- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M/S ALLIED BLENDERS AND DISTILLERS PVT. LTD. v. MR. SURYA RAO TRADING AS LEO FOODS & BEVERAGES
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff, Allied Blenders & Distillers Private Limited, instituted the suit seeking permanent injunctions for trademark and copyright infringement, passing off, dilution, unfair competition and related reliefs against the defendant, M/s Leo Foods & Beverages. On 21.12.2012 the court issued summons and granted an ex parte ad interim injunction restraining the defendant from manufacturing, selling or distributing alcoholic beverages bearing the plaintiff's trademark/label "Officer's Choice" or any deceptively similar mark; a Local Commissioner was also appointed to inspect the defendant's premises. Service by ordinary process repeatedly failed and the defendant was served by substituted service (publication). The defendant did not appear and, on 29.05.2014, the matter proceeded ex parte and the interim injunction was made absolute. The plaintiff later applied (I.A. No. 18243/2014 under Order I Rule 10 CPC) to implead Mr Surya Rao as proprietor of the defendant; he was served by publication and impleaded on 21.07.2015. The plaintiff filed evidence by affidavit of its constituted attorney (PW1) and exhibited documentary proof of trademark registrations, assignments, change of corporate ownership, a scheme of arrangement transferring the liquor business to the plaintiff, copyright registrations for labels, sales and promotion figures, and samples of both plaintiff and defendant labels.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the plaintiff is the registered and/or rightful proprietor of the "Officer's Choice" trademark and related "Officer" formative marks, and the plaintiff's ownership as established by assignment and a scheme of arrangement.
- Whether the defendant's mark "Officere's" and its label are deceptively similar to the plaintiff's registered trademark/label and trade dress, amounting to trademark infringement and passing off.
- Whether the defendant's label infringed the plaintiff's registered copyrights in the Officer's Choice labels.
- Whether the plaintiff's mark qualifies as a "well-known" trade mark for the purposes of protection beyond the registered classes.
- Whether the plaintiff is entitled to permanent injunctive relief and costs against the defendant in view of the evidence and the defendant's non-appearance.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The plaintiff (through predecessors and by assignment) is the registered proprietor of the word mark "Officer's Choice" (registration traced to Cruickshank & Co. Ltd., 1988) and of a series of "Officer" formative marks; assignments and corporate name changes are evidenced by registered deeds and certificates of incorporation.
- A Composite Scheme of Arrangement approved by the Bombay High Court (23.02.2007) transferred the liquor business and the trademarks to the plaintiff, and the Registrar of Trademarks recorded the plaintiff as proprietor (order dated 15.02.2008 and supplementary registration evidence).
- The plaintiff holds registered copyrights in the Officer's Choice labels (exhibited certificates) and uses a distinctive trade dress/label that has acquired distinctiveness and goodwill through long and extensive use since 1988.
- Sales, export and advertising/promotion figures (exhibited) demonstrate extensive use, market penetration and reputation; third-party articles and awards were adduced to show high reputation and that the whiskey is one of the largest-selling in volume.
- The defendant is manufacturing and selling soda under the mark "Officere's" (with similar stylized font and label get-up), which is phonetically and visually deceptive and likely to cause confusion, amounting to trademark infringement, dilution, passing off and copyright infringement (alleged dishonest adoption of the plaintiff's artistic work).
Defendant's Position
The defendant did not enter appearance or participate in the proceedings; accordingly, there is no recorded defence argument in the provided opinion.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Tata Sons Ltd v. Manoj Dodia and Ors: 2011 (46) PTC 244 (Del) | Sets out factors to be considered when deciding whether a trade mark is "well-known" — extent of knowledge/reputation, duration and extent of use and promotion, geographic reach, volume of business, enforcement record and related considerations. | The court relied on the factors enumerated in Tata Sons (alongside statutory factors in ss.11(6) & 11(7) of the Trademarks Act) to evaluate the plaintiff's evidence (sales, promotion, awards, registrations and enforcement) and concluded that "Officer's Choice" is a well-known mark. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded on the record and PW1's affidavit evidence (documents exhibited). It first noted procedural regularity: substituted service, defendant's non-appearance, ex parte continuation and that the interim injunction had been made absolute. The court then examined documentary proof adduced by the plaintiff demonstrating (a) original registration of the "Officer's Choice" mark by the predecessor in 1988 and assignment to BDA (registered deed dated 26.02.1991), (b) corporate name changes and fresh certificates of incorporation, (c) a Composite Scheme of Arrangement sanctioned by the Bombay High Court (23.02.2007) transferring the liquor business and trademarks to the plaintiff, and (d) the Registrar of Trademarks' order (15.02.2008) recording the plaintiff as proprietor. The court accepted the plaintiff's evidence of registered copyrights in the labels (certificates exhibited) and of continuous and extensive use of the mark across multiple product classes.
