Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of Bihar And Others v. Ramesh Prasad Verma (Dead) Through Legal Representatives .

Supreme Court Of India
Jan 31, 2017
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondents held a ten-year lease (starting in 1992) under the Bihar Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1972 for winning pebbles (boulder, gravel and shingle) from the basin of the Pandai River. The royalty initially fixed in 1991 was revised in 1994. By Notification dated 24-3-2001, Schedule II of the Rules was amended, enhancing royalty on “boulder, gravel, shingle which are used for making chips” to Rs 100 per cubic metre with effect from 1-4-2001, but the notification’s footnote required the State to “identify and notify” the relevant areas separately.

Demand notices dated 6-9-2001 and 29-11-2001 sought royalty at the enhanced rate for the period beginning 1-4-2001; the respondents made part payments. On 26-12-2001 the State issued a second Notification identifying areas in the districts of Rohtas and Bettiah where the minerals were fit for making chips, purporting to apply the enhanced rate from 1-4-2001.

The respondents’ administrative appeals failed, after which they invoked Article 226 before the Patna High Court. A Single Judge upheld the State’s stand, but a Division Bench reversed, limiting the enhanced rate to the period starting 26-12-2001. Aggrieved, the State of Bihar appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Notification dated 26-12-2001, which identified specific mining areas, is merely clarificatory and therefore operates retrospectively from 1-4-2001, enabling the State to realise royalty at Rs 100 per cubic metre for the entire period beginning 1-4-2001.
  2. Whether, under Rule 26(5) of the Bihar Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1972, a delegated notification can validly impose or enhance royalty with retrospective effect in the absence of express statutory authorisation.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants (State of Bihar)

  • The Notification of 26-12-2001 is purely clarificatory; it only identifies the areas referenced in the footnote to the 24-3-2001 Notification and therefore relates back to 1-4-2001.
  • No change in the description of minerals was introduced; the enhanced rate had already been validly fixed on 24-3-2001.
  • The High Court mis-read Rule 26 and ignored the legislative intent behind the two notifications.

Respondents (Lessee-operators)

  • Delegated legislation cannot operate retrospectively unless the parent statute expressly authorises it; therefore the 26-12-2001 Notification cannot have retrospective effect.
  • The later notification is non est because it allegedly alters the mineral description contained in Schedule II of the earlier notification.
  • Relied on precedents such as ITO v. M.C. Ponnoose, Hukam Chand v. Union of India, and others to assert the impermissibility of retrospective delegation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
ITO v. M.C. Ponnoose (1969) 2 SCC 351 Delegated legislation generally cannot have retrospective effect unless authorised. Cited by respondents; Court distinguished the case, holding the present notification to be merely clarificatory.
Hukam Chand v. Union of India (1972) 2 SCC 601 Limits on retrospective operation of subordinate legislation. Cited by respondents; Court found it inapplicable given the clarificatory nature of the 26-12-2001 Notification.
CIT v. Bazpur Coop. Sugar Factory Ltd. Same principle against retrospective delegated legislation. Cited by respondents; not accepted for similar reasons.
Bejgam Veeranna Venkata Narasimloo v. State of A.P. (1998) 1 SCC 563 Restriction on imposing retrospective burdens via subordinate legislation. Cited by respondents; Court held it did not apply.
CIT v. Gold Coin Health Food (P) Ltd. (2008) 9 SCC 622 Clarificatory or declaratory statutes presumed to be retrospective. Relied upon by the Court to support treating the 26-12-2001 Notification as clarificatory with retrospective effect.
Zile Singh v. State of Haryana (2004) 8 SCC 1 Explanatory or declaratory legislation is usually retrospective. Cited by the Court in affirming the retrospective operation of clarificatory instruments.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. The Court noted that the respondents never challenged the validity of the 24-3-2001 Notification, nor its enforcement from 1-4-2001.

2. The footnote to that notification expressly contemplated a separate future notification to identify the concerned areas. Hence, the later Notification (26-12-2001) merely fulfilled an already-specified requirement; it did not create a new levy.

3. Examining Rule 26, especially sub-rule (5), the Court held that enhancement or reduction of royalty takes effect from the date of publication. However, where the later instrument only clarifies a pre-existing levy, it can operate retrospectively.

