Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sanjeev Sharma Petitioner v. State Of Delhi & Ors. S

Delhi High Court
Nov 23, 2010
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Sanjeev Sharma, filed a petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C seeking to quash the order dated 22nd July 2009 of the Additional Sessions Judge. The impugned order had set aside the Metropolitan Magistrate's order dated 8th April 2009 and directed release of Car No. DL9CD-2438 on superdari in favour of respondent No. 2, R.K. Gupta, the registered owner.

Respondent No. 2 had filed a complaint on 17th May 2004 alleging theft of the car on 22nd May 2003, leading to FIR No. 377/2004 under Section 379 IPC. Investigation revealed that the petitioner was in possession of the car, claiming to have purchased it from respondent No. 2 on 10th September 2003 for Rs. 1,60,000/-, producing Forms 29 and 30 and a cash receipt signed by respondent No. 2.

Respondent No. 2 admitted signing these documents but claimed they were signed in blank and misused by his brother's widow. The investigation further revealed conflicting statements about the car's location and ownership, and that respondent No. 2 had applied for a duplicate registration certificate submitting a false affidavit denying any criminal involvement of the car.

Both parties filed applications under Section 451 Cr.P.C for release of the car on superdari. The Metropolitan Magistrate dismissed both applications, directing the parties to seek a declaration of title from a civil court. Respondent No. 2 filed a revision petition, and the Additional Sessions Judge set aside the Metropolitan Magistrate's order and directed release of the car to respondent No. 2 on furnishing a superdarinama.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Additional Sessions Judge erred in directing release of the car on superdari in favour of respondent No. 2 despite the petitioner’s claim of ownership supported by signed transfer documents.
  2. Whether the question of ownership and title to the car should have been decided by the criminal court or deferred pending civil adjudication.
  3. The propriety of releasing the vehicle on superdari before the Metropolitan Magistrate’s decision on the closure report and protest petition.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The Additional Sessions Judge ignored that respondent No. 2 had sold the car to the petitioner for Rs. 1,60,000/- and executed the cash receipt and Forms 29 and 30 in favour of the petitioner to facilitate registration transfer.

Respondent No. 2’s Arguments

  • Admitted signing the documents but claimed they were signed in blank and given to his brother years ago, and that the documents were misused after his brother’s death.
  • Denied the car was stolen from his premises and alleged the complaint was made to harass his brother’s widow.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the evidence in the status report, noting that respondent No. 2 admitted signing the cash receipt and Forms 29 and 30, which prima facie supported the petitioner’s claim of purchase. The explanation by respondent No. 2 that the documents were signed in blank and misused was considered an afterthought and a question of fact requiring evidence.

The court observed that respondent No. 2 had filed a false affidavit denying the car’s involvement in any criminal case while applying for a duplicate registration certificate, undermining his credibility.

Since respondent No. 2 failed to reply to the petition denying these facts, the court inferred that the petitioner’s claim had prima facie merit.

The court held that the Additional Sessions Judge erred in releasing the car on superdari to respondent No. 2 before the Metropolitan Magistrate decided on the closure report and protest petition, which could have resolved the ownership dispute.

Holding and Implications

The impugned order dated 22 July 2009 of the Additional Sessions Judge is set aside.

Respondent No. 2 is directed to surrender the car to the police within seven days. The Metropolitan Magistrate is directed to decide the protest petition against the closure report and pass appropriate orders on the release of the car based on that decision.

This decision directly affects the parties by reversing the premature release of the vehicle and deferring the ownership question to the outcome of the criminal proceedings. No new precedent was established.

Show all summary ...

AJIT BHARIHOKE, J.

1. Sanjeev Sharma, the petitioner herein, vide this petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C has prayed for quashing of impugned order of the learned Additional Sessions Judge dated 22nd July 2009 in criminal revision whereby he set aside the order dated 8th April 2009 passed by learned M.M and directed Car No. DL9CD-2438 to be released on superdari in favour of respondent No. 2.

2. Briefly stated, facts relevant for the disposal of this petition are that on 17 May 2004 respondent No. 2 R.K Gupta, who is the registered owner of Car No. DL 9CD-2438(Maruti Zen) filed a complaint at P.S Paschim Vihar claiming that the aforesaid car belonging to him has been stolen from B-3/472, Paschim Vihar on 22 May 2003. On the basis of said complaint, formal FIR No. 377/2004 under Section 379 IPC was registered at P.S Paschim Vihar.

