- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Om Parkash Arya v. Delhi Administration And Others
Structured Summary of the Opinion — P.K. Bahri, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner (appointed as a Language Teacher at D.A.V. Higher Secondary School, Chitra Gupta Road, New Delhi) challenged an order dated December 11, 1973 that granted a selection grade to respondent No. 6. The petitioner sought quashing of that order and a writ of mandamus directing respondents to grant the selection grade to the petitioner after declaring him senior to respondent No. 6.
Key factual chronology (as stated in the opinion):
- The petitioner was appointed on July 27, 1948 as Language Teacher (initial pay scale Rs. 70-150), with subsequent pay-scale revisions recorded in the opinion up to 1970.
- Respondent No. 6 was appointed as Language Teacher on July 15, 1955 (initial pay scale Rs. 100-250), with recorded subsequent pay-scale revisions up to 1967 and uniform pay scale for both from July 1970.
- Academic qualifications noted: petitioner — F.A. Prabhakar; respondent No. 6 — M.A. (Hindi), B.A. (Hons), B.T.
- The selection grade for aided schools was introduced in 1971 and, under the quota for that school, only one selection-grade post for Language Teacher was available; selection grade was granted on the basis of seniority-cum-fitness.
Procedural disposition: The writ petition was heard and the court made the rule absolute, quashed the impugned order granting selection grade to respondent No. 6, and directed that the selection grade be granted to the petitioner effective September 5, 1971. The petitioner had retired long ago; arrears were ordered to be paid within three months and costs fixed at Rs. 1,000.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether seniority between the petitioner and respondent No. 6 should be determined by date of appointment within the same grade (inter-se seniority) or by historical differences in pay-scales.
- Whether the Delhi State Service (Seniority) Rules, 1954 (including the definition of "grade" and Rule 4(2)) are applicable to employees of aided schools such as the D.A.V. school, or whether seniority is governed by the Delhi Education Code, 1965 (and subsequently the Delhi School Education Act, 1973 and rules made thereunder).
- Whether the posts held by the petitioner and respondent No. 6 were posts of the same grade (i.e., created for work of the same nature) or different grades because of assignment to teach different classes (lower versus higher classes).
- Whether any break in continuous service by respondent No. 6 (by purportedly ceasing to be a Language Teacher and being classified as a Trained Graduate Teacher) affected his seniority as a Language Teacher.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- Both petitioner and respondent No. 6 were appointed as Language Teachers; since the petitioner was appointed earlier (27.7.1948 v. 15.7.1955), he should be treated as senior to respondent No. 6.
- Reference to the Delhi State Service (Seniority) Rules, 1954 — specifically Rule 4(2): "The inter-se seniority among members of a grade who become permanent on or after shall be fixed in accordance with the continuous length of their service in the grade." (quoted in the opinion).
- Reference to a Chief Commissioner order dated October 30, 1954 (exercise of power under Rule 5(2) of those Rules) that service in posts in the same grade (brought onto a uniform time-scale) shall count for seniority — supporting the contention that different earlier pay-scales do not change grade.
- The word "grade" should be understood as meaning the posts of Language Teacher (work of the same nature), not mere variations in pay-scales; dictionary meaning (Webster's) cited to support that view.
- Allegation that respondent No. 6 ceased to be a Language Teacher for some period (having been given pay as Trained Graduate Teacher) so there may have been a break in continuous service as Language Teacher.
Respondents' Arguments (Delhi Administration, Education Department and School)
- The Delhi State Service (Seniority) Rules, 1954 are not applicable to employees of aided schools; aided-school employees are governed by the Delhi Education Code, 1965 and (later) the Delhi School Education Act, 1973 and rules thereunder.
- Article 207 of the Delhi Education Code, 1965 provides that "Seniority shall be determined by length of continuous service rendered in a particular grade," but it also states that service in the same grade in a school not under the same management shall not be counted — respondents contend that "grade" is to be equated with pay-scale and that respondent No. 6 was appointed in a better grade/pay-scale and thus must rank senior.
