Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

RAJINDER PRASAD JAIN v. STATE (GNCTD)

Delhi High Court
Nov 10, 2016
Smart Summary (Beta)

High Court of Delhi — Summary of Opinion (Crl.M.C. 4822/2014)

Case: Rajinder Prasad Jain v. State (GNCTD)
Court: High Court of Delhi, Coram: P.S. Teji, J.
Date of decision: 10 November 2016
Counsel for Petitioner: Mr. Shiv Charan Garg and Mr. Imran Khan, Advocates.
Counsel for Respondent (State): Ms. Manjeet Arya, Additional Public Prosecutor. Counsel for respondent No.2: Mr. Arun Arora, Ms. Preet, Advocates.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed an application under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. before the Metropolitan Magistrate (Central, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi) seeking direction to the police to investigate allegations that respondent No.2 (Amit Jain), a relative and erstwhile partner in the petitioner's partnership business, had taken possession of the partnership's income-tax files from the advocate handling the firm's tax matters on a false pretext. The petitioner alleged that this act amounted to criminal breach of trust and misappropriation. An earlier complaint was allegedly made to the SHO but no action was taken, prompting the petitioner to seek judicial intervention under Section 156(3).

By order dated 16.07.2014 the Magistrate declined to direct police investigation under Section 156(3), proceeded instead to call the petitioner to adduce pre-summoning evidence (i.e., proceeded under Section 200 Cr.P.C.), and dismissed the petitioner's request for a police probe. The petitioner challenged that order by filing the present petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. in the High Court. The High Court heard arguments and reserved its decision, issuing the present judgment on 10 November 2016.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Magistrate erred in refusing to direct investigation by the police under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. in respect of the petitioner's complaint alleging criminal breach of trust and misappropriation.
  2. Whether, on the facts as pleaded, police investigation (including forensic examination of signatures and custodial interrogation/recovery) was necessary or whether the Magistrate was justified in exercising the discretion to proceed under Section 200 Cr.P.C. and take pre-summoning evidence himself.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • All the income tax files relating to the partnership were in unlawful possession of respondent No.2 and those files could not be recovered without a police investigation.
  • The specimen signature of the accused had not been taken and police assistance was required to get the signature examined at an FSL (Forensic Science Laboratory).
  • The learned Magistrate failed to properly consider the case law cited by the petitioner on the point and therefore erred in refusing to direct investigation under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' (State or respondent No.2) legal arguments beyond the fact that arguments were heard.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Acharya Arun Dev v. State, 2005 (2) JCC Delhi 897 This information was not available in the provided opinion. This information was not available in the provided opinion.
Krishan Lal v. Dharmendra Bafna, 2009 RLR 421 SC This information was not available in the provided opinion. This information was not available in the provided opinion.
Cogent Silver Fibre Pte. Ltd. v. State, JCC (207) Vol.2 1363 This information was not available in the provided opinion. This information was not available in the provided opinion.
Lallan Singh v. State, 2006 RLR NSC 80 This information was not available in the provided opinion. This information was not available in the provided opinion.
Navdeep Singh v. State, 2005 JCC Vol.1 463 This information was not available in the provided opinion. This information was not available in the provided opinion.
Mahavir Singh v. Police Commissioner, 2006 RLR 368 This information was not available in the provided opinion. This information was not available in the provided opinion.
Standard Chartered Bank v. Yogesh, 2006 RLR 587 This information was not available in the provided opinion. This information was not available in the provided opinion.
Skipper Beverages Pvt. Ltd. v. State, 2001(92) DCT 217 SC The Court (as quoted in the opinion) held that Section 156(3) empowers a Magistrate to direct police investigation but this power must be exercised judiciously and not mechanically; where allegations are not very serious and the complainant has the evidence, there may be no need to direct police investigation. The discretion should be used where the complainant cannot collect or produce evidence and the interests of justice demand police assistance. The High Court relied on and reproduced this principle to emphasize that the Magistrate must apply his mind before directing investigation under Section 156(3) and should not pass such orders mechanically.
Suresh Chand Jain v. State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors., 2001(1) AD (Cri.) SC 34 This information was not available in the provided opinion (it was cited as relied upon in Skipper Beverages). This information was not available in the provided opinion.
Mohd. Salim v. State (Crl.M.C. 3601/2009) decided 10.03.2010 The Court (as quoted in the opinion) reiterated that Sub-section (3) of Section 156 contains the expression "may", making the Magistrate's power discretionary. A Magistrate is not bound to direct police investigation even if allegations disclose a cognizable offence; investigation should be directed only where the assistance of the investigating agency is necessary in the interest of justice, and not mechanically. The High Court applied this principle to conclude that the Magistrate had discretion and was entitled to refuse police investigation where the complainant could himself produce evidence and where the matter appeared to be a partnership dispute within the complainant's reach.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court reviewed the statutory framework governing a Magistrate's options when confronted with a complaint under Section 200 Cr.P.C., namely the choice to (a) direct police investigation under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. or (b) take cognizance and proceed under Section 200 by recording evidence and examining witnesses under Chapter XV. The Court emphasized that Section 156(3) is worded in discretionary terms ("may") and that the Magistrate must exercise this discretion judicially, not mechanically.

