- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bachpan Bachao Andolan v. Union Of India And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The proceeding arises out of a contempt petition filed in an earlier writ petition by Bachpan Bachao Andolan. The petitioner complained about the manner in which the police handled a report concerning a missing child. On 17-1-2013 the Supreme Court had already issued interim directions—reported at (2014) 16 SCC 612—requiring every complaint about a missing child to be treated as a First Information Report (FIR) and investigated forthwith. The present order, dated 26-4-2013, was listed to monitor compliance with those directions and to consider wider implementation of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000 (as amended in 2006). It also addresses doubts raised by certain States, particularly Madhya Pradesh, about recording FIRs in such cases and considers several suggestions from the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC), the National Legal Services Authority (NALSA) and the petitioner.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, upon receiving information about a missing child, the police are mandatorily required to register an FIR under Section 154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, treating the incident as cognizable.
- What additional directions and institutional safeguards are necessary to ensure effective implementation of the Juvenile Justice Act and to trace and protect missing children.
- Whether the existing contempt proceedings against State authorities should continue in light of the updated compliance measures.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner (Bachpan Bachao Andolan)
- Questioned the accuracy of figures filed by certain States regarding compliance and recovery statistics.
State of Madhya Pradesh and Other Respondent States
- Raised doubts about compulsory registration of FIRs for missing children under Section 154 CrPC.
- Filed affidavits claiming implementation of the Court’s earlier directions.
National Human Rights Commission (NHRC)
- Suggested appointment of at least one trained Juvenile Welfare Officer in each police station under Section 63 of the Juvenile Justice Act.
- Recommended installation of computerised cameras and networking mechanisms for tracing children.
National Legal Services Authority (NALSA)
- Proposed use of para-legal volunteers in shifts at police stations to monitor handling of complaints involving children.
- Suggested photographing every recovered child and wide publication of the photographs.
- Called for creation of a Standard Operating Procedure and investigation protocol involving Anti-Human Trafficking Units.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sampurna Behura v. Union of India (2011) 9 SCC 801; (2011) 15 SCC 232 | Comprehensive directions on child protection, including taking photographs of recovered children and housing them in appropriate homes. | The Court directed authorities to comply with and “have due regard to” the guidelines issued in Sampurna Behura while implementing the present order. |
| Order dated 17-1-2013 in the present writ petition, reported at (2014) 16 SCC 612 | Interim direction that every complaint of a missing child must result in an FIR and immediate investigation. | The current order reiterates and clarifies the binding nature of that interim direction, removing any perceived ambiguity under Sections 154 & 155 CrPC. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court found no conflict between its earlier directive and Section 154 CrPC: whenever a child is reported missing, an initial presumption of abduction or trafficking must be drawn. Consequently, the police are obliged to register an FIR under Section 154. Even complaints lodged under Section 155 CrPC must be entered and simultaneously referred to the Magistrate, who should act under Section 155(2)—especially where a girl child is involved.
Recognising partial compliance by some States yet serious deficiencies highlighted by the petitioner, the Court accepted several institutional measures:
- Each police station shall designate at least one trained Juvenile Welfare Officer and have a Special Juvenile Officer on shift duty.
- Para-legal volunteers recruited by Legal Services Authorities shall monitor the handling of cases involving children within police stations.
- NALSA, in collaboration with the Ministry of Women and Child Development, is to explore a nationwide computerised network linking all child-protection stakeholders and to publicise the web portal.
- Every recovered child must be photographed, and the images disseminated via websites, newspapers and television to facilitate reunification with families. The Ministry of Home Affairs is to fund requisite equipment.
- If a child remains untraced for four months, investigations must be transferred to the State Anti-Human Trafficking Unit, which shall file quarterly status reports.
- State authorities must establish adequate shelter or after-care homes within three months; private homes may admit children only upon referral from a Child Welfare Committee and full statutory compliance.
Given these extensive directions, the Court considered the contempt proceedings satisfied at this stage.
Holding and Implications
Key Ruling: The police must invariably register an FIR under Section 154 CrPC in every case of a missing child, based on a presumption of abduction or trafficking, and comply with an array of directions aimed at tracing and protecting such children.
Contempt Proceedings: Dropped in view of the fresh directions and ongoing compliance monitoring.
Future Action: States yet to file status reports are granted an extension until the next hearing; the matter is listed again after three months for further oversight.
