- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
KERALA STATE WAKF BOARD v. RAJESH
High Court of Kerala — CRP Nos. 411 & 481 of 2008 (Order dated 17 March 2016)
Factual and Procedural Background
The subject matter concerns a Will executed by Abdul Sathar Haji Moosa in 1099 ME (1924 AD) which created an institution called "Abdul Sathar Haji Moosa Sait Dharmasthapanam". The institution was registered with the Wakf Board and the B-schedule properties of the Will include a parcel referred to as "Sathar Island".
The institution applied to the Wakf Board for sanction to sell part of the B-schedule property (Sathar Island); sanction was granted and various negotiated sales and an auction attempt failed. Plaintiffs then filed a suit before the Wakf Tribunal claiming that the institution had agreed to sell Sathar Island to them (or their nominees) and that the institution breached the contract, seeking return of the advance. During pendency of that suit, plaintiffs sought and obtained leave to amend the plaint to seek specific performance.
A compromise petition was later filed and recorded by the Wakf Tribunal between the plaintiffs and the institution after deleting the Wakf Board from the party array, resulting in a consent decree between the plaintiffs and the defendants except the Wakf Board. Revisions were filed in this Court: one by the Wakf Board (CRP No. 411/2008) challenging the recording of the compromise and deletion of the Wakf Board without sanction under the Wakf Act; and another (CRP No. 481/2008) by Smt. Shamshad Hussain Sait (a descendant of the testator) challenging the decree and asserting that the Will created a trust benefitting descendants rather than a wakf that would bar family benefits.
The court records also disclose prior proceedings: a Division Bench decision in C.R.P. No. 779 of 2008 interpreted the testament and concluded it created a mixed wakf; that decision is the subject of appeal to the Hon'ble Supreme Court (Civil Appeal Nos.1576 & 1577 of 1970 / (1974) 3 SCC 257 and a subsequent Special Leave Petition SLP No.19222 of 2010 is noted in the record).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a compromise resulting in alienation of property shown as wakf property can be recorded by the Wakf Tribunal without the sanction of the Wakf Board in terms of Section 93 of the Wakf Act, 1995.
- Whether the testament/will of Abdul Sathar Haji Moosa creates a wakf (including a "mixed wakf") or a private trust benefitting descendants, and consequently whether the property (including Sathar Island) is wakf property.
- Whether the Wakf Board was a necessary party to the suit and whether its deletion from the array of parties and exclusion from the compromise process was lawful.
- Procedural consequence: whether the impugned compromise decree should be set aside and the matter remanded for further proceedings permitting parties (including the Wakf Board and claimants) to be heard and to adduce evidence.
Arguments of the Parties
Wakf Board (Petitioner in CRP No. 411/2008)
- Contended that the compromise could not have been recorded without the Wakf Board's sanction under Section 93 of the Wakf Act.
- Asserted that due procedure was not followed because the Wakf Board was not made a party to, and did not have notice of, the compromise petition.
- Maintained that the institution's property is wakf property and therefore cannot be transferred contrary to statutory safeguards.
Smt. Shamshad Hussain Sait (Revision petitioner in CRP No. 481/2008)
- Argued that the Will of 1099 ME does not create a wakf but a trust principally for the benefit of the testator's descendants; contends beneficiaries (including herself and her family) are specified under the Will and can claim shares of income.
- Challenged the impugned decree and the contract for sale relying on testamentary clauses that restrict transfer of different items in the Will.
- Insofar as necessary, supported some of the Wakf Board's contentions regarding sanction and procedure, while maintaining her primary plea that no wakf was created.
Plaintiffs / Institution (as reflected in the record)
- Plaintiffs initially sued for return of advance alleging failure of the institution to fulfil obligations under an alleged agreement to sell.
