Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Chanappa Nagappa Muchalagoda v. Shekar Shantharam Mahapa And Another

Karnataka High Court
Oct 6, 2016
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion: W.C.No.KPK/SR/105/2007

Factual and Procedural Background

The claimant (appellant) filed a claim under the Workmen's Compensation Act for injuries sustained in a road traffic accident on 13-05-2006 while working as a driver of an inter-State goods vehicle (Truck No. MH-08/H-0390) belonging to the first respondent (owner). Immediately after the accident the claimant received inpatient treatment at Sakrappa Primary Health Center, then Govt. Hospital at Rathnagiri (13-05-2006 to 01-06-2006), and later at KIMS Hospital, Hubli (17-06-2006 to 26-08-2006). The claimant alleged permanent disability and sought compensation of Rs.5,00,000/-.

The Labour Officer and Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, Sub-Division-II, Belagavi (WCC) in its judgment dated 16-10-2007 found that the accident occurred in the course of employment and awarded compensation taking monthly income as Rs.3,000/- and functional disability of 50% resulting in a compensation award of Rs.1,81,494/- with interest at 12% p.a. The claimant appealed seeking enhancement of the quantum of compensation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the claimant is entitled to enhancement of compensation as claimed (i.e., whether the quantum awarded by the WCC should be increased)?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The WCC erred in fixing the monthly income at Rs.3,000/-; the owner admitted paying Rs.4,000/- per month plus batta of Rs.30/- per day (and the claimant contended he received Rs.6,000/- and batta of Rs.100/- in his pleadings).
  • The claimant incurred heavy medical expenses for treatment and no compensation was awarded by the WCC for those expenses.
  • Due to the injuries, the claimant is permanently incapacitated from performing driving work; there is assertedly 100% disability, and the WCC should have applied 100% functional disability.
  • The appellant relied on the Central Government notification dated 31-05-2010 amending Section 4(1B) of the Employees Compensation Act (raising monthly wages from Rs.4,000/- to Rs.8,000/-) and argued that the amendment is retrospective and applicable to pending cases, relying also on the 2015 (6) Kar.L.J. 53 decision (SMT. RADHAMMA).

Respondents' Arguments

  • The owner, while admitting employment, in his written statement stated he paid salary of Rs.4,000/- p.m. and batta of Rs.30/- per day; he maintained the vehicle was insured and the insurer should compensate the claimant.
  • The Insurance Company disputed the claimant's averments, denied the master-servant relationship and alleged the accident was not notified to the insurer; it further contended the driver did not possess a valid driving licence as on the date of the accident and therefore the insurer is not liable.
  • On appeal, the Insurance Company's counsel supported the WCC's judgment and contended that the 2010 amendment to Section 4(1B) is prospective and not applicable to an accident occurring on 13-05-2006; he relied on the Full Bench decision reported in 2000 ACJ 5 (KERALA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD v/s VALSALA K) to argue amendments are prospective and that the two-judge bench decision in NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD. v. V.K. NEELAKANDAN (1999(8) SCC 256) is not good law, therefore the appellant's reliance on the 2015 KLJ decision is misplaced.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
KERALA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD v/s VALSALA. K (2000 ACJ 5) Held that amendments are prospective in nature and that the two-judge bench decision in NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD. v. V.K. NEELAKANDAN is not a good law. The court relied on this Full Bench authority to reject the appellant's contention that the 31-05-2010 amendment to Section 4(1B) operates retrospectively; it treated the Full Bench pronouncement as authoritative to deny retrospective operation to the amendment.
NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD. v. V.K. NEELAKANDAN (1999(8) SCC 256) Two-Judge Bench view that benefits available on the date of adjudication should be extended to workmen (i.e., the rate applicable at adjudication may be applied). The court noted that the Full Bench (KERALA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD v. VALSALA K) has held this two-Judge Bench decision is not a correct law. Consequently, the court declined to apply the principle as relied upon by the appellant.
Pratap Narain Singh Deo v. Shrinivas Sabata (1976 ACJ 141 (SC)) Employer becomes liable once injury is caused; the relevant date for determining rate of compensation is the date of the accident, not the date of adjudication. The court treated the larger Bench holding in this case as controlling law supporting the proposition that amendments do not affect rights determined as on date of accident; this supported refusal to apply the 2010 amendment retrospectively.
SMT. RADHAMMA AND OTHERS v/s KRUPAKARI AND ANOTHER (2015 (6) Kar.L.J 53) Held (in that decision) that benefit of Central Government Notification dated 31-05-2010 specifying monthly wages of Rs.8,000/- should be extended where applicable at adjudication. The court observed that that judgment relied upon NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD. v. V.K. NEELAKANDAN; because NEELAKANDAN was declared not a good law by the Full Bench, the court declined to follow the Kar.L.J. decision for retrospective application of the 2010 notification.
ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY v/s SIBY GEORGE AND OTHERS (2012 ACJ 2126) Principle that claimant is entitled to interest at the rate of 12% p.a. from one month after the accident. The court applied this precedent to award interest at 12% p.a. from one month after the date of the accident on the enhanced compensation awarded to the claimant.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's legal analysis proceeded in these principal steps, strictly as reflected in the opinion:

  1. Admissibility and primary facts: The court accepted that the accident occurred on 13-05-2006 during the course of employment and that the claimant sustained injuries. The owner in his written statement admitted employment and a stated salary of Rs.4,000/- p.m. plus batta of Rs.30/- per day. The Insurance Company disputed these contents but did not examine any witness to rebut the owner's admission.
  2. Appropriate measure of monthly income: Because the claimant was a driver of an inter-State transport vehicle (a somewhat skilled occupation requiring technique) and given the owner's unchallenged admission in the written statement, the court concluded that the WCC's finding of Rs.3,000/- p.m. was incorrect and that the claimant's income should be fixed at Rs.4,000/- p.m.
  3. Functional disability assessment: The court reviewed medical evidence (ligament tears, surgery, ongoing incapacity to stand for long periods or fold the leg) and noted that while the treating doctor assessed loss of earning capacity at 37% and the WCC had applied 50% functional disability, the WCC's assessment was on the lower side. The court held that although the claimant cannot perform driving work, he can perform other types of work; therefore a functional disability of 60% (higher than the WCC's 50%) was appropriate.
  4. Computation of enhanced compensation: Using the adjusted monthly income of Rs.4,000/-, applying 60% functional disability and the relevant multiplier/factor of 201.66 (as used by the court), the court calculated the appropriate compensation as Rs.2,90,390/-, replacing the WCC award of Rs.1,81,494/-.
  5. Interest: The court applied the principle in ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY v. SIBY GEORGE that interest at 12% p.a. should be awarded from one month after the date of the accident, and applied that rule to the enhanced award.
  6. On applicability of the 2010 amendment to Section 4(1B) of the Employees Compensation Act: The court held that amendments are prospective unless expressly made retrospective. It relied on the Full Bench authority in KERALA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD v. VALSALA K and the larger Bench principle in Pratap Narain Singh Deo that the relevant date for determining rate of compensation is the date of the accident. Because the decision in NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD. v. V.K. NEELAKANDAN (which would have supported retrospective benefit at adjudication) was declared not a correct law by the Full Bench, the court rejected the appellant's contention that the 31-05-2010 notification (raising monthly wages) should be applied retrospectively to the 2006 accident.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The appeal is allowed in part.

Direct holdings and orders:

  • The court revised the claimant's monthly income to Rs.4,000/- and assessed functional disability at 60%.
  • The claimant is awarded enhanced compensation of Rs.2,90,390/- (in place of Rs.1,81,494/- awarded by the WCC).
  • Interest is awarded at the rate of 12% p.a. from one month after the date of the accident.
  • The Insurance Company is directed to deposit the balance amount within four weeks.
  • The court refused to apply the Central Government Notification dated 31-05-2010 (amending Section 4(1B)) retrospectively and held that the claimant is not entitled to enhanced wages under that amendment for the 2006 accident.

Implications: The decision affects only the parties by increasing the quantum of compensation and directing deposit by the insurer. The court applied established precedent concerning the relevant date for compensation and the non-retrospective operation of statutory amendments; it did not purport to lay down any new, novel legal precedent beyond applying existing authorities to the facts.

