- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Upendra Nath Misra v. Union Of India And Ors.
Structured Summary of the Opinion (High Court) — Writ Petition (C) No.3292/2012
Factual and Procedural Background
This matter concerns disciplinary proceedings initiated against Shri U.N. Mishra (referred to in the opinion as the delinquent), who was posted as Camp Officer in Arunachal Pradesh from December 1996 to April 1997. A charge memo dated 17.01.2001 (under Rule 14 of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965) framed five charges; the opinion reproduces and focuses on three of them:
- Article I: Allegation of preparing fictitious muster rolls and claiming false contingent bills for porters (period 12-12-1996 to 09-04-1997), violating Rule 3(1)(i) & (iii) of the Conduct Rules, 1964.
- Article IV: Allegation of claiming bus fare for 37 porters but paying only 6, implying misappropriation, violating Rule 3(1)(i) & (iii) of the Conduct Rules, 1964.
- Article V: Allegation of selling 246 kgs of sugar in the open market (sugar purchased from Arunachal Pradesh Government Ration shop for distribution among camp personnel), violating Rule 3(1)(i) & (iii) of the Conduct Rules, 1964.
The disciplinary authority relied on muster rolls, acquaintance rolls and evidence of eight verifiers. An Inquiry Officer conducted a departmental inquiry: six witnesses testified (including the Superintending Surveyor R.K. Meena and Assistant Camp Officer S.K. Sen). The Inquiry Officer's report dated 14.07.2003 found Charge I proved, Charge V partially proved, and the remaining charges not proved.
The delinquent submitted written responses (12.03.2001 and 10.11.2003), denied the charges in substance, and explained that he had deposited Rs.79,126/- to "make good" the alleged loss after being advised by seniors (Director NEC and Additional Surveyor General, East Zone). He had also requested copies of the preliminary inquiry report and witness statements relied upon in the regular inquiry; those materials were not supplied.
The disciplinary authority, by order dated 16.05.2005, imposed a penalty of reduction of pay by three stages for three years, with no increments during that period (but without postponing future increments). The delinquent challenged the disciplinary action before the Central Administrative Tribunal (Original Application No.300/2005), which dismissed the application on 25.07.2008. The present writ petition challenges the Tribunal's order and the disciplinary proceedings.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the departmental inquiry and consequent disciplinary action were vitiated by non-supply of the preliminary inquiry report and related records relied upon in the regular inquiry.
- Whether the inquiry findings against the delinquent (in particular Charge I and Charge V) were perverse or unsupported by relevant evidence, including the muster rolls and acquaintance roll.
- Whether the Central Administrative Tribunal erred in dismissing the delinquent's challenge without adequately examining the merits and evidence in the disciplinary proceeding.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's (Delinquent's) Arguments — as presented by Mr. H.K. Das
- The inquiry finding is vitiated because relevant documentary evidence (acquaintance roll, muster rolls maintained by verifiers) and relevant oral testimony (notably of the Superintending Surveyor R.K. Meena) were ignored or not given appropriate weight.
- The adverse finding was based disproportionately on the testimony of a single witness (Assistant Camp Officer S.K. Sen), who denied recruitment of additional porters, despite other testimony supporting engagement of extra porters.
- The delinquent deposited Rs.79,126/- for reasons explained (assurance from senior officers) and that deposit should not be treated as an admission of guilt; on the balance of documentary and oral evidence, the charge of fictitious muster rolls cannot be sustained on preponderance of probabilities.
- The delinquent requested copies of the preliminary inquiry report and statements relied upon in the regular inquiry, but these were not furnished, denying an effective opportunity to meet and challenge evidence.
Respondent's (Government) Arguments — as presented by Mr. S.P. Choudhury, Central Government Counsel
- The denial by Assistant Camp Officer S.K. Sen (SW.5) of having recruited additional local porters supports the inquiry findings; the evidence of SW.4 (Superintending Surveyor) and SW.5 together sustain the conclusion.