The Court relied upon the principles set out in Skipper Beverages (as explained in the quoted passage) and Mohd. Salim, which stress that:

The Magistrate should direct police investigation under Section 156(3) only where the nature of the allegations or the circumstances are such that the complainant is unable to collect or produce necessary evidence without police assistance, or where custodial interrogation or state machinery is necessary for recovery or discovery of facts. For simple allegations where evidence is within the reach of the complainant, the Magistrate may proceed under Section 200 and conduct the inquiry himself.

Applying these principles to the facts before it, the Court observed that the dispute was essentially a partnership dispute between erstwhile partners. The accused's alleged conduct (taking files) related to a business partnership and there had been no prior complaints about the accused's conduct. The Court noted that the petitioner knew the identity of the accused and that the incriminating evidence — including records and witness testimony — lay within the petitioner's own reach. Consequently, the Court concluded that police assistance was not necessary for the collection of evidence or for discovery in this matter.

The Court found no illegality or irregularity in the Magistrate's decision to refuse to direct an investigation under Section 156(3) and to proceed to record pre-summoning evidence instead. The High Court held that the Magistrate had applied his mind and exercised his discretion diligently.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition was found to be without merit and was DISMISSED. Pending applications were disposed of.

Consequences and implications:

  • The impugned order of the Magistrate dated 16.07.2014 refusing to direct police investigation under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. was upheld by the High Court as legal and proper on the facts of the case.
  • The petitioner retains the right to proceed before the Magistrate who may record pre-summoning evidence, summon witnesses, and call for relevant records; the High Court observed that the petitioner can seek the Court's assistance to examine witnesses and obtain documents necessary to prove the allegations.
  • The High Court explicitly noted that its observations (and those in the impugned order) will have no impact on the merits of the eventual trial — i.e., the order does not determine guilt or liability on the substantive allegations.
  • No new legal precedent beyond reaffirmation of existing principles governing Section 156(3) vs. Section 200 discretion was laid down; the decision confirms the established principle that magistrates must exercise discretion judicially in deciding whether police investigation is necessary.

End of summary — prepared from the text of the judgment delivered on 10 November 2016. No information beyond the provided opinion has been added.

Show all summary ...

Crl.M.C. 4822/2014 Page 1 of 8 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI Date of Decision: November 10th, 2016 + CRL.M.C. 4822/2014 RAJINDER PRASAD JAIN ..... Petitioner Through Mr.Shiv Charan Garg and Mr.Imran Khan, Advocates. versus STATE (GNCTD) ..... Respondent Through Ms.Manjeet Arya, Additional Public Prosecutor for the State. Mr.Arun Arora, Ms.Preet, Advocates for respondent No.2. CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE P.S.TEJI P.S.TEJI, J.

1. The present petition has been filed under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (hereinafter shall be referred as Cr.P.C.) for setting aside the order dated 16.07.2014 passed by the learned Metropolitan Magistrate, Central, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi whereby the application of the petitioner filed under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. was dismissed.