- They later amended the plaint to seek specific performance of the alleged contract for sale and entered into a recorded compromise with the institution following deletion of the Wakf Board from the suit, culminating in a consent decree (challenged in revision).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Abdul Sathar Haji Moosa Sait Dharmastapanam v. Commissioner of Agricultural Income Tax, Kerala [(1974) 3 SCC 257] (Civil Appeal Nos.1576 & 1577 of 1970) | The Supreme Court's interpretation of the testament: that three-fourths of the income of the B-schedule properties was primarily earmarked for the benefit of mere relations of the testator, and that that part of the bequest could not be considered a public charitable trust. | The High Court treated this Supreme Court interpretation as binding guidance to be followed and relied upon it in assessing the character of the testament and the consequences for eligibility of beneficiaries; the court stated it must follow that interpretation since it concerns the very same testament now before it. |
| C.R.P. No. 779 of 2008 (Division Bench of the High Court — interpretation of the testament) | Division Bench interpretation that the Will created a "mixed Wakf" carrying elements of wakf, including religious and charitable purposes, and that properties are wakf properties. | The court observed judicial propriety requires following the Division Bench's interpretation of the same testament unless there are reasons to differ; noted that the Division Bench's view is pending in appeal to the Supreme Court and therefore deference is appropriate to that interpretation in the present proceedings. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court undertook a stepwise analysis grounded in the record before it and prior authoritative interpretations of the same testament:
- Character of the Will and registration: The Will of 1099 ME created an institution ("Abdul Sathar Haji Moosa Sait Dharmasthapanam") which was registered with the Wakf Board; the B-schedule properties (including Sathar Island) were the subject of attempted sales and later of litigation.
- Nature of proceedings below: The suit before the Wakf Tribunal began as one for return of advance, was amended to claim specific performance, and culminated in a recorded compromise after the Wakf Board had been deleted from the array of parties.
- On the competing characterizations of the testament, the Court noted a Division Bench of this Court (C.R.P. No. 779/2008) had interpreted the same testament as creating a mixed wakf and that the Supreme Court had considered related appeals (including (1974) 3 SCC 257). Given this, the Court held it must follow the interpretation given by higher/earlier authoritative decisions concerning the same testament unless convincing reasons exist to depart from them.
- Section 93 and sanction: The Court examined Section 93 (judicial proceedings) vis-à-vis Section 51 (management of wakf) and observed the textual difference — Section 51 uses the word "prior" before "sanction", whereas Section 93 does not. From this, the Court inferred that the "sanction" in Section 93 could be understood to include ex post facto sanction as distinct from the expressly "prior" sanction in Section 51. For this reason the Court invited the Wakf Board to state whether it now favored the compromise; the Wakf Board replied in the negative.
- Necessity of Wakf Board as party and propriety of deletion: The Court emphasized that the Wakf Board is a necessary party to suits relating to wakf property to ensure protection of the wakf's best interests. The procedure adopted below — deleting the Wakf Board and recording a compromise without its sanction or notice — was held to be a clear infraction of statutory protections in the Wakf Act. The Court stated that such a compromise resulting in alienation of property could not be countenanced without compliance with statutory requirements.
- Practical consequences and need for full adjudication: Because the testament contains multiple clauses affecting transferability and beneficiaries, and because the character of the property (wakf vs. family trust) has far-reaching consequences, the Court held that a fuller adjudication including pleadings and evidence is necessary rather than allowing the recorded compromise to finalize disposition of the property.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The revisions are allowed and the impugned compromise decree granted by the Wakf Tribunal is set aside.
Direct orders and consequential implications (as stated by the Court):
- W.O.S. No. 21 of 2003 (the suit in the Wakf Tribunal) is remanded to the Wakf Tribunal, Ernakulam to recommence proceedings from the stage immediately before the filing of the compromise petition.
- The petitioner in CRP No. 481/2008 (Smt. Shamshad Hussain Sait) is to be impleaded as an additional defendant in that suit.
- The deletion of the Wakf Board from the array of parties in the suit is set aside and the Wakf Board is restored to its original position as defendant No. 2.
- Parties are permitted to file further pleadings and to adduce all evidence; the Tribunal is directed to dispose of the suit expeditiously.
- Status quo as of the date of the order is to be maintained: the property shall not be alienated or encumbered and no acts of waste shall be committed (the interim order dated 22.09.2008 is confirmed and made absolute until disposal after remand).
- In the interim, the institution is permitted to withdraw amounts from the interest portion of fixed deposits as ordered by this Court for payment of income tax arrears and dues as and when they occur.
The Court did not purport to lay down a new precedent on the ultimate characterization of the testament; rather it followed and deferred to earlier interpretative conclusions (including the Supreme Court's interpretation) and ordered a full adjudicatory process to determine issues of title, beneficiary entitlement and the validity of transfers/compromise under statutory requirements. The Court expressly left open the possibility of any future lawful compromise, but required that any such step be taken in accordance with the Wakf Act and after proper participation of the Wakf Board and interested beneficiaries.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT:
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE THOTTATHIL B.RADHAKRISHNAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN
THURSDAY, THE 17TH DAY OF MARCH 2016/27TH PHALGUNA, 1937 CRP.No. 411 of 2008 ( )
------------------------
W.O.S. NO. 21/2003 OF WAKF TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM.