4. Linguistic analysis of the words “fit and suitable for making chips” revealed no substantive alteration in mineral description. The Notification simply confirmed that minerals from the identified districts matched those already covered.

5. Relying on CIT v. Gold Coin Health Food (P) Ltd. and Zile Singh, the Court reiterated that clarificatory or declaratory instruments ordinarily have retrospective effect, unless expressly excluded.

6. The High Court’s apprehension that lessees might not have passed the burden to purchasers was deemed speculative and unsupported by the record.

7. Consequently, the enhanced royalty of Rs 100 per cubic metre is payable from 1-4-2001 on minerals extracted from the notified areas, and the Division Bench’s contrary interpretation was declared erroneous.

Holding and Implications

Appeals ALLOWED – High Court judgment set aside.

Direct Effect: Respondents must pay royalty at Rs 100 per cubic metre for the period commencing 1-4-2001, after adjustment of amounts already deposited. Broader Implication: The decision underscores that where a subsequent notification is merely clarificatory of an earlier one, it can validly operate retrospectively even under delegated legislation; however, it sets no new statutory precedent beyond this clarification.

Show all summary ...

Amitava Roy, J.— Leave granted. Vexed by the determination thereby limiting the application of Notification No. SS-2.MM-11/2001-2361…/M dated 26-12-2001 to the date of issuance thereof, for the purpose of realising royalty in respect of the minerals mentioned therein @ Rs 100 per cubic metre, otherwise prescribed by the Notification dated 24-3-2001 notifying the Bihar Minor Mineral Concession (Amendment) Rules, 2001, the State of Bihar and its functionaries concerned are in appeal seeking redress. The impugned judgment and order dated 21-8-2009 2009 SCC OnLine Pat 299, (2010) 1 PLJR 238 is common in both the appeals and consequently, marginal variation in the contextual facts notwithstanding, the legal issues raised are the same, permitting analogous disposal of the proceedings in hand.

2. We have heard Mr Gopal Singh, learned counsel for the appellants and Mr Sunil Kumar, learned counsel and Mr Nagendra Rai, learned Senior Counsel for the respondents in appeals corresponding to SLPs (C) Nos. 3652 of 2010 and 3653 of 2010 respectively.

3. The facts, as construed to be germane for the adjudication, fall in a short compass and for the sake of brevity and convenience would be lifted from the appeal corresponding to SLP (C) No. 3652 of 2010. To reiterate, nothing turns on the facts with fringe differences in the two appeals and in course of the arguments as well, no marked distinguishable features have been highlighted warranting individual analysis thereof.

4. The respondent had been granted a lease for 10 years from the year 1992 under the Bihar Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1972 (hereinafter referred to as “the Rules”) and on the expiry of the term thereof, the same had not been renewed. The lease had been accorded to win pebbles (gutika) from the basin of Pandai River. The rate of royalty, as was fixed by the Notification dated 17-8-1991 initially at the commencement of the lease, stood revised thereafter on 29-8-1994. Eventually, by the aforementioned Notification dated 24-3-2001 ushering in the amendment to the Rules, amongst others the rate of royalty for “boulder, gravel, shingles, which is used for making chips”, was prescribed to be Rs 100 per cubic metre. The relevant excerpt from Schedule II to the Rules qua the above minerals is extracted hereinbelow for ready reference:

“Royalty
Sl. No. Name of the minerals Rate per cubic metre (in rupees) 1 2 3 1. Boulder, Gravel, Shingle 50.00 2. Boulder, Gravel, Shingle which are used for making chips 100.00”

At the foot of the notification, the following note was attached:

“Note.—In respect of minerals mentioned in Sl. Nos. 1 and 2, the identified areas of the two categories of the said minerals, shall be notified separately, as per rules.
***
3. This order will come into force from 1-4-2001.”

