- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ananta Kamilya v. State Of West Bengal
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal arises from a conviction and sentence dated September 27 and 28, 2012, respectively, by the Additional District & Sessions Judge, 1st Fast Track Court, Contai, Purba Medinipur in Sessions Trial No. 42/September 2006. The appellant was convicted under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code for the murder of Srikanta Kamilya.
The case originated from a written complaint lodged on January 2, 2005, reporting an assault on the deceased on December 25, 2004. The deceased was injured by the appellant and others with a bamboo stick at his residence while repairing his blacksmith workshop and cow-shed. The deceased was taken to multiple hospitals, ultimately succumbing to his injuries on January 1, 2005, at Ramchandra Bhanja Medical College, Cuttack, Orissa.
Following the complaint, an FIR was registered and investigation conducted by the Sub Inspector of Pataspur Police Station. The appellant and others were charged with murder under Section 302/34 IPC. After trial including oral and documentary evidence, the appellant was convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment with a fine.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the presence of the appellant at the place of occurrence was proved beyond reasonable doubt.
- Whether the prosecution proved the seizure of the weapon of offence.
- Whether the injury sustained by the deceased was sufficient to cause death and whether negligence in treatment could be a cause of death.
- Whether the common intention and specific intention of the appellant to commit murder were established beyond reasonable doubt.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant's presence at the place of occurrence was not proved beyond reasonable doubt due to contradictions in eyewitness testimonies (PW 1 to PW 5).
- The seizure of the weapon of offence was not proved.
- The injury sustained by the deceased was simple with prognosis guarded, allowing for the possibility that death resulted from negligence in medical treatment.
- The common intention of the accused and the appellant's intention to commit murder were not established beyond reasonable doubt.
- Relied on the decision in Kartarey v. State of U.P (AIR 1976 SC 76) to support these submissions.
State's Arguments
- The appellant's name was recorded in the medical report of the treating medical officer, establishing his connection to the incident.
- Eyewitnesses PW 1 and PW 2 proved the place, time, and manner of the murder beyond reasonable doubt.
- The commission of offence by other accused persons was also proved beyond reasonable doubt, corroborated by the evidence of the Investigating Officer (PW 8).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Kartarey v. State of U.P, AIR 1976 SC 76 | Consideration of evidence and intention in murder cases. | The court found the facts distinguishable and held Kartarey did not assist the appellant as the injury and eyewitness evidence were clear in this case. |
| Anwarul Haque v. State of U.P, (2005) 10 SCC 581 | Non-recovery of weapon does not discredit eyewitness testimony corroborated by medical evidence. | The court applied this principle to uphold the eyewitness evidence despite non-recovery of the lathi used in the assault. |
| Ile Singh v. State, 1980 Supp SCC 690 | Motive becomes academic when direct evidence connects accused with murder. | The court relied on this to reject the appellant's contention regarding lack of proof of intention to murder. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the evidence of eyewitnesses PW 1, PW 2, PW 3, and PW 5, all of whom were present at the occurrence and consistently testified about the appellant assaulting the deceased with a lathi causing a head injury. Their testimonies were corroborated by the medical expert (PW 9) who conducted the post mortem and confirmed the cause of death as blunt force injuries to the head.
Contradictions among eyewitnesses related to other accused persons did not affect the finding against the appellant. The court held that non-recovery of the weapon did not undermine the eyewitness and medical evidence, applying the settled legal principle from Anwarul Haque.
The appellant’s argument regarding the injury being simple and prognosis guarded was rejected as the deceased underwent multiple hospital treatments and ultimately died from the injuries sustained. The court found no merit in the contention of death due to medical negligence.
Regarding the appellant’s intention to commit murder, the court noted that direct evidence connecting the appellant to the murder rendered the need to prove motive academic, citing Ile Singh.
The court distinguished the appellant’s reliance on Kartarey, finding the facts in the present case clear and supported by direct and medical evidence.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is dismissed.
The conviction and sentence of the appellant for the offence under Section 302 IPC stand affirmed. The decision results in the appellant continuing to serve life imprisonment with a fine as imposed by the trial court. No new precedent was established; the court applied established principles of law to the facts of the case.
Debasish Kar Gupta, J.:— This appeal is preferred by the appellant against a judgment and order of conviction dated September 27, 2012, and sentence dated September 28, 2012, passed by the learned Additional District & Sessions Judge, 1st Fast Track Court, Contai, Purba Medinipur in Sessions Trial No. 42.September/2006 arising out of G.R (E) 06 of 2005 convicting the appellant for commission of offence punishable under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (hereinafter referred to as the I.P.C) and sentencing him to suffer rigorous imprisonment for life and also to pay a fine of Rs. 1000/-, in default to suffer rigorous imprisonment for a further period of one month.
2. The facts of the case in a nutshell are as under:-
3. A written complaint was submitted by one Ganesh Chandra Kamilya (PW 1) of village-Makrampur, police station-Pataspur, District-Purba Midnapur on January 2, 2005 at 10.15 hours.