- Respondent No. 2 (school) averred that the petitioner taught classes below 8th class (unqualified/untrained language teacher) while respondent No. 6 taught higher classes (qualified teacher in a higher pay-scale), implying posts of different nature and thus different grades.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Shri Brat Pal Mandal v. Lt. Governor, Delhi (Civil Writ Petition No. 608/78; Division Bench: V.S. Deshpande, C.J. & Harish Chandra, J.) | Principle: Whether posts having different pay-scales represent distinct grades depends on whether the posts were created for work of the same nature; posts created for higher classes vs lower classes can be different grades despite a common label. | The court in the present opinion distinguished this precedent on facts: in Shri Brat Pal Mandal it was proved that posts were created for different types of work (higher classes IX & X v. lower classes) and thus were different grades; in the present case there was no proof that respondent No. 6's post was created to teach higher classes or that the petitioner's post was limited to lower classes, and both were appointed as "Language Teacher." Consequently the precedent was found distinguishable and not controlling. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded through the following analytical steps (as presented in the opinion):
- Examined the respective appointment dates, pay-scale histories and qualifications of the petitioner and respondent No. 6, noting that both were appointed as "Language Teacher" though appointed in different years and at different earlier pay-scales.
- Considered the legal texts and definitions relied upon by the parties: the petitioner relied on the Delhi State Service (Seniority) Rules, 1954 (including Rule 4(2) and the Chief Commissioner's order of October 30, 1954 under Rule 5(2)), while the respondents relied on Article 207 of the Delhi Education Code, 1965 and contended that aided school employees are governed thereby rather than by the 1954 Rules.
- Addressed the meaning of "grade": the petitioner argued (and the court accepted the approach) that "grade" refers to posts created for work of the same nature and is not synonymous merely with pay-scales; the court examined the definition in Rule 2 of the 1954 Rules (a post or group of posts created for work of the same nature) and the absence of a contradictory definition in the Delhi Education Code, 1965, and applied dictionary meaning (Webster's) to support that interpretation.
- Considered respondents' factual averments that the petitioner taught lower classes and respondent No. 6 taught higher classes (and the school’s contention that respondent No. 6 had been in a better pay-scale). The court found these averments vague and not supported by documentary evidence: the appointment letter of respondent No. 6 did not specify that he was appointed only for higher classes (and the copy was not placed on record), and there was no appointment letter produced for the petitioner showing he was appointed only for lower classes. The petitioner placed on record a certificate (Directorate of Education, dated March 26, 1953) showing he was qualified to teach Hindi in higher classes.
- Distinguished the cited Division Bench decision (Shri Brat Pal Mandal) on the ground that in that case it was proved that posts were created for different class levels (and so were different grades); here there was no proof that the posts differed in nature. On those facts the court concluded both incumbents held posts in the same grade (Language Teacher).
- Having determined that the posts were in the same grade, the court applied the seniority principle (seniority by date of appointment within the grade) and held that petitioner, appointed earlier, must rank senior to respondent No. 6. The court expressly stated it need not decide the contention about any break in respondent No. 6's continuous service as Language Teacher, because petitioner succeeded on the earlier point (seniority by appointment date in same grade).
Holding and Implications
Core Holding: The writ petition is allowed; the impugned order dated December 11, 1973 granting the selection grade to respondent No. 6 is quashed, and the respondents are directed to grant the selection grade to the petitioner with effect from September 5, 1971 (in the pay-scale of Rs. 550-700).
Direct consequences ordered by the court (as recorded in the opinion):
- The selection grade granted to respondent No. 6 is quashed.
- The petitioner is directed to be granted the selection grade effective September 5, 1971 in pay-scale Rs. 550-700.
- Although the petitioner had retired long ago, the court ordered that arrears be paid within three months.
- The petitioner was awarded costs quantified at Rs. 1,000.
Broader implications: The opinion confines itself to the facts and the interpretation of "grade" in the given factual matrix and distinguishes earlier authority on its facts; the court did not purport to lay down a sweeping new precedent beyond its factual conclusion that, on the evidence, both persons held posts of the same grade and seniority followed appointment date.
Rule made absolute.
P.K Bahri, J.:— In this writ petition the petitioner has prayed for quashing of the order dated December 11, 1973, by which the selection grade has been granted to respondent No. 6 and has prayed that a writ of mandamus be issued directing the respondents to grant the said selection grade to the petitioner after declaring that the petitioner is senior to respondent No. 6.
