Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Samalbhai Nathubhai v. Someshvar, Mangal

Bombay High Court
Aug 2, 1880

M. Melvill, J.:— This is not the case of an ordinary partnership, arising out of contract. It is the case of joint ownership in a trading business, created through the operation of Hindu law between the members of an undivided Hindu family. The rights and liabilties arising out of such a relation cannot be determined, (as the District Judge has determined them), by exclusive reference to the Indian Contract Act, but must be considered also with regard to the general rules of Hindu law, which regulate the transactions of united families.

As stated in Ramlal v. Lakhmichund(1) an ancestral trade may descend, like other inheritable property, upon the members of a Hindu undivided family. The partnership so created, or surviving, has many, but not all, of the elements existing in an ordinary partnership. For example, the death of one of the partners does not dissolve the partnership. Nor, as a rule, can one of the partners, when severing his connection with the business, ask for an account of past profits and losses.

Whether a Hindu, who becomes entitled by inheritance, to a share in a trading business, is, ipso facto, and without his own consent, involved in all the liabilities of a partner, it is not necessary for us to determine. In the present case, we find sufficient reason for holding the respondeat Mangal liable for the plaintiff's claim. The three respondents are brothers, and admittedly a united family. The trading business, in respect of which the claim has arisen, was started by Jivram Haribhai, father of the respondents. At that time, and down to Jivram's death, Jivram and his sons lived together as a joint family. The presumption (which is not rebutted) is that the business was started by means of joint family funds. It, therefore, became the joint property of Jivram and his sons. After Jivram's death, Mangal continued to live with his brother for a year; but since that time he has generally been absent from Kapadvanj, whore the firm is carried on. The business has been, continued in the name of Jivram Haribhai, but has been managed by the eldest brother Someshvar only, Mangal having been absent, and the third respondent being a minor. We cannot agree with the District Judge that these circumstances entitle Mangal to repudiate a liability arising out of the ordinary transactions of the firm. During his father's lifetime he was joint owner of the firm of Jivram Haribhai. After his father's death he acquiesced in the continuance of the firm under the same name, and ostensibly, therefore, with the same constitution. He has never done any act to divest himself of his share in the business. He has given no notice of repudiation and has made no partition with his brothers. He has only been absent for six years; and there would, therefore, be nothing to prevent him from demanding his share of the partnership stock, or claiming to share in the profits. We can see no reason for exempting him from the ordinary rule of Hindu law, which makes every member of a united family liable for debts properly incurred by a manager for the benefit of the family. The eldest brother Someshwar must be regarded as manager on behalf of the family of so much of the family property as is represented by the trading business; and it has never been suggested that the debt due to the plaintiff, for goods supplied to the shop, was not properly and necessarily incurred in the course of the ordinary transactions of the firm, and presumably, therefore, for the benefit of all the joint owners of the firm.

For these reasons we reverse the decree of the District Court, and restore that of the Subordinate Judge. Costs of appeal and second appeal on respondent Mangal.

Decree reversed.