Show all summary ...

W.C.NO.KPK/SR/105/2007 ON THE FILE OF THE LABOUR OFFICER AND WORKMENS COMPENSATION COMMISSIONER, SUB-DIVISION NO.2, BELGAUM, PRAYING TO ENHANCE THE COMPENSATION. THIS APPEAL COMING ON FOR HEARING THIS DAY, THE COURT DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: JUDGMENT Appellant is the claimant being not satisfied with the quantum of compensation awarded in the judgment and order dated 16-10-2007 passed by the Labour Officer and Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, Sub-Division-II, Belagavi in WCA/SR- 105/2007, filed this appeal seeking enhancement of compensation.

2. The main grievance of the claimant is that the compensation awarded taking into consideration income as Rs.3,000/- p.m., is contrary to law. He filed a claim petition claiming that he was working as a driver in the Truck bearing registration No.MH-08/H-0390 belonging : 3 : to the first respondent herein. On 13-5-2006, as per the instructions of owner of the vehicle after loading the sand at Islamapura, proceeding towards Rathnagiri, on Ambaghat due to the axle cut the vehicle lost control and turned turtle and met with an accident. Immediately after the accident, the driver was shifted to Sakrappa Primary Health Center, thereafter he had taken treatment in Govt. Hospital at Rathnagiri as inpatient from 13-05-2006 to 1-06-2006. Thereafter he had taken treatment as inpatient from 17-06-2006 to 26-08-2006 at KIMS hospital at Hubli. He claims that he has spent huge amount. In view of the injuries sustained and permanent disability he cannot do the work of a driver. The accident occurred during the course and out of employment. The said vehicle is insured with the second respondent. Hence both the owner and the insurer had to compensate the claimant and sought for compensation of Rs.5,00,000/-. : 4 :

3. In response to the notice issued by the WCC, owner of the vehicle entered appearance and admitted that the claimant was working as driver and he was paying salary of Rs.4,000/- p.m. and batta of Rs.30/- per day. The said vehicle met with an accident on 13-5-2006. Since the vehicle is covered by insurance policy the second respondent has to compensate the claimant and hence sought for dismissal of the claim petition as against him.

4. The Insurance Company filed written statement denying the entire averments made in the claim petition and disputed the relationship of master and servant between the claimant and owner of the vehicle. The occurrence of accident is not made known to the Insurance Company. Driver of the offending vehicle did not possess the valid and effective driving license as on the date of accident. Hence the Insurance Company is not liable to compensate the claimant. : 5 :

5. On the basis of pleadings of the parties, the WCC has framed necessary issues.

6. The claimant, in order to prove his case got examined himself as P.W.1 and got marked the documents as Ex.P1 to Ex.P14. The doctor who has issued the disability certificate was examined as P.W.2. On behalf of respondents, none of the witnesses were examined, however insurance policy was marked as Ex.R1.

7. The WCC, after appreciating the oral and documentary evidence let in by the parties, taking into consideration IMV report, spot panchanama, copy of the complaint and charge sheet held that the claimant has sustained injuries in the road traffic accident occurred on 13-5-2006 during the course and out of employment. Hence, the claimant is entitled for compensation. With regard to quantum of compensation is concerned, : 6 : though the claimant claims that owner of the vehicle was paying him salary of Rs.6,000/- p.m. and batta of Rs.100/- per day, no document has been produced to establish the same. The Insurance Company also disputed the salary paid by the owner of the vehicle. In view of that, the Tribunal had taken the income as Rs.3,000/- p.m. In the accident, the claimant has sustained fracture of ligament and undergone surgery. Even after surgery, there is anterior cruciate ligament tare and also medial lateral ligament tare. He cannot stand for long time and fold his leg. The doctor assessed the disability to an extent of 37%. At the time of accident, the claimant was aged about 33 years. The WCC taking the income of Rs.3,000/- p.m. and taking 60% thereof, applying the relevant factor of 201.66 and taking into consideration functional disability to an extent of 50% awarded a sum of Rs.1,81,494/- with interest at the rate of 12% p.a. from one month after date of passing of the judgment and order. The : 7 : claimant, being not satisfied with the quantum of compensation filed this appeal.