On the well-known mark issue, the court applied the statutory indicators in sections 2(1)(zg), 11(6) and 11(7) of the Trademarks Act, 1999 together with the factors summarized in Tata Sons v. Manoj Dodia. It reviewed the plaintiff's sales and export figures, advertising and promotional expenditure, press reports and awards and concluded that the mark had acquired a high degree of recognition and reputation in the relevant public and was therefore "well-known".
Turning to infringement, the court compared the defendant's label and mark "Officere's" (exhibited) with the plaintiff's registered label and mark and found on visual inspection that the defendant's label was deceptively and confusingly similar to the plaintiff's label. The court concluded that use of "Officere's" for allied/cognate goods amounted to trademark infringement, dilution and passing off, and that the defendant's label also infringed the plaintiff's registered copyrights by adopting distinctive elements of the plaintiff's artistic work.
Given the admitted non-participation by the defendant and the uncontroverted documentary evidence adduced by the plaintiff, the court found the plaintiff entitled to permanent injunctive relief and to costs.
Holding and Implications
PERMANENT INJUNCTION GRANTED
Holding (core rulings):
- The court held that the plaintiff is the proprietor of the "Officer's Choice" mark and related "Officer" formative marks by virtue of registration, assignment and the sanctioned scheme of arrangement.
- The mark "Officer's Choice" qualifies as a "well-known" mark under the statutory framework and the judicially recognized factors.
- The defendant's mark "Officere's" and its label were found to be deceptively similar to the plaintiff's mark/label and to infringe the plaintiff's registered trademarks and copyrights and to amount to passing off; accordingly, permanent injunctions were granted in terms of the plaintiff's prayers (paragraph 26(i), (ii) and (iii) of the plaint) restraining the defendant (and related persons/agents) from manufacturing, selling, distributing, advertising or dealing in goods bearing "Officere's" or any identical or deceptively similar mark/label, and from doing acts causing confusion or deception.
- Costs of Rs. 9,71,558/- were awarded to the plaintiff against the defendant.
Implications:
- The direct effect is that the defendant is permanently restrained from using "Officere's" (or deceptively similar marks/labels) in relation to alcoholic beverages and other goods specified in the decree, and the plaintiff recovers quantified costs.
- The opinion applies established statutory factors (ss.2(1)(zg), 11(6), 11(7)) and the judicial guidance in Tata Sons for determining "well-known" status; the decision enforces the plaintiff's existing registered rights and does not announce a novel principle beyond the cited authorities.
% 16.01.2017 VIBHU BAKHRU, J
1. The plaintiff has filed the present suit inter alia seeking a decree of permanent injunction restraining infringement of trademark and copyright, passing off, dilution, unfair competition, delivery up, etc. against the defendant.
2. On 21.12.2012, this court directed issuance of Summons in the present suit. By the same order, an ex parte ad interim injunction was granted and the defendant, M/s Leo Foods & Beverages, was restrained from manufacturing, selling or distributing any alcoholic beverage bearing the plaintiffs trademark/label Officers Choice or from using any other mark deceptively similar to the trademark/label Officers Choice. Further CS(COMM) 1227/2016 Page 2 of 15 a Local Commissioner was also appointed to visit the premises of the defendant.
