Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Smt. Maya Devi v. State Of N.C.T Of Delhi And Another

Delhi High Court
Oct 1, 2007
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition under section 227 of the Constitution of India read with section 482, Cr. P.C. challenges the order dated 19th September 2007 passed by the Metropolitan Magistrate in a Domestic Violence Application. The impugned order directed that the complainant, Ms. Jay Shree, not be dispossessed from the shared household at the matrimonial house located at F-304, Mansarover Garden, Ramesh Nagar, New Delhi. The complainant was residing with her parents at the time and had requested to be allowed to stay at the shared household. The Protection Officer and SHO were directed to ensure compliance with the order, with a report to be filed before the Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India and section 482, Cr. P.C. is maintainable against the order passed by the Magistrate under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005.
  2. Whether the petitioner should have availed the specific remedies provided under the Domestic Violence Act, namely modification, alteration, revocation of orders by the Magistrate or appeal to the Court of Session.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
N.P Ponnuswami v. Returning Officer, Namakkal Constituency (1952 SCR 218) Where a statute creates a right or liability and provides a special remedy for enforcing it, that remedy alone must be availed of. The Court relied on this principle to hold that since the Domestic Violence Act provides specific remedies, the High Court should not entertain a petition under section 482 Cr.P.C. or Article 227 of the Constitution.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted that the Domestic Violence Act, 2005, under which the Magistrate passed the impugned order, specifically empowers the Magistrate to modify, alter, or revoke orders upon application and provides an appeal mechanism to the Court of Session within thirty days. Sections 25 and 29 of the Act were cited to emphasize these provisions. The Court reasoned that since a specific remedy is available under the Act, the petitioner cannot bypass it by invoking the High Court’s jurisdiction under Article 227 or section 482 Cr.P.C. The Court further relied on established precedent to reinforce that when a special remedy is provided by statute, that remedy must be pursued exclusively. The petitioner had not availed the remedies under the Domestic Violence Act and directly approached the High Court, rendering the petition misconceived and not maintainable.

Holding and Implications

The petition is dismissed with costs of Rs. 2,500/-.

The petitioner is directed to deposit the costs with the Trial Court within one month, failing which the Trial Court shall recover the same according to law. The decision directly affects the parties by dismissing the petition for lack of maintainability and emphasizes adherence to the statutory remedies provided under the Domestic Violence Act, without setting any new precedent.

Show all summary ...

V.B Gupta, J.:— The present petition is filed under section 227 of the Constitution of India read with section 482, Cr. P.C for quashing of the order dated 19th September, 2007 passed by learned Metropolitan Magistrate, Delhi in the Domestic Violence Application.

2. The impugned order, relevant for the disposal of present petition reads as under—

“No site plan of the shared household at matrimonial house is available on record. Learned Counsel seeks some time to file the same. At present complainant is stated to be residing with her parents In her petition she has made a request that she be allowed to stay at the shared household at matrimonial house.

In view of the submissions of complainant and DIR, it is hereby directed that complainant namely Ms. Jay Shree be not dispossessed from shared household at matrimonial house, i.e, F-304, Mansarover Garden, Ramesh Nagar, New Delhi. The order be complied with by the Protection Officer with the assistance of SHO concerned. The report in this behalf be filed before the Court on or before 9.10.2007 at 1 p.m Copy of order be given dasti for compliance.

MM/DELHI/19.9.2007”

3. At the outset, it may be pointed out that the impugned order has been passed by the learned Magistrate under The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005. As per this Act, the Magistrate has got ample power to modify, alter or revoke any order made under it and further there is specific provision for filing of appeal to the Court of Session against the order of Magistrate under the Act. The relevant provisions in this regard are sections 25 and 29 of the Act, which read as under:—

“25. Duration and alteration of orders:—

(1) A protection order made under section 18 shall be in force till the aggrieved person applies for discharge.

(2) If the Magistrate, on receipt of an application from the aggrieved person or the respondent, is satisfied that there is a change in the circumstances requiring alteration, modification or revocation of any order made under this Act, he may, for reasons to be recorded in writing pass such order, as he may deem appropriate.

29. Appeal.—There shall lie an appeal to the Court of Session within thirty days from the date on which the order made by the Magistrate is served on the aggrieved person or the respondent, as the case may be, whichever is later.”

4. So, according to section 25 of the Act, any aggrieved person may make an application before the Magistrate and the Magistrate after being satisfied that there is change in the circumstances requiring alteration, modification and revocation of any order made under this Act, he may, for reasons to be recorded in writing pass such order, as he may deem appropriate.

5. Section 29 of the Act provides for appeal to the Court of Session within thirty days from the date on which the order made by the Magistrate is served on the aggrieved person or the respondent.

6. When specific remedy by way of appeal or by way of alteration, modification or revocation of any order, has been provided under the Act, prima facie, the present petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, or section 482, Cr. P.C is not maintainable before this Court.

7. It has been laid down in various judicial decisions by this Court as well as by the Apex Court that where the specific remedy is open to the party under specific Act, the High Court will not interfere under section 482 of Cr. P.C In case of N.P Ponnuswami v. Returning Officer, Namakkal Constituency . 1952 SCR 218., the Apex Court has laid down that:—

“where a right or liability is created by a statute which gives a I special remedy for enforcing it, the remedy provided by that statute only must be availed off.”

8. Here, in the case in hand, the Act under which the Magistrate has passed the impugned order, specifically provide the remedy by way of appeal or by way of modification, alteration etc.

9. So, admittedly the petitioner has got alternative remedy under the Domestic Violence Act which she has not availed of and has straightway approached this Court.

10. Under these circumstances, the present petition is misconceived and is not maintainable and same is hereby dismissed with costs of Rs. 2,500/-.

11. The petitioner is directed to deposit the costs with the Trial Court within one month from the date of this order, failing which the Trial Court shall recover the same in accordance with law. Copy of this judgment be sent to the Trial Court forthwith.

12. Petition Dismissed.