Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of Rajasthan v. Fatehkaran Mehdu .

Supreme Court Of India
Feb 3, 2017
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Smt. Sushma Devi applied in 1998 for a quarry licence over 4.95 ha of khatedari land at Nayanagar, Rajasthan. Mining Engineer Shri Fatehkaran Mehdu issued the licence, but the document contained extensive cuttings. When Sushma Devi returned it for correction, no fresh licence was issued. Instead, Mehdu later cancelled her licence and, in 1997-1998, sanctioned quarry licences in favour of Shri Kishan Singh Rawat on adjoining “gap-land.”

Sushma Devi’s writ petition was dismissed for availability of an alternative remedy; her statutory appeal succeeded on 29-4-1999, restoring her licence. Meanwhile Kishan Singh instituted civil suits to restrain Sushma Devi from mining.

Following a preliminary enquiry, the Anti-Corruption Bureau (ACB) registered FIR No. 342/2001 against Mehdu and Kishan Singh for offences under Sections 13(1)(d)/13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (“PC Act”) and Section 120-B IPC. After investigation, Charge-sheet No. 208/2005 was filed. On 5-5-2009 the Special Judge (Anti-Corruption), Udaipur framed charges.

Both accused filed criminal revision petitions. On 16-11-2010 the High Court of Rajasthan allowed the revisions and quashed the charges. The State of Rajasthan appealed to the Supreme Court, leading to the present judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court, in exercise of revisional jurisdiction under Section 397 CrPC, was justified in quashing the order dated 5-5-2009 framing charges against the respondents under Sections 13(1)(d)/13(2) PC Act and Section 120-B IPC.
  2. What is the correct scope of judicial interference at the stage of framing of charge, particularly in corruption cases involving public servants.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (State of Rajasthan)

  • Sufficient material existed in the charge-sheet to frame charges; the Special Judge rightly found a prima facie case.
  • The High Court exceeded its revisional jurisdiction because no exceptional ground under Section 397 CrPC was shown.
  • Mehdu abused his position to facilitate illegal mining by Kishan Singh, issuing a technical map showing 80,000 sq ft despite only 52,272 sq ft being available, thereby causing loss to the State and Sushma Devi.

Respondents (Fatehkaran Mehdu & Kishan Singh Rawat)

  • No allegation of Mehdu obtaining any pecuniary advantage for himself or others was made out; hence Section 13(1)(d) PC Act was inapplicable.
  • The assertion that 80,000 sq ft was allotted is factually wrong; records show only two licences of 12,500 sq ft each (total 25,000 sq ft).
  • Cancellation of Sushma Devi’s licence, later reversed on appeal, was at best an error correctable by departmental remedies and did not constitute criminal misconduct.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Amit Kapoor v. Ramesh Chander, (2012) 9 SCC 460 Defines the limited scope of revisional jurisdiction under Section 397 CrPC and the principles governing interference at the stage of framing of charge. The Supreme Court relied on the principles enumerated (para 27 series) to hold that the High Court erred in quashing the charges because the case did not fall within the narrow categories warranting revisional interference.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the charge-sheet and the Special Judge’s order, noting specific allegations that:

  • Mehdu sanctioned only three bighas (52,272 sq ft) of gap-land to Kishan Singh but issued a technical map depicting 80,000 sq ft, enabling unauthorised mining.
  • Mehdu cancelled Sushma Devi’s licence without due process, facilitating Kishan Singh’s illegal mining and causing revenue loss.

The Special Judge had therefore found a clear prima facie case warranting trial; final adjudication required evaluation of oral and documentary evidence.

The High Court quashed the charges primarily on a 13-11-2009 letter from the Mining Engineer stating no 80,000 sq ft licence existed. The Supreme Court held that the High Court:

  • Failed to address the allegation that the technical map (not the licence) showed the inflated area.
  • Engaged in a premature assessment of evidence, contrary to the settled law that, at the charge stage, only a strong suspicion is needed.
  • Misapplied Section 397 CrPC by substituting its view for that of the trial court in the absence of patent illegality or perversity.

Applying the principles in Amit Kapoor, the Court emphasized that revisional powers must be exercised sparingly and that quashing of charges is an exception, not the norm.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Allowed; High Court judgment set aside; order dated 5-5-2009 framing charges restored.