- The scope of judicial review in departmental disciplinary matters is limited; interference is not warranted unless there is clear perversity ("unless perversity is writ large"). The court should not exercise discretionary jurisdiction to interfere in this case.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mani Shankar Vs. Union of India ((2008) 3 SCC 484) | Illustrates that although judicial review in departmental action is limited, courts must examine compliance with principles of natural justice, whether relevant evidence was considered, and whether conclusions are justified on preponderance of probability. | The Court invoked this authority to frame the correct standard of review — that the inquiry must respect natural justice and take relevant evidence into account; the Court used this principle to assess whether the departmental inquiry's findings were sustainable. |
| State of U.P. v. Shatrughan Lal and Another ((1998) 6 SCC 651) | Holds that non-supply of requested documents relating to a preliminary enquiry which are relied upon in a regular departmental enquiry results in vitiation of the inquiry. | The Court applied this ratio directly: because the delinquent's request for preliminary inquiry records (which were relied upon in the regular inquiry) was not complied with, the Court found the departmental proceeding vitiated in law on this ground. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court undertook a stepwise analysis grounded in examination of procedural fairness, evidentiary sufficiency and the scope of judicial review:
- Scope of review: The Court acknowledged the limited scope of judicial review in disciplinary matters but noted, by reference to Mani Shankar, that this limitation does not prevent the Court from examining whether natural justice has been complied with, whether relevant evidence was considered, and whether the inference drawn is justified on the preponderance of probabilities.
- Non-supply of preliminary inquiry records: Relying on the ratio in State of U.P. v. Shatrughan Lal, the Court found that both R.K. Meena (SW.4) and S.K. Sen (SW.5) had deposed in the preliminary inquiry and that the regular departmental inquiry relied upon that preliminary inquiry. The delinquent specifically requested copies of the preliminary inquiry report and witness statements, but those were not furnished. The Court held that failure to supply those documents — which were relied upon in the regular enquiry — vitiated the departmental proceeding.
- Denial of effective opportunity to test evidence: The Court reasoned that had the delinquent been given the preliminary inquiry records, he would have had an effective opportunity to cross-examine the two witnesses (SW.4 and SW.5) on matters they had previously deposed to. The non-supply therefore constituted a denial of natural justice with substantive effect.
- Contradictory and unresolved testimony: The Court analysed testimonial conflicts: SW.4 (Superintending Surveyor R.K. Meena) testified that additional porters were engaged on his verbal order after assessment of need; SW.5 (Assistant Camp Officer S.K. Sen) denied engaging additional porters. The Court found that the Inquiry Officer ignored SW.4's vital evidence and resolved the conflict by giving one-sided weight to SW.5, without reconciling the contradiction. This non-reconciliation and selective consideration amounted to a perverse finding.
- Characterization of the refund and the delinquent's probationary status: The Court noted the delinquent was a recent recruit on probation during the relevant period. The delinquent stated he refunded Rs.79,126/- after being assured by seniors that making good the amount would close the matter. The Court emphasised that accepting such a refund as an admission of guilt, without cogent evidence connecting the delinquent to manipulation of muster rolls, was improper. On the available documentary and oral evidence, there was no reasonable link shown between the delinquent and the alleged fabrication.
- Charge V analysis: The material did not establish that sugar was sold in the open market at a higher rate by the delinquent. What was proved, per the Court, was a failure of supervision by the Khalasi; but lack of supervision was not the charge framed in the memorandum. Thus the Court found the partially proved finding to be irrelevant to the charge as framed and therefore misconceived.
- Review of Tribunal's approach: The Court found the Central Administrative Tribunal took a "shortcut" approach by focusing on the refund of Rs.79,126/- and did not examine the evidence on the merits (documentary and oral evidence) or the cogency of the inquiry findings. Accordingly, the Tribunal's order was found unsustainable.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The writ petition is allowed; the disciplinary proceeding and the impugned Tribunal order are quashed.
Specific directions and direct consequences:
- The disciplinary action taken pursuant to the Charge Memo dated 17.01.2001 is declared vitiated in law and is quashed.