Implications: The order imposes nationwide operational duties on police stations, Legal Services Authorities and Child-Protection Units, but does not create new substantive precedent beyond reinforcing existing child-protection jurisprudence. Its immediate effect is the mandatory registration of FIRs for missing children and the establishment of structural safeguards across India.
Order
1. This matter has been listed pursuant to the direction Contempt Petition (C) No. 186 of 2013 given on 26-4-2013, when the contempt petition filed in the writ petition by the petitioner, complaining of the manner in which a complaint made regarding a missing child was sought to be handled by the police station concerned, was being considered. It has also come up on account of the other directions which had been given for implementing the various provisions of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000, as amended in 2006 (“the Juvenile Act”, for short).
2. On 17-1-2013, when this matter came up for consideration, we had given an interim direction (2014) 16 SCC 612 that in case a complaint with regard to any missing children was made in a police station, the same should be reduced into a first information report and appropriate steps should be taken to see that follow up investigation was taken up immediately thereafter.
3. An element of doubt has been raised on behalf of the State of Madhya Pradesh regarding the recording of first information report relating to a missing child, having regard to the provisions of Section 154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (“CrPC”, for short), which relates to information in cognizable cases. We do not, however, see any difficulty in the orders, which we have already passed. We make it clear that, in case of every missing child reported, there will be an initial presumption of either abduction or trafficking, unless, in the investigation, the same is proved otherwise. Accordingly, whenever any complaint is filed before the police authorities regarding a missing child, the same must be entertained under Section 154 CrPC. However, even in respect of complaints made otherwise with regard to a child, which may come within the scope of Section 155 CrPC, upon making an entry in the book to be maintained for the purposes of Section 155 CrPC, and after referring the information to the Magistrate concerned, continue with the inquiry into the complaint. The Magistrate, upon receipt of the information recorded under Section 155 CrPC, shall proceed, in the meantime, to take appropriate action under sub-section (2), especially, if the complaint relates to a child and, in particular, a girl child.
4. On the last occasion, when the matter was taken up, we were informed by some of the States that the directions, which we had given in our order dated 17-1-2013 (2014) 16 SCC 612, had been duly implemented and affidavits to that effect have also been filed. Some of the information given therein is seriously objected by Mr H.S Phoolka, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. In any event, even if the figures shown are incorrect, in order to rectify the situation, we are inclined to accept the suggestion made by Ms Shobha, learned advocate, appearing for the National Human Rights Commission, that each police station should have, at least, one Police Officer, especially instructed and trained and designated as a Juvenile Welfare Officer in terms of Section 63 of the Juvenile Act.
5. We are also inclined to accept the suggestion that there should be, in shifts, a Special Juvenile Officer on duty in the police station to ensure that the directions contained in this order are duly implemented. To add a further safeguard, we also direct the National Legal Services Authority, which is being represented by its Member-Secretary through Ms Anitha Shenoy, learned advocate, that the para-legal volunteers, who have been recruited by the Legal Services Authorities, should be utilised, so that there is, at least, one para-legal volunteer, in shifts, in the police station to keep a watch over the manner in which the complaints regarding missing children and other offences against children, are dealt with.
6. Ms Shobha, learned counsel, has also made another useful suggestion regarding a computerised programme, which would create a network between the Central Child Protection Unit as the Head of the Organisation and all State Child Protection Units, District Child Protection Units, City Child Protection Units, Block Level Child Protection Units, all Special Juvenile Police Units, all police stations, all Juvenile Justice Boards and all Child Welfare Committees. The said suggestion should be seriously taken up and explored by the National Legal Services Authority with the Ministry of Women and Child Development. Once introduced, the website link should also be made known to the public at large. The State Legal Services Authorities should also work out a network of NGOs, whose services could also be availed of at all levels for the purpose of tracing and re-integrating missing children with their families which, in fact, should be the prime object, when a missing child is recovered.
7. Various other suggestions have been made by Ms Shobha in her written submission, regarding installation of computerised cameras, which can also be considered by all the authorities concerned.
8. A similar response has been made on behalf of the National Legal Services Authority, and similar suggestions have been made. The details, as indicated in the response, can always be worked out in phases by the Juvenile Justice Boards and the Child Welfare Committees in consultation with the National Legal Services Authority, since each has a responsible role to play in the welfare of children, which, if the statistics given are to be believed, are difficult to accept. In fact, as has been pointed out by Mr Phoolka, out of more than 3000 children missing in 2011, only 517 first information reports had been lodged. The remaining children remain untraced and are mere slips of paper in the police stations.
