Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Girish Raghunath Mehta v. Inspector Of Customs And Another

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 7, 2016
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 26-02-2004 an Inspector of Customs (NCCP Customs, Mumbai) received intelligence that the appellant was selling crushed poppy straw without invoices. A raid at 6, Pravin Chambers, Keshvji Naik Road, Mumbai led to the seizure of 30 kg of poppy straw from co-accused Karim Patel, who identified the appellant as the seller. Samples were taken, sealed, and later confirmed positive for opium derivatives. The appellant’s statement under Section 67 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (“NDPS Act”) was recorded on 27-02-2004, admitting the sale without licence.

Both accused were prosecuted. The Special Court convicted the appellant for (i) illegal sale of 30 kg of poppy straw and (ii) illegal possession of commercial quantity. The Bombay High Court (2007 SCC OnLine Bom 1433) set aside the possession conviction but upheld the conviction for the illegal sale. Having completed his four-year sentence (and fine of Rs 20,000), the appellant appealed to the Supreme Court. The co-accused did not appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether non-compliance with Section 42 (recording and forwarding of prior information) invalidated the conviction.
  2. Whether the chain of custody was broken owing to alleged absence of seals/labels and improper sample records.
  3. Whether the appellant’s Section 67 statement was admissible, voluntary, and sufficient for conviction.
  4. Whether the Supreme Court should disturb concurrent findings of the lower courts under Article 136 of the Constitution.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Intelligence notes (Ext. 47 and Ext. 18) were recorded belatedly and inconsistently, violating the mandatory Section 42 requirements (citing Abdul Rashid Ibrahim Mansuri, Jagraj Singh, Sukhdev Singh).
  • The gunny bag produced lacked labels/seals; PW-2 could not confirm their presence; sample registers were deficient; panch witnesses were either absent or repeatedly used.
  • The Section 67 statement was a coerced “confession” before a police officer, in custody, and inadmissible (relying on Tofan Singh, Bal Mukund, Raju Premji, Noor Aga).

State’s Arguments

  • Section 42 does not apply; recovery was from a public place, attracting Section 43, which was complied with.
  • No contemporaneous objection was raised about labels; integrity of samples confirmed by the chemical examiner (PW-8).
  • The Section 67 statement was recorded before arrest, was never retracted, and was voluntary (supported by PW-2).
  • Concurrent findings of fact by two courts below should not be disturbed in an Article 136 appeal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Abdul Rashid Ibrahim Mansuri v. State of Gujarat (2000) 2 SCC 513 Mandatory nature of Section 42 compliance. Held inapplicable; recovery was under Section 43.
State of Rajasthan v. Jagraj Singh alias Hansa (2016) 11 SCC 687 Effect of Section 42 violations. Distinguished on same ground as above.
Sukhdev Singh v. State of Haryana (2013) 2 SCC 212 Section 42 requirements. Not applicable; Section 43 governed.
Sajan Abraham v. State of Kerala (2001) 6 SCC 692 Flexibility in Section 42 compliance. Reconciled with Mansuri via Karnail Singh.
Karnail Singh (2009) 8 SCC 539 Substantial compliance test for Section 42. Applied to affirm adequacy of compliance.
Tofan Singh v. State of Tamil Nadu (2013) 16 SCC 31 Admissibility of Section 67 statements; issue referred to larger Bench. Not decisive; conviction upheld on other evidence.
Union of India v. Bal Mukund (2009) 12 SCC 161 Limited weight of Section 67 confessions. Distinguished; other evidence confirmed guilt.
Raju Premji v. Customs, NER Shillong Unit (2009) 16 SCC 496 Admissibility of co-accused statements. Same treatment as Bal Mukund.
Noor Aga v. State of Punjab (2008) 16 SCC 417 Voluntariness of confessions. Court found the appellant’s statement voluntary.
2007 SCC OnLine Bom 1433 Bombay High Court decision partly allowing appeal. Affirmed as correct by Supreme Court.

Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court found that the appellant’s sale of 30 kg of poppy straw to an unlicensed purchaser was proved by (i) immediate recovery from the co-accused (PW-1 Bhaskar Shetty’s testimony) and (ii) the appellant’s unretracted, pre-arrest Section 67 statement (Ext. 20). The Court ruled:

  • Section 42 v. Section 43: Because the contraband was seized in a public place, Section 43 applied; Section 42’s recording formalities were irrelevant.
  • Chain of Custody: No objection about labels or seals was raised when the exhibits were produced; PW-8 confirmed intact seals; hence no break in chain.
  • Section 67 Statement: Recorded before arrest, never retracted, and therefore voluntary and admissible; even without it, other evidence established guilt.
  • Precedents Cited by Appellant: Distinguished or held inapplicable on factual grounds; Karnail Singh recognised substantial, not rigid, compliance with procedural mandates.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS DISMISSED.

