaining leave of the appellate court while appeals under Section 378 whether by the State Government, Central Government or by the complainant against the order of acquittal constitute another category of appeals which are circumscribed by the requirement of obtaining leave of the High Court. In his submission, the appeal under the proviso to Section 372 falls in the first category of appeals and as rightly observed by the High Court of Gauhati in the present case, no leave of the High Court was required. The learned Amicus Curiae then traced the legislative history and submitted that in the 1898 Code of Criminal Procedure, as originally enacted, no right was conferred on the complainant to file an appeal against acquittal, which for the first time was introduced in Section 417 of the 1898 Code in the year 1955. He further submitted that though the Law Commission in its 41st Report had rejected the suggestion of permitting the victim to file appeals against the order of acquittal, in its 154th Report the Law Commission had relied on the 1985 Union Nations Declaration of Basic Principles of Justice for victims of crimes and abuse of power. The Report of the Law Commission noted that the victims were the worst sufferers in the crime and needed to be given certain rights and compensation. The learned Amicus Curiae then stated that these developments led to the constitution of Malimath Committee which recommended that the victims should have the right to file appeal against acquittal and that is how the proviso to Section 372 came to be inserted by the Amendment Act of 2008. He laid emphasis on the following portion from the Objects and Reasons which weighed with Parliament while inserting the proviso:

“2. … At present, the victims are the worst sufferers in a crime and they do not have much role in the court proceedings. They need to be given certain rights and compensation, so that there is no distortion of the criminal justice system.”

He submitted that the Statement of Objects and Reasons clearly stressed that the administration of criminal law has tendency to distort and therefore the victims are the worst sufferers and as such Parliament had given an unrestricted right to the victim to prefer appeal against acquittal.

7. In his written submissions, the learned Amicus Curiae sought to bring out the anomalies in the decision of this Court in Satya Pal Singh (2015) 15 SCC 613 in the following terms:

“(1) This Hon'ble Court in Satya Pal Singh case (2015) 15 SCC 613 has missed out the significance of the word “conviction” used in the proviso to Section 372 CrPC. Under the Code, against a conviction, an appeal does not necessarily lie to the High Court. Section 374 lays down different fora for preferring an appeal against conviction.
(i) If a person is convicted in a trial held by the High Court in its extraordinary original criminal jurisdiction, an appeal lies to the Supreme Court.
(ii) Any person convicted by the Sessions Judge or the Assistant Sessions Judge, an appeal lies to the High Court.
(iii) If a person is convicted by any court in which the sentence of imprisonment for more than 7 years is passed, he may appeal to the High Court.
(iv) Any person convicted in a trial held in the Court of a Metropolitan Magistrate or Assistant Sessions Judge or Magistrate of the First Class or Second Class, his appeal will lie to the Court of Session.
(v) If any person is sentenced by the aforesaid judicial authorities i.e Metropolitan Magistrate, Assistant Judge, Sessions Judge and sentenced under Section 325, an appeal lies to the Court of Session.
(vi) Any person convicted and sentenced by the Magistrate under Section 360, an appeal lies to the Court of Session.
(2) The proviso to Section 372 not only deals with filing of appeal by the victim but it also provides for Forum. The Forum of such appeals is same as in case of appeals against conviction. Section 374 shows that some appeals against conviction lie before the Sessions Court. Therefore, some appeals of the victim against acquittal would lie before the Sessions Court. In respect of such appeals there is no question of obtaining leave. This creates serious anomaly.
(3) The proviso to Section 372 deals with the rights of the victim to file an appeal against the following order:
(i) against acquittal
(ii) against conviction for a lesser offence and
(iii) against imposition of inadequate compensation
As far as imposing inadequate compensation is concerned, the Government has no role to play. Once it is laid down that a right of appeal under the proviso is controlled by Section 378(3) CrPC then such a stipulation would apply to appeals against all the three orders.”

8. Though the learned Amicus Curiae has suggested that these matters be referred to larger Bench to reconsider the decision of this Court in Satya Pal Singh (2015) 15 SCC 613, we do not think that such course ought to be adopted in the present matter. The special leave petition has been pending in this Court for last 5 years. In any case, in the present matter, the victim had preferred an application to treat the appeal initially filed under Section 372 to be one under Section 372 read with Section 378 CrPC. Though the High Court observed that no such leave was necessary, the matter now assumes different complexion in the light of the decision in Satya Pal Singh (2015) 15 SCC 613. However, since there was already an application on behalf of the victim to treat the appeal under Section 372 read with Section 378 CrPC, in our considered view, the leave ought to be granted, which we presently do. The pending appeal shall now be considered on merits by the High Court. This appeal, thus, stands disposed of.

II. Criminal appeals arising out of SLPs (Crl.) Nos. 8316-17 of 2012

9. These appeals, at the instance of the original informant question the orders dated 20-6-2012 2012 SCC OnLine Bom 2125 and 28-6-2012 2012 SCC OnLine Bom 2124 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Nagpur Bench, Nagpur. By order dated 20-6-2012 2012 SCC OnLine Bom 2125, Criminal Application No. 399 of 2012 preferred by the State of Maharashtra seeking leave to appeal against the judgment and order dated 4-2-2012 passed by the Extra Joint Ad-hoc Additional Sessions Judge, Kelapur in Sessions Trial No. 6 of 2011 acquitting the accused of the offences punishable under Sections 302, 201 read with Section 34 IPC was rejected by the High Court. The appeal under Section 372 CrPC preferred by the informant, who also happens to be the widow of the deceased was rejected in the light of the earlier rejection dated 20-6-2012 2012 SCC OnLine Bom 2125. It appears that the State of Maharashtra did not challenge the rejection of their application seeking leave to appeal. This Court issued notice in the aforesaid matter on 12-10-2012 and the matter was thereafter tagged with SLP (Crl.) No. 7014 of 2012, namely, the earlier matter arising out of the judgment of the Gauhati High Court.

10. Section 372 CrPC has conferred upon a victim a substantive and independent right to maintain an appeal against acquittal. The widow of the deceased in the present matter comes within the definition of “victim” as incorporated in Section 2(wa). Merely because leave to appeal was not granted to the State to prefer an appeal against acquittal, the appeal preferred by the victim informant ought not to have been rejected by the High Court summarily. We, therefore, set aside the order dated 28-6-2012 2012 SCC OnLine Bom 2124 passed by the High Court rejecting criminal appeal preferred by the appellant and remit the matter to the High Court for fresh consideration. It will be open to the High Court to consider the matter for grant of leave to appeal to the appellant in the light of paras 17 and 18 of the decision of this Court in Satya Pal Singh (2015) 15 SCC 613.

11. These appeals are thus allowed in the aforesaid terms.

12. Before we part, we must express and record our sincere appreciation for the assistance rendered by the learned Amicus Curiae. The Court is deeply grateful to him.