Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Larsen & Toubro Ltd. v. D.L.F Industries Ltd. .

Delhi High Court
Aug 2, 2002
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed an application under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, along with Order 1, Rule 10 read with Section 151 CPC, seeking impleadment of additional parties in a dispute arising from a subscription agreement dated 16th May, 1994 between the petitioner and DLF Industries Ltd. The respondent, DLF Industries Ltd., moved an application under Order 7, Rule 11 read with Section 151 CPC stating that it had been amalgamated with DLF Universal Ltd. pursuant to a court order dated 8th August, 2000. Additionally, the respondent had sold its entire shareholding to Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. and entered into a supplementary agreement dated 4th February, 2000 whereby Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. assumed all rights and obligations under the subscription agreement. The petitioner prayed for impleadment of DLF Universal Ltd. and Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. as respondents 2 and 3 respectively. Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. alone filed a reply to the application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether DLF Universal Ltd. and Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. should be impleaded as respondents in the arbitration petition based on the amalgamation and shareholding transfer.
  2. Whether the arbitration clause in the subscription agreement binds Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. as successor and/or assigns of DLF Industries Ltd.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner sought impleadment of DLF Universal Ltd. and Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. as respondents, citing amalgamation of DLF Industries Ltd. with DLF Universal Ltd. and the transfer of shareholding to Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • DLF Industries Ltd. stated it was amalgamated with DLF Universal Ltd. by court order dated 8th August, 2000.
  • Respondent pointed out that Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. assumed all rights and obligations under the subscription agreement pursuant to a supplementary agreement dated 4th February, 2000.
  • DLF Universal Ltd. argued that since the amalgamation occurred after the supplementary agreement, it had no rights or obligations under the subscription agreement and thus should not be impleaded.

Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd.’s Position

  • Filed a reply acknowledging its role as successor and assignee with respect to the subscription agreement and its obligations under the arbitration clause.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the subscription agreement dated 16th May, 1994, which included an arbitration clause and a binding provision on successors and assigns. The supplementary agreement of 4th February, 2000 established that Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. assumed all rights, obligations, and responsibilities under the subscription agreement from DLF Industries Ltd., including indemnifying the seller and cooperating with it. The court noted the amalgamation order dated 8th August, 2000, which merged DLF Industries Ltd. into DLF Universal Ltd. However, since the rights and obligations had already been transferred to Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. before the amalgamation, DLF Universal Ltd. did not hold any such rights or obligations under the subscription agreement. Consequently, the court concluded that only Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. needed to be impleaded as a respondent, and impleadment of DLF Universal Ltd. was unnecessary. The arbitration clause was held to bind Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. as successor and/or assign.

Holding and Implications

The court partly allowed the application and directed that Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. be impleaded as respondent No. 2 in the arbitration petition. The petitioner was ordered to file an amended petition within two weeks. The court held that DLF Universal Ltd. need not be impleaded as it holds no rights or obligations under the subscription agreement post-amalgamation. The decision directly affects the parties by clarifying the proper respondents in the arbitration proceedings and confirms that the arbitration clause binds the successor and assigns. No new precedent was set by this ruling.

Show all summary ...

K.S Gupta, J.:— In the petition under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 petitioner filed this application under Order 1, Rule 10 read with Section 151 CPC alleging that in response to the petition, DLF Industries Ltd., respondent moved an application under Order 7, Rule 11 read with Section 151 CPC on 6th January, 2001 wherein it is stated that respondent had been amalgamated with DLF Universal Ltd. vide order dated 8th August, 2000 passed in Company Petition No. 58/2000 by this Court. During the pendency of agreement dated 16th May, 1994, the respondent sold off their entire shareholding to Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. and have further entered into a supplementary agreement dated 4th February, 2000 with it whereby Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. will take up all matters directly with the petitioner in relation to the subscription agreement. It was prayed that DLF Universal Ltd. and Gujarat Ambuja Cement Ltd. be impleaded as respondents 2 and 3 respectively.

2. Needless to say that Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. alone has filed reply to the application.

3. I have heard Shri Bharat Sangal for petitioner, Anil Seth for DLF Universal Ltd. and Shri Manmohan for Gujarat Ambuja Cement Ltd.

4. Copy of subscription agreement dated 16th May, 1994 entered into in between DLF Industries Ltd., respondent and Larsen & Toubro Ltd., petitioner is placed at pages 15 to 23 on the file.

5. Bare perusal thereof would show that petitioner had agreed to subscribe to the Public issue of Multi Option Convertible Debentures (MOCD) to be issued by DLF Cements Ltd. to the extent of Rs. 3,33,54,000 out of the promoter's quota and within six months from the date of issue of MOCD, the respondent had to buy from the petitioner who was bound to dispose of its equity holding to the respondent or any other party nominated by the respondent, at the price which was to be calculated in the manner set out in para No. 8 of the agreement. Para 15 of the agreement provides for arbitration. Para 18 thereof which is material, provides as under:

“This agreement shall enure to the benefit of and shall be binding upon the parties hereto and their successors and assigns.”

6. Paras 3 and 4 of Supplementary agreement to share purchase agreement dated 4th February, 2000 executed in between DLF Industries Ltd. (Seller) and Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. (Purchaser) (Copy Annexure R-II filed along with list of documents dated 6th January 2001) are reproduced below:

“(3) The seller has represented that though, Larsen & Toubro Limited (L&T), F.L Smidth & Co., A/s (FLS) and the Industrialization Fund for Developing Countries (IFU) who together hold equity shares of the face value of Rs. 10.00 crores approx. in the paid-up equity capital of the Company, are considered to be associates of the seller (as promoters of the Company), the Seller does not have any control over them and the agreements between the Seller and L&T dated May 16, 1994 (subscription agreement) and between the Seller, IFU and FLS dated April 12, 1994 (share purchase agreement) have been furnished to the purchaser.

7. The purchase shall take up all matters directly with FLS and IFU in relation to the share purchase agreement and with L&T in relation to the subscription agreement, as all rights, obligations and responsibilities for complying with the terms of the share purchase agreement and subscription agreement have been assumed by the purchaser and the purchaser will at all times keep the seller indemnified against all claims arising against the seller under the share purchase agreement and subscription agreement. The seller shall, however, cooperate with the purchaser and shall do such acts, deeds and things and execute such documents and writings as may be required by the purchaser in relation thereto.”

8. Order dated 8th August, 2000 passed in Company petition No. 58/2000 connected with Company Application No. 1765/99 (Copy Annexure R- I filed along with list of documents dated 6th January, 2001) would reveal that said DLF Industries Ltd. was amalgamated with DLF Universal Ltd. As the rights/obligations/responsibilities for complying with the terms of aforesaid subscription agreement dated 16th May, 1994 had been assumed by Gujarat Ambuja Cement Ltd. pursuant to said para 4, it being the successor and assigns of DLF Industries Ltd. needs to be impleaded as respondent in the petition. Since amalgamation of DLF Industries Ltd. with DLF Universal Ltd. was ordered subsequently on 8th August, 2000 the DLF Universal Ltd. could not have any rights/obligations/responsibilities under the said subscription agreement towards Larsen & Toubro Ltd. and, therefore, its impleadment is not necessary as a respondent. Needless to say that arbitration clause as contained in said subscription agreement will be binding on Gujarat Ambuja Cement Ltd., it being successor and/or assigns of DLF Industries Ltd.

9. Thus, while partly allowing the application, Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. is directed to be impleaded as respondent No. 2 in the petition.

10. Amended copy of petition be filed by the petitioner within two weeks.

11. Application partly allowed.