3. Although summons were sent to the defendant, however, the same returned un-served on numerous occasions and the defendant was directed to be served by way of substituted service by an order dated 17.01.2014. In compliance thereof, the citation was published in the newspaper Andhra Bhoomi.
4. Despite being served, the defendant did not enter appearance and participate in the present proceedings. Accordingly, by an order dated 29.05.2014, it was proceeded ex parte. By the same order, the interim order dated 21.12.2012 was made absolute.
5. Thereafter, the plaintiff filed an application being I.A. No. 18243/2014 under Order I Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 for impleading Mr Surya Rao (being the proprietor of the defendant). Notice was issued to Mr Surya Rao however he could not be served by ordinary process as well; therefore, he was also served by substituted service by publication of citation in the newspaper The Vaartha, Hyderabad Edition dated 30.04.2015 and The Times of India, Hyderabad Edition dated 08.05.2015. Thereafter, on 21.07.2015, Mr Surya Rao was impleaded as a defendant in his capacity as proprietor of the defendant, M/s Leo Foods & Beverages.
6. Mr S.S. Sanyal (PW1), being the constituted attorney of the plaintiff, has filed an affidavit by way of evidence affirming the averments made in CS(COMM) 1227/2016 Page 3 of 15 the plaint. PW1 has filed a copy of the power of attorney whereby he was authorized to depose on behalf of the plaintiff as Ex Pw1/1.
7. Briefly stated, the facts that emerge from the affidavit of PW1 are as follows: 7.1 Plaintiff, Allied Blenders & Distillers Private Limited, is a company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956 and is engaged in the business of manufacturing and marketing alcoholic beverages, including Indian Made Foreign Liquor (IMFL) under brands such as 'Officer's Choice', 'Class Vodka', 'Lord & Master', 'Calypso'. '1000 Guineas', 'Kyron', 'Sumo', 'Jolly Roger', etc.. 7.2 It is stated that the present suit has been filed to injunct the defendant from violating plaintiff's rights under the marks 'Officer', 'Officer' formative marks, including Officer's Choice and Officer's Club. 7.3 It is averred by PW1 that the mark Officer's Choice was registered by the predecessor-in-interest of the plaintiff, M/s Cruickshank & Company Ltd. in the year 1988. Thereafter, M/s Cruickshank & Company Ltd. assigned various trademarks, including Officer's Choice to M/s BDA Breweries & Distilleries Ltd. by way of a registered deed of assignment dated 26.02.1991(Ex Pw1/34). On 27.01.1992, the name M/s BDA Breweries & Distilleries Ltd. was changed to M/s BDA Ltd. and thereafter to M/s BDA Pvt. Ltd., on 26.12.2005. Pursuant to the change of names as mentioned above, the Registrar of Companies issued fresh certificates of incorporation, which have been exhibited as Ex Pw1/35 and Ex Pw1/36 respectively. CS(COMM) 1227/2016 Page 4 of 15 7.4 It is stated that plaintiff's earlier name, M/s Chabbria Marketing Ltd., was changed to M/s Allied Blenders & Distillers Ltd. on 16.04.2007 and further to M/s Allied Blenders & Distillers Pvt. Ltd. on 26.04.2007. PW1 has also placed on record certificates of incorporation issued by the ROC which have been exhibited as Ex Pw1/37 and Ex Pw1/38. 7.5 Thereafter, by way of a Composite Scheme of Arrangement - approved by an order of the Bombay High Court dated 23.02.2007- the liquor business of M/s BDA Pvt. Ltd. was transferred to M/s Allied Blenders & Distillers Pvt. Ltd. (the plaintiff herein) and the plaintiff became the proprietor of the mark Officers Choice in several classes. The order of the Bombay High Court approving the said Scheme of Arrangement has been exhibited as Ex Pw1/39. 7.6 PW1 has averred that by virtue of the said Scheme of Arrangement, the plaintiff became the proprietor of the trademark Officers Choice and other Officer formative marks as mentioned in paragraph 5 and 6 of the plaint in various classes such 05, 21, 25, 30, 32, 33, 34, 35, etc. 7.7 The plaintiff is also engaged in selling of packaged drinking water under the trademark Officers Choice. PW1 has placed on record an agreement dated 06.04.1994 (Ex Pw1/22) between the plaintiffs predecessor (BDA Limited) and Farm Foods whereby Farm Foods was appointed as a Clearing and Forwarding Agent for Officers Choice packaged drinking water. PW1 has also produced an agreement dated 28.09.2006 