- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Atanasio Monseratte v. State Of Goa
Factual and Procedural Background
The petition was heard by F.M. Reis, J. Counsel for the petitioners (Mr. Nitin Sardessai, Senior Counsel) and for respondents No. 1 and 2 (Mr. A.N.S. Nadkarni, Advocate General) and respondent No. 3 (Mr. S.N. Joshi) appeared. The petitioners challenged the timeline for completion of delimitation and for notifying reserved seats under the City of Corporation of Panaji Act, 2002, in relation to issuance of the municipal election Notification by respondent No. 3. The respondents waived service and the matter was heard forthwith with their consent.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the delimitation process must be completed at least 30 days before issuance of the municipal election Notification.
- Whether reservation of seats under Section 10 of the City of Corporation of Panaji Act, 2002 must be completed at least 30 days prior to issuance of the municipal election Notification.
- Whether the Court can or should fix a time limit for notifying reserved seats, given the statute's silence and the legislative/consultative nature of the process.
- If a time limit is appropriate, what is a reasonable gap between notification of reserved seats and the municipal election Notification.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The delimitation process must be completed at least 30 days before the municipal election Notification.
- Reservation of seats under Section 10 must likewise be completed at least 30 days prior; alternatively, a reasonable time limit of at least 15 days should be fixed for completing reservation.
Respondents No. 1 & 2 (State) Arguments
- The Advocate General, on instructions of the Director of Municipal Administration, stated the delimitation Notification under Section 9(2) of the City of Corporation of Panaji Act, 2002 would be issued on or before 11 January 2016.
- No time limit can be fixed by the Court for notifying reserved seats because it is a legislative process and the statute does not prescribe any time limit.
Respondent No. 3's Arguments
- Notification of reserved seats requires consultation with the State Government and, in normal course, the process takes about 15 days.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court considered the submissions of all parties and accepted the Advocate General's statement that the delimitation Notification under Section 9(2) would be issued on or before 11 January 2016. The Court recognised that notifying reserved seats involves a consultative/legislative process and that a reasonable time-gap is justified between the date of the notification of reserved seats and the date of the municipal election Notification. Balancing the petitioners' request for a fixed period and the respondents' position that the statute prescribes no limit, the Court exercised its supervisory power to prescribe a practical timeline while noting the legislative/consultative character of the reservation process.
Holding and Implications
Rule disposed of.
Holding: The Court accepted the respondents' undertaking that delimitation Notification under Section 9(2) will be issued on or before 11 January 2016, and directed the concerned authorities to take all steps to issue the notification notifying the reserved seats preferably 10 days prior to issuance of the municipal election Notification.
Implications: The direct effect is a Court-directed timeline—preferably a 10-day gap between the notification of reserved seats and the election Notification—and disposal of the Rule in the terms stated. The opinion does not state any broader precedent being established.
F.M Reis, J.:— Heard Mr. Nitin Sardessai, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners, Mr. A.N.S Nadkarni, learned Advocate General appearing for the respondents No. 1 and 2 and Mr. S.N Joshi, learned Counsel appearing for the respondent No. 3.
2. Rule. Learned Counsel appearing for the respondents waive service. Heard forthwith, with the consent of the learned Counsel.
3. The main grievance of Mr. Nitin Sardessai, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners is that the delimitation process has to be completed, according to him, at least 30 days before issuance of Notification of the subject municipal elections by the Respondent No. 3. The learned Senior Counsel further points out that even the reservation of seats in terms of Section 10 of the City of Corporation of Panaji Act, 2002 has to be completed, according to him, at least 30 days prior to issuance of such a Notification. The learned Senior Counsel, however, submits that a reasonable time limit of at least 15 days is to be fixed to complete the exercise of reservation of seats.
4. Mr. A.N.S Nadkarni, learned Advocate General appearing for the respondents No. 1 and 2, upon instructions of the Director of Municipal Administration who is present in the Court, states that the Notification with regard to delimitation in terms of Section 9(2) of the City of Corporation of Panaji Act, 2002 would be issued on or before 11th January, 2016. But, however, according to the learned Advocate General no time limit can be fixed by the Court to notify the reserved seats, as it is a legislative process and the statute itself does not provide for any time limit.
5. Mr. S.N Joshi, learned Counsel appearing for the respondent No. 3 points out that such an exercise of notifying the reserved seats has to be carried out with the consultation of the State Government and according to him, in normal course, such process takes about 15 days.
6. Taking note of the aforesaid submissions, we accept the statement of the learned Advocate General that the Notification with regard to delimitation in terms of Section 9(2) of the City of Corporation of Panaji Act, 2002 would be issued on or before 11 January, 2016.
7. As far as the Notification, notifying the reserved seats is concerned, we find that a reasonable time-gap would be justified between date of such Notification and the date of Notification for the subject Municipal election.
8. In such circumstances, we direct the concerned authorities to take all steps to issue such notification, notifying the reserved seats preferably 10 days prior to issuance of such notification for the subject Municipal election.
9. Rule stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms, with no order as to costs.
Alert