2. Facts, in brief, are that an application under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. was filed by the petitioner before the learned Magistrate. In the application, it was alleged that the respondent no.2 Amit Jain/proposed accused was son of the brother of the petitioner with Crl.M.C. 4822/2014 Page 2 of 8 whom partnership business was carried out by the petitioner for a long time. A suit for partition was filed by the petitioner wherein the respondent no.2 took the stand that the business was duly partitioned in the year 1988. It was alleged that the respondent no.2 had taken all the files of the said firm from Sh. Inderjeet Ahuja, Advocate who was dealing with the income tax matters of the firm. It was alleged that the respondent no.2 had taken files on the false pretext that he was authorized by the petitioner. It was alleged that such an act of the respondent no.2 amounted to criminal breach of trust and misappropriation. A complaint in this regard was allegedly filed by the petitioner before the SHO, but since no action on the same was taken by the police, he approached the Court by filing the application/complaint.

3. The learned Magistrate has gone through the material placed before him and declined the request of the petitioner to refer the matter to the police for further investigation vide impugned order dated 16.07.2014 while observing that all the facts and circumstances of the case are within the knowledge of the complainant/petitioner-herein and no ground for directing the police to investigate is made out. The learned Magistrate called the petitioner to adduce pre-summoning evidence. Feeling aggrieved of the same, the present petition has been preferred by the petitioner.

4. Arguments advanced by the counsel for the parties were heard.

5. The grounds taken in support of the present petition and the Crl.M.C. 4822/2014 Page 3 of 8 arguments advanced by the counsel for the petitioner are that all the income tax files pertaining to the petitioner are in unlawful possession of the respondent no.2 and the same cannot be recovered without the investigation by police. It was further submitted that the specimen signature of the accused has not been taken so far and the investigation by police is required to get the same examined from FSL. It was further submitted that the learned Magistrate has not properly considered the case law on the point.

6. In support of the above contentions, judgments in the case of Acharya Arun Dev v. State 2005 (2) JCC Delhi 897, Krishan Lal

v. Dharmendra Bafna 2009 RLR 421 SC, Cogent Silver Fibre Pte. Ltd. v. State JCC (207) Vol.2 1363, Lallan Singh v. State 2006 RLR NSC 80, Navdeep Singh v. State 2005 JCC Vol. 1 463, Mahavir Singh v. Police Commissioner 2006 RLR 368 and Standard Chartered Bank v. Yogesh 2006 RLR 587 have been relied upon.

7. It is a well settled law that a Magistrate has two options when a complaint case is filed under Section 200 Cr.P.C. before him i.e. either to get the matter investigated through police under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. or to proceed under Section 200 Cr.P.C. When the Magistrate proceeds under Section 156(3) of the Code, he passes the order without taking cognizance of the offence. If the Magistrate wishes to proceed under section 200 of the code then he has to take cognizance of the matter and follow the procedure prescribed under chapter-XV. It is an alternative procedure which Crl.M.C. 4822/2014 Page 4 of 8 the Magistrate 'may' or 'may not' adopt at the stage when he is examining the complainant under Section 156(3) of the Code. Under Section 200 Cr.P.C., the Magistrate has a duty to record evidence led by the complainant and also to examine his witnesses and if necessary even to call for a police report and then to decide as to whether he has to proceed under chapter-XV or has to dismiss the complaint. The power to refer the cognizable offence and direct the police to investigate the cognizable offence is envisaged in Section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C. It is not necessary to refer every complaint filed under Section 200 to the police for investigation under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. In Skipper Beverages Pvt. Ltd. vs. State 2001(92) DCT 217 SC, while relying upon Suresh Chand Jain vs. State of Madhya Pradesh and Ors., 2001(1) AD (Cri.) SC 34, Supreme Court held:

7. It is true that Section 156(3) of the Code empowers a Magistrate to direct the police to register a case and initiate investigations but this power has to be exercised judiciously on proper grounds and not in a mechanical manner. In those cases where the allegations are not very serious and the complainant himself is in possession of evidence to prove his allegations there should be no need to pass orders under Section 156(3) of the Code. The discretion ought to be exercised after proper application of mind and only in those cases where the Magistrate is of the view that the nature of the allegations is such that the complainant himself may not be in a position to collect and produce evidence Crl.M.C. 4822/2014 Page 5 of 8 before the Court and interests of justice demand that the police should step in to held the complainant.