Consequences: The Special Judge (Anti-Corruption) will proceed with the trial expeditiously. The judgment reinforces the limited scope of revisional jurisdiction under Section 397 CrPC, particularly cautioning High Courts against quashing charges where a prima facie case exists. No new legal doctrine is created, but existing principles are reaffirmed.

Show all summary ...

Ashok Bhushan, J.— Leave granted. These two appeals have been filed against the common judgment dated 16-11-2010 Criminal Revision Petition No. 592 of 2009 of the High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jodhpur allowing SB Criminal Revision Petition No. 592 of 2009, Fatehkaran Mehdu v. State of Rajasthan and SB Criminal Revision Petition No. 598 of 2009, Kishan Singh Rawat v. State of Rajasthan. The High Court vide its order, allowing the criminal revisions, set aside the order dated 5-5-2009 passed by the Special Judge Anti-Corruption Cases, Udaipur, framing charges against both the respondents under Sections 13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 read with Section 120-B IPC.

2. The brief facts of the case, as emerged from materials on record, need to be noted for deciding the issues raised in these appeals. Both the appeals having arisen out of First Information Report No. 342 of 2001 and order dated 5-5-2009 framing charges, the facts being common, it shall be sufficient to refer to the facts from Criminal Appeal No. 216 of 2017 arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 3998 of 2011, State of Rajasthan v. Fatehkaran Mehdu.

3. The respondent, Fatehkaran Mehdu was working as Mining Engineer at Tehsil Bijolia, District Bhilwara, State of Rajasthan in the year 1997-1998. One Smt Sushma Devi had submitted an application for the grant of quarry licence for a mineral (Sandstone) as per the Rajasthan Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1986 (hereinafter referred to as “the 1986 Rules”). The application was made for grant of quarry licence for khatedari land situated at Nayanagar in different plots, including Plot No. 1181/124. She deposited a banker's cheque of Rs 1,75,000 dated 23-4-1998 and the quarry licence for 4.95 ha (30 bighas and 12 biswas) was prepared in the name of Smt Sushma Devi Dhakad and Shri Manoj Kumar Sandhya on 6-5-1998. On noticing that the quarry licence issued on 6-5-1998 contained various cuttings, she contacted Fatehkaran Mehdu and handed him the licence for issue of fresh licence. Shri Mehdu after taking all papers from Smt Sushma Devi did not issue her a fresh licence, whereas, Smt Sushma Devi had started mining operations. On 18-7-1998 one Shri K.K Boda, inspected the area and stopped the mining activities informing Smt Sushma Devi that no quarry licence was issued in her favour. On 11-8-1998, Mining Engineer Fatehkaran Mehdu directed Smt Sushma Devi to stop the mining activities; Fatehkaran Mehdu was transferred in August 1998 out of Tehsil Bigolia.

4. Aggrieved by non-issuance of quarry licence Sushma Devi filed Writ Petition No. 566 of 1999 before the High Court of Rajasthan which was dismissed by order dated 8-3-1999 Civil Writ No. 566 of 1999 due to availability of alternate remedy of filing an appeal under the 1986 Rules. Smt Sushma Devi filed an appeal before the appellate authority and the appellate authority vide order dated 29-4-1999 allowed the appeal and restored the quarry licence of Smt Sushma Devi.

5. On the other hand, Shri Kishan Singh Rawat, the respondent was also granted quarry licence on gap-land in Block Nos. 263-A and 264-A which contained a condition that the said approval shall not be effective outside Plot No. 1345/1185/124. Plot No. 1185/124 was situated towards south of Plot No. 1181/124, which was included in the quarry licence of Smt Sushma Devi.

6. Kishan Singh Rawat along with certain other persons had filed a suit against the consenting party of Khatedari Land No. 1238/125 on 23-6-1998 for stopping Sushma Devi from carrying on mining operations. Another Suit No. 1181/24 was filed on 13-7-1998 by Kishan Singh against the khatedars of Plot No. 1181/124 restraining them from interfering in mining operation on Plot No. 1345/1185/124 area 3 bighas.

7. After holding Preliminary Enquiry No. 7 of 2000 against Fatehkaran Mehdu, Deputy Superintendent of Police, Prevention of Corruption Bureau of Udaipur, lodged a first information report against Fatehkaran Mehdu and Kishan Singh Rawat under Sections 13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Section 120-B IPC.

