Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

RAKESH SETHI v. SUBHASH SETHI

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Dec 2, 2016

raised objections at every stage for obvious reasons to delay the ultimate conclusion of the lis. [16]. The auction was held as per schedule. On 26.04.2016, both the parties were present at the site. Bidders as per list came forward to participate in the auction. Highest bid of Rs.2,25,00,000/- was offered jointly by Sh. Sandeep Mahajan, Mrs. Manu Garg, Amaninder Singh and Des Raj and the same was accepted and they were held to be joint purchasers in equal share of the property being the highest bidders in the open auction held on 26.04.2016. The highest bidders paid the requisite 25% of the amount of total auction amount of Rs.2,25,00,000/- on 26.04.2016 and the balance amount of Rs.1,68,75,000/- was to be paid within 15 days from the date of auction i.e. 26.04.2016. The Court Auctioneer prepared the report regarding auction on 27.05.2016. [17]. During the course of arguments, it was argued by the learned counsel for the petitioner that there was no proper publication in the newspaper for the auction to be conducted on 26.04.2016. Both the parties were required to filed their affidavits. Learned counsel for the respondent with reference to

8 of 12 CR No.3682 of 2016 (O&M) 9 Annexures R-1 and R-2 brought on record submitted that the auction notice was appearing in the Chandigarh Tribune and The Tribune on 16.01.2016 and 25.03.2016 respectively. The aforesaid fact could not be denied by the petitioner with reference to any material on record despite giving opportunity. [18]. Since the suit property was agreed to be sold on collector's rate and the petitioner/judgment-debtor did not move any application for purchasing the same even on collector's rate, the objections with regard to inter se auction cannot be appreciated in the light of aforesaid facts. An attempt has been made by the petitioner that there was an agreement/ compromise entered into between the parties on 26.04.2016 and the petitioner was prevented from taking part in auction for the reasons that his signatures were obtained on the compromise and by that time auction was completed. [19]. I am afraid that no such material has come on record to presume such an event. Even otherwise, auction dated 26.04.2016 showed the participation of the petitioner. Petitioner has concealed the factum of fixing the collector's rate as per order dated 11.12.2015. Even otherwise, after the auction the remedy available to the petitioner was in terms of Order 21 Rule 89/90 CPC. Petitioner did not apply for getting the sale set aside

9 of 12 CR No.3682 of 2016 (O&M) 10 by depositing any amount in Court for payment to the purchaser a sum equal to the 5% of the purchase money and other amounts as required under Rule 89 Order 21 CPC. [20]. In terms of Order 21 Rule 90 CPC, no sale can be set aside on the ground of irregularity or fraud in publishing or conducting the auction unless upon the evidence to show that the judgment-debtor has sustained injury by reasons of such irregularity or fraud. Due to decline in rise in price index, petitioner even did not offer the collector's rate for inter se auction between the parties. [21]. During pendency of the revision petition, at one point of time petitioner intended to seek instructions to show his intention to purchase half share of the respondent at the rate on the property was auctioned in favour of the auction-purchasers. The fact was duly noticed in the order dated 22.10.2016, but thereafter the petitioner did not show his readiness and willingness towards the proposal. The alleged defect in the attachment and sale of the property are not the grounds defined under Order 21 Rule 90 CPC. Even no such objections were filed by the petitioner under Order 21 Rules 89 and 90 CPC. [22]. In terms of Order 21 Rule 92 CPC, in the absence of any application made under Rules 89 or 90 of Order 21 CPC.

10 of 12 CR No.3682 of 2016 (O&M) 11 The Court shall make an order of confirmation of sale and thereafter sale shall become absolute. Since there was no objection made by the petitioner under Rule 89 of Order 21 CPC and no such amount was deposited as required under the said Rule, therefore, the petitioner cannot be allowed to question the proceedings. [23]. In Annapurna Vs. Mallikarjun, (2014) 6 SCC 397, the Hon'ble Apex Court after considering Article 127 of the Limitation Act held that although Order 21 Rule 89 CPC does not prescribe any period of limitation for making an application, but Article 127 of the Limitation Act prescribes period of 60 days within which the application was required to be made. The deposit of requisite money is a condition precedent and is a sine qua non to an application for setting aside the execution of sale and such amount has to be deposited within prescribed time. In the instant case, neither any objection or application in terms of Order 21 Rules 89 and 90 CPC was moved, nor any amount was deposited within the time prescribed. [24]. In terms of Rule 90 of Order 21 CPC, the sale has to be made absolute in the auction of sale property. The Court has power to set aside the auction on deposit of required amount by the judgment-debtor. Such powers are discretionary and are

11 of 12 CR No.3682 of 2016 (O&M) 12 based on sound principles of law. Mere establishing some irregularity or fraud are not the grounds unless and until objector establishes that material irregularity and fraud has resulted in substantial injury to the objector. [25]. In view of facts enumerated in the preceding paras, I am of the considered view that no indulgence can be granted to the petitioner. This revision petition is accordingly dismissed. December 02, 2016 (RAJ MOHAN SINGH) Atik JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned Yes / No Whether reportable Yes / No

12 of 12