Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/S. Krishnanath Balkrishna And Co. v. Rai Bahadur Seth Ram Ratan

Bombay High Court
Dec 22, 1960
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a summary suit. The defendant had been granted leave to defend subject to conditions. The defendant failed to carry out those conditions, and the suit was set down for judgment. At the hearing the defendant's counsel (Mr. Thakkar) sought an order permitting payment of the decretal amount by instalments. The plaintiffs' counsel (Mr. Chhaya) objected, contending that leave to defend had become in-fructuous and that the defendant was therefore not entitled to appear. Counsel for the plaintiffs relied on the decision in Pestonji v. Jamshedji. The Court considered amendments made by this High Court (under s. 122) to O. XXXVII, r. 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure (1936) and the present provisions permitting appearance without leave though leave is still required to defend.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a defendant whose leave to defend has become in-fructuous by failure to fulfil conditions may still appear at the hearing and apply for payment of the decretal amount by instalments.
  2. Whether the precedent in Pestonji v. Jamshedji controls when the local amendment to O. XXXVII, r. 3 (post‑1936) permits appearance without leave.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendant (through Mr. Thakkar) sought to apply for payment of the decretal amount by instalments at the hearing.

Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • Mr. Chhaya objected that, because the defendant had failed to fulfil the conditions on which leave to defend was granted (rendering that leave in-fructuous), the defendant was not entitled to appear; relying on Pestonji v. Jamshedji.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pestonji v. Jamshedji . 1925 28 Bom. L.R 138. Held that in a summary suit under O. XXXVII, a defendant who has obtained no leave to defend (or whose leave to defend is rendered in-fructuous) cannot appear at the hearing and ask the Court to make the decretal amount payable by instalments; such a defendant must apply for instalments under O. XX, r. 11(2) or O. XXXVII, r. 4. The Court distinguished this ratio on the basis that the applicable provisions had been amended for this High Court (under s.122) in 1936 so that a defendant need not obtain leave to file appearance (only to defend). The Court treated the ratio as limited to rules in force in 1925 and held that under the amended O. XXXVII, r. 3 the defendant may appear and apply for instalments.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted the distinction between the pre‑1936 rule and the post‑1936 amendment made by this High Court under s. 122: originally O. XXXVII, r. 3 did not permit a defendant to appear without leave; after amendment a defendant may appear without leave though leave remains necessary to defend. The Court referred to Sub‑rule (4) of r. 3 as amended, which directs that if a defendant permitted to defend fails to complete security or comply with directions within the time limited, the plaintiff shall be entitled to judgment forthwith. Because the defendant had failed to fulfil the conditions, the plaintiffs were entitled to judgment and the defendant could not be heard on matters constituting a defence. However, the Court reasoned that an application for instalments is not a defence but seeks the decree to be made payable by instalments; accordingly the defendant was entitled to appear and to apply for instalments under O. XX, r. 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Holding and Implications

Decree granted; defendant permitted to pay the decretal amount by instalments.

Direct effect on the parties: Decree as prayed was entered. The defendant is ordered to pay the decretal amount in monthly instalments of Rs. 10,000 each, the first payable on or before January 15, 1961, and subsequent instalments on or before the 15th day of each succeeding month. In default of payment of any two instalments the whole decretal amount or unpaid balance shall become payable forthwith. Two‑thirds of the institution fee is to be repaid to the plaintiffs.

No broader precedent was announced beyond the Court's application of the amended O. XXXVII, r. 3 to permit appearance for the limited purpose of applying for instalments; the decision addresses the parties' rights in this proceeding.

Show all summary ...

Mody, J.:— This is a summary suit for disposal. In this suit the defendant was granted leave to defend but on certain conditions. The defendant has failed to carry out those conditions and the suit has, therefore, been set down for judgment.

2. Mr. Thakkar appears for the defendant and states that he wants to apply for instalments. Mr. Chhaya, the learned counsel for the plaintiffs, raises a preliminary objection that Mr. Thakkar is not entitled to appear at all in this suit inasmuch as the leave granted to the defendant to defend has become in-fructuous as the conditions on which that leave was granted have not been fulfilled.