The appellant’s conviction under Section 15 read with Section 8(c) NDPS Act and sentence of four years’ rigorous imprisonment plus a Rs 20,000 fine remain intact. As the sentence has already been served, the judgment primarily affirms the findings below and underscores that seizures from public places fall under Section 43, and voluntary Section 67 statements retain evidentiary value. No new legal precedent was created.

Show all summary ...

Adarsh Kumar Goel, J.— These appeals have been preferred by the appellant against his conviction under Section 15 read with Section 8(c) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (for short “the Act”) and sentence to undergo rigorous imprisonment for four years and to pay a fine of Rs 20,000, to further undergo rigorous imprisonment for six months, in default of payment of fine, for illegal sale of 30 kg of poppy straw to the co-accused, A-2, who did not have valid licence as per the Maharashtra NDPS Rules, 1985.

2. The case of the prosecution is that the Inspector of Customs, NCCP Customs, Mumbai received intelligence information on 26-2-2004 that the appellant was selling crushed opium poppy straw without any bills on cash basis from his premises at 6, Pravin Chambers, Keshvji Naik Road, Mumbai. Co-accused Karim Patel was to purchase 30 kg of poppy straw. A raid was organised and Karim Patel was apprehended with 30 kg of poppy straw. The raid was conducted by PW 1, Bhaskar Shetty, Inspector of Customs, along with others including PW 5, Canute Menezes. The said accused stated that he had purchased the poppy straw without any bill on cash payment of Rs 5400. On search of the premises belonging to the appellant, some documents were recovered. The appellant was found in the shop and stated that he was proprietor and a lady present there was the manager of the firm. Co-accused Karim Patel, who was also brought by the raiding party with it, opened the bag which had coloured powder in a polythene bag. A small quantity was tested on the field testing kit and result was positive for the presence of opium. The powder was weighed and found to be 30 kg. Three samples of 24 g each were collected and sealed. The remaining powder was sealed and kept in the same bag. The label with signatures of panchas and the investigating officer PW 1 Bhaskar Shetty was affixed on the bag. Co-accused Karim Patel identified the appellant as the person who had sold the powder to him without bill on cash payment. It is not relevant to mention about the rest of stock of opium kept in the shop and thereafter recovery of cash amount from the house of the appellant as conviction of the appellant has been upheld only for the charge mentioned earlier. Co-accused Karim Patel also stated that he had purchased poppy straw powder on several occasions from the appellant and sold the same.

3. The statement of the appellant was recorded under Section 67 of the Act on 27-2-2004 to the effect that he had sold 30 kg powder to A-2 without receipt and without medical prescription. A-2 did not have a valid permit. After completion of investigation, both the accused were sent up for trial. The prosecution examined 11 witnesses which included investigating officer who effected recovery of the contraband, Superintendent of Customs who received information, Assistant Chemical Examiner, the landlord of the premises in possession of the appellant as a licensee/tenant and PSI of the State Excise. The trial court convicted and sentenced the appellant not only for the offence mentioned above but also for illegal possession of commercial quantity of poppy straw powder.

4. On appeal, the High Court partly allowed 2007 SCC OnLine Bom 1433 the appeal, quashed and set aside the conviction and sentence for illegal possession of commercial quantity of poppy straw powder but upheld the conviction and sentence for illegal sale transaction of 30 kg of poppy straw powder. The High Court also upheld the conviction of the co-accused for abetment of the said offence by purchasing 30 kg of poppy straw powder from the appellant without any valid licence and permit. The co-accused has not preferred any appeal as stated by the learned counsel. The appellant has undergone the sentence during pendency of the proceedings.

5. The learned counsel for the appellant has taken the Court through the evidence on record and submitted that conviction and sentence awarded to the appellant was unsustainable. There are discrepancies in recording of prior information, resulting in violation of mandatory requirement of Section 42 of the Act. Reference was made to intelligence note, Ext. 47, and the statement of PW 4 to submit that the information was received one or two days prior to 26-2-2004 during investigation of an earlier case while it was recorded only on 26-2-2004 and not immediately. There are contradictions in time and manner of recording of information, Ext. 18, while there is another note which is contradictory. Reliance has been placed on Abdul Rashid Ibrahim Mansuri v. State of Gujarat (2000) 2 SCC 513, State of Rajasthan v. Jagraj Singh (2016) 11 SCC 687, (2016) 6 Scale 32 and Sukhdev Singh v. State of Haryana (2013) 2 SCC 212.

6. It was further submitted that the gunny bag produced in the Court did not carry the label and the signatures. The same could not be linked to the appellant. PW 2 was unable to say whether the bag produced had seal or label or not. He also submitted that record of the samples was not maintained. The panchas were not examined. The same panchas were used for several occasions. He also submitted that the statement of the accused under Section 67 amounted to confession before the police and was not admissible as held in Tofan Singh v. State of T.N. (2013) 16 SCC 31, Union of India v. Bal Mukund (2009) 12 SCC 161, Raju Premji v. Customs (2009) 16 SCC 496 and Noor Aga v. State of Punjab (2008) 16 SCC 417. Even if the statement of the appellant under Section 67 was admissible, it was a weak piece of evidence and had only corroborative value. No independent witness was joined while recording the statement. The appellant was in custody at the time of recording the statement. The statement was not voluntary. Its contents were not read over to him. A-2 was also in custody and his statement was also not voluntary. Statement of the co-accused could not be taken as substantive evidence. The same could not be relied upon in view of the decision in Bal Mukund (2009) 12 SCC 161 and Raju Premji (2009) 16 SCC 496.

