- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Chandigarh Administration Petitioner v. State Of Haryana And Others S
SANJAY KISHAN KAUL C.J (Oral)
Jai Gopal Verma, respondent No. 3, retired from service in the year 2003 and the present petition raises the issue as to whether he was an employee of the petitioner-Chandigarh Administration or the State of Haryana-respondents No. 1 and 2 for the purposes of pension.
The order dated 12.11.1968 of the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India (Annexure P-3) is relied upon by all the parties. The same reads as under:-
“ORDER:-
In exercise of the powers conferred by Sub-section (2) of Section 82 of the Punjab Reorganization Act, 1966 (3) of 1966 the Central Government hereby determines that all persons belonging to the Education Department who immediately before the appointed day were serving in connection with the affairs of the State of Punjab in the territories specified in section 4 of the said Act, and who were required provisionally to serve in connection with the affairs of the Union Territory of Chandigarh in Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs Order No. 22/6(II)66SR (S) dated the 24th October, 1966, shall be deemed to have been finally allotted to the Union Territory of Chandigarh with effect from the Ist November, 1966.
Sd/- B. Shukla,
Deputy Secretary to Govt. of India.”
The aforesaid thus shows that the critical date is 24.10.1966 to determine as to who was to be allocated to Union Territory, Chandigarh and the same position is applicable qua respondent No. 3.
Respondent No. 3 approached the Central Administrative Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench vide O.A No. 762-HR-2006 seeking pension from the petitioner herein on the ground that in view of the aforesaid office order he becomes the employee of Union Territory, Chandigarh. This plea was supported by the State of Haryana but was disputed by the petitioner/Union Territory, Chandigarh.
The defence of the petitioner before the Tribunal was predicated on the findings recorded earlier in O.A No. 267-CH-1987 which was a petition filed by 10 petitioners where respondent No. 3 herein was the 10 petitioner. That petition dealt with the claim for consideration of promotion to the post of Superintendent/Administrative Officer in District Education Officer where a finding was recorded against respondent No. 3 that he belongs to the Haryana State Cadre on account of one document which shows adverse remarks recorded on his work and conduct which in turn was modified by the Director of School Education, Haryana dated 28.8.1986 We may note that even the petitioner did not place the relevant orders before the Tribunal qua respondent No. 3 nor are they placed before us in respect of allocation of respondent No. 3 i.e whether to the Union Territory, Chandigarh or not. The Tribunal found that the principle of resjudicata would not apply and the observations in the earlier proceedings were per-incurium as the State of Haryana was not a party and had been given no opportunity to defend itself. We may note that admissibility of pension to respondent No. 3 is not in question and the issue is only as to on whom the burden falls i.e the petitioner or respondent No. 1-State of Haryana. It is thus really lis inter-se these two parties which was to be adjudicated in the Original Application from which the present proceedings arise. The Tribunal herein has found in favour of the respondent's stand.
The reasoning of the Tribunal is contained in para No. 13. The Government Co-Educational High School, Manimajra became part of Union Territory of Chandigarh and respondent No. 3 is stated to have been deployed in that school. Thus, in terms of the office order referred to aforesaid, the services of respondent No. 3 in the composite State of Punjab were placed with the Union Territory, Chandigarh. Not only that even the promotion has been made by the petitioner herein while no promotion order has been passed by the State of Haryana. It was thus found that if respondent No. 3 was not part of the Union Territory Cadre, there would have been no occasion for promotion order to have been passed qua him by the petitioner. Infact, Annexure P-5 dated 29.09.1996 is a communication relied upon which had been issued by the petitioner asking respondent No. 3 and others as to whether they were interested in promotion against certain posts available. In case of deputation, such an offer ought not to have been made to respondent No. 3 but at best it would have been communicated to the parent department. This was followed by a promotion order of respondent No. 3 and others and vide Annexure P-7 dated 12.11.1969 respondent No. 3 was again adjusted as Accountant in Manimajra School. He was thereafter notionally promoted as Accountant/Assistant vide order dated 14.11.1990 (Annexure P-8). This order, however, mentions respondent No. 3 as deputationist but also mentions in regard to re-fixation of seniority from the original date of promotion the matter was being sorted out. No communications in this behalf have been addressed to the State of Haryana.
We are in agreement with the view taken by the Tribunal. Firstly, the notification makes it clear as to who is to be allocated where. The engagement of respondent No. 3 at the Manimajra School, which became part of Union Territory, Chandigarh thus does not leave this in doubt. This is not sole factor as even promotion offer was made to respondent No. 3 and promotion was also made thereafter. In this behalf no communications were marked to the State of Haryana though one of the communications referred to respondent No. 3 as deputationist. What is most material is that the petitioner has failed to place on record the list which must have been drawn at the relevant stage to show as to who all were absorbed in Union Territory, Chandigarh cadre, a material document in possession of the petitioner. It is not an adversarial suit in which respondent No. 3 ought to have produced a document to substantiate onus on him. The petitioner was the employer. The petitioner could have easily produced the relevant official documents to substantiate their stand or otherwise by producing the list of the persons who were absorbed in the Union Territory cadre. This they have failed to do. We may also note that respondent No. 3 is a 71 years old pensioner and at this stage he should not be made to run from one Government to another on account of inter-se conflict among the Governments as to who would pay the pension. The factum of service of respondent No. 3 with the petitioner for a period of 38 years is in any case not in doubt.
Dismissed.
Alert