8. After conducting the investigation, Charge-Sheet No. 208/2005 dated 24-10-2005 was submitted. The Special Judge, Prevention of Corruption Act, Udaipur vide order dated 5-5-2009 framed charges against both the respondents under Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Section 120-B IPC. Aggrieved by order dated 5-5-2009, Fatehkaran Mehdu filed SB Criminal Revision Petition No. 592 of 2009 and Kishan Singh Rawat filed SB Criminal Revision Petition No. 598 of 2009. The High Court of Rajasthan vide its judgment and order dated 16-11-2010 Criminal Revision Petition No. 592 of 2009 set aside the order dated 5-5-2009 allowing the revision against which these two appeals have been filed by the State of Rajasthan.

9. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the records. The learned counsel for the appellant submits that there were sufficient materials on record against the respondent, relying on which the learned Special Judge has framed the charges and the High Court committed an error by interfering with the charges framed, in exercise of revisional jurisdiction. It is submitted that there was no ground made out for exercise of revisional jurisdiction under Section 397 CrPC for quashing the charges framed. It was proved on the materials on record that the respondent Mehdu had facilitated Shri Kishan Singh Rawat to carry on illegal mining by which, he obtained illegal benefits to the detriment of the State of Rajasthan as well as Smt Sushma Devi. The quarry licence granted to Sushma Devi was cancelled by Mehdu to facilitate Kishan Singh Rawat to carry on illegal mining on the plot, which was included in the quarry licence of Sushma Devi. Shri Mehdu being a public servant has committed an offence under Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2).

10. The learned counsel for the respondent, refuting the submission of the appellant contends that the High Court on valid grounds has set aside the order framing the charge, since there was no allegation before the Special Judge on which, it can be said that any offence under Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the PC Act and Section 120-B IPC was made out. The allegation against Shri Mehdu that he has granted quarry licence of 80,000 sq ft to Kishan Singh Rawat, was factually incorrect since Kishan Singh Rawat was sanctioned quarry licence of only 25,000 sq ft. It is submitted that cancellation of licence of Smt Sushma Devi by Shri Mehdu cannot amount to any offence within the meaning of the aforesaid sections and the order of the appellate authority, setting aside the cancellation order does not lead to any presumption that an offence was committed by Shri Mehdu.

11. Before we proceed to examine the respective contentions, it is necessary to look into the charge-sheet to find out the nature of allegations made against the respondents. The charge-sheet has been brought on record as Annexure A-9. It is relevant to note some of the allegations, as recorded in the charge-sheet against the respondent. The charge-sheet notices the following:

“Whereas it is also pertinent to mention here that area of Plot No. 1345/1185/124 is three bighas 52,272 sq ft whereas, Shri Fatehkaran Mehdu Mining Engineer, Bijolia has granted sanction of 80,000 sq ft as gap fat. Thus, Shri Fatehkaran Mehdu, Mining Engineer in collusion with Shri Kishan Singh Rawat granted sanction for 80,000 sq ft land as against 52,272 sq ft available land, by which obviously proceeding for giving land to Shri Kishan Singh Rawat out of Plot No. 1181/124 of Smt Sushma Devi situated neighbouring has been done by collusion.”

12. Further, after noticing the facts, pertaining to grant of quarry licence to Kishan Singh Rawat and Smt Sushma Devi the following was stated:

“By investigation it was also found that illegal mining was done on Plot No. 1185/124 of Shri Kishan Singh Rawat for years. In the year 1997 the Mining Engineer in collusion under gap fat policy with a view to provide undue profit by back door got surrendered 3 bighas land out of 5 bighas in favour of the State Government and recorded without name so that gap fat could be approved under above policy. Under the rules lease can be granted only on land without name. To land so surrendered, Plot No. 1345/1185/124 was given, rest of two bighas land of Khatedar Property No. 1185/124 was given which presently is recorded as khatedari land in name Dhiru, son of Limbu Bheel, r/o Suradiya Tehsil Beawar in khata which is ancestral village of Kishan Singh Rawat. Plot No. 1185/124 combined rakba 2 bighas land is also recorded as khatedari therefore, gap fat permission cannot be accorded under gap fat policy but Mining Engineer in files of office accorded approval of Plot No. 1345/1185/124 rakba 3 bighas, entry in which regard was made with special stipulation on quarry licence but in technical map told about according approval on Plot No. 1185/124 combined so that if any time measurement is carried out then same could be found according to technical map and according to same Shri Kishan Singh Rawat could get illegal profit. On spot Shri Kishan Singh Rawat in present time is also doing mining work on Plot No. 1185/124 com. Rakba 2 bighas land and whenever question for measurement arises then he shows being approval on the basis of department's technical map whereas, in quarry licence and files permission is accorded only to Plot No. 1345/1185/124, total area of which comes to be 52,272 sq ft whereas, according to technical map area 80,000 sq ft is shown. Under khatedari policy Shri Fatehkaran Mehdu only with a view to cause loss to tenure-holders of Plot No. 1181/124 situated in south of Plot No. 1185/124, called back issued quarry licence of Smt Sushma Dhakad in name of correcting same by violating all rules, cancelled quarry licence and information in which regard was not given to licence-holders.”