10. Section 156(3) of the Code aims at curtailing and controlling the arbitrariness on the part of the police authorities in the matter of registration of FIRs and taking up investigations, even in those cases where the same are warranted. The Section empower the Magistrate to issue directions in this regard but this provision should not be permitted to be misused by the complainants to get police cases registered even in those cases which are not very serious in nature and the Magistrate himself can hold enquiry under Chapter XV and proceed against the accused if required. Therefore the Magistrate, must apply his mind before passing an order under Section 156(3) of the Code and must not pass these orders mechanically on the mere asking by the complainant. These powers ought to be exercised primarily in those cases where the allegations are quite serious or evidence is beyond the reach of complainant or custodial interrogation appears to be necessary for some recovery of article or discovery of fact.

8. Remedy provided in Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. is a discretionary as the provision proceeds with the word 'may'. The Magistrate is required to exercise his mind while doing so and pass orders only if he is satisfied that the information reveals commission of cognizable offence/offences and also about necessity of police investigation for digging out of evidence neither in possession of the complainant nor Crl.M.C. 4822/2014 Page 6 of 8 can be procured without the assistance of the police. The complainant, as a matter of right, cannot insist that the complaint case filed by him should be directed in every eventuality to the police for investigation. In Mohd. Salim vs. State (Crl.M.C. 3601/2009 decided on 10.03.2010), this Court held:

11. The use of the expression "may" in Sub- section (3) of Section 156 of the Code leaves no doubt that the power conferred upon the Magistrate is discretionary and he is not bound to direct investigation by the Police even if the allegations made in the complaint disclose commission of a cognizable offence. In the facts and circumstances of a given case, the Magistrate may feel that the matter does not require investigation by the Police and can be proved by the complainant himself, without any assistance from the Police. In that case, he may, instead of directing investigation by the Police, straightaway take cognizance of the alleged offence and proceed under section 200 of the code by examining the complainant and his witnesses, if any. In fact, the Magistrate ought to direct investigation by the Police only where the assistance of the Investigating Agency is necessary and the Court feels that the cause of justice is likely to suffer in the absence of investigation by the Police. The Magistrate is not expected to mechanically direct investigation by the Police without first examining whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, investigation by the State machinery is actually required or not. If the allegations made in the complaint are simple, where the Court can straightaway proceed to conduct the trial, the Magistrate is Crl.M.C. 4822/2014 Page 7 of 8 expected to record evidence and proceed further in the matter, instead of passing the buck to the Police under Section 156(3) of the Code. Of course, if the allegations made in the complaint require complex and complicated investigation of which cannot be undertaken without active assistance and expertise of the State machinery, it would only be appropriate for the Magistrate to direct investigation by the Police. The Magistrate is, therefore, not supposed to act merely as a Post Office and needs to adopt a judicial approach while considering an application seeking investigation by the Police.

9. In the instant case, for the detailed reasons in the orders, the Magistrate did not deem it fit to order investigation under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. This Court does not find any illegality or irregularity in the impugned order to interfere with. The dispute between the petitioner/complainant and the respondent no.2/proposed accused is primarily a dispute between the partners of the firm. Earlier both the parties were having a partnership business and prior to the present complaint, there was no other complaint regarding conduct and behavior of the respondent no.2. There are allegations against respondent no.2 that he had taken away income tax files, relating to the partnership business, from the advocate when he was not authorized to do so at all. For all these grievances, investigation by police is not at all required. Therefore, the judgments relied upon by the counsel for the petitioner render no assistance to him. Crl.M.C. 4822/2014 Page 8 of 8

10. From the above discussion, it reveals that the petitioner is aware about the identity of the accused and the entire incriminating evidence is well within his reach. The petitioner can seek assistance of the Court to examine relevant witnesses and summon the relevant record to prove his contentions before the Trial Court. In my considered view, assistance of the police is not required to collect evidence on this aspect. The discretion has been exercised diligently and right of the petitioner to pursue the case has not been foreclosed. This Court finds no infirmity or impropriety in the order under challenge.

11. Consequently, the present petition is unmerited and is dismissed. Pending application also stands disposed of. It is however made clear that observations in the impugned orders and this order will have no impact upon the merits of the case. (P.S.TEJI) JUDGE NOVEMBER 10, 2016