- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of Uttar Pradesh And Others v. Dhirendra Pal Singh .
Factual and Procedural Background
Dhirendra Pal Singh, an Assistant Store Superintendent in the Uttar Pradesh Irrigation Department, retired on 30 June 2009. Upon retirement the State released his General Provident Fund, leave encashment, and 70% of his gratuity and pension but withheld the remaining 30%. The State cited alleged discrepancies in departmental stock and, by orders dated 23 July 2015 and 6 August 2015, permanently withheld the balance and directed recovery of ₹ 7,26,589 from Mr Singh’s retiral dues.
Mr Singh’s earlier civil suit (Civil Suit No. 338 of 2012) was withdrawn after issuance of the 2015 orders, whereupon he filed Writ-A No. 49921 of 2015 before the Allahabad High Court. A learned Single Judge quashed the State’s orders, holding that no departmental enquiry had been conducted under Article 351-A of the U.P. Civil Service Regulations, and directed release of the withheld amounts with 10% interest. The State’s intra-court appeal was dismissed by the Division Bench on 31 May 2016. The State of Uttar Pradesh then appealed to the Supreme Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, in the absence of a departmental or judicial proceeding under Article 351-A of the U.P. Civil Service Regulations, the State could withhold a portion of Mr Singh’s pension and gratuity and order recovery of alleged losses.
- Whether the High Court erred in awarding interest at the rate of 10% per annum on the withheld pension and gratuity.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (State of Uttar Pradesh)
- Contended that the High Court wrongly granted interest at 10% per annum because Mr Singh filed the suit only in 2012 and subsequently withdrew it.
Respondent (Dhirendra Pal Singh)
- Maintained that, having made several representations and faced prolonged non-payment, he was entitled to interest on the delayed pension and gratuity.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| State of Kerala v. M. Padmanabhan Nair (1985) 1 SCC 429 | Pension and gratuity are vested rights; culpable delay attracts interest. | Relied upon to affirm liability of the employer to pay interest on delayed retirement benefits. |
| Y.K. Singla v. Punjab National Bank (2013) 3 SCC 472 | Interest on delayed gratuity may be awarded at 8% p.a. | Used as a benchmark to fix 8% interest on unpaid gratuity. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court noted that Article 351-A empowers the Governor to withhold or withdraw pension only when the pensioner is “found” guilty of grave misconduct in duly instituted departmental or judicial proceedings. It was undisputed that no such proceedings were ever initiated against Mr Singh. Furthermore, the foundational document alleging stock discrepancy was dated 26 December 2009—more than five months after his retirement—contradicting the requirement that proceedings relate to events within four years prior to institution.
Consequently, the Court upheld the High Court’s finding that the State’s orders dated 23 July 2015 and 6 August 2015 were illegal and liable to be quashed. On the question of interest, the Court surveyed precedent: Padmanabhan Nair approved 6% interest on pension arrears, while Y.K. Singla approved 8% on delayed gratuity under Section 7(3-A) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. Balancing these authorities, the Court reduced the High Court’s 10% rate, directing:
- Interest at 6% per annum on unpaid pension from the date it fell due.
- Interest at 8% per annum on unpaid gratuity from the date of retirement.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISPOSED OF WITH MODIFICATION: The quashing of the State orders remains; the interest component is revised to 6% on pension and 8% on gratuity.
Implications: The respondent will now receive the withheld amounts with interest at the specified rates. The judgment reiterates that pension and gratuity cannot be withheld without strict compliance with Article 351-A and offers guidance on appropriate interest rates for delayed retirement benefits, yet does not establish a new legal test beyond existing precedent.
Order
1. Leave granted. This appeal is directed against the order dated 31-5-2016, passed by the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, in State of U.P v. Dhirendra Pal Singh 2016 SCC OnLine All 971, whereby the intra-court appeal was dismissed affirming the order dated 10-12-2015 passed by the learned Single Judge in Dhirendra Pal Singh v. State of U.P Writ-A No. 49921 of 2015
2. Brief facts of the case are that respondent Dhirendra Pal Singh was Assistant Store Superintendent with the Irrigation Department of the State of Uttar Pradesh. He stood retired on 30-6-2009 on attaining the age of superannuation. At the time of his retirement, GPF, leave encashment and 70% of gratuity and pension were cleared, but rest of the 30% of gratuity and computation of pension were held up. The stand of the appellants is that there were some discrepancies in the stock in the store of the Department and some enquiries were going on as to loss caused to the public exchequer. After making representations when the remaining amount of gratuity and pension was not cleared, the respondent filed Civil Suit No. 338 of 2012. However, the same was dismissed as withdrawn as the appellant State authorities, vide order dated 23-7-2015 finally, on the basis of alleged discrepancies withheld the remaining part of gratuity and pension of the respondent and, vide order dated 6-8-2015, directed recovery of Rs 7,26,589, from the retiral dues payable to the respondent, which was challenged in the writ petition.
