Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Baleshwar Mahto And Another v. State Of Bihar And Another

Supreme Court Of India
Jan 9, 2017
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Anandi Prasad (PW-7), his father Lala Mahto and his brother Bindeshwar Prasad went to sow paddy on agricultural land that was simultaneously claimed by the accused side. A large group led by the present appellants—Khelawan Yadav (A-1) armed with a rifle and Baleshar Mahto (A-2) armed with a gun—arrived and objected. After an exhortation to kill, A-1 fired at Lala Mahto, causing a fatal head injury; A-2 fired at PW-7, while other assailants wounded Bindeshwar. PW-7 lodged a fardbeyan at Bind Police Station, leading to registration of an FIR for offences under Sections 302/307 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 27 of the Arms Act.

The Sessions Court convicted A-1 of murder (Section 302 IPC) and Arms Act offences, sentencing him to life imprisonment, and convicted A-2 of attempt to murder (Section 307 IPC) and Arms Act offences, sentencing him to seven years’ rigorous imprisonment. All other accused were acquitted, and that acquittal became final. The Patna High Court, by judgment dated 13 March 2013 (2013 SCC OnLine Pat 149), dismissed the separate appeals of A-1 and A-2, affirming the convictions and sentences. The Supreme Court granted special leave on 21 February 2014; A-2 obtained bail on 13 October 2014, while A-1 remained in custody during the pendency of the appeals.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution proved, beyond reasonable doubt, that A-1 committed murder under Section 302 IPC and that A-2 committed attempt to murder under Section 307 IPC, both also attracting Section 27 of the Arms Act.
  2. Whether alleged inconsistencies between ocular testimony and medical evidence created reasonable doubt warranting acquittal.
  3. Whether the existence of a land dispute and injuries on the accused transformed the incident into a sudden fight, thereby negating the requisite intent for the offences charged.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The occurrence stemmed from a land dispute; both sides received injuries, yet the investigation ignored wounds on the accused, rendering it biased.
  • Medical findings (particularly by Dr C.P. Sinha, PW-2) allegedly contradicted PW-7’s description of gunshot injuries, undermining the prosecution’s narrative.
  • Unexplained discrepancies between ocular and medical evidence, coupled with the acquittal of co-accused, required rejection of eyewitness testimony and acquittal of the appellants.