between BDA Private Limited and NHN Corporation Ltd. (Ex Pw1/4) for bottling of Officers Choice packaged drinking water. CS(COMM) 1227/2016 Page 5 of 15 7.8 PW1 has placed on record a copy of Form TM-24 dated 14.08.2007 as Ex Pw1/40 whereby the plaintiff requested the Registrar of Trademarks for recording of its name, being the subsequent proprietor, in place of BDA Private Limited in respect of 16 trademarks, including the mark Officers Choice. The said request was allowed by an order no PR/354 dated 15.02.2008 of the Registrar of Trademarks and the change of proprietorship in favour of the plaintiff was recorded. The said order has been exhibited as Ex Pw1/41. 7.9 PW1 states that the word mark Officers Choice was initially registered under the name of BDA Limited with registration number 489582 under Class 33 in respect of Wines, Spirits and Liqueurs. It is further stated that by an order dated 06.09.2010 (exhibited as Ex Pw1/42), plaintiffs name was recorded in the Register as the registered proprietor of the mark Officers Choice. 7.10 PW1 has stated that plaintiff has been using the trademark Officers Choice in a distinctive design, colour scheme, layout, get up as its trade dress/label and the same have become exclusively associated with the plaintiff. PW1 has also placed on record Officers Choice labels which are exhibited as Ex Pw 1/44 and Ex Pw 1/45. 7.11 It is further submitted that plaintiffs predecessor, BDA Ltd. was the proprietor of Officers Choice label registered under copyright registration number A-54982/98 dated 11.08.1998 and A-57173/99 dated 16.12.1999, which have been exhibited as Ex Pw1/116 and Ex Pw1/117 respectively. It is stated that plaintiff has become the owner of the copyright subsisting in CS(COMM) 1227/2016 Page 6 of 15 the Officers Choice label. Further, PW1 has placed on record 3 registration certificates exhibited as Ex Pw1/118, Ex Pw1/119 and Ex Pw1/120 to prove that plaintiff is the registered proprietor of the copyright in respect of the labels in question. 7.12 PW1 has averred that plaintiffs products are sold throughout India and overseas under the mark Officers Choice which have acquired an enviable reputation and goodwill as a result of its excellent quality, distinctive packaging, taste, blending, etc. 7.13 It is further stated that plaintiff has acquired common law rights in overall combination of the mark Officers Choice by virtue of exclusive extensive use since the year 1988. It is averred that plaintiff is the registered proprietor of a series of Officer formative marks, including Officer, Officers Special, Officers No.1, Officers & Gentleman and Officers Club under various classes. PW1 states that the Officer formative brands are used and associated with the plaintiff and emanate from plaintiffs repertoire of spirits/alcohol as well as non-alcoholic products. It is further stated that the said registrations were under the name of the group company of the plaintiff and has been transferred in the name of the plaintiff subsequently. 7.14 It is stated by PW1 that plaintiffs whiskey under the trademark Officers Choice is the largest selling whiskey in the world. PW1 has placed on record various news articles to further his case, which are exhibited as Ex Pw1/122 (Colly). PW1 has also placed on record the certified sales figures of the plaintiffs products bearing the trademark CS(COMM) 1227/2016 Page 7 of 15 Officers Choice and other Officers Choice formative marks as Ex Pw1/46 and Ex Pw1/123 which shows that the plaintiff sold 1.13 million cases, each containing 9 litres, in the year 1994-95 which rose to 9.55 million in the year 2008-09 and further to 30.18 million in the 2014-15. 7.15 It is averred by PW1 that in December, 2012, it came to know that a firm, M/s Leo Foods and Beverages, with its office at 10-1-5/1, West Marredpally, Secunderabad - 500003, Andhra Pradesh is manufacturing, packaging and selling soda under the mark and label Officeres. It is averred that the mark Officeres is phonetically similar to the plaintiffs Officer formative marks and further that it is deceptively and confusingly similar to plaintiffs trademarks Officers Choice and Officer Club. 7.16 It is stated by PW1 that defendant has adopted the mark Officeres with same writing style and stylized font on its label to that of the plaintiffs Officer and Officers Choice label. PW1 has placed on record the impugned labels of the defendant bearing the impugned mark Officeres as Ex Pw1/121(Colly). 