2. The facts, in brief, are that the petitioner was appointed as Language Teacher in the D.A.V Higher Secondary School, Chitra Gupta Road, New Delhi, on July 27, 1948, in the pay scale of Rs. 70-150 which pay scale was revised to ks. 80-200 on October 1, 1950, and was again revised to Rs. 130-300 on July 7, 1969 and revised to Rs. 170-380 and then to Rs. 190-4 25 during the subsequent years till 1967, whereas admittedly respondent No. 6 was also appointed as Language Teacher in the same School on July 15, 1955, in the pay scale of Rs. 100-250 and was placed in pay scale of Rs. 120-300 with effect from March 10, 1959, being a Trained Language Teacher and his scale was revised to Rs. 170-380, on July 1, 1959 and to Rs. 190-4 25, on December 21, 1967. Afterwards with effect from July 1970, the pay scale of both the petitioner and respondent No. 6 was revised to Rs. 220-500 and initial pay of both of them was fixed at Rs. 310/- with effect from May 27, 1970, in the said pay sea.
3. The academic qualification of the petitioner is F.A Prabhakar while respondent No. 6 is M.A (Hindi), B.A (Hons) B.T The case of the petitioner, in brief, is that as he and respondent No. 6 were appointed as Language Teachers and he having been appointed earlier in time, should be treated as senior to respondent No. 6. It has been urged that mere fact that respondent No. 6 was having better pay-scale than the petitioner earlier is of no importance in as much as the grade of the posts in which both the petitioner and respondent No. 6 were, was of Language Teacher. The selection grade was introduced by the Delhi Administration in the aided schools in the year 1971. According to the quota of the post of selection grade fixed by the Delhi Administration, only one post of selection grade in the category of Language Teacher was given in this school and admittedly there were only two Language Teachers working in the said school. It is also not disputed that the selection grade is granted on the basis of seniority-cum-fitness. In the present case, it is admitted in the counter, filed on behalf of respondents 1, 4 & 5, i.e Delhi Administration and its officers in Education Department, that the selection grade has been granted to respondent No. 6 treating respondent No. 6 as senior to the petitioner. So, it is clear that the petitioner has not been superseded on merit. If it is to be held that the petitioner is senior to respondent No. 6, it is not disputed before me that then the petitioner is entitled to the grant of said selection grade in place of respondent No. 6. In the petition the petitioner has made reference to Delhi State Service (Seniority) Rules, 1954, which lay down Rule 4(2) that:
“The inter-se seniority among members of a grade who become permanent on or after shall be fixed in accordance with the continuous length of their service in the grade.”
4. He has also made reference to order issued by the Chief Commissioner of Delhi on October 30, 1954, in exercise of the power given under Rule 5(2) of the said Rules that “the entire service rendered by a Government servant in a post or posts belonging to the same grade or class of a grade in a particular group which had different rates of pay prior to the introduction of revised scales of pay on the recommendations of the Central Pay Commission but were brought on to a uniform time-scale, shall count for the purpose of seniority in the grade With which those posts have now been bracketed.” So, on the basis of these Rules the petitioner urges that he and respondent No. 6 were appointed as Language Teacher i.e in the same grade of posts. Since the petitioner was appointed earlier in time, he should rank senior to respondent No. 6 irrespective of the fact that respondent No. 6 for some years enjoyed better pay-scale than the petitioner.
5. Another point urged by the petitioner is that respondent No. 6 had ceased to be Language Teacher for some period and he was given the pay of Trained Graduate Teacher and so, he had not worked continuously as Language Teacher after the pay-scale of both the petitioner and respondent No. 6 had become uniform. Respondents 1, 4 & 5 in their counter pleaded that the Delhi State Service (Seniority) Rules, 1954, are not applicable to the employees of the aided schools like the D.A.V School in question and thus, the principles laid down in those Rules for determining inter se seniority of the employees of the aided school are not to be given any importance. It has been urged that the employees of the aided schools are governed by the Delhi Education Code, 1965, and now by the Delhi School Education Act, 1973 and the Rules framed thereunder. Reference is made to article 207 appearing in Delhi Education Code, 1965, which is to the following effect:
“Seniority shall be determined by length of continuous service rendered in a particular grade. Service rendered by an employee in the same grade in a school not under the same management shall, however, not be counted for purposes of seniority.”