13. There was a clear allegation in the charge-sheet that quarry licence to Kishan Singh Rawat was given by Shri Mehdu in furtherance of object and purpose of illegally benefitting Kishan Singh Rawat. It was further stated that although, approval for quarry licence on Plot No. 1345/1185/124 area 3 bighas was granted, total area of which comes to only 52,272 sq ft, whereas in the technical map, area was shown 80,000 sq ft dishonestly benefiting Kishan Singh Rawat.

14. Considering the charge-sheet and other materials on record, the charges have been framed. In para 1 of the order, the learned Special Judge has noted the following facts:

“1. It is worth mentioning that total area of Land No. 1345/1185/124 is total three bighas i.e 52,272 sq ft while Fatehkaran Mehdu issued sanction of 80,000 sq ft in the form of gap fat area and thus, accused Fatehkaran Mehdu connived with Kishan Singh Rawat, he connived in the proceedings for getting allotted more land to Kishan Singh Rawat out of the land of neighbour Sushma Devi, on which on establishing the prima facie case making out, the then Additional Superintendent of Police of Prevention of Corruption Bureau, Udaipur, sent a first information report without numbering to the Headquarter, on which case First Information Report No. 342 of 2001 was registered on 18-9-2001 and was received for investigation.”

15. Further in para 2, the order states:

“2. From the investigation it was established that Smt Sushma Devi, Manoj Kumar Sandhya and Jitmal Balai submitted application on 1-5-1998 in prescribed form. Landowners of khasra numbers concerned expressed their consent in favour of applicants, thereafter, on 6-5-1998 Shri Mehdu granted approval for issuing quarry licence and licence were issued. Smt Sushma Devi checked quarry licence on 8-5-1998, then came to know that serious nature of lacunae were found. At the same time Smt Sushma Devi contacted Fatehkaran Mehdu, Mineral Engineer about the abovesaid, then he issued directions for making correction in the quarry licence and handed over letters, etc. to the Office Assistant Sohanlal. Stating excessive cuttings, Shri Mehdu instead of taking all the papers from Smt Sushma Devi for issuing new quarry licence, with intentions to get other person Kishan Singh unlawful benefits, connived with him and mala fide issued licence.”

16. In para 2, it has further been noted:

“2. Under the quarry licence passed by Shri Fatehkaran Mehdu, Shri Kishan Singh undertook unauthorised mining work for years on five bighas land in place of three bighas land due to which the State Government suffered loss of annual rent, etc. and Kishan Singh earned unlawful profits. On account of conspiracy hatched with him and connivance for getting Kishan Singh benefitted, it established that Shri Fatehkaran Mehdu allotted land to Kishan Singh Rawat contrary to rules or in the form of gap and fat due to which the present charge-sheet under Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Section 120 of the Penal Code was filed in which Kishan Singh Rawat, beneficiary was also made accused.”

17. The Special Judge after considering the contention put forth by the learned counsel for the parties noted the charge that against the total area of 52,272 sq ft available, Shri Mehdu has issued sanction for 80,000 sq ft in the form of “gap area” to Kishan Singh Rawat to unduly benefit him, and the same can be decided after recording oral and documentary evidence. The Special Judge found a clear prima facie case of framing charges. It is relevant to extract the findings from para 6 of the order. In para 6 of the order, the following has been stated:

“6. Prima facie charge has been framed against accused persons that with the intentions to cause loss to khatedars of Land No. 1181/124 situated in the southern side of Land No. 1185/124, on which licence was issued to Smt Sushma Dhakar, Shri Fatehkaran Mehdu called for the same in the name of rectifying the same, he cancelled the quarry licence in violation of all the rules and its information was not conveyed to the licence-holders. Shri Mehdu did not try to settle the disputes on the spot rather he issued licence to parties without any acceptable demarcation and cancelled without adopting process. Dispute prevailing between Land Nos. 1185/124 and 1181/124 could have been settled earlier by carrying out measurement in detail through the Department of Revenue, but no effort was made in this context, consequently, Kishan Singh Rawat has undertaken unauthorised mining work on five bighas area of Land No. 1185/124 in place of three bigha land due to which State Government has suffered loss of annual rent, etc. It also established in the investigation that Fatehkaran Mehdu had got the intentions behind cancelling of quarry licence of Smt Sushma Dhakar that Kishan Singh Rawat be benefitted by allotting land to Kishan Singh Rawat neighbour of Smt Dhakar in the name of gap fat and Shri Mehdu has got Kishan Singh Rawat financially benefitted unlawfully by allotting land in the form of gap fat having misused his post and powers. It is universal principle of law that court is supposed to see at the stage of framing of charge as to whether prima facie case worth triable makes out on the basis of evidence and the facts put forth by the prosecution or not. Final disposal of the charges framed against the accused on merits is not required at the said stage.”

18. In view of what has been noted above, whether the High Court was right in quashing the order framing charges by the Special Judge on 5-5-2009, is the question to be answered in these appeals. What is the basis for quashing the charges by the High Court, has to be found out from the order of the High Court, allowing the criminal revisions.

19. The High Court, after noticing the few allegations against the respondent observed that there was no allegation made by the prosecution against the respondent to the effect that by any corrupt or illegal means Shri Mehdu obtained any valuable thing or pecuniary advantage for himself or for any other person. With regard to alleged allotment of 80,000 sq ft in favour of Kishan Singh Rawat, it was held prima facie not to be correct since Mining Engineer concerned had certified that there was no allotment of 80,000 sq ft by Mehdu to Kishan Singh Rawat. It is useful to extract paras 8 and 9 of the judgment of the High Court which is to the following effect:

“8. Having gone through the aforesaid provision and judgments cited at the Bar and upon perusal of the order dated 5-5-2009, this Court does not find any allegation made by the applicant or prosecution against the present petitioner that by any corrupt or illegal means he obtained any valuable thing or pecuniary advantage either for himself or for any other person. Even alleged allotment of 80,000 sq ft land in favour of Petitioner 2 Kishan Singh was prima facie found to be incorrect since Mining Engineer concerned himself certified that there was no allotment of 80,000 sq ft area by the present petitioner in favour of Petitioner 2 Kishan Singh and only allotment made was way back in 1997-1998 of 25,000 sq ft. Mere fact that applicant Smt Sushma Devi had to file appeal before the competent authority under the Mining Act against the alleged illegal cancellation of her quarry licence and succeeded therein does not amount to any criminal charge against the present petitioner under the purview of Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. Obviously, these proceedings are quasi-judicial in nature undertaken in exercise of powers conferred upon the Mining Engineer under the said Act and any error which can be corrected by appellate or revisional authority does not amount to a criminal charge established against the said authority. This Court does not find any allegation of taking bribe or any other allegation of that nature which would come within the ambit of words employed in Section 13(1)(d), namely; “by corruption or illegal means obtains for himself or for any other person any valuable thing or pecuniary advantage.
9. In the absence of any such allegation, this Court cannot appreciate how the charge under Sections 13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act read with Section 120-B IPC has been framed against the present petitioners.”

20. The High Court based its judgment for quashing the charges on the aforesaid conclusion, as recorded in paras 8 and 9. Sections 13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 under which charges have been framed, are to the following effect:

“13. Criminal misconduct by a public servant.—(1) A public servant is said to commit the offence of criminal misconduct—
***
(d) if he—
(i) by corrupt or illegal means, obtains for himself or for any other person any valuable thing or pecuniary advantage; or
(ii) by abusing his position as a public servant, obtains for himself or for any other person any valuable thing or pecuniary advantage; or
(iii) while holding office as a public servant, obtains for any person any valuable thing or pecuniary advantage without any public interest; or
***
(2) Any public servant who commits criminal misconduct shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which shall be not less than one year but which may extend to seven years and shall also be liable to fine.”