8. Sri.Vittal S Theli, learned counsel appearing for the appellant contended that the judgment and order passed by the WCC taking the income as Rs.3,000/- p.m. is contrary to law, since the vehicle is inter-State transport vehicle and that the owner of the vehicle admitted that he was paying salary of Rs.4,000/- p.m. and batta of Rs.30/- per day. The claimant has spent huge money for the medical treatment, no compensation has been awarded by the WCC. In view of the injuries sustained, the claimant has become permanently disabled to do the driving work. There is 100% disability, the WCC ought to have taken 100% functional disability while awarding the compensation.

9. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant further contended that in view of the amendment of : 8 : Section 4(1B) of Employees Compensation Act, as per the Central Government notification dated 31-05-2010, which has come into force on the same date, the monthly wages was enhanced from Rs.4,000/- to Rs.8,000/- p.m. This amendment is retrospective in operation, which is applicable for all pending cases. He also brought to my notice the judgment reported in 2015 (6) Kar.L.J 53 (SMT.RADHAMMA AND OTHERS v/s KRUPAKARI AND ANOTHER) and contended that he is entitled for enhanced compensation and also medical expenditure he has incurred for his treatment.

10. On the other hand, Sri.N.R.Kuppellur, advocate appearing on behalf of Sri.B.C.Seetharama Rao, for Insurance Company argued in support of the judgment and order passed by the WCC and contended that no material has been placed to show that the owner of the vehicle was paying the claimant salary of Rs.6,000/- p.m., as claimed by him. Further the amendment of : 9 : Section 4(1B) is not applicable to the present case. The amendment is prospective in operation, which will be coming into force only w.e.f. 31-05-2010. In the instant case, the accident occurred on 13-5-2006. Hence, the amended provision is not applicable to the facts of the present case. The Full Bench of Hon'ble Supreme Court in a judgment reported in 2000 ACJ 5 (KERALA STATE ELETRICITY BOARD v/s VALSALA. K) clearly held that all amendments are prospective in nature and also held that the two-Judges Bench of Hon'ble Supreme Court in NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO.LTD. v/s V.K. NEELAKANDAN reported in 1999(8) SCC 256 is not a good law. Hence the judgment relied upon by the appellant is not applicable to the facts of the present case since the said judgment was passed based on NEELAKANDANs case. Hence sought for dismissal of the appeal. : 10 :

11. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties, the only issue that arise for consideration in this appeal is Whether the claimant is entitled for enhancement of compensation as claimed by him?

12. The occurrence of the accident, injuries sustained by the claimant during the course of employment are not in dispute. The owner of the vehicle in his written statement clearly admitted that the claimant was working as a driver in his vehicle and he was paying him salary of Rs.4,000/- p.m. and batta of Rs.30/- per day. The Insurance Company though disputed the same, has not stepped into the witness box to dispel the contention of the owner of vehicle. The claimant was driver of an inter-State transport vehicle. The driver working in the inter-State transport vehicle cannot be compared with the daily wage employees. Driving of the : 11 : goods vehicle is somewhat skilled and some technique is necessary. At the age of 33 years, in view of injury to both the legs he cannot drive the vehicle. Hence, I am of the opinion that income of the claimant has to be taken at Rs.4,000/- instead of 3,000/- p.m.

13. Looking to the injuries sustained by the claimant and treatment he has taken in Government Hospital at Rathnagiri as inpatient for a period of 18 days and in KIMS Hospital at Hubli for a period of 65 days and the ligament tare of interior cruciate and ligament tare of medial lateral ligament, the claimant cannot do the driving work. However, this injury will not come in the way of appellant in doing the other works. Though the doctor assessed the loss of earning capacity to an extent of 37%, the Tribunal assessed the functional disability at 50% while awarding compensation. I feel assessment of the functional disability is lower side. In view of the ligament tare, he cannot do the driving work and he : 12 : cannot stand for a long time and long walk, however he can do other works. Hence it is appropriate to take the functional disability of 60% and award the compensation. Taking into consideration income of the claimant at Rs.4,000/- p.m. and taking 60% thereof, applying the relevant factor 201.66 and considering the functional disability to an extent of 60%, the claimant is entitled for compensation of Rs.2,90,390/- as against Rs.1,81,494/- awarded by the WCC. Further, as per the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY v/s SIBY GEORGE AND OTHERS, reported in 2012 ACJ 2126 the claimant is entitled for interest at the rate of 12% p,.a. from one month after the accident.