State's Arguments

  • The defence selectively cited portions of evidence; a holistic reading of ocular and medical testimony shows consistency.
  • The High Court had already undertaken a detailed evaluation and correctly upheld the convictions.
  • Independent and injured eyewitnesses corroborate the prosecution version; even PW-2 did not rule out bullet injuries.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kamaljit Singh v. State of Punjab Minor variances between medical and ocular evidence do not eclipse eyewitness testimony unless the medical findings wholly rule it out. Used to hold that the alleged contradictions did not vitiate the prosecution case.
Solanki Chimanbhai Ukabhai v. State of Gujarat Same principle on reconciliation of medical and ocular evidence. Reinforced reliance on eyewitness account.
State of U.P. v. Krishna Gopal (1988) 4 SCC 302 Appellate interference permissible where trial court’s appreciation is manifestly erroneous. Cited to support High Court’s affirmation of conviction.
Abdul Sayeed v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2010) 10 SCC 259 Special evidentiary weight of injured witnesses and treatment of medical–ocular consistency. Relied on to accord high credence to PW-7’s testimony.
Ramlagan Singh v. State of Bihar (1973) 3 SCC 881 Credibility of injured witnesses. Part of chain of authority validating PW-7’s evidence.
Malkhan Singh v. State of U.P. (1975) 3 SCC 311 Same as above. Same application.
Machhi Singh v. State of Punjab (1983) 3 SCC 470 Value of injured eyewitness testimony. Same application.
Appabhai v. State of Gujarat 1988 Supp SCC 241 Weight of injured witness evidence. Same application.
Bonkya v. State of Maharashtra (1995) 6 SCC 447 Credibility of injured witnesses. Same application.
Bhag Singh (1997) 7 SCC 712 Same theme of injured witness reliability. Same application.
Mohar v. State of U.P. (2002) 7 SCC 606 Injured witness status. Same application.
Dinesh Kumar v. State of Rajasthan (2008) 8 SCC 270 Injured witness credibility. Same application.
Vishnu v. State of Rajasthan (2009) 10 SCC 477 Injured witness credibility. Same application.
Annareddy Sambasiva Reddy v. State of A.P. (2009) 12 SCC 546 Injured witness credibility. Same application.
Balraje @ Trimbak v. State of Maharashtra (2010) 6 SCC 673 Injured witness credibility. Same application.
Jarnail Singh v. State of Punjab (2009) 9 SCC 719 Evidentiary value of injured witnesses. Same application.
Shivalingappa Kallayanappa v. State of Karnataka 1994 Supp (3) SCC 235 Credibility of injured witnesses. Same application.
State of U.P. v. Kishan Chand (2004) 7 SCC 629 Relevance of stamped (injured) witnesses. Same application.
Krishan v. State of Haryana (2006) 12 SCC 459 Lengthy cross-examination failing to shake injured witness. Same application.
State of Haryana v. Bhagirath (1999) 5 SCC 96 Court not bound by medical opinion lacking logic or probability. Used to prefer credible ocular evidence over speculative medical opinion.
Thaman Kumar v. State (UT of Chandigarh) (2003) 6 SCC 380 Medical evidence not sole touchstone; holistic evaluation required. Supportive of overall reasoning.
Krishnan v. State (2003) 7 SCC 56 Same principle as immediately above. Supportive of overall reasoning.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court found no merit in the appellants’ challenge, endorsing the High Court’s appreciation of evidence.

  • Contradictory Defence: In their Section 313 CrPC statements the appellants totally denied the incident, yet on appeal they argued a mutual fight—an inconsistency that weakened their credibility.
  • Ocular–Medical Consistency: The Court analysed PW-2’s medical testimony and the post-mortem report, concluding that rifle-shot injuries were compatible with the recorded wounds. Applying Kamaljit Singh and allied precedents, minor variances did not undermine the eyewitness account.
  • Injured Eyewitness Reliability: PW-7, himself wounded, was considered highly reliable under the principles laid down in Abdul Sayeed and a line of earlier cases. Independent witnesses (PWs 4 & 5) further corroborated the sequence of events.
  • Land-Dispute Argument Rejected: The longstanding land dispute evidenced motive and prior animosity; arriving armed with deadly weapons indicated pre-formed intent rather than a sudden quarrel.
  • No Prejudice from Non-Explanation of Accused Injuries: The Court noted that the defence’s claim of injuries on the accused was inconsistent with its own denial of the incident and did not cast doubt on the prosecution story.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Dismissed. The Supreme Court affirmed A-1’s conviction under Section 302 IPC and Section 27 Arms Act with a sentence of life imprisonment; A-1, aged about 80, was given liberty to seek remission. A-2’s conviction under Section 307 IPC and Section 27 Arms Act was upheld, but his seven-year sentence was reduced to the period already undergone, discharging his bail bond.

Implications are confined to the parties: the convictions stand final; the decision reiterates settled principles on reconciling medical and ocular evidence and on the probative force of injured eyewitnesses, without laying down new legal precedent.

Show all summary ...

Dr A.K Sikri, J.— These appeals are preferred by two appellants, named, Khelawan Yadav and Baleshar Mahto (hereinafter referred to as “A-1 and A-2”, respectively). While A-1 has been convicted for the offence punishable under Section 302 of the Penal Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”) and also under Section 27 of the Arms Act, for which he is sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment (RI) for life, A-2 has been found guilty for the offence punishable under Section 307 IPC and also Section 27 of the Arms Act. Sentence awarded to him is RI for 7 years under both counts. The aforesaid conviction and sentences given by the Sessions Court have been upheld by the High Court vide its common judgment dated 13-3-2013 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 149 in the two separate appeals preferred by these appellants. It is this judgment which is impugned by the appellants in these appeals.