- The impugned order of the Central Administrative Tribunal dated 25.07.2008 in Original Application No.300/2005 is declared unsustainable and quashed.
- The petition is allowed; the parties are left to bear their respective costs.
Implications beyond the parties: The opinion does not articulate the creation of a new legal precedent; it applies existing authorities (Mani Shankar and Shatrughan Lal) to the facts to conclude that non-supply of preliminary inquiry records and failure to consider and reconcile relevant evidence vitiated the disciplinary process. The direct effect is the quashing of the disciplinary action and the Tribunal's order; no broader novel legal principle is declared in the text.
(Hrishikesh Roy, J). Heard Mr. H.K. Das, the learned counsel representing the petitioner. The respondents are represented by the learned Central Govt. lawyer Mr. S.P. Choudhury.
2. The matter pertains to a disciplinary proceeding for alleged misconduct of the respondent during his posting as Camp Officer in Arunachal Pradesh from December, 1996 to April, 1997. In the charge memo, drawn up on 17.1.2001 Writ Petition (C) No.3292/2012 2 of 8 (Annexure-1), under Rule 14 of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965 (hereinafter referred to as the CCS Rules), five charges were leveled and for the purpose of present discussion, it will suffice to extract the charges, under Article-I, IV and V, for ready reference:- Statement of Articles of charge framed against Shri U.N. Mishra, Superintending Surveyor, O.C. No.5 Party (NEC), Survey of India, Shillong. ARTICLE-I That the said Shri U.N. Mishra, Superintending Surveyor while posted as Deputy Superintending Surveyor, No.12 Party (NEC) was attached to No.29 Party (NEC) and appointed as Camp Officer of Camp No.1 during field season 199697. While performing the duties of the Camp Officer in Arunachal Pradesh during the period December, 1996 to April, 1997, the said Shri U.N. Mishra with malafide intention prepared fictitious muster rolls of those porters who were not at all engaged and also prepared muster rolls for much longer period of those porters who were engaged for much shorter period and claimed false contingent bills on account of wages of these porters on various occasions during the period from 12-12-1996 to 09-04-1997. Thus the said Shri U.N. Mishra failed to maintain absolute integrity and acted in a manner unbecoming of a Govt. servant and thereby violating Rule 3(1)(i) & (iii) of CCR (Conduct) Rules, 1964. ARTICLE-II ARTICLE-III ARTICLE-IV That the said Shri U.N. Mishra, Superintending Surveyor, O.C. No.5 Party (NEC), Survey of India, Shillong, while functioning as Camp Officer in the field Camp of No.29 Party (NEC) claimed in contingent bill bus fare paid to 37 porters from Tezu to Shillong on the close of the field, but the payment was made to 6 porters and no fare was paid at all to remaining 31 porters. Thus Shri U.N. Mishra failed to maintain absolute integrity and acted in a manner unbecoming of a Govt. servant and thereby violating rule 3(1)(i) & (iii) of ccr (conduct) rules, 1964. article-v That the said Shri U.N. Mishra, Superintending Surveyor, O.C. No.5 Party (NEC), Survey of India, Shillong, while function as Camp Officer in the field Camp of No.29 Party (NEC) sold 246 Kgs of sugar in the open market at market rate for personal gain, whereas the sugar was purchased from Arunachal Pradesh Govt. Ration shop for distribution amongst camp personnel. Thus he failed to maintain absolute integrity and acted in a manner unbecoming of a Govt. servant and thereby violating rule 3(1)(i) & (iii) of ccr (conduct) rules, 1964. writ petition (c) no.3292/2012 3 of 8
3. The disciplinary authority proposed to prove the charge by placing reliance on the muster rolls for the concerned period submitted by the Camp Officer and the eight verifiers. The Superintending Surveyor who is higher in hierarchy above the delinquent and the Surveyor who is below him, were named amongst the list of witnesses to prove the charges.