14. The contention of Mr.Vittal S Teli that the claimant is entitled for the benefit of notification dated 31-05-2010 amending Section 4(1B) of Employees Compensation Act cannot be acceptable. All : 13 : amendments to the Act are prospective in operation unless it is specifically made retrospective. The identical issue came up before the Full Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in a judgment reported in 2000 ACJ 5 (supra). The Hon'ble Supreme Court after examining the amendment of Section 4 and 4A of the Workmens Compensation Act laid down a law. Paragraphs 2 to 4 of the judgment read as under:

2. Various High Courts in the country, while dealing with the claim for compensation under the Workmens Compensation Act have uniformly taken the view that the relevant date for determining the rights and liabilities of the parties is the date of accident.

3. A four-judge Bench of this court in Pratap Narain Singh Deo V. Shrinivas Sabata, 1976 ACJ 141 (SC), speaking through Shinghal, J, has held that an employer becomes liable to pay compensation as soon as the personal injury is caused to the workman by the accident which arose out of and in the course : 14 : of employment. Thus, the relevant date for determination of the rate of compensation is the date of the accident and not the date of adjudication of the claim.

4. A two-Judge Bench of this court in NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD. v.

V.K.NEELAKANDAN, Civil Appeal Nos.16904- 16906 of 1996, decided on 6-11-1996, however, took the view that Workmens Compensation Act, 1923 being a special legislation for the benefit of the workmen, the benefit as available on the date of adjudication should be extended to the workmen and not the compensation which was payable on the date of the accident. The two-Judge Bench in NEELAKANDANs case (supra), however, did not take notice of the judgment of the larger Bench in Pratap Narain Singh Deos case, 1976 ACJ 141 (SC), as it presumably was not brought to the notice of their Lordships. Be that as it may, in view of the categorical law laid down by the larger Bench in Pratap Narain Singh Deos case, the : 15 : view expressed by the two-Judge Bench in Neelakandans case is not correct."

15. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in a judgment referred to above held that the law declared by two-judges bench in NEW ASSURANCE CO. LTD. v/s V.K.NEELAKANDAN is not a correct law. However, this Court relying upon the judgment of the NEELAKANDANs case, in the judgment reported in 2015(6) KLJ 53 (supra) held in paragraph 7 as under:

7. The Central Government vide Notification S.O.1258(E), dated 31-5-2010 with effect from 31-5-2010 has specified monthly wages, as Rs.8,000/- for the purposes of sub-section (1) of section 4. In the light of amendment having coming to effect with effect from 18-01-2010 and present appeal being a continuation of original proceedings, the benefit that accrue to workman cannot be denied. The Honble Apex Court in the case of NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED v. B.K.NEELAKANDAN AND OTHERS has held : 16 : such benefit which accrues to an workman when the case is finally adjudicated, will have to be extended. It has been held as under:

3. It is not in dispute We are finally determining the rights of the workmen today. The Act is a special legislation for the benefit of the labour. Keeping in view the scheme of the Act, we are of the view that the only interpretation which can be given to the amendment is that if any benefit is conferred on the workmen and the said benefit is available on the date when the case is finally adjudicated, the said benefit should be extended to the workmen.

16. Hence, the judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for the appellant cannot be looked into since the said judgment was passed relying upon the judgment made in NEELAKANDANs case which was declared to be not a good law. Hence, the claimant is not entitled for the benefit of amended Section 4(1B) of the Employees Compensation Act. Accordingly, I pass the following: : 17 : ORDER The appeal is allowed in part. The judgment and order dated 16-10-2007 passed by the Labour Officer and Commissioner for Workmens Compensation, Belagavi sub-Division-2, Belagavi. The claimant is entitled to compensation of Rs.2,90,390/- with interest at 12% p.a. from one month after the date of accident. The Insurance Company is directed to deposit the balance amount within a period of four weeks. Sd/- JUDGE mpk/-*