.....
PETITIONER/2ND RESPONDENT:
------------------------------------------------
KERALA STATE WAKF BOARD,
REPRESENTED BY ITS CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER,
VIP ROAD, KALOOR, KOCHI-682 017.
BY SRI.T.KRISHNAN UNNI, SENIOR SC,
ADVS. SRI.M.M.SAIDU MUHAMMED, SC,
SRI.A.A.ABUL HASSAN, SC,
SRI.SAJU.S.A., SC,
SRI.K.SHIBILI NAHA, SC.
RESPONDENTS/PLAINTIFFS/1ST DEFENDANT:
---------------------------------------------------------------------
1. RAJESH, S/O. CHANDRASSERIL SUSEELAN,
AGED 32, BUSINESS, MOOTHAKUNNAM VILLAGE,
PARAVOOR TALUK.
*2. CHANDRABOSE, AGED 60 , S/O. KUTTAN, (DIED)
VALLOTTUTHARA HOUSE, VADAKKUMPURAM KARA,
CHENNAMANGALAM VILLAGE, PARAVOOR TALUK.
* THE DEATH OF THE 2ND RESPONDENT IS RECORDED,
VIDE ORDER DATED 02/01/2012 IN CRP. NO.411/2008.
3. ABDUL SATHAR HAJI MOOSA SAIT DHARMASTHAPANAM,
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESENT, MANAGING TRUSTEE
ADAM ABOOBACKER SAIT, PULLEPPADY CHITTOOR ROAD,
ERNAKULAM VILLAGE, KANAYANNUR TALUK.
* ADDL. R4 TO R6 IMPLEADED
4. VISHALAM M.N., W/O. LATE CHANDRA BOSE,
AGED 71 YEARS, VALLATTUTHARA HOUSE,
VADAKKUMPURAM P.O., CHENDAMANGALAM,
PARAVOOR, PIN-683 512.
1
CRP.No. 411 of 2008
5. V.C. LEKHA, D/O. LATE CHANDRA BOSE,
AGED 38 YEARS, VALLATTUTHARA HOUSE,
VADAKKUMPURAM P.O., CHENDAMANGALAM,
PARAVOOR, PIN-683 512.
6. V.C. BIJU, S/O. LATE CHANDRA BOSE,
AGED 36 YEARS, VALLATTUTHARA HOUSE,
VADAKKUMPURAM P.O., CHENDAMANGALAM,
PARAVOOR, PIN-683 512.
* ADDL. R4 TO R6 ARE IMPLEADED AS LEGAL HEIRS OF
DECEASED 2ND RESPONDENT AS PER ORDER DATED 17/03/2016.
R1 BY ADVS. SRI.ELVIN PETER P.J.,
SRI.K.R.GANESH.
R3 BY ADVS. SRI.P.B.KRISHNAN
SRI.M.A.MOHAMMED SIRAJ
SRI.M.ISHA
SRI.M.P.RAMNATH
BY SRI.JOSEPH KODIANTHARA, SR. ADVOCATE.
ADVS. SRI.VARGHESE C.KURIAKOSE,
SRI.V.ABRAHAM MARKOS
SRI.MATHEWS K.UTHUPPACHAN
SRI.BINU MATHEW
SRI.TERRY V.JAMES
SRI.N.SUBRAMANIAM
SRI.M.S.NARAYANAN
SRI.P.T.GIRIJAN
SMT.USHA NARAYANAN
SRI.M.NARENDRA KUMAR.
THIS CIVIL REVISION PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
ON 17-03-2016, ALONG WITH CRP. NO.481 OF 2008, THE COURT
ON THE SAME DAY PASSED THE FOLLOWING:
rs.
2
CRP.No. 411 of 2008
APPENDIX
PETITIONER'S ANNEXURES:-
ANNEXURE A COPY OF THE COMPROMISE PETITION & ITS TYPED COPY. ANNEXURE A (IN I.A. NO.621/2012): COPY OF THE LETTER RECEIVED FROM
THE CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT
DATED 17/02/2012.
ANNEXURE B JUDGMENT IN W.O.S.21/2003 OF WAKF TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM DATED 17/10/2007.
ANNEXURE C COPY OF THE DECREE IN W.O.S. 21/2003 OF WAKF TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM DATED 17/10/2003.
