Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Smt. Savita Chadha v. Ravinder Singh Chadha .

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Aug 5, 1987
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — J.V. Gupta, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The parties, Ravinder Singh (husband, respondent in the appeal) and Savita Chadha (wife, appellant), were married on 16 April 1983 and lived together until about 28 July 1983 (approximately four months). The husband filed a petition for divorce on 11 October 1984 under Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, alleging cruelty by the wife. The trial court framed two issues (entitlement to decree of divorce on the grounds alleged and relief) and, after trial, held that the husband had proved cruelty and granted a decree of divorce. The wife appealed against the decree; this opinion is the appellate court's decision on that appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner-husband is entitled to a decree of divorce by dissolution of marriage on the grounds of cruelty as stated in the petition under Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955?
  2. Relief (i.e., whether the trial court's decree dissolving the marriage should be affirmed or set aside).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Wife's) Arguments

  • Even if the allegations in the petition are assumed to be correct, they do not amount to cruelty; many were mere "wear and tear" of married life and not grounds for divorce.
  • The wife lived with the husband for only about four months, which was argued to be too short a period to establish cruelty justifying divorce.
  • The parties were not strangers prior to marriage (an elder sister of the wife was already married into the husband's family), so the short duration should be viewed in that context.
  • The husband did not call his own relations as witnesses, whereas the wife's relative (Subhash Chand Khosla) supported her; authorities (Dr N.G. Dastane v. Mrs S. Dastane and others cited) were relied upon for the proposition that short stay does not, by itself, support a cruelty finding.

Respondent's (Husband's) Arguments

  • Cruelty must be assessed on the totality of acts and conduct, not by isolating individual acts; taken together the wife's conduct amounted to mental cruelty.
  • The wife addressed the husband as "Bhai Sahib," taunted him about economic status, refused household duties, made excessive demands beyond his means, threatened suicide, refused medical treatment, and caused complaints to police and departmental authorities — all of which caused mental agony and endangered the husband's peace and honour.
  • Authorities (Shri Amrik Singh P.C.S. v. Smt. Surjit Kaur and Harbhajan Singh Monga v. Amarjeet Kaur) were relied upon to support the view that cumulative conduct that produces mental agony can amount to cruelty.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dr N.G. Dastane v. Mrs S. Dastane (1975) 2 SCC 326; AIR 1975 SC 1534 Cited by the appellant to support the proposition that a short stay after marriage cannot, by itself, afford grounds for divorce on the basis of cruelty. The court noted this line of authority was relied on by the appellant but, in the circumstances of the present case, held that short duration alone was not decisive and that subsequent events taken together warranted the trial court's finding. The court did not overturn the trial court on that basis.
Raj Kumar v. Saroj Bala (1983 H.L.R 524) Cited by the appellant in support of the argument that short stay does not necessarily constitute cruelty. Referenced as part of appellant's authorities; the appellate court nevertheless found that cumulative conduct in this case established cruelty and did not set aside the trial court's finding.
Rajpal Sood v. Sanelata Kapoor (1984 H.L.R 142) Cited by the appellant on the issue that short duration of cohabitation cannot alone support a decree for cruelty. Included among authorities relied on by the appellant; the court proceeded to examine the totality of facts and did not disturb the trial court's conclusion.
Santosh Kumari v. Parveen Kumar (1986-2) 90 PLR 581 Cited by the appellant to argue that brief cohabitation is insufficient to establish cruelty. Not treated as dispositive; appellate court emphasized subsequent conduct and cumulative facts and upheld the trial court's finding of cruelty.
Shri Amrik Singh P.C.S. v. Smt. Surjit Kaur (1975 Cur. L.J. 360) Cited by the respondent and expressly relied on by the court to illustrate how sustained disrespect, nagging and total lack of regard for the husband and his family may amount to mental cruelty. The court expressly referred to this case ("Shri Amrik Singh's case (supra)") for its articulation of mental cruelty arising from total disrespect and persistent misbehaviour; the court used it to support the proposition that cumulative behaviour causing "untold mental agony" can justify divorce and found the trial court's conclusion consistent with that principle.
Harbhajan Singh Monga v. Amarjeet Kaur (AIR 1986 MP 41) Cited by the respondent for the proposition that the totality of conduct must be considered in assessing cruelty (mental cruelty concept). Referenced by the respondent; the appellate court evaluated the totality of facts and affirmed the trial court's finding of cruelty in line with the approach endorsed by such authorities.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The appellate court reviewed the record and noted that the trial court had examined each witness in detail and had made specific factual findings. Those findings, as summarized by the appellate court, included that:

  • The wife allegedly addressed the husband as "brother" on the first night after marriage.
  • She got up late, did not prepare tea for his friends and relatives, did not perform household work, and misbehaved with the husband and his mother in the presence of others.
  • She pressured the husband to install a flush latrine beyond his means, refused to take prescribed medicines (even when ill), threatened suicide when rebuked, and on occasions refused to share her bed with the husband.
  • She, her brother and father were alleged to have lodged complaints against the husband with police and his departmental authorities, which the husband asserted were false.