3. In support of his argument Mr. Chhaya has relied upon the judgment in the case of Pestonji v. Jamshedji . 1925 28 Bom. L.R 138.. In that case it was held that in a summary suit brought under the provisions of O. XXXVII of the Civil Procedure Code, the defendant, who has obtained no leave to defend, cannot appear at the hearing and ask the Court to make the decretal amount payable by instalments and that the only way open to such a defendant is to apply for instalments either under O. XX, r. 11(2), or under O. XXXVII, r. 4 of the Civil Procedure Code. What is to be noted in this connection is, however, that the relevant provisions of the law at the time when that judgment was given were substantially different in this respect from those applying at the present time. That judgment was given in 1925 and what applied then were the provisions of O. XXXVII, r. 3, of the Civil Procedure Code. Under O. XXXVII, r. 3, it was not open to a defendant not only to defend, the suit but even to appear in the suit except with the leave of the Court. So far as this High Court is concerned, this High Court has, under the provisions of s. 122 of the Civil Procedure Code, made certain amendments in the Civil Procedure Code. Those amendments were made in 1936 i.e after the said judgment in Pestonji v. Jamshedji. After the said amendments the provision as now contained in O. XXXVII, r. 3 is substantially different from that contained in the original r. 3 of O. XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure. Under the provisions of the said r. 3 as amended by this High Court it is now not necessary for the defendant to obtain the leave of the Court for filing his appearance, although it continues to be necessary for him to obtain the leave of the Court to defend the suit. Therefore, there is a material distinction between the original rule as applicable to this High Court before 1936 and the amended rule as now applicable to this High Court after 1936. Under the old provisions not only could the defendant not defend the suit but he could not even appear in the suit without the leave of the Court. Under the new provisions the leave of the Court is not necessary for appearing in the suit but it is necessary only for the purpose of defending the suit. Sub-rule (4) of r. 3 as amended provides that if the defendant be permitted to defend as to the whole or any part of the claim the Judge shall direct (on the summons for judgment) that on failure to complete the security (if any) or to carry out such other directions as the Judge may have given within the time limited in the order, the plaintiff shall be entitled to judgment forthwith. In this case there were conditions imposed by the order which granted leave to the defendant to defend. Those conditions have not been fulfilled. Under that order, therefore, the plaintiffs have become entitled to a judgment forthwith. The defendant cannot, therefore, now be allowed to urge any defence whatever. What the defendant is now applying for however is not for being heard in his defence but he is making an application on the footing that a decree may be passed as applied for by the plaintiffs but that decree be made payable by instalments.

4. In my opinion, therefore, the defendant is at this stage entitled to appear. The ratio of the judgment in Pestonji v. Jamshedji is that as the defendant who had not obtained leave to defend or who had been granted leave to defend but only on conditions and who had failed to fulfil the conditions was not entitled even to appear in the suit, he could not appear at the final hearing of the suit and as he could not at all appear he could not apply for instalments at such hearing. Under the amended provisions, however, he is entitled to appear without leave. Although he has not fulfilled the conditions on which he was granted leave to defend, he can still appear and he has to be heard. The points on which he can be heard, however, must be other than those urged by way of his defence. The defendant cannot now be heard on anything which can be said to be by way of his defence to the claim in the suit. In my opinion, therefore, as the application for instalments is not by way of a defence but as a matter of fact proceeds on the footing that a decree be passed as asked for by the plaintiffs, it is open to the defendant to appear at this hearing and to apply for instalments under the provisions of O. XX, r. 11, of the Code of Civil Procedure.

5. On the facts placed before me I am satisfied that I should grant to the defendant instalments which I will presently order.

6. Decree as prayed.

7. The defendant to pay the decretal amount in instalments of Rs. 10,000 each per month. The first of such monthly instalments to be paid on or before January 15, 1961 and the subsequent of such monthly instalments to be paid on or before the 15th day of each succeeding month thereafter. In default of payment of any two instalments the whole of the decretal amount or the unpaid balance thereof, as the case may be, to become payable forthwith. Two-thirds of the institution fee to be repaid to the plaintiffs.

Solicitors for the defendant: Vakil Dadabhoy & Bharucha.