ANNEXURE A, B, C IN I.A. NO.765/2015
ANNEXURE A DATED 04/03/2015, COPY OF THE NOTICE SENT BY THE
I.T. DEPARTMENT.
ANNEXURE B DATED NIL, COPY OF THE ACKNOWLEDGMENT
FOR AY 2012-2013.
ANNEXURE C DATED NIL, COPY OF THE ACKNOWLEDGMENT
FOR AY. 2013-2014.
RESPONDENT'S ANNEXURES:- NIL.
//TRUE COPY//
P.S. TO JUDGE
rs.
3
"CR" THOTTATHIL B.RADHAKRISHNAN &
ANU SIVARAMAN, JJ.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
C.R.P.Nos.411 & 481 of 2008
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = Dated this the 17thday of March, 2016
O R D E R
Thottathil B.Radhakrishnan, J.
1. These revisions are filed under the proviso to Section 83(9) of the Wakf Act, 1995, hereinafter referred to as the 'Act'. The first among the captioned matters is by the Wakf Board and the second is by an individual who claims to be a descendant of the testator of a Will which we would hereinafter refer to as 'Will', in view of the dispute between the parties whether the bequest made thereunder also amounts to a wakf. The fact that she is a descendant of the said person is not in dispute before us.
2.Abdul Sathar Haji Moosa executed the Will on the 25thof the 2ndmonth (Kanni) of 1099 ME corresponding to 1924 AD. The relevant facts for the purpose of considering the proceedings of the court below are that the said Will creates an institution by name 'Abdul Sathar Haji Moosa Sait Dharmasthapanam'.
4
C.R.P.Nos.411 & 481 of 2008
2
That was registered with the Wakf Board. An application was filed for sale of a part of the property included in the B Schedule of that Will. That parcel is referred to by parties as 'Sathar Island'. Application was filed by the institution before the Wakf Board for sanction to sell Sathar Island. That was granted. Certain negotiated sales did not get through. Ultimately, attempt was made to auction out. That also did not fructify. Later on, the plaintiffs laid a suit before the Wakf Tribunal contending that the institution had agreed to sell Sathar Island to the plaintiffs or their nominees and that the said transaction stands with the approval which was granted by the Wakf Board earlier, however that, the institution has failed to discharge its obligations under that contract for sale and therefore, the plaintiffs are entitled to return of the advance paid. The suit so laid was one for return of advance. During the pendency of that suit and after the defendants, including the Wakf Board, had filed the written statements, an application was filed to amend the plaint essentially converting it as a suit for specific performance of the so-called contract
5
C.R.P.Nos.411 & 481 of 2008
3
for sale. After leave to amend was granted, the matter stood before the Wakf Tribunal for quite sometime. Thereafter, a compromise petition was filed by the plaintiffs and the institution after applying for deletion of the Wakf Board from the party array. That compromise petition was recorded by the Wakf Tribunal and resultantly, a consent decree as between the plaintiffs and the defendants to the suit except the Wakf Board was granted.
3.The revision by the Wakf Board is on the plea that the compromise could not have been recorded without its sanction in terms of Section 93 of the Act and also that due procedure was not followed in the matter of deciding on the compromise petition to which the Wakf Board was not even made a party. It further points out that it did not have even notice of the compromise petition. The Wakf Board is of the firm stand that the institution's property, which according to the Wakf Board is Wakf property, cannot be transferred.
6
C.R.P.Nos.411 & 481 of 2008
4
4.The other revision by Smt.Shamshad Hussain Sait, a descendant of Abdul Sathar Haji Moosa Sait is instituted on grounds which are deeper and beyond what has been urged by the Wakf Board. According to her, the Will of 1099 ME is not a resultant Wakf and is predominantly having all qualities of a trust which inures to the benefit of descendants of the testator. She says that she, her father's grand father and other persons are specified beneficiaries of the different terms of that Will and there is no Wakf created to the exclusion of the eligibility of those members of the testator's family to draw the benefit of the trust so created. She also impeaches the impugned decree as also the contract for sale on which it is founded relying on the terms of the Will which contains certain processes amounting to interdiction from transfer of property on the different items dealt with in that Will. To the extent needed she also appears to sail with the Wakf Board, insofar as the question of sanction of the Board and other matters are concerned; though, however, not giving up her plea that there is no Wakf at all.