5. It would be appropriate as well to quote at this juncture, Rule 26 of the Rules pertaining to rent/royalty an assessment as hereinbelow:

“26. Rent/royalty and assessment.—(1) When a lease is granted or renewed.—
(a) Dead rent shall be charged at the rates specified in Schedule I;
(b) Royalty shall be charged at the rates specified in Schedule II; and
(c) Surface rent shall be charged at the rate specified by the Collector from time to time for the area occupied or used by the lessee.
(2) On and from the date of commencement of these Rules, the provisions of sub-rule (1) shall also apply to the leases granted or renewed prior to the date of such commencement and subsisting on such date.
(3) If the lease permits the working of more than one mineral in the same area, the Collector may charge separate dead rent in respect of each mineral:
Provided that the lessee shall be liable to pay the dead rent or royalty in respect of each mineral, whichever be higher in amount.
(4) Notwithstanding anything contained in any instrument of lease the lessee shall pay rent/royalty in respect of any minor mineral own, extracted and removed at the rate specified from time to time in Schedules I and II.
(5) The State Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, amend the first and second Schedules so as to enhance or reduce the rate at which rents/royalties shall be payable in respect of any minor mineral with effect from the date of publication of the notification in the Official Gazette.
(6) The Competent Officer, after such enquiry and verification as he may deem necessary of the monthly returns furnished by the lessee in Form ‘H’ shall assess the amount of rent/royalty payable by the lessee at the end of the prescribed period.”
(emphasis supplied)

6. As would be evident from the Notification dated 24-3-2001, thereby the rate of royalty for boulder, gravel, shingle, which are used for making chips, though had been stipulated to be Rs 100 per cubic metre, the footnote thereof clarified that the identified areas thereof would be notified separately as per the Rules. Otherwise, the rates were made effective on and from 1-4-2001. As the respondent was dealing in boulder, gravel, shingle which are used for making chips, the adjudicate understandably would be limited to these minerals.

7. Be that as it may, as the recorded facts demonstrate, demand notices dated 6-9-2001 and 29-11-2001 for the terms 1-4-2001 to July 2001 and 1-7-2001 to October 2001 for Rs 28,80,079 and Rs 16,75,353, followed in response whereto, the appellant deposited Rs 11 lakhs and Rs 8.5 lakhs correspondingly. At that stage, the Notification dated 26-12-2001 adverted to hereinabove, was issued by the Government of Bihar, Mines and Geological Department, to the effect that boulder, gravel, shingle found in the districts of Rohtas and Bettiah are capable of being made into stone chips, for which the royalty would be payable @ Rs 100 per cubic metre, as fixed by the Notification dated 24-3-2001 issued under Rule 26 of the Rules. The said Notification mentioned that the districts mentioned therein had been identified on the basis of a report of a team of experts constituted for the purpose. Pleaded facts are available to the effect that the State Government on 5-5-2001 had indeed constituted an Expert Committee to notify the areas in the basin of Pandai River, wherefrom the above minerals, if extracted, would attract the royalty @ Rs 100 per cubic metre, as ordained by the Notification dated 24-3-2001.

8. As with the issuance of the Notification dated 26-12-2001, the royalty @ Rs 100 per cubic metre for the minerals concerned was sought to be realised by the State Government w.e.f 24-3-2001, the respondents separately assailed the demand notices unsuccessfully before the departmental appellate authority, whereafter they laid the impeachment thereto before the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

9. The learned Single Judge dismissed CWJC No. 1254 of 2002 the impugnment observing that once the areas were identified by the Notification dated 26-12-2001, the demand would relate back to 1-4-2001.

10. The respondents, as a consequence, carried the challenge in appeal to the Division Bench, which upheld the same.

11. As the impugned verdict would reveal, the Division Bench noticed that the respondents had not challenged the validity of the Notification dated 24-3-2001 and had confined their demurral only to the retrospective application thereof, pursuant to the Notification dated 26-12-2001. The Division Bench held the view that once the rate of royalty had been enhanced, as effected by the Notification dated 24-3-2001, it was incumbent on the part of the authorities concerned also to notify the relevant areas therewith, so as to enable the lessees to pass on the liability to the purchasers in the transactions to follow. As, in absence of the identification of the areas by the Notification dated 23-4-2001, there was a possibility that the higher rates of royalty would not be applicable to them, the respondents might not have passed on such liability in their contemporary transactions. It was thus concluded that the realisation of royalty at the higher rates, as fixed by the Notification dated 24-3-2001, was not realisable from the date prior to 26-12-2001.