4. In his written response given on 12.3.2001 (Annexure-2), the delinquent spoke about his inexperience as a new recruit and stated that he admitted to the Charge-I only because, he was assured by the Director, NEC that the entire matter will be closed, if the amount involved in the alleged irregular transaction was made good. Similar advise was tendered by the Additional Surveyor General, East Zone and that is how the delinquent arranged for making good the alleged loss (Rs.79,126/-) to the organization. But in substance, all the charges were denied by the delinquent in his written response.
5. Dissatisfied with the reply, an Inquiry Officer was appointed by the disciplinary authority and before him, the delinquent specifically requested for a copy of the preliminary inquiry report and the statement of witness recorded during the preliminary inquiry, if they are to be considered in the regular departmental inquiry.
6. In order to prove the charge, six witnesses were presented together with some documentary evidence like the muster rolls and the acquaintance roll, etc.
7. The witness Ram Das Sao (SW.1), who was the Khalasi, P.K. Roy, Store keeper (SW.2) D.N. Dev, Plane Tabler Grade-II (SW.3) in their respective testimony, spoke about engagement of local porters since additional manpower was needed for the survey work, in the difficult terrain of Arunachal Pradesh. The Superintending Surveyor R.K. Meena (SW.4) in his deposition confirmed about the verification of the muster rolls and also wage payment to the porters, on the basis of such verification. As regards engagement of additional porters, the SW.4 as the boss of the delinquent stated that extra porters were allowed to be engaged, after inspection of the survey area on the assessment that the available porters will be inadequate to carry out the survey job. It was specifically stated by the Superintending Surveyor that the extra porters were engaged on his verbal order. The SW.4 also stated that he failed to obtain sanction of the Director for engagement of the additional porters and this was his own lapse as the Superintending Surveyor. He further testified that recruitment might have Writ Petition (C) No.3292/2012 4 of 8 been done by the Assistant Camp Officer S.K. Sen and that the instructions for engagement of the additional porters were issued to both the Camp Officer and the Assistant Camp Officer. However in his deposition, S.K. Sen, the Assistant Camp Officer as the SW.5, while admitting the recruitment of the regular porters at Shillong, denied to have engaged the additional porters in the field. However this witness by virtue of his 19 years experience in survey work, felt that the difficult terrain in which the work was to be undertaken would require the assistance of additional porters. In the cross-examination, the SW.5 admitted that during his field visit he found the records of porters were correctly maintained at the work site. The witness J. Khanmujai, as a Plane Tabler Grade- II, gave evidence on how the porters were deployed in different kinds of duties and stated that wages were disbursed to the porters by the Assistant Camp Officer S.K. Sen, during his visit to the camp site.
8. During examination of the delinquent in the inquiry proceeding, he stated that the recruitment of the local porters were done mainly by the Assistant Camp Officer (S.K. Sen), as he was an experienced hand in the area. He further stated that the additional porters were engaged on the verbal approval of the Superintending Surveyor. It was also testified that the presence of the porters were physically verified by the Assistant Camp Officer during his inspection at site and the cross verification of the muster rolls.
9. After purported consideration of the evidence on record, the Charge No.I, relating to preparation of fictitious muster rolls for the porters, was found to have been proved and the Charge No.V relating to sale of sugar in the open market were found to be partially proved. The other three charges were found to be not proved in the report given on 14.7.2003 (page-135), by the Inquiry Officer.
10. When the inquiry report was furnished to the delinquent, in his written response given on 10.11.2003 (Annexure-14) he contended that the concerned muster roll for the porters were prepared by the Plane Tablers, who were working in the Camp from 16.1.199728.2.1997 and although these Plane Tablers were co-accused under the same charges, they were exonerated. Thus the genuineness of the muster rolls is projected to be beyond question. It was further stated that the wages for the porters were paid on the basis of the acquaintance roll and although the concerned records of payment were available, the inquiry officer disregarded the vital evidence, to give a negative finding Writ Petition (C) No.3292/2012 5 of 8 against the delinquent. Thus the bonafide of the finding in the inquiry is questioned on the ground that relevant evidence were ignored and finding was given by giving disproportionate weightage to the negative evidence of the Assistant Camp Officer S.K. Sen (SW.5), who denied to have made recruitment of the additional porters.
