Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Dalip Singh v. Niranjan Singh & Others S

Punjab & Haryana High Court
May 6, 2009
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Opinion: VINOD K. SHARMA, J. (ORAL)

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion contains two matters disposed of by the court on 6.5.2009.

First, C.M. No. 5610-C of 2009: an application under Section 149 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking condonation of a 38-day delay in making good a deficiency in court fee. The applicant averred that court fee was not affixed at the time of filing the appeal due to an inadvertent, bona fide mistake and was affixed with a delay of 38 days.

Second, R.S.A. No. 1912 of 2009: a regular second appeal against the judgment and decree dated 23.12.2008 of the learned Courts below, which had dismissed a suit filed by the plaintiff/appellant. The plaintiff had sought to challenge a decree (which he had suffered) as being null and void on account of alleged fraud and misrepresentation and also pleaded that the decree was invalid for want of registration. The learned trial Court dismissed the suit, holding that the plaintiff/appellant could not challenge a decree which he had himself suffered and that the suit was not maintainable because the plaintiff/appellant was not in possession of the suit property. The lower appellate Court held that the suit was time barred.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a decree obtained by fraud and misrepresentation which is otherwise bad for want of registration could be sustained in law? (This was posed as the substantial question of law by the appellant.)

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The decree was allegedly obtained by the father of the defendant/respondent by fraud and misrepresentation.
  • Under the decree, the right was transferred for the first time but was not registered; therefore, no valid title could pass to the defendant/respondents or his father.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's or other parties' specific legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Regarding C.M. No. 5610-C of 2009 (Section 149 application): the court accepted the applicant's averment that the court fee was inadvertently not affixed at the time of filing and that the fee was affixed after a delay of 38 days due to a bona fide mistake. For those reasons stated in the application, the court condoned the 38-day delay in making good the deficiency in court fee and allowed the application.

Regarding R.S.A. No. 1912 of 2009 (regular second appeal): the court reviewed the findings of the learned Courts below and the contentions raised by the appellant. The court noted:

  • The learned trial Court had held that the plaintiff/appellant could not challenge a decree which he had himself suffered.
  • The suit as framed was not maintainable because the plaintiff/appellant was not in possession of the suit property; in the absence of possession, a suit for declaration and permanent injunction was not maintainable.
  • The lower appellate Court had correctly held that the suit was time barred; the suit was filed after three years of knowledge, since the mutation in favour of the predecessor-in-interest of the defendants had been sanctioned in the presence of the plaintiff/appellant.
  • Although there could be some substance in the contention regarding registration, the court reiterated the settled law (as described in the opinion) that it is not open to a plaintiff/appellant to challenge a decree for want of registration after having suffered that decree himself.

On the basis of these considerations — incompetence of the suit as framed (no possession relief sought), the bar of limitation, and the settled principle that a party who has suffered a decree cannot later challenge it for want of registration — the court concluded that the substantial question of law raised by the appellant did not arise for consideration in the appeal.

Holding and Implications

C.M. No. 5610-C of 2009: The application for condonation of the 38-day delay in making good the deficiency in court fee is allowed. The court condoned the delay and C.M. stands allowed.

R.S.A. No. 1912 of 2009: The appeal is dismissed. The court found no merit in the appeal and upheld the judgments and decree of the learned Courts below.

Implications: The direct effects are that the delay in payment of court fee was condoned for the pending proceeding, and the second appeal was dismissed, leaving intact the conclusions of the lower courts (non-maintainability of the suit, limitation bar, and the principle that a plaintiff who has suffered a decree cannot challenge it later for want of registration). The opinion does not state that any new precedent was established.

Delivered by: VINOD K. SHARMA, J. (ORAL) — 6.5.2009

Show all summary ...

VINOD K. SHARMA, J. (ORAL)

C.M No. 5610-C of 2009

This is an application under Section 149 of the Code of Civil Procedure for condoning the delay of 38 days in making good the deficiency in court fee.

It has been averred in the application that in-advertantly the court fee was not affixed at the time of filing of the appeal and the court fee has been affixed with a delay of 38 days, which is not intentional but bona fide mistake.

For the reasons stated in the application, the delay of 38 days in making good deficiency in court fee is condoned.

C.M stands allowed.

R.S.A No. 1912 of 2009

This regular second appeal is directed against the judgment and decree dated 23.12.2008 passed by the learned Courts below dismissing the suit filed by the plaintiff/appellant to challenge the decree suffered by the plaintiff, to be null and void being outcome of fraud and misrepresentation. A plea was also raised, that the decree was not valid for want of registration.

The learned trial Court dismissed the suit by holding, that it is not open to the appellant/plaintiff to challenge the decree suffered by him. It was also held, that the suit as framed was not maintainable, as admittedly the plaintiff/appellant was not in possession of the suit property. In absence of possession, the suit for declaration and permanent injunction was not maintainable.

Though there could be some substance in the contention regarding registration, but in view of the settled law that it is not open to the plaintiff/appellant to challenge the decree for want of registration after having suffered the same himself.

Furthermore keeping in view the fact, that the learned lower appellate Court rightly held, that the suit was time barred. No fault can be found with the judgment and decree passed by the learned Courts below.

The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant contends that the appeal raises the following substantial question of law for consideration :-

1. Whether the decree obtained by fraud and misrepresentation which is otherwise bad for want of registration, could be sustained in law ?

In support of the substantial question of law the learned counsel for the appellant contends, that the decree was obtained by father of the defendant/respondent, by fraud and misrepresentation. It is contended that though under the decree the right was transferred for the first time, it was not got registered, therefore, no valid title could pass on to the defendant/respondents or his father.

This plea of the learned counsel for the appellant cannot be accepted, as the learned Courts below rightly held, that the suit as framed, was not competent as the relief of possession was not sought, though defendant/respondents were in possession.

The suit was also time barred, as it was filed after three years of knowledge as admittedly the mutation in favour of the predecessor-in-interest of the defendants was sanctioned in presence of the plaintiff/appellant.

The suit otherwise also was not maintainable in view of the settled law that it was not open to the plaintiff to challenge the decree for want of registration having suffered the decree.

The substantial question of law, raised does not arise for consideration in this appeal.

No merit.

Dismissed.

6.5.2009 (VINOD K. SHARMA) ‘sp’ JUDGE