21. What are the allegations against Mehdu to frame charge under Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) have to be found out from the charge-sheet and other materials. We have already extracted the relevant allegations made against Shri Mehdu in the charge-sheet as well as the facts noticed by the learned Special Judge. While framing the charge, the substance of the allegation against Mehdu is that he has granted a quarry licence to Kishan Singh Rawat on three bighas area of Plot No. 1345/1185/124, total area of which comes to 52,272 sq ft whereas, he was sanctioned 80,000 sq ft. Further allegation is that Mehdu permitted Kishan Singh Rawat to indulge in unauthorised mining over the larger area than that granted to him putting the Government as well as Smt Sushma Devi to loss.

22. The High Court in its order has observed that it has been certified by the present Mining Engineer that Mehdu had never sanctioned alleged 80,000 sq ft in favour of Kishan Singh Rawat for which observation, the High Court based a letter dated 13-11-2009 filed as Annexure A-11 in the appeal, which was also taken on the record by the High Court. The said letter was addressed to Fatehkaran Mehdu in reply to his query, as to whether, Kishan Singh Rawat was granted quarry licence for 80,000 sq ft. The answer given in the said letter dated 13-11-2009 is to the following effect:

“As per the information sought with regard to the captioned subject, as per the record available in the office no licence of 80,000 sq ft has been granted to Shri Kishan Singh Rawat in Arazi No. 1185/124 Mauza Village Nayanagar, Tehsil Bijoliya, District Bhilwara. In the circumstances, it is not possible to give the copy. In the year 1997-1998, the quarry licence-holder in Plot Nos. 263-A and 264-A of Arazi No. 1185/124 Shri Gopal Singh Rawat, s/o Shri Anna Singh Rawat, r/o Suradia, Tehsil Byawar, District Ajmer (Rajasthan) was granted permission and quarry licence of total 12,500-12,500 sq ft. The said quarry licence was transferred in the name of Kishan Singh Rawat, s/o Devi Singh Rawat, resident of Suradia, Tehsil Byawar, District Ajmer (Rajasthan), which is not effective at present.”

23. The respondents have brought on record the copy of the quarry licence granted to Kishan Singh Rawat as Annexures A-3 and A-4 which indicates that two quarry licences were for 12,500 sq ft each. It appears that the High Court failed to advert the substance of allegation against Shri Mehdu, as we have already noticed from the charge-sheet that Shri Mehdu although, granted quarry licence only for three bighas gap land in Plot No. 1345/1185/124, but technical map issued by Shri Mehdu was to an area of 80,000 sq ft, which was a source for Kishan Singh Rawat to carry on unauthorised mining over the larger area than that actually allotted to him.

24. In the charge-sheet, the following has been specifically noted:

“… On spot Shri Kishan Singh Rawat in present time is also doing mining work on Plot No. 1185/124 com. Rakba 2 bighas land and whenever question for measurement arises then he shows being approval on the basis of department's technical map whereas, in quarry licence and files permission is accorded only to Plot No. 1345/1185/124, total area of which comes to be 52,272 sq ft whereas, according to technical map area 80,000 sq ft is shown.”

(emphasis supplied)

25. As noted above, the learned Special Judge had observed that final adjudication of charge cannot be made unless oral and documentary evidence is received. The High Court has not adverted to the technical map which mentions 80,000 sq ft and without adverting to that allegation, has erroneously observed that there is no allegation which may come within the meaning of Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Act. Both charge-sheet and order of the learned Special Judge have specifically noted the allegations, which clearly makes out an offence under Sections 13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the Prevention and Corruption Act, 1988 and Section 120-B IPC.

26. The scope of interference and exercise of jurisdiction under Section 397 CrPC has been time and again explained by this Court. Further, the scope of interference under Section 397 CrPC at a stage, when charge had been framed, is also well settled. At the stage of framing of a charge, the court is concerned not with the proof of the allegation rather it has to focus on the material and form an opinion whether there is strong suspicion that the accused has committed an offence, which if put to trial, could prove his guilt. The framing of charge is not a stage, at which stage final test of guilt is to be applied. Thus, to hold that at the stage of framing the charge, the court should form an opinion that the accused is certainly guilty of committing an offence, is to hold something which is neither permissible nor is in consonance with the scheme of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

27. Now, reverting to the limit of the scope of jurisdiction under Section 397 CrPC, which vests the court with the power to call for and examine the records of an inferior court for the purposes of satisfying itself as to the legality and regularity of any proceedings or order made in a case. The object of this provision is to set right a patent defect or an error of jurisdiction or law or the perversity which has crept in the proceeding.