The court observed that cruelty is not limited to physical violence and includes mental cruelty of a degree that renders continued association unsafe for the complaining spouse's mental or physical health. The court relied on the principle, as explained in Shri Amrik Singh's case (cited by the respondent), that persistent disrespect, unconcealed dislike, and constant nagging may amount to mental cruelty, causing "untold mental agony."

The appellate court acknowledged that short cohabitation alone is not conclusive proof of cruelty. However, it examined subsequent events after the wife left the matrimonial home (July 1983): the wife's complaints to police and departmental authorities and the alleged false allegations, and concluded that, when taken together with the conduct while cohabiting, these matters supported the trial court's finding of cruelty.

The court also noted attempts were made in the appellate court to explore reconciliation but concluded that reconciliation was not possible at that stage. Ultimately, the court treated the question as one of fact — whether, on the totality of the evidence, the conduct amounted to cruelty — and found no illegality or infirmity in the trial court's factual conclusions to justify interference on appeal.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED.

Implications:

  • The trial court's decree dissolving the marriage on the ground of cruelty in favour of the husband is upheld.
  • The dismissal was ordered "with no order as to costs" (i.e., no costs awarded).
  • The court treated the matter as primarily one of fact and did not purport to lay down any new legal principle; it applied existing authorities on mental cruelty and the requirement of examining the totality of conduct. The opinion does not state that a new precedent was established.
Show all summary ...

J.V Gupta, J.:— This appeal is directed by the wife Savita Chadha against the decree of the Additional District Judge, Gurgaon, dated 3rd March, 1986 whereby the marriage between the parties was dissolved by a decree of divorce at the instance of the husband Ravinder Singh. The marriage between the parties was solemnised on 16th April, 1983. They lived together for about 4 months i.e upto 28th July, 1983. The present petition for divorce was filed on 11th October, 1984, on the ground of cruelty on the part of the wife.

2. According to the allegations in the petition filed by the husband, on the very first night of the marriage, the wife had told him that she was not willing to marry him and that she was forced to marry him by her parents. According to the husband, she addressed him as “Bhai Sahib”. From the very beginning the wife used to taunt her husband that she belonged to a very rich family while the husband was no match for her as he could not provide the facilities under which she was habitual in her parent's house. It was further alleged that at the insistance of the wife, the husband provided flush latrine in the house even though he was not in a position to bear the expenses for the same. She had been telling the husband that she would go to see picture in a taxi and when the husband and his mother tried to convince her that they were not in a position to fulfil her demands, she used to quarrel with them. She never used to do any house-hold work and used to get up at 9 A.M and used to ask for bed-tea from the mother of the husband. Whenever she was told to behave like a good wife, she used to threat that she would commit suicide and the blame would come to them. It was further pleaded that except once or twice the wife did not allow the husband to share her bed and whenever he used to approach her, she would threat him that she would jump from the roof. She always used to insult and misbehave with him and his mother even in the presence of others. During the stay at her husband's house, she suffered some woman disease and she was got treated from lady doctor at Gurgaon and thereafter at Delhi. As per the advice of the doctor, she was required to take certain medicines but she refused to take the same and told the husband that if she was compelled to take medicines, she would commit suicide. Thereupon the husband sent a telegram to the parents of the wife asking them to come, since he feared that some incident may not happen on her refusing to take the medicines. Vijay Khanna, brother of the wife, came to Gurgaon but instead of advising his sister, he started abusing the husband and his mother and also threatened them. According to the husband, the wife also made false complaints against him with the Antidowry Cell and also to the police at Delhi and Gurgaon as well as to the Departmental Authorities of the husband. On these allegations it was inter alia stated that these acts taken together constitute cruelty and, therefore, the husband was entitled to the decree for divorce.

3. In the written statement the wife controverted the said allegations made by the husband, According to her, she had conceived but the husband had compelled her for a forced abortion against her will and under threat and coercion. She denied that she had addressed the husband as brother or that she had told him that she was Page: 512not willing to marry him or that she was forced to marry him by her parents. According to the wife, the husband and his parents were not satisfied with the dowry given in the marriage and from the very beginning they were complaining about the same though dowry worth Rs. 70,000/- was given at the time of marriage. It was further alleged that after the forcible abortion when she fell ill seriously and the husband and his parents thought that she was going to die, they sent a telegram to Darjeeling, whereupon her brother came to Gurgaon. It was at the instance of the husband and his mother that she was taken away by her brother to Darjeeling for treatment. As a matter of fact, according to the wife, the husband and his parents had no intention to bring her back to their house and they intended to get rid of her. Telegram Exhibit R.1 dated 21st October, 1983 was sent in this behalf in which it was stated, “please do not sent Savita at any cost. I cannot keep her.” She denied that she ever refused to tike medicines except at the initial stage when she refused to take the pills to have forcible abortion but the husband gave her beatings for not obeying his orders and under those circumstances she had to take the pills which resulted in the abortion and she fell seriously ill. However, it was admitted that she had sent letters to the Legal Aid Cell for woman at Delhi and also to the authorities at Gurgaon, requesting them to get the matter reconciled.