12. Consequently, both the respondents, as held, were required to pay royalty at the rate fixed by the Notification dated 24-3-2001 w.e.f 26-12-2001, following necessary adjustments of the amounts already deposited by them.

13. Whereas, the learned counsel for the appellant has emphatically urged that the Notification dated 26-12-2001 is apparently clarificatory in nature and only identifies the areas wherefrom the minerals involved, if extracted would attract the rate of royalty otherwise fixed by the Notification dated 24-3-2001, and that the High Court has ex facie erred in its interpretation thereof, the impugned decision has been endorsed on behalf of the respondents by pleading that the Rules by themselves being a delegated legislation, in the absence of any provision in the parent statute authorising realisation of royalty with retrospective effect, the Notification dated 26-12-2001 cannot be given a retrospective effect on and from 24-3-2001 and thus, no interference by this Court is called for. The learned counsel for the respondents have contended further that the Notification dated 26-12-2001 is even otherwise non est, as it seeks to alter as well the description of the minerals set out in Schedule II of the Notification dated 24-3-2001. Reliance on their behalf has been placed on the decisions of this Court in ITO v. M.C Ponnoose (1969) 2 SCC 351, Hukam Chand v. Union of India (1972) 2 SCC 601, CIT v. Bazpur Coop. Sugar Factory Ltd. (1988) 3 SCC 553, Bejgam Veeranna Venkata Narasimloo v. State of A.P (1998) 1 SCC 563

14. The materials available on record and the competing assertions have received our due consideration. Admittedly, the Notification dated 24-3-2001 occasioning enhancement of the rate of royalty for boulder, gravel, shingle which are used for making chips and extracted by the respondents' firm from the basin of Pandai River, is not under assailment by them. They have not questioned as well the enforcement of this Notification w.e.f 1-4-2001. As claimed by them, in response to the demand notices thereafter, they have made part payments of the royalty claimed. They have unequivocally averred that they deal in boulder, gravel, shingle, which are used for making chips.

15. The footnote to the Notification dated 24-3-2001, in clear terms, proclaims that the areas of the two categories of the minerals, corresponding to Sl. Nos. 1 and 2 (boulder, gravel, shingle, which are used for making chips) once identified, would be notified separately as per the Rules. Eventually, such areas being located in the districts of Rohtas and Bettiah, having been identified by the Expert Committee constituted for the purpose, the Notification dated 26-12-2001 followed. A plain reading of this Notification would demonstrate, in unambiguous terms, that it is in continuation of the one dated 24-3-2001 fixing the rate of royalty at Rs 100 per cubic metre for boulder, gravel, shingle, from which chips are prepared. Though it mentioned that the boulder, gravel and shingle found in the districts of Rohtas and Bettiah were fit and suitable for making stone chips, in our comprehension, though imputed by the respondents, there is in reality no alteration in the description of the minerals so as to exclude those extracted by them from the purview of this Notification or the one dated 24-3-2001. The words “is” and “fit and suitable” for making, in the attendant facts and circumstances, unmistakably refer to boulder, gravel and shingle from which either are used for making chips or are capable of making the same. The assertion of the respondents to the contrary does not commend for acceptance and is rejected.

16. In re Rule 26, it is apparent therefrom that when a lease is granted or renewed, amongst others royalty would be charged at the rate specified in Schedule II and that the State Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, amend the First and Second Schedules so as to enhance or reduce the rate at which rents/royalty would be payable in respect of any minor mineral w.e.f the date of the publication of the notification in the Official Gazette. Though it has been contended on behalf of the respondents that the mandate contained in sub-rule (5) of Rule 26 authorising the State Government to enhance or reduce the rate of rents/royalties, has to be construed to make such enhancement or reduction effective essentially on and from the date of the publication of the notification in the Official Gazette to that effect, we are unable to subscribe to this plea vis-à-vis the Notification dated 26-12-2001 in its operation. In our estimate, having regard to the relevant provisions of the Rules and, in particular the two notifications in hand and most importantly the footnote to the one dated 24-3-2001, the Notification dated 26-12-2001 is only clarificatory in nature, inasmuch as it declares only the areas from which, if the minerals concerned are extracted would draw the rate of royalty already fixed by the Notification dated 24-3-2001, payable on and from 1-4-2001.