2. The case against the appellants, as set up by the prosecution was that Anandi Prasad (PW 7) along with his father, Lala Mahto and brother Bindeshwar Prasad had gone to their field to sow paddy seeds. While they were ploughing the field, A-1 armed with rifle, Dulli Mahto armed with lathi, Rajendra Mahto armed with gun, Arun Yadav armed with gun, Umesh Prasad armed with garasa, Subhash Prasad armed with bhala, Baleshwar Mahto (A-2), Siwan Mahto armed with gun, Ram Bilas Yadav armed with garasa, Surendra Yadav armed with gun, Ram Lagan Prasad armed with gun came there. A-1 questioned Anandi Prasad (PW 7) for their aforesaid act as according to A-1 those fields belonged to him. PW 7, however, resisted this claiming that these were their fields which they were ploughing. This resistance on the part of PW 7 led Dulli Mahto to exhort others to kill PW 7 and his father and brother. Khelawan opened fire from his rifle and the firing of which hit on the head of Lala Mahto and his head was smashed and he fell down there. Baleshwar also opened fire which hit on the left shoulder of Anandi and also on his head. Ram Bilas hit him on his head with “garasa”. Umesh also hit on the head of Bindeshwar, the brother of Anandi. Dulli hit them with “lathi”, other accused had also opened fire due to which nobody could dare to come there. Lala Mahto, father of PW 7 succumbed to the injuries inflicted by the aforesaid persons.

3. PW 7 informed Bind Police Station about the aforesaid incident by giving his fardbeyan (Ext. 9). In his fardbeyan, PW 7 also mentioned that Brahmdeo Sao, Kameshwar Prasad and Ramu Sao had witnessed the aforesaid occurrence. FIR was registered on the basis of the said fardbeyan and investigation commenced thereafter. On the conclusion of the investigation, the charge-sheet was submitted under Sections 302 and 307 IPC as well as under Section 27 of the Arms Act for causing murder of Lala Mahto and attempt to murder of PW 7 and his brother Bindeshwar Prasad. All the accused persons were put on trial. The trial court found A-1 and A-2 guilty of the offences, as mentioned above, but acquitted all others. Against the acquittal of other accused persons, challenge was not laid by the State or the complainant and, therefore, their acquittal attained finality. However, these appellants filed their separate appeals challenging the conviction and sentences awarded by the trial court in which attempt they have failed as the High Court has found the appeals to be devoid of any merits. During the pendency of the appeal before the High Court, the appellants were given bail by suspending their sentences, the High Court, therefore, directed them to surrender before the trial court to serve out their sentences.

4. In the SLPs filed by the appellants, leave was granted on 21-2-2014 SLPs (Cri) Nos. 10277-78 of 2013. Thereafter, on 13-10-2014, A-2 was released on bail. Insofar as A-1 is concerned, he was not granted bail and, therefore, he has remained in jail during the pendency of these appeals.

5*. Mr Nagendra Rai, learned Senior Counsel appeared for these two appellants to argue these appeals. Mr Abhinav Mukherji, counsel contested the appeal by making his submissions on behalf of the respondent State. Insofar as the appellants are concerned they have made threefold submissions in their endeavour to show that the prosecution has not been able to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt and, in fact, it was a case of faulty and partial investigation. The threefold submissions in this behalf, projected by the learned counsel, are the following:

5.1 It is submitted, in the first instance, that it was admittedly a case of land dispute as both the parties were claiming that the land which was being ploughed by the complainant belonged to the accused persons. It was further pointed out that even as per the prosecution, quarrel erupted when the appellants objected to the said fields being ploughed by PW 7, his father and brother. The learned counsel argued that, in fact, in the fight that ensued, even accused party was attacked by the complainant's party and both the sides had received injuries. However, the investigating officer (IO) did not bother to mention about the injuries suffered by the persons belonging to the accused party and this aspect was totally side-tracked. Referring to the deposition of Dr C.P Sinha (PW 2), it was pointed out that A-2 was also found injured on whose person as many as six injuries were found. It was argued that there were two plots, Plot No. 3497 and Plot No. 3595 whereas Plot No. 3497 belonged to the complainant party, Plot No. 3595 belonged to the accused persons. It was submitted that at the time of incident, the complainant party was in fact ploughing Plot No. 3595 which belonged to the accused party. For this purpose, the deposition of PW 10, Shri Jai Narain Singh who is also the resident of that area was referred to. On this basis, it was argued that fault lay with the complainant party who had interfered with the plot belonging to the accused party which gave justifiable reason to the accused party to protest and because of this reason sudden fight took place. The submission was that it was not a premeditated act but both the parties got raged due to the aforesaid dispute about the ownership of the plots. A-1, therefore, could not be convicted of committing murder and punished under Section 302 IPC, more so, when the accused party also got injured in the said fight.

5.2 It was further submitted that the medical evidence by the doctors who examined PW 7, his brother as well as his father was at variance with the ocular evidence i.e the description of the incident as given by PW 7. In this behalf, it was submitted that PW 2, Dr C.P Sinha, who had examined Bindeshwar Prasad, brother of PW 7, found that the injuries were caused by hard fluid substances and were simple in nature. The same medical evidence was also referred to in respect of father of PW 7 which showed only one incised wound which according to PW 2 was caused by a sharp-cutting weapon. The learned counsel for the appellants referred to post-mortem report (Ext. 7) of deceased Lala Mahto. It is stated therein that that injury was caused by sharp-cutting heavy weapon. It was, thus, argued that the version of PW 7 that it was a gunshot injury, was clearly wrong and contrary to the medical evidence and, therefore, PW 7 did not describe the incident correctly and was unworthy of any credence.

5.3 The last submission of the counsel for the appellants was that injuries on the deceased as well as on PW 7 and his brother were not duly explained. This submission was also based on what is argued above, namely, the injuries as stated by the eyewitnesses are at variance with the injuries recorded in the medical examination of these persons. It was, thus, submitted that when there happens to be inconsistency between the ocular and the medical evidence and when medical evidence makes the ocular testimony improbable, the same becomes a relevant factor in the process of evaluation of such evidence. However, the High Court has not at all appreciated the medical evidence even when the medical evidence completely derails the prosecution version so far factum of murder by means of rifle is concerned. In such case the ocular evidence should have been rejected in toto. It was also submitted that in the present case when the evidence of prosecution witnesses (PWs) has been disbelieved with regard to other co-accused (since acquitted) then in that event there was no justification to accept its reliability with regard to other co-accused. A number of judgments were cited in support of the aforesaid arguments advanced by both the counsel for the appellants.

6. The learned counsel for the State, on the other hand, submitted that the appellants had made the aforesaid submission by selectively picking certain portions from oral testimonies of the witnesses. According to him, when the ocular evidence is read in its entirety along with the medical evidence, the plea of the appellant would be found to be untenable. It was submitted that the High Court in its detailed judgment had dealt with all the aforesaid submissions and after duly appreciating the same did not find any substance therein. He also referred to the statements of some independent witnesses as well who supported the prosecution version. He emphasised that even as per the deposition of PW 2, bullet injury by rifle was not ruled out.

7. After considering the respective submissions along with the material on record and going through the judgments of the courts below, we are inclined to concur with the view taken by the High Court in affirming the conviction and sentence of these two appellants.