4. In the replication filed on behalf of the husband, he controverted the allegations contained in the written statement and reitrated the stand taken in the petition.

5. On the pleadings of the parties the trial court framed the following issues:—

1. Whether the petitioner husband is entitled to a decree of divorce by dissolution of marriage on the grounds stated in the petition under section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955?

2. Relief.

6. After discussing each and every witness, the trial court came to the conclusion that the husband had fully proved on the record that he was entitled to the decree of divorce on the ground of cruelty and consequently decree of divorce was passed.

7. The learned counsel for the appellnt (wife) submitted that all the allegation made in the petition even if be taken to be correct, do not amount to cruelty. According to the learned counsel, the wife hardly stayed for 4 months with the husband and this is to short a period to allege cruelty on the part of the wife. It was contended that all the allegations made were in the nature of wear and tear of the married life. No decree of divorce could be passed on those grounds. It was also submitted that the elder sister of the wife was already married to the elder brother of the husband through the respondent-husband was adopted by his father's brother's wife and since childhood he had been living in that family. Thus it was suggested that it was not a marriage between the two strangers. Rather the parties were known to each other prior to their marriage. Even the husband did not produce any of his relations to support his case whereas Subhash Chand Khosla, wife's sister's husband has appeared as R.W 2 and has supported the case of the wife-appellant. In support of his contention he Page: 513has referred to Dr N.G Dastane v. Mrs S. Dastane. (1975) 2 SCC 326 , AIR 1975 SC 1534, Raj Kumar v. Saroj Bala 1983 H.L.R 524, Rajpal Sood v. Sanelata Kapoor 1984 H.L.R 142 and Santosh Kumari… v. Parveen Kumar…. (1986-2) 90 PLR 581 to contend that short stay after marriage cannot afford ground for divorce on the basis of cruelty. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent-husband submitted that it is not the individual act as such which is to be seen as to whether it amounts to cruelty or not. It is the totality of all the facts taken together which is to be seen as to whether it amounts to mental cruelty to the husband or not. In support of this contention he referred to Shri Amrik Singh P.C.S. v. Smt. Surjit Kaur 1975 Cur. L.J 360 and Harbhajan Singh Monga… v. Amarjeet Kaur…. AIR 1986 MP 41.

8. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have gone through the relevant evidence on the record. It may not be necessary to discuss the entire evidence again because the trial court has discussed each and every witness in detail. The trial court has concluded that from the evidence led by the husband various things which emerge inter alia are that the wife had addressed the husband as the brother on the first night after the marriage; she used to get up late in the morning; was not preparing tea for his friends and relatives; was not doing any house-hold work and used to misbehave with the husband and his mother in the presence of the friends and relatives; had forced the husband to install flush laterine even though it was beyond his means; had not been taking the medicines prescribed to her by the doctors even if she was sick and was getting weak; had been threatening to commit suicide and that the wife her brother and father had been lodging false complaints against the husband with the police as also in the office of the husband and thus the behaviour of the wife had caused mental cruelty and mental agony to him and the living of the husband with the wife would further endanger his mental peace and honour.

9. Efforts were made in this Court to find the possibility of reconciliation, if any. It appears that at this stage no reconciliation as such was possible between the parties. It is true that the parties lived together as husband and wife only for 4 months and that by itself was not a sufficient period to reach the conclusion that the wife had treated the husband with such a cruelty as to claim divorce on that ground. However, the subsequent events after she had left the matrimonial home in July, 1983, the complaint filed by the wife and his brother and father to the police and making false allegations against the husband, if taken together, it could hot be successfuly argued on behalf of the appellant-wife that the acts committed by her do not amount to cruelty to her husband. The expression cruelty is not confined to physical violence but conceives of mental cruelty as well. Mental cruelty has to be of such a kind as to make the complaining spouse's continued association with the other spouse unsafe for his/her mental and physical health. It was held in Shri Amrik Singh's case (supra) that the wife appeared to be arrogant and temperamental lady and that her misbehaviour, which consisted of total disrespect towards the husband, the members Page: 514of his family and unconcealed dislike for them all, besides constant nagging which appears to have continued unabated till they finally separated, caused untold mental agony to him. It could not be disputed whether on the totality of the facts and circumstances of the case it amounts to cruelty or not will be the question of fact and no judgment as such can be of much help. As regards the facts of the present case, taking into consideration the situation which has arrived, I do not find any illegality or infirmity in the findings of the trial Court as to be interfered with in appeal. Consequently, the appeal fails and is dismissed with no order as to costs.

R.M.S
Appeal dismissed.