9. One of the submissions, which has been made in the response filed by Nalsa, is with regard to the role of the police and the directions given by this Court, from time to time, in Sampurna Behura v. Union of India (2011) 9 SCC 801, (2011) 15 SCC 232. Accordingly, in addition to what has been recorded, as far as the suggestions made on behalf of the National Human Rights Commission is concerned, we add that, as suggested on behalf of Nalsa, every found/recovered child must be immediately photographed by the police for purposes of advertisement and to make people aware of the missing child. Photographs of the recovered child should be published on the website and through the newspapers and even on the TV so that the parents of the missing child could locate their missing child and recover him or her from the custody of the police. The Ministry of Home Affairs shall provide whatever additional support by way of costs that may be necessary for the purpose of installing such photographic material and equipment in the police stations. Apart from the above, all the parties involved shall have due regard to the various directions given in Sampurna Behura case (2011) 9 SCC 801, (2011) 15 SCC 232 where also provision has been made for a child to be sent to a home and for taking photographs and publishing the same so that recovery could be effected as early as possible.
10. The other suggestion of Nalsa is that a Standard Operating Procedure must be developed to handle the cases of missing children and to invoke appropriate provisions of law where trafficking, child labour, abduction, exploitation and similar issues are disclosed during investigation or after the recovery of the child, when the information suggests the commission of such offences. As part of the Standard Operating Procedure, a protocol should be established by the local police with the High Courts and also with the State Legal Services Authorities for monitoring the case of a missing child. In Delhi, such a protocol could be established with the help of the All India Legal Aid Cell on Child Rights, set up by Nalsa, in association with the Delhi State Legal Services Authority, and the petitioner herein, Bachpan Bachao Andolan. In fact, the same could be treated as a nodal agency of the All India Legal Aid Cell on Child Rights.
11. We have given directions in regard to the utilisation of the para-legal volunteers, which is one of the suggestions made on behalf of Nalsa.
12. As has been pointed out by Mr Phoolka, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner, an Office Memorandum was issued on 31-1-2012, by the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India, by way of an advisory on missing children and the measures needed to prevent trafficking and for tracing of such children. In the said office memorandum, a missing child has been defined as a person below eighteen years of age, whose whereabouts are not known to the parents, legal guardians and any other person, who may be legally entrusted with the custody of the child, whatever may be the circumstances/causes of disappearance. The child will be considered missing and in need of care and protection within the meaning of the latter part of the Juvenile Act, until located and/or his/her safety/well being is established.
13. In case a missing child is not recovered within four months from the date of filing of the first information report, the matter may be forwarded to the Anti-Human Trafficking Unit in each State in order to enable the said Unit to take up more intensive investigation regarding the missing child. The Anti-Human Trafficking Unit shall file periodical status reports after every three months to keep the Legal Services Authorities updated. It may also be noted that, in cases where first information reports have not been lodged at all and the child is still missing, an FIR should be lodged within a month from the date of communication of this order and further investigation may proceed on that basis. Once a child is recovered, the police authorities shall carry out further investigation to see whether there is an involvement of any trafficking in the procedure by which the child went missing and if, on investigation, such links are found, the police shall take appropriate action thereupon.
14. The State authorities shall arrange for adequate shelter homes to be provided for missing children, who are recovered and do not have any place to go to. Such shelter homes or after-care homes will have to be set up by the State Government concerned and funds to run the same will also have to be provided by the State Government together with proper infrastructure. Such homes should be put in place within three months, at the latest. Any private home, being run for the purpose of sheltering children, shall not be entitled to receive a child, unless forwarded by the Child Welfare Committee and unless they comply with all the provisions of the Juvenile Justice Act, including registration.
15. Having regard to the order passed herein, the contempt proceedings, which have been initiated by the petitioner, are dropped.
16. In the event, all the States have not yet filed their status reports, the time for filing the same is extended till the next date.
17. We appreciate the efforts of the petitioner organisation, Mr H.S Phoolka, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner, all the other counsel, who have appeared in this matter on behalf of the different authorities, including Nalsa and the National Human Rights Commission, and we hope that such interest will continue to subsist hereafter.
18. Let this matter be listed again after three months.
Alert