8. We may mention, in the first instance, that in the statement of the appellants recorded under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), the defence taken was that of the total denial of the occurrence. It was stated that because of the long-standing land dispute they were falsely implicated in this case. On the contrary, according to these appellants, they were attacked by the complainant party for which the accused party had got PS Case No. 117/1982 registered against them and the case in question was nothing but a counterblast. This defence is not only against the record but not even argued or pleaded by the counsel for the appellants. On the contrary, the entire focus of the appellants' argument is that on the basis that due to the land dispute, a sudden quarrel and scuffle took place between the two parties wherein both were injured. This is clearly contrary to the stand taken by the appellants in their statements given under Section 313 CrPC where they completely denied the occurrence itself.

9. Regarding the argument of the counsel for the appellants that there is contradiction between the oral evidence and the medical records, we do not find any such inconsistency as alleged by the defence. Insofar as injury inflicted on the deceased Lala Mahto is concerned, no doubt PW 2 (Dr C.P Sinha) has stated that it seemed to have been caused by a sharp-cutting weapon. However, at the same time it is pointed out that injury in nature was one incised wound 4½″ × 1″ × scalp bone-deep on the right side of head injuring the right parietal lobe of brain, laceration of the cortex cells resulting into unconsciousness and paralysis of the left side of the body. It is significant to mention that he has further categorically stated that in his opinion such an injury could have been caused by rifle shot as well. Likewise, in the post-mortem report also, it is stated that injury was ante-mortem which was incised wound of the same measurement and description as given in report of PW 2. This post-mortem report further discloses that on dissection, it was found that skull was cut and fractured corresponding to the level of the injury and brain was lacerated by pieces of bone.

10. Likewise, insofar as injuries which were found on the person of Bindeshwar Prasad, brother of PW 7 description thereof is as under:

“(i) One lacerated wound 1″ × 1/4″ × 1/4″ on the head internally.
(ii) Three lacerated wounds of various sizes—sizes ranging 2½″ × ¼″ × ¼″ to 1″ × ¼″ × ¼″ on the back.”

No doubt, it is mentioned that the aforesaid injuries were simple in nature. However, the learned counsel for the appellants conveniently omitted to mention about the injuries inflicted upon PW 7 which according to PW 2 were as under:

“1. Multiple pea-sized gunshot wound (pellets) on the left scapular region of the back. “All were superficial.”
2. One pea-sized pellet wound on the left side of head posteriorly. It was also superficial.”

These injuries are sufficient to rope in A-2 for the offences under Section 307 IPC.

11. When we examine the matter in the aforesaid perspective we do not find any inconsistency between ocular evidence and the medical evidence. How medical evidence is to be collated with ocular evidence is described by this Court in Kamaljit Singh v. State of Punjab (2003) 12 SCC 155 in the following fashion:

“8. It is trite law that minor variations between medical evidence and ocular evidence do not take away the primacy of the latter. Unless medical evidence in its term goes so far as to completely rule out all possibilities whatsoever of injuries taking place in the manner stated by the eyewitnesses, the testimony of the eyewitnesses cannot be thrown out. (See Solanki Chimanbhai Ukabhai v. State of Gujarat (1983) 2 SCC 174.) The position was illuminatingly and exhaustively reiterated in State of U.P v. Krishna Gopal (1988) 4 SCC 302. When the acquittal by the trial court was found to be on the basis of unwarranted assumptions and manifestly erroneous appreciation of evidence by ignoring valuable and credible evidence resulting in serious and substantial miscarriage of justice, the High Court cannot in this case be found fault with for its well-merited interference.”

12. Here, PW 7 is also an injured witness. When the eyewitness is also an injured person, due credence to his version needs to be accorded. On this aspect, we may refer to the following observations in Abdul Sayeed v. State of M.P (2010) 10 SCC 259:

“28. The question of the weight to be attached to the evidence of a witness that was himself injured in the course of the occurrence has been extensively discussed by this Court. Where a witness to the occurrence has himself been injured in the incident, the testimony of such a witness is generally considered to be very reliable, as he is a witness that comes with a built-in guarantee of his presence at the scene of the crime and is unlikely to spare his actual assailant(s) in order to falsely implicate someone. “Convincing evidence is required to discredit an injured witness.” [Vide Ramlagan Singh v. State of Bihar (1973) 3 SCC 881, Malkhan Singh v. State of U.P (1975) 3 SCC 311, Machhi Singh v. State of Punjab (1983) 3 SCC 470, Appabhai v. State of Gujarat 1988 Supp SCC 241, Bonkya v. State of Maharashtra (1995) 6 SCC 447, Bhag Singh (1997) 7 SCC 712, Mohar v. State of U.P (2002) 7 SCC 606(b-c), Dinesh Kumar v. State of Rajasthan (2008) 8 SCC 270, Vishnu v. State of Rajasthan (2009) 10 SCC 477, Annareddy Sambasiva Reddy v. State of A.P (2009) 12 SCC 546 and Balraje v. State of Maharashtra (2010) 6 SCC 673.]
29. While deciding this issue, a similar view was taken in Jarnail Singh v. State of Punjab (2009) 9 SCC 719, where this Court reiterated the special evidentiary status accorded to the testimony of an injured accused and relying on its earlier judgments held as under:
‘28. Darshan Singh (PW 4) was an injured witness. He had been examined by the doctor. His testimony could not be brushed aside lightly. He had given full details of the incident as he was present at the time when the assailants reached the tubewell. In Shivalingappa Kallayanappa v. State of Karnataka 1994 Supp (3) SCC 235 this Court has held that the deposition of the injured witness should be relied upon unless there are strong grounds for rejection of his evidence on the basis of major contradictions and discrepancies, for the reason that his presence on the scene stands established in case it is proved that he suffered the injury during the said incident.
29. In State of U.P v. Kishan Chand (2004) 7 SCC 629 a similar view has been reiterated observing that the testimony of a stamped witness has its own relevance and efficacy. The fact that the witness sustained injuries at the time and place of occurrence, lends support to his testimony that he was present during the occurrence. In case the injured witness is subjected to lengthy cross-examination and nothing can be elicited to discard his testimony, it should be relied upon (vide Krishan v. State of Haryana (2006) 12 SCC 459). Thus, we are of the considered opinion that evidence of Darshan Singh (PW 4) has rightly been relied upon by the courts below.’
30. The law on the point can be summarised to the effect that the testimony of the injured witness is accorded a special status in law. This is as a consequence of the fact that the injury to the witness is an inbuilt guarantee of his presence at the scene of the crime and because the witness will not want to let his actual assailant go unpunished merely to falsely implicate a third party for the commission of the offence. Thus, the deposition of the injured witness should be relied upon unless there are strong grounds for rejection of his evidence on the basis of major contradictions and discrepancies therein.”

13. In this very judgment, relationship between the medical evidence and ocular evidence was also discussed, based on a number of earlier precedents, as under: (Abdul Sayeed case (2010) 10 SCC 259)

“33. In State of Haryana v. Bhagirath (1999) 5 SCC 96 it was held as follows:
‘15. The opinion given by a medical witness need not be the last word on the subject. Such an opinion shall be tested by the court. If the opinion is bereft of logic or objectivity, the court is not obliged to go by that opinion. After all opinion is what is formed in the mind of a person regarding a fact situation. If one doctor forms one opinion and another doctor forms a different opinion on the same facts it is open to the Judge to adopt the view which is more objective or probable. Similarly if the opinion given by one doctor is not consistent with probability the court has no liability to go by that opinion merely because it is said by the doctor. Of course, due weight must be given to opinions given by persons who are experts in the particular subject.’
34. Drawing on Bhagirath case (1999) 5 SCC 96, this Court has held that where the medical evidence is at variance with ocular evidence,
‘it has to be noted that it would be erroneous to accord undue primacy to the hypothetical answers of medical witnesses to exclude the eyewitnesses' account which had to be tested independently and not treated as the “variable” keeping the medical evidence as the “constant”’.
35. Where the eyewitnesses' account is found credible and trustworthy, a medical opinion pointing to alternative possibilities cannot be accepted as conclusive. The eyewitnesses' account requires a careful independent assessment and evaluation for its credibility, which should not be adversely prejudged on the basis of any other evidence, including medical evidence, as the sole touchstone for the test of such credibility.
‘21. … The evidence must be tested for its inherent consistency and the inherent probability of the story; consistency with the account of other witnesses held to be creditworthy; consistency with the undisputed facts, the “credit” of the witnesses; their performance in the witness box; their power of observation, etc. Then the probative value of such evidence becomes eligible to be put into the scales for a cumulative evaluation.’
[Vide Thaman Kumar v. State (UT of Chandigarh) (2003) 6 SCC 380 and Krishnan v. State (2003) 7 SCC 56]”