6. So it has been pleaded that respondent No. 6 was appointed in a better grade i than the petitioner. Thus, respondent No. 6 has to rank senior to the petitioner. According to the respondents, the grade and the pay-scale are one and the same thing. Respondent No. 2, on behalf of the School, in a separate counteraffidavit has taken more or less similar pleas. It has been at any time. It was explained that cadre of teachers of the aided school could be changed only with the permission of the Delhi Administration which permission was never sought or given and mere fact that the scale of pay of Trained Graduate Teacher and Trained Language Teacher was same and salary of respondent No. 6 has been drawn showing him in the category of Trained Graduate Teachers would not mean that at any time the cadre of respondent No. 6 has been changed. The Delhi State Service (Seniority) Rules, 1954, are applicable only to the employees of Delhi Administration and obviously they have no applicability to the employees of the aided schools. It is clear that the employees of the aided schools are to be governed by Delhi Education Code, 1965, earlier and now by the Delhi School Education Act, 1973 and the Rules made thereunder. As the matter of grant of selection grade pertains to the year 1971, so the Delhi Education Code, 1965, is clearly applicable to the petitioner and respondent No. 6. Article. 207, already quoted above, makes it clear that seniority has to be determined by length of continuous service rendered in a particular grade. The word ‘grade’ has not been defined in the Delhi Education Code, 1965, but it has been defined in Rule 2 of Delhi State Service (Seniority) Rules, 1954, to mean a post or a group of posts created for work of the same nature in a department or office.
7. The learned counsel for the petitioner has vehemently argued that the word ‘grade is not synonymous with the pay-scales available to the posts in that particular grade. He has urged that posts of particular grade may have different and varying pay-scales yet the incumbents of those posts would be deemed to be working the same grade. Even if the definition of grade given in Rule 2 of the Delhi Delhi State Service (Seniority) Rules, 1954, is held to be not relevant yet in absence of any definition of ‘grade’ given in Delhi Education Code, 1965, the court has to resort to dictionary meaning of the word. Delhi Administration which has already framed the Delhi State Service (Seniority) Rules, 1954, before this Delhi Education Code, 1965, was brought in existence had already given a definition of ‘grade’. No different definition of ‘grade’ had been given by the Delhi Administration. So normally the same definition of ‘grade’ which appears in the Delhi State Service (Seniority) Rules, 1954, should cover the word ‘grade’ appearing in Delhi Education Code, 1965.
8. Even otherwise in Webster's Third New International Dictionary, the word ‘grade’ has been defined to mean “a position or level in a course of advancement or decline or in a scale of ranks; a class constituted by things that are at the same stage or have the same relative position, level, rank or degree”. It is admitted case that both the petitioner and respondent No. 6 were appointed to the post of Language Teacher. The word ‘grade’ would mean the posts of Language Teacher in the present case and not the different pay-scales available to the posts in the said grade. In case the seniority was to be determined on the basis of pay-scales then there was nothing which prevented the authorities to say so in clear terms in Article 207 of the Delhi Education Code, 1965.
9. Mr. S.N Kumar, Advocate, who appeared for respondents 2 & 6, has however, vehemently argued that it has been averred in the counter-affidavit of respondent No. 2 that the petitioner was appointed to teach classes below 8th. class while respondent No. 6 has been teaching higher classes above 8th class. So, he has urged that the posts to which the petitioner and respondent No. 6 were appointead were different posta and respondent No. 6 having held a better post should be deemed to be senior to the petitioner. What has been averred in the counter-affidavit of respondent No. 2 in this respect is to the following effect:
“……The petitioners was an unqualified, untrained language teacher employed in the year 1948 teaching Hindi below the 8th class ……..The higher classes were taught by qualified teachers in a higher pay-scale. Respondent No. 6 was appointed in the pay-scale starting with Rs. 100/-…………..”