7.17 PW1 further states that products bearing the registered mark/logo/label Officer, Officers Choice, Officers Club and other Officers formative trademarks are associated exclusively with the plaintiff and use by the defendant of the phonetically identical and deceptively similar mark and label Officeres for allied and cognate goods would amount to infringement and dilution of plaintiffs trademarks, apart from amounting to passing off of its products and business associated with the plaintiff. CS(COMM) 1227/2016 Page 8 of 15 7.18 Further it is stated that defendant has infringed the registered copyrights of the plaintiff as mentioned above. It is stated that label of the defendant has been inspired and derived from the label of the plaintiff inasmuch as the stylized font and other distinct features of the plaintiffs label have been copied by the defendant. It is thus alleged that it is a case of dishonest adoption by the defendant of an artistic work of the plaintiff. 7.19 PW1 has averred that plaintiff is the prior adopter, user and registered proprietor of the said trademarks which have been used exclusively and extensively by the plaintiff for alcoholic beverages, packaged water, etc. It is further averred that plaintiffs marks are well known marks and have acquired high degree of distinctiveness and reputation in relation to the plaintiffs products.
8. In view of the above, the plaintiff has duly proved that its predecessor-in-interest was the proprietor of the mark Officer's Choice. PW1 has place on record a registration certificate dated 17.03.2009 bearing number 489582 (Ex Pw1/25) to show that the mark Officer's Choice was registered by M/s Cruickshank & Company Ltd. in April, 1988. The plaintiff has duly proved that M/s Cruickshank & Company Ltd. assigned various trademarks relating to Officer's Choice to M/s BDA Breweries & Distilleries Ltd. by way of a registered deed of assignment dated 26.02.1991(Ex Pw1/34). The plaintiff has also duly proved that the name of M/s BDA Breweries & Distilleries Ltd. was changed to M/s BDA Ltd. and subsequently to M/s BDA Pvt. Ltd. by placing on record fresh certificates of incorporation (Ex Pw1/35 and Ex Pw1/36). CS(COMM) 1227/2016 Page 9 of 15
9. The plaintiff has also proved that the liquor business of M/s BDA Pvt. Ltd. was transferred to the plaintiff by way of a Composite Scheme of Arrangement approved by the Bombay High Court vide order dated 23.02.2007 (Ex Pw1/39) and further that plaintiff has become the owner of the trademarks as mentioned in paragraph 5 and 6 of the plaint.
10. The plaintiff has also placed on record an order dated 15.02.2008 of the Registrar of Trademarks whereby the request of the plaintiff was accepted and plaintiff was recorded as the proprietor of the marks in question in place of M/s BDA Private Limited (the previous owner of the marks in question).
11. The plaintiff has also duly proved that the plaintiff holds copyright registrations in its favour in respect of the Officer's Choice labels, which have been exhibited as Ex Pw1/118, Ex Pw1/119 and Ex Pw1/120.
12. The plaintiff has duly proved that the defendant is selling soda under the mark Officere's which is deceptively similar to the plaintiffs registered trademark Officer's Choice. The plaintiff has placed on record the label of the defendant bearing the mark Officere's. A mere glance at the said label makes it evident that the said label is deceptively and confusingly similar to the registered label of the plaintiff.
13. It is averred by the plaintiff that its mark Officer's Choice has acquired a status of a well known mark owing to continuous and extensive use over a long period of time, spanning a wide geographical area coupled with vast promotion and publicity. CS(COMM) 1227/2016 Page 10 of 15
14. Section 2(1)(zg) of the Trademarks Act, 1999 defines the term well- known trademark as under : (zg) well-known trade mark, in relation to any goods or services, means a mark which has become so to the substantial segment of the public which uses such goods or receives such services that the use of such mark in relation to other goods or services would be likely to be taken as indicating a connection in the course of trade or rendering of services between those goods or services and a person using the mark in relation to the first-mentioned goods or services.