7
C.R.P.Nos.411 & 481 of 2008
5
5.The materials before the court below did not have any substantial documentary or oral evidence for the Wakf Tribunal to take stock of the real nature of the property or the institution before it. Ultimately, everything went through a compromise between the parties after excluding the Wakf Board. We have however seen that there was an earlier suit as W.O.S.No.23 of 2007 at the instance of the institution, i.e., Abdul Sathar Haji Moosa Sait Dharmasthapanam arraying the revision petitioner in C.R.P.No.481 of 2008, Smt.Shamshad Hussain Sait and her siblings as defendants. The Wakf Tribunal then took the view that the property is not Wakf property. Therefore, that suit was returned for presentation before proper court. This Court through C.R.P.No.779 of 2008 interfered with that decision of the Wakf Tribunal and held that what the testator had created through the Will of 1099 ME is essentially what can be called as a mixed Wakf which, according to the learned Judges, is not a mere Wakf-alal-aulad but it also provides for religious and charitable purposes. What we understand from the said judgment is that the
8
C.R.P.Nos.411 & 481 of 2008
6
resultant conclusion was that the Will created an institution which carries with it the different elements of a Wakf as discernible from the definition of 'Wakf' in the Act. Resultantly, the learned Judges held that a Wakf was created and the properties are Wakf properties. We are shown that the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India had issued notice on the petition for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No.19222 of 2010 and had also granted interim stay of further proceedings on that suit. We are also told that subsequently Their Lordships have granted leave to appeal. Incidentally, it has also been brought to the notice of this Court that certain issues relating to payment of Agricultural Income Tax under the Kerala Agricultural Income Tax Act became a moot issue between the taxation authorities of State of Kerala and the institution Abdul Sathar Haji Moosa Sait Dharmasthapanam. One of the prime contentions that is reflected through the judgment delivered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India on that matter is the quality of the B schedule properties, of which Sathar Island is a part. This matter is dealt with by the
9
C.R.P.Nos.411 & 481 of 2008
7
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Civil Appeal Nos.1576 and 1577 of 1970 reported as Abdul Sathar Haji Moosa Sait Dharmastapanam v. Commissioner of Agricultural Income Tax, Kerala [(1974)3 SCC 257]. When a document, that is to say, the testament of Abdul Sathar Haji Moosa, was interpreted by the Division Bench through CRP No.779 of 2008 in a particular manner, judicial propriety would insist that this Bench of coequal strength would follow that, unless of course, reasons are ripe enough to take a different view. We have bestowed our anxious consideration to the contents of the testament. Even if we were to disagree and refer this matter for consideration of a Full Bench by expressing our opinion on the interpretation and construction of a testament of Adul Sathar Haji Moosa, we see that the practical solution to the problem will not come through by that exercise. We say this because, the interpretation given by the Division Bench through CRP.No.779 of 2008 is pending consideration in the civil appeal noted above. Going back to the precedent (1974)
(3) SCC 257 noted above, we have to stand not only guided
10
C.R.P.Nos.411 & 481 of 2008
8
but following the interpretation given therein because what has been interpreted by Their Lordships of the Hon'ble Supreme Court is the very same testament which is now before us. It was held, among other things, in that precedent that it is clear that the 3/4thincome of the B Schedule Properties was primarily earmarked for the benefit of the mere relations of the testator. Therefore, the Apex Court was in agreement with the High Court that the said part of the bequest cannot be considered as a public charitable trust. 6.With the aforesaid being the substance of the conflict between the parties, particularly with reference to the plea raised by the petitioner in C.R.P.No.481 of 2008 (Shamshad), we need to further note that the question whether the property called Sathar Island is essentially Wakf property is a matter which will have far reaching consequences. The registration of a wakf with the Wakf Board is not per se decisive of its title or of the quality of wakf to the exclusion of consideration of such issues in competent jurisdictions. We are told that the so-
11
C.R.P.Nos.411 & 481 of 2008
9
called Wakf created through the testament of Adul Sathar Haji Moosa has been registered and shown in the register of Wakfs and was published in the Gazette by the State Government. That statutory exercise of putting in place the appropriate control over the Wakfs and operating the regulating machinery of the Act, in our view, may not wholly be determinative of issues touching title to property and the quality of the institution created through the testament of Adul Sathar Haji Moosa when such issue is raised for adjudication and decision in the competent jurisdiction.
7. Insofar as Section 93 of the Act is concerned, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Wakf Board argued that Section 93 contains a statutory prescription interdicting compromise of suits without the sanction of the Wakf Board,. Under the law as it stood at the relevant point of time, the provision in Section 51 of the Act provided for certain transactions with the prior sanction of the Wakf Board. Sections 51 and 93 occur in two different chapters of the Act.