11. The disciplinary authority then considered the enquiry findings and under the impugned order of 16.05.2005 (Annexure-15) imposed the penalty of reduction of pay by 3 stages in the time scale of pay for a period of three years with further direction that during the period of such reduction, the charged officer will not earn increments and the penalty will not have the effect of postponing future increments of pay.
12. Aggrieved by the disciplinary action taken against him, the delinquent approached the Central Administrative Tribunal, Guwahati with prayer for quashing the disciplinary action. However, the learned Tribunal focused their scrutiny to the deposit of Rs.79,126/- made by the delinquent towards drawal of excess wages for hiring excess porters and on this basis the charges were found to have been correctly proved against the delinquent. Thus the Original Application No. 300/2005 was found to be without merit and the same was dismissed by the impugned Order dated 25.07.2008 (page 207). 13.1 Assailing the legality of the disciplinary proceeding and the verdict of the Tribunal, the learned counsel Mr. HK Das submits that the enquiry finding stands vitiated as relevant evidence was ignored and conclusions were arbitrarily drawn only on the basis of the evidence of the single witness, SK Sen, who denied to have made the recruitment of additional porters. But in the process, the relevant testimony of the Superintending Surveyor R.K. Meena (SW.4) on recruitment being made by the Assistant Camp Officer S.K. Sen with verbal approval of the boss (Mr. Meena) was ignored and thus he contends that a perverse finding was recorded against the delinquent. 13.2 Referring to documents such as acquaintance roll, muster rolls maintained by the verifiers, the petitioners counsel contends that these were vital and relevant documents but they were not taken into account by the enquiry officer, to render a perverse finding against the delinquent. 13.3 The petitioners counsel contends that the charge of maintenance of fictitious muster roll records in respect of the engaged porters cannot be held to Writ Petition (C) No.3292/2012 6 of 8 be established on the criteria of preponderance of probability if the documentary and verbal evidence are taken into account and accordingly he argues that the delinquent is being victimized on the basis of unsubstantiated adverse finding, in the disciplinary enquiry. 14.1 On the other hand, Mr. SP Choudhury, the learned CGC submits that when the Assistant Camp Officer S.K. Sen (SW.5) has denied to have made the recruitment of any local porters, the finding in the enquiry stands supported by the evidence of the SW.4 and accordingly it is argued that the finding cannot be treated as unsubstantiated conclusion. 14.2 Referring to the limited scope of judicial review in disciplinary actions, Mr. Choudhury submits that unless perversity is writ large, interference is not called for and accordingly he argues that this is not a case where the Court should exercise its discretionary jurisdiction.
15. The scope of judicial review on departmental action may no doubt be limited but at the same time, it would be necessary to examine whether the principles of natural justice has been complied with by the disciplinary authority. The Court is also entitled to consider whether relevant evidence had been taken into account and that inference is drawn based upon such relevant evidence and whether the pre ponderance would justify the conclusion reached against a delinquent. [See: Mani Shankar Vs. Union of India reported in (2008)3 SCC 484]
16. In State of U.P. Vrs- Shatrughan Lal and Another, reported in (1998) 6 SCC 651, the non-supply of the requested documents relating to the preliminary enquiry which were relied upon in the regular enquiry, was found to result in vitiation of the enquiry proceeding. In the same line in the present case, the Court is required to consider whether the non-supply of the records pertaining to the preliminary enquiry would vitiate the departmental proceeding. Both the Superintending Surveyor R.K. Meena (SW.4) and the Assistant Camp Officer S.K. Sen had deposed in the preliminary enquiry that the proceeding of this enquiry was very much relied upon in the regular departmental enquiry. A specific request was made by the delinquent for a copy of the preliminary enquiry report but the same was not furnished to him. Therefore, applying the ratio laid down in Shatrughan Lal (supra), the same itself is a ground for declaring the departmental proceeding to be vitiated in law. Writ Petition (C) No.3292/2012 7 of 8
17. Furthermore had the records of the preliminary enquiry containing the deposition of the Superintending Surveyor R.K. Meena and the Assistant Camp Officer S.K. Sen which was relied upon during the regular enquiry been available with the delinquent, he would have had the opportunity to effectively cross- examine the same two witnesses who again participated in the regular enquiry. But since the request for the records of the preliminary enquiry was not acceded to, the denial of natural justice complained of by the delinquent, is found to have substance.