28. It is useful to refer to the judgment of this Court in Amit Kapoor v. Ramesh Chander (2012) 9 SCC 460, where scope of Section 397 CrPC has been succinctly considered and explained. Paras 12 and 13 are as follows:

“12. Section 397 of the Code vests the court with the power to call for and examine the records of an inferior court for the purposes of satisfying itself as to the legality and regularity of any proceedings or order made in a case. The object of this provision is to set right a patent defect or an error of jurisdiction or law. There has to be a well-founded error and it may not be appropriate for the court to scrutinise the orders, which upon the face of it bears a token of careful consideration and appear to be in accordance with law. If one looks into the various judgments of this Court, it emerges that the revisional jurisdiction can be invoked where the decisions under challenge are grossly erroneous, there is no compliance with the provisions of law, the finding recorded is based on no evidence, material evidence is ignored or judicial discretion is exercised arbitrarily or perversely. These are not exhaustive classes, but are merely indicative. Each case would have to be determined on its own merits.
13. Another well-accepted norm is that the revisional jurisdiction of the higher court is a very limited one and cannot be exercised in a routine manner. One of the inbuilt restrictions is that it should not be against an interim or interlocutory order. The Court has to keep in mind that the exercise of revisional jurisdiction itself should not lead to injustice ex facie. Where the Court is dealing with the question as to whether the charge has been framed properly and in accordance with law in a given case, it may be reluctant to interfere in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction unless the case substantially falls within the categories aforestated. Even framing of charge is a much advanced stage in the proceedings under CrPC.”

29. The Court in para 27 has recorded its conclusion and laid down principles to be considered for exercise of jurisdiction under Section 397 particularly in the context of quashing of charge framed under Section 228 CrPC. Paras 27, 27.1, 27.2, 27.3, 27.9 and 27.13 are extracted as follows: (Amit Kapoor case (2012) 9 SCC 460)

“27. Having discussed the scope of jurisdiction under these two provisions i.e Section 397 and Section 482 of the Code and the fine line of jurisdictional distinction, now it will be appropriate for us to enlist the principles with reference to which the courts should exercise such jurisdiction. However, it is not only difficult but is inherently impossible to state with precision such principles. At best and upon objective analysis of various judgments of this Court, we are able to cull out some of the principles to be considered for proper exercise of jurisdiction, particularly, with regard to quashing of charge either in exercise of jurisdiction under Section 397 or Section 482 of the Code or together, as the case may be:
27.1 Though there are no limits of the powers of the Court under Section 482 of the Code but the more the power, the more due care and caution is to be exercised in invoking these powers. The power of quashing criminal proceedings, particularly, the charge framed in terms of Section 228 of the Code should be exercised very sparingly and with circumspection and that too in the rarest of rare cases.
27.2 The Court should apply the test as to whether the uncontroverted allegations as made from the record of the case and the documents submitted therewith prima facie establish the offence or not. If the allegations are so patently absurd and inherently improbable that no prudent person can ever reach such a conclusion and where the basic ingredients of a criminal offence are not satisfied then the Court may interfere.
27.3 The High Court should not unduly interfere. No meticulous examination of the evidence is needed for considering whether the case would end in conviction or not at the stage of framing of charge or quashing of charge.
***
27.9 Another very significant caution that the courts have to observe is that it cannot examine the facts, evidence and materials on record to determine whether there is sufficient material on the basis of which the case would end in a conviction; the Court is concerned primarily with the allegations taken as a whole whether they will constitute an offence and, if so, is it an abuse of the process of court leading to injustice.
***
27.13 Quashing of a charge is an exception to the rule of continuous prosecution. Where the offence is even broadly satisfied, the Court should be more inclined to permit continuation of prosecution rather than its quashing at that initial stage. The Court is not expected to marshal the records with a view to decide admissibility and reliability of the documents or records but is an opinion formed prima facie.”

30. Applying the above tests, we are of the considered opinion that the High Court erred in quashing the charges framed by the order dated 5-5-2009. In the result, both the appeals are allowed. The order of the High Court is set aside and the order dated 5-5-2009 is restored. The learned Special Judge may proceed with the trial in accordance with the law expeditiously.