(emphasis in original)

14. We may point out at this stage that apart from PW 7, there were independent witnesses and injured eyewitnesses whose depositions have been taken into account. We would like to reproduce the following description of these witnesses as recorded by the High Court in the impugned judgment: (Baleshwar Mahto case 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 149, SCC OnLine Pat paras 13-14)

“13. The remaining witnesses happen to be material witnesses. PW 4 had deposed that on the day and time of occurrence while he was going to ease himself towards south to his village, he found Lala Mahto ploughing the field while Anandi was sowing the seeds. At that time Dulli Mahto armed with lathi, Ram Khelawan armed with rifle, Siwan Mahto, Baleshwar Mahto, Ram Lagan Prasad, Surendra, Rajendra, Arun armed with gun, Ram Bilas and Umesh armed with garasa and Subhash armed with bhala came and said that they will not allow to plough the field. Lala Mahto retaliated by saying that land belongs to him, hence he will plough. On this Dulli Mahto ordered. Khelawan fired causing injury over head of Lala Mahto who fell down. Blood began to ooze. Thereafter, Baleshwar had fired causing injury over left upper portion of back as well as overhead. Ram Bilas assaulted with garasa over head of Anandi. Umesh and Dulli assaulted Bindeshwar with Paina which was corrected as Dulli had assaulted with lathi and Umesh with garasa then thereafter all of them left the place. They had taken dead body to PS along with Anandi and Bindeshwar. During cross-examination he had narrated that the total area of the disputed land happens to be six decimal having boundary north, Dulli Mahto; south, Harnath Sah; west, Lala Mahto and east, Prabhu Mahto. He had not seen Dulli Mahto quarrelling with Lala Mahto with regard to the disputed land. However, the dispute was going on amongst them with regard to other plot lying in the same vicinity. Sections 144 and 145 CrPC proceedings had already been fought in between. In para 5 he had deposed that he was going towards pond lying south to the village and during the said course he had seen mob present at the disputed land who were only accused persons. He heard sound of firing from that place only. He became afraid and remained there. The persons who were engaged in nearby field witnessed the same. In para 6 he had said that the villagers came after half an hour. Accused persons had already escaped therefrom before arrival of the villagers. Then thereafter he had gone to the place of occurrence and had seen the injured. In para 10 there happens to be contradiction. In para 11 he had denied with regard to counter case. He had further denied having seen Dulli Mahto in injured condition.
14. PW 5 is one of the injured who had deposed that on the alleged date and time of occurrence he along with his father Lala Mahto, brother Anandi and Indu had gone to the PO land and were engaged in agriculture work. At that very time Dulli armed with lathi, Ram Khelawan armed with rifle, Sheo Nandan, Baleshwar, Ram Lagan, Arun, Surendra and Rajendra armed with guns, Subhash armed with bhala, Ram Bilas and Umesh armed with garasa came there out of whom Khelawan had forbidden his brother Anandi to plough the field. He claimed that the land belongs to him. The same was retaliated over which Dulli ordered to kill. Ram Khelawan fired causing injury over head of his father. Baleshwar fired causing injury over upper portion of back of Anandi as well as head. Ram Bilas had assaulted with garasa over his head. Umesh and Dulli had assaulted him with garasa and lathi respectively. Other accused were terrorising the villagers by making indiscriminate firing. Then thereafter all the accused persons left therefrom. Brahmadeo Sah, Jagarnath Yadav, Kameshwar Yadav and Biseshwar Sah along with others have witnessed the occurrence out of whom Biseshwar had gone in camp of the accused. Thereafter, the villagers lifted his father to PS along with them where his brother Anandi gave his fardbeyan. Thereafter they were sent to hospital from where they were referred to PMCH during the course of which his father died. On 20-7-1982 he had produced bloodstained cloth before the police. During cross-examination at para 2 he had admitted that both the persons are on litigating terms since before the occurrence. In para 4 he had disclosed that his father had ploughed the aforesaid land about three or four days ago. As he was not present so he could say whether any sort of litigation had taken place or not. At the time of occurrence paddy seed was being sown. Then said that at that very time the field was being ploughed as well as they were also engaged in putting seed. He had given the boundary of the land north, Dulli Mahto; south, Harnath Sah; east and west, Lala Mahto (prosecution party). Then he had disclosed that the khasra number of PO land happens to be 3497. He is not aware with the fact whether there was any sort of dispute with regard to PO land. In para 9 he had said that he had gone to PO land along with his father and brother. They had not met with accused in midst of way. He had not seen the accused persons in the vicinity of the PO land. In para 11 he had said that for the first time he had seen accused persons at some distance from his field approximately four lagga west who were variously armed. They came and said to shoot, over which firing was made. His brother Indu fled away while they remained in the field. Firing was made which caused injury to his father. At that very time his father was east to him at a distance of 4-5 hands. He has seen his father sustaining firearm injury at south-western corner of the field. He fell down over which he along with Anandi rushed and tried to lift him. No firing was made at that very time. Then he said that they had already sustained injury. He further said that Anandi had sustained injury just after falling of his father. The whole occurrence was over within 5 to 10 minutes. He had said that even after sustaining gunshot injury, his brother rushed to his father. He had also gone there and during course thereof, he was assaulted. In para 14 he had said that he had not found any injury over the person of Umesh and Ram Khelawan at the PO. He himself volunteered in course of fleeing there was confrontation with villagers during course of which they sustained injury. He had also heard with regard to Dulli Mahto. In para 12 he had disclosed that he had seen blood at south-western corner of his field.”