18. The vital evidence of the Superintending Surveyor R.K. Meena, who verbally approved the engagement the additional porters after assessing the requirement of additional man power on account of the difficult terrain was wholly ignored to render the adverse finding against the delinquent only on the basis of the solitary testimony of the Assistant Camp Officer S.K. Sen (SW.5), who denied to have recruited local porters. But the testimony of this witness materially contradicts the testimony of the Superintending Surveyor R.K. Meena (SW.4). Yet the contradiction in the evidence was never resolved and an adverse finding was recorded by giving one sided weightage to the testimony of SW.5. This according to us has resulted to a perverse finding for non-consideration of the relevant evidence and non-reconciliation of the contradictory evidence adduced in the departmental enquiry.
19. It cannot also be overlooked that the delinquent was a recent recruit and was on probation during the concerned period of 5 (five) months, when he was deployed for the survey work in Lohit district of Arunachal Pradesh. He explained the circumstance under which he arranged for refund of Rs. 79,126/-alleged to have been misappropriated through maintenance of incorrect muster roll records. But the possibility of an inexperienced employee being forced to make good the loss at the nascent stage of his career on being prompted by the seniors in the organization, was totally ignored. Instead this act of refund of the amount was found to be an act of admission of guilt by the delinquent. In a disciplinary proceeding, it is the obligation of the authorities to prove the guilt by presenting cogent evidence on the principle of preponderance of probability and in the absence of any evidence to show that the delinquent had manipulated the muster rolls, an adverse finding cannot be given against the Charge No.I on the basis of inference drawn on account of the deposit of the money by the Writ Petition (C) No.3292/2012 8 of 8 delinquent. If the acquaintance roll and the muster roll (Exihibit-52) maintained by the 8 (eight) verifiers reflect that extra labours were engaged as was corroborated by the oral evidence of the witnesses, it is not logical to conclude that the delinquent had produced fictitious records to show payment of wages to non-existence porters. In fact no reasonable evidence is seen here to connect the delinquent with the allegation under Charge No. I.
20. In so far as the Charge No.V which is partially proved, the material clearly shows that there is no evidence to show that sugar was sold in the open market at a higher rate by the delinquent. But what was held to be proved was that the delinquent had failed to exercise sufficient control over the sale, by the Khalasi. But want of supervision was not the charge leveled against the delinquent in the Memo dated 17.01.2001 and therefore, the finding that the Charge No.V is proved is an irrelevant conclusion which has no relevance to the charge and is thus misconceived.
21. As regard the Order of the Tribunal, challenged in this proceeding, what is noticed is that the Tribunal failed to examine the case on merit and took a shortcut. The learned Tribunal was prompted to reach a quick conclusion on account of the deposit of the excess wages/reimbursement by the petitioner for hiring excess porters. There was no examination and appreciation of the evidences led against the charges or whether finding in the disciplinary enquiry was based on cogent and relevant evidence. Therefore in our assessment, the learned Tribunal as noted earlier has failed to examine the merit of the challenge in accordance with the legal duty and therefore we declare that the impugned order dated 25.07.2008 in the Original Application No. 300/2005, is unsustainable and the same is quashed.
22. In view of the above discussion and having noted the infirmities in the disciplinary proceeding, we declare the same to have been vitiated in law and accordingly we quash the disciplinary action taken against the delinquent in pursuant to the Charge Memo dated 17.01.2001 (Annexure-I). Thus, the petition stands allowed with this declaration by leaving the parties to bear their respective costs. JUDGE JUDGE Barman/Nilakhi
Alert