Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kiran Antariksh Ukey v. Research Officer

Bombay High Court
Jan 27, 2015

ORAL JUDGMENT (PER P.N DESHMUKH, J.):

Rule. Rule is made returnable forthwith. Heard finally by consent of learned Counsel for the parties. Both these petitions can be disposed of by this common judgment.

2) The petitioners are convicted for the offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 of Indian Penal Code and sentenced to suffer imprisonment for life. Presently, petitioner no. 1 is lodged in Open Jail at Nagpur and petitioner no. 2, who is wife of petitioner no. 1, is lodged in Women Cell, Central Jail, Nagpur. By the present petitions, the petitioners have challenged the communication dated 22/9/2014 issued by respondent no. 2 and sought direction to respondents to transfer them along with their two minor daughters to Atapady Open Prison, Sangli. In support of their contentions, the petitioners have relied upon directions issued by this Court vide judgment dated 11/8/2014 in Criminal Writ Petition Nos. 481/2014, 530/2014 and 624/2014.

3) It appears that this Court in the aforesaid judgment dated 11/8/2014 had issued directions to respondent Selection Committee to consider if petitioners can be sent to Open Colony in accordance with law. In view of the said directions, respondents appear to have held a meeting on 19/9/2014 and have taken a decision that the petitioners are not entitled for the said relief. In fact, this Court vide judgment dated 11/8/2014 passed in Criminal Writ Petition Nos. 481/2014, 530/2014 and 624/2014 observed thus:

“The wife of the petitioner, namely, Sau. Kiran was released on parole and then unauthorisedly over-stayed in excess of 798 days. She, therefore, is completing about four years of actual imprisonment and, therefore, does not qualify for consideration along with her husband.”

4) In view of above directions of this Court, the Selection Committee considered the issue. It is noted that the law applicable to the petitioners is in form of Rules, namely, Maharashtra Open Colonies for Temporarily Released Prisoners Rules, 1971 and there is nothing in the Rules, which indicate that a woman prisoner when considered along with her husband prisoner for being sent to the Open Colony becomes entitled to be sent to the Open Colony merely for the fact that she happens to be wife of another prisoner.

5) We find that the above Rules were duly considered by the respondents while considering the case of petitioner Sau. Kiran Ukey. However, she was found to be not eligible on the following grounds:

(A) Sau. Kiran Ukey has undergone only imprisonment of 5 years, 3 months and 25 days. This made her ineligible under Rule 4(i)(c).

(B) Sau. Kiran Ukey had over-stayed her parole leave for 798 days and was required to be arrested and brought back to prison. This made her ineligible under Rule 4(i)(a).

(C) Women prisoners are not entitled to be transferred to Open Colonies as per Rule 4(ii)(m).

6) It is further noted that petitioner Sau. Kiran Ukey was released on parole for 30 days by order dated 23/5/2011 passed by the Divisional Commissioner, Nagpur. Thereafter, her parole was extended for 60 days. She was expected to present herself back to the prison on her own, but instead of doing so, over-stayed for 798 days and was required to be arrested and brought back to prison on 8/10/2013. For this act of unauthorized over-stay, offence punishable under Section 224 of Indian Penal Code was registered against her and she was released on bail on 15/2/2014.

7) In view of above, both the criminal writ petitions are devoid of merits and hence, they are dismissed. Rule is discharged. No order as to costs.

The fee payable to the learned Counsel appointed for petitioners in Criminal Writ Petition No. 959/2014 is quantified as rupees fifteen hundred.