17. No other interpretation would accord with the legislative intendment contained in Rule 26 as well as the objectives of the two Notifications.

18. All the decisions cited at the Bar are to the effect that a delegated legislation cannot traverse beyond the contours of the authority endowed by the parent statute and unless authorised by it, is not empowered to make any law or provision with retrospective effect, impairing the already vested rights of those likely to be adversely affected thereby. In our mind, these pronouncements, in the singular facts of the case are of no avail to the respondents having regard in particular to the clarificatory nature of the Notification dated 26-12-2001.

19. In CIT v. Gold Coin Health Food (P) Ltd. (2008) 9 SCC 622, a three-Judge Bench of this Court, while dwelling on the sweep of a clarificatory or declaratory legal provision, relied on the following extract from the celebrated treatise “Principles of Statutory Interpretation”, 11th Edn., 2008 by Justice G.P Singh:

“19. … ‘The presumption against retrospective operation is not applicable to declaratory statutes. As stated in Craies and approved by the Supreme Court: “For modern purposes a declaratory Act may be defined as an Act to remove doubts existing as to the common law, or the meaning or effect of any statute. Such acts are usually held to be retrospective. …” …An explanatory Act is generally passed to supply an obvious omission or to clear up doubts as to the meaning of the previous Act. It is well settled that if a statute is curative or merely declaratory of the previous law, retrospective operation is generally intended. The language “shall be deemed always to have meant” or “shall be deemed never to have included” is declaratory, and is in plain terms retrospective. In the absence of clear words indicating that the amending Act is declaratory, it would not be so construed when the amended provision was clear and unambiguous. An amending Act may be purely clarificatory to clear a meaning of a provision of the principal Act which was already implicit. A clarificatory amendment of this nature will have retrospective effect and, therefore, if the principal Act was existing law when the Constitution came into force, the amending Act also will be part of the existing law.’ ”
(emphasis supplied)

20. The following quote contained in Zile Singh v. State of Haryana (2004) 8 SCC 1, AIR 2004 SC 5100 was also noted with approval:

“14. The presumption against retrospective operation is not applicable to declaratory statutes.… In determining, therefore, the nature of the Act, regard must be had to the substance rather than to the form. If a new Act is “to explain” an earlier Act, it would be without object unless construed retrospectively. An explanatory Act is generally passed to supply an obvious omission or to clear up doubts as to the meaning of the previous Act. It is well settled that if a statute is curative or merely declaratory of the previous law, retrospective operation is generally intended.… An amending Act may be purely declaratory to clear a meaning of a provision of the principal Act which was already implicit. A clarificatory amendment of this nature will have retrospective effect (Ibid., pp. 468-69).”
(emphasis supplied)

21. The proposition has been so well laid that we do not wish to burden the present rendition by referring to other rulings in the same vein. Suffice it to state that any legislation or instrument having the force of law, if clarificatory, declaratory or explanatory in nature and purport, in order to supply an obvious omission or to clear up doubts qua any prior law, retrospective operation thereof is generally intended. Applying this test, in the absence of any indication to the contrary, either in the parent Act or the Rules or the notifications involved, we are thus of the unhesitant opinion that on a conjoint reading of Rule 26 and the two notifications, the enhanced rate of royalty at Rs 100 per cubic metre for boulder, gravel and shingle, which are used or are capable of being used for making chips would be realisable w.e.f 1-4-2001 and axiomatically thus, the respondents are liable to discharge the demand, therefor, as raised in terms thereof. The respondents were fully aware of the amended rate of Rs 100 per cubic metre for the minerals extracted by them and thus the reasoning of the High Court that they might not have passed on the burden to their purchasers is without any factual basis and being clearly speculative is untenable. The High Court, in our view, had clearly erred in interpreting the relevant legal provisions and the Notification dated 26-12-2001 in particular in holding that the enhanced rates, as fixed by the Notification dated 24-3-2001, would be payable for the minerals involved, as extracted from the two areas, mentioned in the Notification dated 26-12-2001 on and from that date. The determination made by the High Court is thus indefensible and consequently, the impugned decision 2009 SCC OnLine Pat 299, (2010) 1 PLJR 238 is hereby set aside.

22. The appeals are thus allowed. No costs.