3. There was no departmental enquiry initiated against the respondent and after about more than six years, order as to finally withholding of remaining pension on the ground of alleged misconduct and the recovery was directed to be made from the respondent after serving a notice on him. The learned Single Judge of the High Court found that the orders challenged in the writ petition cannot be sustained in law as neither recourse of Article 351-A of the U.P Civil Service Regulations was resorted to, nor any departmental enquiry was held. The learned Single Judge further directed that the remaining amount of gratuity and pension of the respondent shall be released with interest @ 10% p.a on the sum withheld by the State authorities. The Division Bench, in special appeal filed by the State, found no illegality in the order passed by the learned Single Judge.
4. We have heard the learned counsel for the appellants and the respondent.
5. Article 351-A of the U.P Civil Service Regulations reads as under:
“351-A. The Governor reserves to himself the right of withholding or withdrawing a pension or any part of it, whether permanently or for a specified period and the right of ordering the recovery from a pension of the whole or part of any pecuniary loss caused to the Government, if the pensioner is found in departmental or judicial proceedings to have been guilty of grave misconduct, or to have caused pecuniary loss to the Government by misconduct or negligence, during his service, including service rendered on re-employment after retirement:
Provided that—
(a) such departmental proceedings, if not instituted while the officer was on duty either before retirement or during re-employment—
(i) shall not be instituted with the sanction of the Governor,
(ii) shall be in respect of event which took place not more than four years before the institution of such proceedings, and
(iii) shall be conducted by such authority and in such place or places as the Governor may direct and in accordance with the procedure applicable to proceedings on which an order of dismissal from service may be made.
(b) Judicial proceedings, if not instituted while the officer was on duty either before retirement or during re-employment, shall have been instituted in accordance with sub-clause (ii) of clause (a), and
(c) the Public Service Commission, U.P, shall be consulted before final orders are passed.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this article—
(a) departmental proceedings shall be deemed to have been instituted when the charges framed against the pensioner are issued to him, or, if the officer has been placed under suspension from an earlier date, on such date; and
(b) judicial proceedings shall be deemed to have been instituted—
(i) in the case of criminal proceedings, on the date on which complaint is made, or a charge-sheet is submitted, to a criminal court; and
(ii) in the case of civil proceedings, on the date on which the plaint is presented or, as the case may be, an application is made to a civil court.”
6. Admittedly, no departmental enquiry was initiated in the present case against the respondent for the misconduct, if any, nor any proceedings drawn as provided in Article 351-A of the U.P Civil Service Regulations. The learned Single Judge of the High Court has observed that the document which is the basis of enquiry and relied upon by the State authorities, copy of which was Annexure CA-1 to counter-affidavit filed in the writ petition, itself reflected that the document showing discrepancy in the stock was dated 26-12-2009 i.e after about more than five months of retirement of the respondent. In the circumstances, keeping in view Article 351-A of the U.P Civil Service Regulations, we agree with the High Court that the orders dated 23-7-2015 and 6-8-2015 were liable to be quashed and, to that extent, we decline to interfere with the impugned order.
7. The learned counsel for the appellants argued that the High Court has erred in awarding interest @ 10% p.a on the sum due to the respondent. In this connection, it is submitted that the suit was filed by the respondent only in 2012 and that too was withdrawn.
8. We have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the appellants and reply given by the learned counsel for the respondent.
9. In State of Kerala v. M. Padmanabhan Nair (1985) 1 SCC 429, this Court has held that pension and gratuity are no longer any bounty to be distributed by the Government to its employees on the retirement but are valuable rights in their hands, and any culpable delay in disbursement thereof must be visited with the penalty of payment of interest. In the said case the Court approved 6% p.a interest on the amount of pension decreed by the trial court and affirmed 1983 SCC OnLine Ker 205, 1984 KLT 542 by the High Court. As to the rate of interest on amount of gratuity, in Section 7(3-A) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, it is provided that if the amount of gratuity payable is not paid by the employer within the period specified in sub-section (3), the employer shall pay, from the date on which gratuity becomes payable to the date on which it is paid, simple interest at such rate, not exceeding the rate notified by the Central Government from time to time for repayment of long-term deposits, as that Government may by notification specify. It further provides that no such interest shall be payable if the delay in payment is due to the fault of the employee, and the employer has obtained permission in writing from the controlling authority for the delayed payment on this ground. In the present case, there is no plea before us that the appellants had sought any permission in writing from the controlling authority. As to the delay on the part of the employee, it has come on the record that he made representations, whereafter he filed a suit in respect of withheld amount of gratuity and pension. In Y.K Singla v. Punjab National Bank (2013) 3 SCC 472, this Court, after discussing the issue relating to interest payable on the amount of gratuity not paid within time, directed that interest @ 8% p.a shall be paid on the amount of gratuity.
10. In the light of the law laid down by this Court, as above, and further considering the facts and circumstances of the case, we modify the impugned order 2016 SCC OnLine All 971 passed by the High Court in respect of interest directed to be paid on the amount of withheld gratuity and pension. We direct that the appellants shall pay interest @ 6% p.a on the unpaid amount of pension from the date it had fallen due and interest @ 8% p.a on the unpaid amount of gratuity from the date of retirement of the employee.
11. With the modification, as above, in the impugned order 2016 SCC OnLine All 971 passed by the High Court, this appeal stands disposed of. No order as to costs.
Alert