4. According to the above written complaint, on December 25, 2004 at 8/9 O'clock in the morning the father of PW 1 namely, Srikanta Kamilya was repairing his blacksmith workshop and cow-shed at his residence. Suddenly, the appellant along with Rampada Kamilya and Smt. Arati Kamilya arrived at that place and assaulted him on his head with a bamboo stick. PW 4 (widow of the deceased person) went to rescue her husband. Accused Arati Kamilya assaulted PW 4. The father of PW 1 became senseless. PW 1, PW 2 and PW 3 took his father to Pataspur police station where from he was removed to Pataspur Public Health Centre. The deceased person was shifted to Egra Hospital for better treatment and thereafter he was transferred to Midnapur (Paschim) Hospital. Subsequently, the deceased person was further transferred to P.G Hospital, Kolkata. As per advice of the doctors, the deceased person was further removed to Ramchandra Bhanja Medical College, Cuttack, Orrissa for treatment. He breathed his last on January 1, 2005 at Ramchandra Bhanja Medical College, Cuttack, Orrissa.
5. Inquest examination was conducted over the dead body of the deceased person at SCB Cuttack Neurosurgery Bed no. 2, Ramchandra Bhanja Medical College, Cuttack, Orissa by the local police with reference to Mangalabag U.D Case No. 1 dated January 1, 2005. The dead body was identified by PW 1. After conducting post mortem examination Dr. P. Mahanti, Assistant Professor of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology of Ramchandra Bhanja Medical College, Cuttack, Orrissa (PW 9), prepared post mortem report of the dead body of the deceased person on January 1, 2005 at 14.30 hours in the aforesaid hospital. According to the opinion of PW 9, the cause of death was sustaining of injuries on head by blunt object which were ante mortem in nature and sufficient to cause death.
6. A formal FIR bearing Pataspur P.S Case No. 01/2005 was registered on January 2, 2005 at 10.15 hours after making G.D Entry No. 59 of 2005 initiating a case against Ananta Kamilya (appellant), Rampada Kamilya, Paresh Roy and Smt. Arati Kamilya for commission of offence punishable under Section 304/34 of the I.P.C Sub Inspector Joydev Sasmal (PW 8) attached to Pataspur P.S was entrusted with the investigation of the case.
7. On receipt of the charge of investigation PW 8 went to the place of occurrence prepared rough sketch map of the place of occurrence along with index. One bamboo stick was recovered from the place of occurrence. In course of investigation the appellant and Smt. Arati Kamilya were arrested. Charge sheet against the appellant, Smt. Arati Kamilya and Rampada Kamilya was submitted by the I.O for commission of offence punishable under Section 302/34 of the I.P.C showing accused Rampada Kamilya as absconder.
8. Charge was framed on December 18, 2006 against the appellant, Smt. Arati Kamilya and Rampada Kamilya for commission of offence punishable under Section 302/34 of the I.P.C by committing murder of Srikanta Kamilya in furtherance of their common intention.
9. After considering oral evidence of 9 prosecution witnesses and other documentary evidences as also statements of accused recorded under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C the impugned judgment, order of conviction and sentence were passed.
10. It is submitted by Mr. Mainak Bakshi, learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the appellant, that the presence of the appellant at the place of occurrence was not proved beyond all reasonable doubts in view of the doubt regarding the presence of purported eyewitnesses PW 1 to PW 5 at the place of occurrence. According to him, there were contradictions in between the evidences adduced by the aforesaid prosecution witnesses.
11. It is also submitted by Mr. Bakshi that the seizure of weapon of offence was also not proved.
12. According to Mr. Bakshi, the injury sustained by the deceased person was simple with prognosis guarded. So, the probability of the death of the deceased person due to negligence in giving proper treatment in due time could not be ruled out.
13. It is further submitted by Mr. Bakshi that not only the common intention of the accused persons in furtherance to their act of committing murder of the deceased person was not proved in the trial but also the intention of the appellant commission of such murder of the deceased person was not proved beyond all reasonable doubts.
14. Reliance is placed by Mr. Bakshi on the decision of Kartarey v. State of U.P, reported in AIR 1976 SC 76 in support of his above submissions.
15. It is submitted by Mr. Ranabir Roy Chowdhury learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the State respondent that the name of the appellant, amongst other accused persons, was incorporated in the medical report of the medical officer of Pataspur Block Public Health Centre, Purba Medinipur, who had treated the deceased person on December 25, 2004. The place, time of occurrence and the manner in which the commission of murder of the deceased person took place was proved from the evidence of PW 1 and PW 2, both being eyewitnesses. According to him, the commission of offence by Rampada Kamilya and Smt. Arati Kamilya was proved beyond all reasonable doubts in view of the evidence of eyewitness PW 2 which was corroborated with the evidence of I.O (PW 8).
16. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the respective parties as also after considering evidence on record I find that the prosecution case was based on the evidence of PW 1, PW 2, PW 3, and PW 5. All the above witnesses, according to their respective evidence, were present at the place of occurrence at the material point of time. According to PW 1, the appellant came to the place of occurrence with Rampada Kailla and Arati Kamilla on the date of occurrence at about 08.00/09.00 hours while the deceased person was repairing his blacksmith shop and cow-shed. The appellant and his associates raised protest. Suddenly, the appellant assaulted the deacesed person on his head with lathi (banser tara). His head was fractured with profuse bleeding. The deceased fell down on the ground. The deceased was conscious. The PW 1, PW 2, PW 3 and PW 5 took the deceased to the patashpur polish station first. Then he was removed to the Patashpur Public Health Center. Then he was removed to Egra Hospital for better treatment and thereafter, he was transferred to Midnapur (Paschim) Hospital. Subsequently, the deceased was shifted to P.G Hospital, Kolkata. A few days, thereafter, he was removed to Ramchandra Bhanja Medical College, Cuttack, Orissa.
17. The above evidence of the PW 1 was fully corroborating with those of other eyewitnesses, namely, PW 2, PW 3 and PW 5. None of the above witnesses was slackened during cross-examination. The evidence of the aforesaid eyewitnesses in respect of the injury which caused the death of the deceased ultimately was corroborating with the evidence of the PW 9, the medical expert who had conducted the post mortem examination over the dead body of the deceased. That apart, the outcome of preliminary investigation as recorded in the inquest report, was also corroborating with the ocular evidence of the aforesaid eye witnesses.The finding of the learned court below was correct in this regard.
18. After scrutiny of the evidence of PW 4, I find that it was not stated by her that the appellant or his any other associates. In other words, the evidence of PW 1, PW 3 was not corroborating with those of PW 2, PW 4 and PW 5. There were contradictions in between the evidence of the above eye witnesses with regard to the role played by the other accused persons, namely Sri Rampada Kamilya and Smt. Arati Kamilya. So, the findings of the learned trial judge in this regard do not require interference.
19. Regarding the next contention of the appellant in respect of seizure of weapon of offence, from the oral evidence of eyewitnesses, namely the PW 1, PW 2, PW 3 and PW 5 it was revealed that the deceased got injury on his head as he had been assaulted by the appellant with the help of a lathi. As a result, his head was fractured. The nature of injury was corroborating with the inquest report. The evidence of medical expert (PW 9) read with the cause of death mentioned in the post mortem report supported the above evidence of the eye witnesses. According to the settled proposition of law, the evidence of eye witness which was corroborated by the evidence of medical expert should not be discarded merely because the weapon of offence had not been recovered in course of investigation. Reference may be made to the decision of Anwarul Haque v. State of U.P, reported in (2005) 10 SCC 581 and the relevant portion of the above decision is quoted below:-
“15. Eyewitness in the present case have described the knife, and merely because the knife has not been recovered during investigation same cannot be a factor to discard the evidence of PW 1 and 2. Wounds noticed by the doctor (PW 3) also throw considerable light on this aspect. The doctor's opinion about the weapon, though theoretical, cannot betotally wiped out. In that view of the matter the appellant has been rightly convicted under Section 324 I.P.C”
20. In view of the above settled principle of law, the facts and circumstances of this case also does not support the aforesaid contention of the appellant.
21. The decision of Kartarey (supra) does not help the appellant in view of distinguishable fact of the case in hand that the deceased sustained only one injury on his head as a result of assaulting him by a lathi (blunt) object and that fact was brought on record with the evidence of eyewitnesses and corroborated by the opinion of the doctor (PW 9).
22. While considering the next contention of the appellant that the injury sustained by the deceased was simple with remarks “prognosis guarded”, it was not in dispute that the deceased was removed to the Pataspur Primary Health Centre immediately after the incedent. He was then removed to the Egra Hospital without delay. Thereafter, he was transferred to Midnapur (Paschim) Hospital. Again, he was transferred to P.G Hospital, Kolkata. Ultimately, he had been admitted in Ramchandra Bhanja Medical College, Cuttack, Orissa, where he breathed his last. From the opinion of the doctor read with the post mortem report, there was no doubt regarding the cause of death. In view of the above, there is no substance in the aforesaid contention of the appellant.
23. With regard to the next contention of the appellant that the intention of the appellant for commission of murder of the deceased was not proved in the trial, it the well settled principle of law decided in Ile Singh v. State, reported in 1980 Supp SCC 690, requirement of motive become academic when there is direct evidence to to connect the accused with murder. Therefore, the impugned judgement does not require interference on the above ground also in view of availability of direct evidence on record in the case in hand.
24. This appeal stands dismissed.
25. Let this judgment together with the Lower Court's records be sent back to the learned Court below expeditiously.
26. Urgent photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be given to the parties, on priority basis.
Md. Mumtaz Khan, J.:— I agree.
Alert