12
C.R.P.Nos.411 & 481 of 2008
10
Section 93 belongs to that bunch of statutory provisions which deals with judicial proceedings whereas Section 51 falls under the chapter which deals with the management of the Wakf. Therefore, the quality of prior sanction provided in Section 51 and the term "sanction" in Section 93 could be differentially understood with the use of the word 'prior' before the word 'sanction' in Section 51 and the non-use of the word 'prior' before the word 'sanction' in Section 93. We can necessarily infer the legislative intention that the sanction under Section 93 could also be ex post facto sanction. Therefore, during the pendency of these revisions, we had required the Wakf Board to express itself whether at this point of time, at least, it has any particular view favouring the compromise. The answer placed before this Court through a statement is in the negative.
8.Wakf Board is a necessary party to all suits and proceedings relating to a Wakf property. This is the prescription of the Act. The Wakf Board was made a party to the suit from which these
13
C.R.P.Nos.411 & 481 of 2008
11
revisions arise. That authority was excluded from the process of arriving at the compromise. The very presence of the Wakf Board in the Wakf Tribunal as a party to such suits is to ensure that the best interest of the Wakf is always under the continuous gaze of the Wakf Board which is duty bound to alert the Wakf Tribunal if something were to go against the interest of the Wakf. Therefore, the procedure adopted by the court below by deleting the Wakf Board from the party array and thereafter, recording a compromise between the parties resulting in the alienation of the property through court cannot be countenanced. It is a clear infraction of the all guarding doctrines inbuilt into the statutory provisions in the Act. It does not make any difference whether the decree is a compromise decree and further examination of that compromise could be had only at the hands of the court which granted the compromise or recorded the compromise. The provisions of Order XIII of the C.P.C which govern compromise as is understood in the general civil procedural law is not the trump card of the petitioners in these revisions. It is not the
14
C.R.P.Nos.411 & 481 of 2008
12
fraudulent manner of obtaining the leave or compromise that is being projected. It is the recording of a compromise without sanction of law and in violation of the compulsion of Section 93 of the Act. Also, the eligibility of a beneficiary of the testament of Abdul Sathar Haji Moosa to contest any application for sale of the property covered by the said testament including the Sathar Island has necessarily to be recognized particularly when she claims an eligibility for share of income as already noted by Their Lordships in the Supreme Court through the decision in (1974) 3 SCC 257 (supra). We also cannot ignore that the testament of Abdul Sathar Haji Moosa taken as a whole contains very many clauses which require to be focused upon by any judicial authority if it were to grant a decree by compromise or even otherwise in relation to the reliefs sought for in the plaint.
9.For the aforesaid reasons, these revisions are allowed and the impugned decree granted by the Tribunal is set aside and W.O.S.No.21 of 2003 is remanded to the Wakf Tribunal,
15
C.R.P.Nos.411 & 481 of 2008
13
Ernakulam to commence proceedings from the stage before which the compromise petition noted above was filed. We order impleadment of the petitioner in CRP No.481/2008 as an additional defendant in that suit. The parties will be entitled to place further pleadings and adduce all evidence. The removal of the Wakf Board from the array of parties in the said suit is also set aside and the Wakf Board is restored to its original position as defendant No.2 in the said suit. The parties are directed to mark appearance before the Tribunal on 19.05.2016. We do not express either way on the possibility or otherwise of any further compromise being settled or recorded by the Court in accordance with law. 10.The Wakf Tribunal will dispose of the suit as expeditiously as possible and we hope that parties will co-operate for such disposal.
In the meanwhile, the institution is permitted to withdraw the amounts from the interest portion that has accrued in the fixed
16
C.R.P.Nos.411 & 481 of 2008
14
deposits lying as ordered by this Court for paying off the Income Tax arrears as well as dues as and when they occur. The plaintiffs, under the interim order of this Court, have registered sale deeds. It is also submitted that they have put certain other parties in possession. These are lis pendens transfers. Accordingly, it is directed that status quo as on today will be maintained and the property shall not be encumbered or alienated and no acts of waste shall be committed on the suit property following the interim order dated 22.09.2008 which order is confirmed and made absolute till the disposal of the suit after remand. sd/-
Thottathil B.Radhakrishnan, Judge
sd/-
Anu Sivaraman, Judge
sj18/3 /True Copy/ P.A. to Judge
17
Alert