15. Section 11(6) and 11(7) of the Trademarks Act, 1999 lays down various factors to be taken into account by the Registrar while determining whether the mark is a well known trademark. The same are quoted below: (6) The Registrar shall, while determining whether a trade mark is a well-known trade mark, take into account any fact which he considers relevant for determining a trade mark as a well-known trade mark including
(i) the knowledge or recognition of that trade mark in the relevant section of the public including knowledge in India obtained as a result of promotion of the trade mark;
(ii) the duration, extent and geographical area of any use of that trade mark;
(iii) the duration, extent and geographical area of any promotion of the trade mark, including advertising or publicity and presentation, at fairs or exhibition of the goods or services to which the trade mark applies;
(iv) the duration and geographical area of any registration of or any application for registration of that trade mark CS(COMM) 1227/2016 Page 11 of 15 under this Act to the extent they reflect the use or recognition of the trade mark;
(v) the record of successful enforcement of the rights in that trade mark; in particular, the extent to which the trade mark has been recognised as a well-known trade mark by any court or Registrar under that record. (7) The Registrar shall, while determining as to whether a trade mark is known or recognised in a relevant section of the public for the purposes of sub-section (6), take into account
(i) the number of actual or potential consumers of the goods or services;
(ii) the number of persons involved in the channels of distribution of the goods or services;
(iii) the business circles dealing with the goods or services, to which that trade mark applies.
16. This Court in the case of Tata Sons Ltd v. Manoj Dodia and Ors: 2011 (46) PTC 244 (Del) laid down certain factors which shall be considered while deciding if a mark is a well known mark. The relevant extracts are quoted as under : "5. A well known trademark is a mark which is widely known to the relevant general public and enjoys a comparatively high reputation amongst them. On account of advancement of technology, fast access to information, manifold increase in international business, international travel and advertising/publicity on internet, television, magazines and periodicals, which now are widely available throughout the world, of goods and services during fairs/exhibitions, , more and more persons are coming to know of the trademarks, which are well known in other countries and which on account of the quality of the products being sold under those names and extensive promotional and marketing efforts have come to enjoy trans- CS(COMM) 1227/2016 Page 12 of 15 border reputation. It is, therefore, being increasingly felt that such trademark needs to be protected not only in the countries in which they are registered but also in the countries where they are otherwise widely known in the relevant circles so that the owners of well known trademarks are encouraged to expand their business activities under those marks to other jurisdictions as well. The relevant general public in the case of a well known trademark would mean consumers, manufacturing and business circles and persons involved in the sale of the goods or service carrying such a trademark. *** *** *** ***
13. Trademarks Act, 1999 does not specify the factors which the Court needs to consider while determining whether a mark is a well known mark or not, though it does contain factors which the Registrar has to consider while determining whether a trademark is a well known mark or not. In determining whether a trademark is a well known mark or not, the Court needs to consider a number of factors including (i) the extent of knowledge of the mark to, and its recognition by the relevant public; (ii) the duration of the use of the mark; (iii) the extent of the products and services in relation to which the mark is being used; (iv) the method, frequency, extent and duration of advertising and promotion of the mark; (v) the geographical extent of the trading area in which the mark is used; (vi) the state of registration of the mark; (vii) the volume of business of the goods or services sold under that mark; (viii) the nature and extent of the use of same or similar mark by other parties; (ix) the extent to which the rights claimed in the mark have been successfully enforced, particularly before the Courts of law and trademark registry and (x) actual or potential number of persons consuming goods or availing services being sold under that brand.