15. The aforesaid analysis of ours is sufficient to reject the other contentions advanced by the appellants. When the appellants had come to the place of occurrence armed with deadly weapons, their intention and purpose would be more than apparent and, therefore, the appellants cannot argue that the incident occurred at the spur of the moment. The argument that there was a long-standing land dispute between the two parties, in fact, goes against the appellants as it shows previous animosity due to the said dispute because of which the appellants in order to teach “lesson” to the complainant party attacked them in the manner described by the prosecution. In view of the aforesaid discussion, various judgments cited by the learned counsel for the appellants will have no bearing or application to the facts of the instant case. It is, therefore, not even necessary to discuss them.

16. We, therefore, do not find any error in convicting A-1 for the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC as well as Section 27 of the Arms Act and A-2 for the offence punishable under Section 307 IPC and Section 27 of the Arms Act.

17. Coming to the sentence, insofar as A-1 is concerned, since life imprisonment is the minimum sentence that is to be awarded for commission of offence of murder under Section 302 IPC, we maintain the same. However, we are conscious of the fact that A-1 is almost 80 years of age. Further, the incident occurred almost 34 years ago. In these circumstances, he may prefer a representation to the State for remission of his further sentence. When such a representation is filed by A-1, the same shall be given due consideration by the competent authority within the four corners of law. A-2 is also 80 years of age. Going by this consideration coupled with the fact that the incident happened 34 years ago, we modify the sentence of 7 years' RI to that of the period already undergone. Since he is on bail, his bail bond shall stand discharged. The appeals are disposed of in the aforesaid terms.