- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ayudhia Nath C-134 And Others v. State Of Punjab And Another
A.L Bahri, J.:— Ayudhia Nath four other petitioners are employed as Conductors in the Punjab Roadways, Pathankot Depot. They pray for issuing a writ under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution for quashing the order Annexure P/1 whereby they have been transferred from Pathankot to other Stations. The General Manager, Punjab Roadways, Pathankot passed order on July 26, 1987 transferring the petitioner and other employees about 125 in number to various other depots of Punjab Roadways outside Pathankot Division. This was done without any authority and in violation of the policy decision. There are three divisions of Punjab Roadways at Ferozepur, Jalandhar and Chandigarh. There are several depots under the Divisions. The employees are working in each depot separately under the control of the General Manager of particular depot. The services of the employees are governed by the Punjab Roadways Operational State Service Class III Rules, 1977. The seniority of the employees is maintained at the depot level. Sometime back a decision was taken that as and when some buses of one depot are transferred to another depot corresponding staff would also be transferred. One Page: 344seniormost and one juniormost and so on would be transferred. (Extract of transfer policy is Annexure P/2). It was decided to transfer some buses of Pathankot Depot to other depots. The details of the buses so ordered to be transferred are mentioned in the writ petition. While passing the impugned order of transfer of the petitioners, policy adopted by the Committee constituting Divisional Manager shri B.S Sudan, D.D.S.T Shri I.S Sarda, Mechanical Engineer, Shri B.S Sandhu and General Manager, Punjab Roadways Pathankot Shri Lakhminder Singh was not adhered to. Under the policy firstly options were to be invited from the employees for their transfer to the stations where buses were to be transferred. If the number of persons opting was less than the number of persons to be transferred then under this policy one seniormost and one juniormost in all the cadres were to be transferred. However, while passing the impugned order this policy was ignored. Under Rule 12 of the Rules it was State Government who could transfer one employee from one depot to another or to another Division. The General Manager of the Pathankot depot on its own could not pass the order of transfer. It was asserted in the writ petition that seniormost as well as juniormost employees were still working in the Pathankot Depot whereas the petitioners were arbitrarily picked up for transfer. The stand of the respondents in the written statement filed by General Manager, Punjab Roadways, Pathankot Depot is that the transfer has been made in accordance with the policy decision. However, it may be noticed that on facts it is not disputed that seniormost and juniormost officers were not effected by the transfer order. With respect to Rule 12 of the Rules it was stated that the decision to transfer was taken by the State Government and the General Manager has only given effect to the policy decision of the Government. Copies of order of transfer of different petitioners were filed. In the replication filed by the petitioner the stand of the respondents has been controverted.
2. Since it is an admitted case that a policy decision was taken to transfer alongwith buses corresponding staff to other depots, it was expected of the respondents to follow the said policy.
3. As stated in the written statement options were taken. However, the number of Government employees opting was less than the persons to be transferred and in accordance with the policy decision the impugned order (Annexure P/1) was issued. This stand does not appear to be correct. In para 16 of the Writ Petition it was alleged by the petitioners that there are conductors who were appointed in the year 1981 to 1986, who appear in the seniority list at S. Nos. 185 to 317 and were junior-most were still retained. Their details are given in Annexure P.3 Similarly, there were 31 Senior-most conductors who were appointed during the period 1962 to 1966 and who were above the petitioners were also retained. In reply to this para, in the written statement this position was admitted that some conductors who were junior-most and senior-most were not affected by the order of transfer. It is surprising that in view of this admitted fact the respondents still assert that the order of transfer was in accordance with the policy formulated. Rajasthan High Court in Asu Singh v. State Of Rajasthan (1983(3) Services Law Reporter, 783) observed that it was not open to the State not to follow the guidelines or instructions in the matter of transfer. The Supreme Court in B. Varadha Rao v. State of Karnataka Page: 345[1986(3) Services Law Reporter 60] held that transfer of a Government servant who is appointed to a particular cadre of transferable post from one place to another is ordinary incident of service and therefore, does not result in any alteration of any of the conditions of service to his disadvantage. It was further observed in para 5 of the judgment that if power of transfer is abused, the exercise of the power is vitiated. The matter was also under consideration of this Court in Dina Nath Arora v. State of Punjab [1987(2) Services Law Reporter 19] decided by GokaTChand Mital, J. Under the policy decision mid-term transfers Were prohibited except in compelling circumstances and that too after approval of the next higher authority or the Chief Minister through Chief Secretary. No compelling circumstances were brought on the record and the order of transfer was held to be violative of the policy framed by the Government. Keeping in view the ratio of the decision referred to above and the policy framed by the State in the matter of transfer of buses to other depots with corresponding staff, I find that the impugned order of transfer was in clear violation of the aforesaid policy as persons seniormost and juniormost were still retained at Pathankot whereas petitioners who had not opted were ordered to be transferred while passing the impugned order (AnnexureP/1).
4. For the reasons recorded above, this writ petition is allowed with costs. Counsel's fee Rs. 500/-. Order dated July 26, 1987 (Annexure P/1) as regards the petitioners transfer is quashed.
5. Petition allowed.
Alert