17. In this context, PW1 has deposed to the effect that: CS(COMM) 1227/2016 Page 13 of 15
i. the plaintiff (through its predecessor) is using the mark Officer's Choice continuously and extensively since the year 1988;
ii. the plaintiffs sales of the products bearing the trademark Officer's Choice and other related marks have increased from 1.13 million cases in the year 1994 to 30.18 million in the year 2014-15 (Ex Pw1/46 and Ex Pw1/123);
iii. the plaintiffs expenditure on advertisement and brand promotion of Officer's Choice has increased from `6.35 crores in the year 1993-94 to ` 264.59 crores in 2014-2015 (Ex Pw1/125);
iv. the exports Officer's Choice have arisen from 80,900 cases in 2006-07 to 10,02,456 in the year 2010-11 [Ex Pw1/83 (Colly)];
v. the plaintiff's whiskey Officer's Choice was reported to be the largest selling whiskey in the world by the newspaper, The Times of India in an article dated 11.08.2014 (Ex Pw1/85);
vi. the plaintiff's whiskey Officer's Choice is described as the largest selling whiskey in the world by The Millionaires Club 2014 (Ex Pw1/87);
vii. that Officer's Choice whiskey is world's no. 1 whiskey in the world in terms of volume as per an article in the IWSR Magazine, August, 2014 edition (ExPw1/88); and
viii. Officer's Choice has been presented with several awards including "World's Greatest Brand & Leaders 2015- Asia and GCC" by URS International. [Ex pw1/124(Colly)]. CS(COMM) 1227/2016 Page 14 of 15
18. Tested on the parameters as indicated in section 11(6) and 11(7) of the Act, it is plainly evident that the mark Officer's Choice has become a "well known" mark.
19. In view of the above, the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of permanent injunction restraining the defendant from using the mark Officere's or any other mark deceptively similar to the mark of the plaintiff. Accordingly, the decree is granted in terms of prayers made in paragraph 26 (i), (ii) and (iii) of the plaint, which read as under :
i. an order for permanent injunction restraining the Defendant, its directors, principal officers, wholesalers, distributors, partners or proprietors, as the case may be, its officers, servants and agents from manufacturing, selling, exporting, importing, offering for sale, distributing, advertising, directly or indirectly dealing in alcoholic beverages, especially IMFL or goods of any description bearing the trade mark and/or trade name "Officere's" or any identical or deceptively similar mark/label to the Plaintiffs trademarks/label marks "Officer", 'Officer's Club' and/or "Officer's Choice" as also other "Officer" formative marks, amounting to infringement of the Plaintiffs registered trademarks as enumerated in the Plaint;
ii. an order for permanent injunction restraining the Defendant, its directors, principal officers, wholesalers, distributors, partners or proprietors, as the case may be, its officers, servants and agents from manufacturing, selling, exporting, importing, offering for sale, distributing, advertising, directly or indirectly dealing in alcoholic beverages, especially IMFL or goods of any description bearing the trade mark and/or trade name Officere's or any identical or CS(COMM) 1227/2016 Page 15 of 15 deceptively similar mark/label to the Plaintiffs trade marks/label marks "Officer", 'Officer's Club' and/or "Officer's Choice" as also other "Officer" formative marks, amounting to infringement of the Plaintiff's registered copyright as enumerated in the Plaint;
iii. an order for permanent injunction restraining the Defendant, its directors, principal officers, wholesalers, distributors, partners, or proprietor as the case may be, its officers, servants and agents from manufacturing, selling, exporting, importing, offering for sale, distributing, advertising, directly or indirectly dealing in IMFL or other goods bearing trade mark "Officere's" or any deceptively similar mark/label(s) including, but not limited to "Officer's Choice" and "OC', including any identical / similar logo as that of the Plaintiff s "Officer's Club" and "Officer's Choice" so as to misrepresent their products as those of the Plaintiff and from doing any other thing as may cause confusion or deception leading to passing off of the Defendant's goods and business as those of the Plaintiff;
20. The plaintiff has submitted a statement of costs, which includes counsel fees, court fees, fees of the local commissioner and other miscellaneous expenses computed at 9,71,558/-. The same are reasonable and the plaintiff is entitled to the same. Accordingly, costs quantified at 9,71,558/- are decreed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant.
21. Decree Sheet be drawn accordingly. VIBHU BAKHRU, J JANUARY 16, 2017
Alert