3. As per the status report filed by respondent No. 1 under the signatures of ASI Nirmaljeet Singh, during investigation above said Maruti car was found in possession of the petitioner Sanjeev Sharma who claimed that he had purchased the car from Raj Kumar Gupta on 10 September 2003 in consideration of Rs. 1,60,000/-. He also produced Forms No. 29 and 30 and cash receipt dated 10 September 2003, duly signed by respondent No. 2. Respondent No. 2 Raj Kumar Gupta admitted his signatures on Forms No. 29 and 30 as also on the cash receipt and claimed that he had signed those documents in blank and given them to his younger brother, late Sanjay Gupta, about 5/6 years back in connection with one Opel Car. He also claimed that after the death of his brother Sanjay Gupta, his wife Mrs. Ritu Gupta misused those blank documents. As per the status report, during investigation Mrs. Ritu Gupta stated that aforesaid car was never stolen from her premises No. B-3/472, Paschim Vihar, Delhi and it was never parked there. She claimed that R.K Gupta has given her address in the complaint to harass her. She further stated that actually said car was purchased by late Sanjay Gupta in the name of his younger brother R.K Gupta (respondent No. 2) who, taking benefit of the same, sold it to the petitioner Sanjeev Sharma. Investigation also revealed that aforesaid car was financed by M/s Baldev Finance Company and that respondent No. 2 R.K Gupta, concealing the fact that he had filed an FIR relating to theft of the car, applied for duplicate Registration Certificate at Transport Authority, Janak Puri and submitted a false affidavit that the car was not involved in a criminal/court/theft case. The investigating officer found the averments in the FIR to be false and submitted the final report before the Metropolitan Magistrate, seeking closure of the case.

4. Both the petitioner as well as respondent No. 2, claiming themselves to be the owner of the car in question, moved applications under Section 451 Cr.P.C for release of the car in their respective favour on superdari. The learned M.M, vide his order dated 8 April 2009 observed, “since both the parties are claiming ownership qua stolen vehicle, it would be appropriate for the parties to get the declaration from the Civil Court regarding their title towards the stolen vehicle. Hence, both the application stands dismissed.” Thereafter he listed the case for 16 May 2009 for consideration of an application under Section 91 Cr.P.C moved by respondent No. 2 (complainant) as also the protest petition filed by the complainant against the closure report.

5. Respondent No. 2, feeling aggrieved by the dismissal of his application under Section 451 Cr.P.C filed a revision petition and learned Additional Sessions Judge, after hearing the parties, set aside the order of the learned Metropolitan Magistrate dated 8 April 2009 and directed release of aforesaid car on superdari to the registered owner i.e respondent No. 2, on furnishing a superdarinama in the sum of Rs. 2.00 lacs to the satisfaction of the learned Metropolitan Magistrate, subject to the condition that the superdar shall not tamper with the car and produce it as and when directed by the trial court.

6. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the impugned order dated 22 July 2009 is bad in law as learned Additional Sessions Judge, while directing release of car on superdari in favour of the registered owner i.e R.K Gupta (respondent No. 2), has ignored the fact that respondent No. 2 had sold the car to the petitioner for Rs. 1,60,000/- and executed the consideration receipt as well as Forms 29 & 30 in his favour to facilitate the transfer of registration of the car in petitioner's name.

7. There is merit in the contention of learned counsel for the petitioner. As per the status report, respondent No. 2 was confronted with those documents and he admitted his signatures on the receipt as well as Forms 29 & 30. Respondent No. 2, however, took the defence that he had signed those documents in blank and given it to his brother late Sanjay Gupta 5/6 years back, which explanation of respondent No. 2, prima facie, is an afterthought. It is also clear from the status report that respondent No. 2 lodged the complaint regarding the theft of the car in question on 17 May 2004 and the FIR was registered at P.S Paschim Vihar on 4 June 2004. Despite that, the complainant (respondent No. 2), while applying for duplicate certificate of said car submitted a false affidavit claiming that the car was not involved in any crime/theft/superdari/challan etc.

8. Further, though respondent No. 2 was served with the notice of instant petition filed by the petitioner, he has not cared to file a reply denying the facts stated in the status report or the petition. The fact that the cash receipt for Rs. 1.60 lacs and Forms No. 29 and 30 are admittedly signed by respondent No. 2 prima facie leads to an inference that the car in question was sold by respondent No. 2 to petitioner No. 1. The explanation of respondent No. 2 that he had given blank signed cash receipt Forms No. 29 and 30 to his brother 5/6 years earlier, is a question of fact which requires evidence.

9. In view of the above discussed facts and circumstances, I find that learned Additional Sessions Judge has committed a grave error in releasing the car on superdari in favour of respondent No. 2, before the finding of learned Metropolitan Magistrate on the closure report filed by the police and the protest petition filed by respondent No. 2. Reasonable course of action under the circumstances was to wait for the outcome of the closure report/protest petition filed by respondent No. 2 which could have settled the question of title also.

10. In view of the discussion above, the impugned order of learned Additional Sessions Judge dated 22 July 2009 is set aside. Respondent No. 2 is directed to surrender the car in question to the police within seven days. It is directed that the learned M.M, while deciding the protest petition against the closure report shall also pass appropriate order for the release of the car in terms of his finding on the protest petition.

11. The petition is disposed of accordingly.

(AJIT BHARIHOKE)

JUDGE

NOVEMBER 23, 2010

ks