7. The learned counsel for the State supports the conviction and sentence of the appellant. He submitted that concurrent finding of the courts below is based on evidence and the same is not liable to be disturbed in an appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution. It was pointed out that the contentions advanced by the learned counsel for the appellant are not shown to have been raised before the High Court. He next submitted that Section 42 applies only when the recovery is to be effected from a building, conveyance or enclosed place. The present case is covered by Section 43 as the recovery is from a public place. As regards the plea of absence of label, neither was any question raised at the time of production of the bag nor is the fact of recovery of the contraband from the co-accused in dispute. Recovery was proved by independent direct evidence. The co-accused from whom recovery was effected has not even challenged his conviction. As regards the record of samples, it is pointed out that the evidence of the chemical examiner, PW 8 is categorical that all the samples were in sealed condition. The appellant never retracted his statement under Section 67 to the effect that the contraband recovered from the co-accused was sold by the appellant and that the said co-accused had no licence to purchase the contraband and thereby the appellant contravened the conditions of his licence. He was not in custody when his statement was recorded as is clear from the statement of PW 2, Gerard Joseph, who recorded the statement.

8. After due consideration, we do not find any merit in the submissions on behalf of the appellant. Both the courts below have concurrently held that the appellant was found to have sold the contraband to the co-accused without any licence. The said finding, inter alia, is based on the evidence of PW 1 Bhaskar Shetty, Inspector of Customs who seized the contraband from the co-accused Karim Patel. Further, the evidence in the form of statement of the appellant himself (Ext. 20) under Section 67 of the Act before his arrest clearly shows that the appellant had sold the contraband to the co-accused Karim Patel who did not have any licence to purchase thereof. Even otherwise, the connection of contraband with the appellant was clearly established after which the burden was on the appellant to show that he had effected sale to an authorised person. Recovery from the co-accused was from an open place to which Section 42 of the Act is not attracted. At the time of production of gunny bag no objection was raised on behalf of the appellant that the bag did not carry any label or sign of identity. Thus, the absence of label and sign of identity could not be presumed. The samples were duly tested by the chemical analyser and were found to be intact. There is, thus, no serious infirmity in the findings recorded by the courts below in convicting and sentencing the appellant.

9. The contention raised on behalf of the appellant on the basis of judgments of this Court in Abdul Rashid Ibrahim Mansuri (2000) 2 SCC 513, Jagraj Singh (2016) 11 SCC 687, (2016) 6 Scale 32 and Sukhdev Singh (2013) 2 SCC 212 cannot be accepted. As already noticed, Section 42 of the Act has no application to the fact situation of the present case. The said section applies when the contraband is recovered from a building, conveyance or enclosed place. Where recovery is from a public place, Section 43 applies. This Court reconciled the view taken in Abdul Rashid Ibrahim Mansuri (2000) 2 SCC 513 and Sajan Abraham v. State of Kerala (2001) 6 SCC 692 in larger Bench judgment in Karnail Singh (2009) 8 SCC 539. It was held that in view of technological advancements, it may not be possible to record information as per the requirement of Section 42. Strict compliance by the investigating agency should not be required in an emergency situation so as to avoid misuse by wrongdoers/offenders/drug peddlers. Whether there is adequate substantial compliance is a question of fact in each case. Apart from the finding that the present case is governed by Section 43, there is no ground to interfere with the concurrent finding of the courts below that there is adequate compliance with Section 43 of the Act.

10. Similarly, the contention on the basis of the judgments in Tofan Singh (2013) 16 SCC 31, Raju Premji (2009) 16 SCC 496 and Noor Aga (2008) 16 SCC 417 also cannot be accepted. There can be no doubt that the Court has to satisfy itself that the statement under Section 67 was made voluntarily and at a time when the person making such a statement had not been made an accused. Whether the statement is voluntary and free from encumbrance has to be judged from the facts and circumstances of each case. In Tofan Singh (2013) 16 SCC 31, the question whether the investigating officer investigating the matter under the Act is a police officer and whether the statement recorded by the investigating officer under Section 67 of the Act can be treated as a confessional statement has been referred to the larger Bench. It is not necessary to go into this aspect in the present case as there is adequate evidence to prove the sale of the contraband by the appellant for which the co-accused has been convicted and sentenced. The prosecution version is based not only on the statement under Section 67 but also on the evidence of recovery of the contraband immediately after sale and the circumstances showing that the contraband was sold by the appellant to the co-accused, without any authorisation. Thus, we do not find any ground to interfere with the conviction and sentence awarded to the appellant.

11. The appeals are dismissed.