10. It is significant to mention that respondent No. 2 has kept his affidavit quite vague. There is no clear averment that respondent No. 6 was appointed only for teaching higher classes. 1 was shown the appointment letter of respondent No. 6 by Mr. Kumar during the course of argument and I directed that photo copy of the same be placed on the record (but I find that the said photo copy has not been filed on the record) which shows that there is no mention in that appointment letter that respondent No. 6 had been appointed for teaching higher classes. It only shows that respondent No. 6 had been appointed as Language Teacher. No appointment lettear 1 of petitioner has been shown or brought on record to show that he was appointed to teach only lower classes; rather the petitioner has placed on record photo copy of certificate issued by Directorate of Education, Delhi State, dated March 26, 1953, which shows that the petitioner was qualified to teach Hindi in the higher classes as well. So, it is not shown positively that the petitioner was appointed as Language Teacher to each lower classes and respondent No. 6 was appointed as Language Teacher to teach higher classes. I may mention that respondent No. 6 has adopted the averments made in the counter-affidavit of respondent No. 2 and has not given any separate facts. Mr. kumar has cited a judgment decided by a Division Bench of this Court (V.S Deshpande, C.J and Harish Chandra, J.) in Civil Writ Petition No. 608/78, Shri Brat Pal Mandal v. Lt. Governor, Delhi. This judgment pertain to a case between different teachers of Government Schools. It has been proved in the said case that the petitioners in the said writ had been appointed in Grade II while respondents 3 to 71 had been appointed in Grade III. It was also found out in the said case that the petitioners, who were Trained Graduate Teachers, were appointed to the posts created for teaching classes IX & X while respondents 3 to 71 had been appointed to the posts of teacher meant to teach lower classes. The fixation of inter se seniority between the said employees was subject-matter of decision in that writ. It was held that the question which needed to be answered was whether the posts held by the petitioners and respondents were in one grade with a higher and a lower pay-scale for each set of posts or whether the posts, held by them having different pay-scales, were in two different grades'. Then, after making reference to the definition of ‘grade’ given in the Seniority Rules, 1954, it was opined that in order that posts could be treated to be in the same grade it must be proved that the posts have been created for work of the same nature as it was found in that case that posts, to which the petitioners were appointed, had been created to teach higher classes of IX & X while the posts, to which the respondents were appointed, were created for teaching lower classes, made it clear that those posts have not been created for same type of work and thus, they did not fall in the same grade and the claim of the petitioners to rank senior to the respondents was upheld. This judgment is distinguishable on facts. Here in the present case, it is not at all alleged or proved that the posts to which respondent No. 6 was appointed, had been created for teaching any higher classes. It is also not proved from any documentary evidence that the post, to which the petitioner was appointed, has been created for teaching only lower classes. Both, the petitioner and respondent No. 6, have been appointed to the posts of Language Teachear. Hence, it is not shown that the post which respondent No. 6 held and the post which the petitioner held, were for different type of work so as not to be treated in one grade.
11. So, in view of the above discussion, I hold that the petitioner and respondent No. 6 were holding posts in the same grade and petitioner was appointed earlier in time to respondent No. 6, hence, the petitioner must rank senior to respondent No. 6. The petitioner has given application (C.M 3692/87 requiring for directions to respondents to produce the record. The Delhi Administration has mentioned that it was not in possession of any summoned record. Some record was produced and shown to counsel for the petitioner on behalf of the School. However, the record of posts fixation was not brought. Counsel for the petitioner has argued that if that record had been produced, it would have shown that respondent No. 6 had changed the cadre at some point of time by becoming Trained Graduate Teacher and thus, there was a break in the continuous length of service by him as Language Teacher. 1 need not go into this question because the petitioner is to succeed on the point already decided by me above.
12. In view of the above discussion, I make the rule absolute and allow the petition and quash the impugned order granting selection grade to respondent No. 6 and direct the respondent to grant selection grade to the petitioner with effect from September 5, 1971, in the pay-scale of Rs.: 550-700. The petitioner is stated to have retired long back. His arrears be paid within three months. The petitioner shall have costs which I quantify at Rs. 1,000/-.
13. Rule made absolute.
Alert