Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mukesh Petitioner v. State Of Haryana

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Mar 6, 2009
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition challenges the judgment dated 10.3.2003 of the Additional Sessions Judge, Bhiwani, which dismissed the accused-petitioner Mukesh's appeal against the judgment dated 18/24.5.2001 of the Sub Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Loharu. The SDJM had convicted and sentenced the petitioner to rigorous imprisonment for three months under Section 279 IPC; rigorous imprisonment for six months under Section 337 IPC; and rigorous imprisonment for one year and a fine of Rs. 500/- under Section 304-A IPC.

Factual background: On 14.8.1997 at about 8:30 p.m., the complainant Shish Ram was returning in his tractor (No. HYO-3038) and observed Mahipal (son of Umed Singh) riding a scooter with a pillion passenger near Manphara T-Point. A tractor allegedly came from the opposite side rashly and negligently and hit the scooter; Mahipal died at the spot and the other occupant was taken to Bhiwani Hospital. A case was registered, investigated and a report under Section 173 Cr.P.C. was submitted.

Procedural history: The petitioner was charged under Sections 279, 337 and 304-A IPC, pleaded not guilty and contested trial. Prosecution examined witnesses PW1–PW11 (including SI/SHO Jagdish Parshad, the complainant Shish Ram, and medical witnesses). The petitioner was examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C. and denied the allegations. The trial court convicted; the petitioner's appeal failed; this petition followed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conviction recorded by the trial court (and sustained on appeal) was vitiated by any irregularity or illegality.
  2. Whether, in view of the petitioner's status as a first offender and the protracted proceedings already endured, the sentence should be modified or leniency granted.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner is a first offender and has no bad antecedents.
  • He has suffered agony due to protracted proceedings spanning from the 1997 occurrence, and has already undergone about five months of the substantive sentence.
  • A lenient view should be taken in respect of the quantum of sentence.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed the impugned judgment and found that it was based on an appreciation of the evidence in the right perspective. The court observed that no irregularity or illegality had been pointed out or detected that would result in a miscarriage of justice; accordingly, the conviction was maintained. As to sentence, the court noted the long delay since the 1997 occurrence, the petitioner's suffering from protracted proceedings, the approximately five months already undergone of the substantive sentence, and the absence of bad antecedents. On these grounds the court concluded that some leniency was appropriate and modified the sentence accordingly. The court imposed a condition that the petitioner pay Rs. 20,000 as compensation to the legal heirs of the deceased within three months, failing which the petition would stand dismissed in toto. The court directed that a copy of its judgment be sent to the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bhiwani for compliance.

Holding and Implications

Petition dismissed with modification of sentence.

Direct effects: The trial court's conviction is maintained. The sentence is modified to the period already undergone by the petitioner. The petitioner is ordered to pay Rs. 20,000 as compensation to the legal heirs of the deceased within three months; failure to do so will cause the petition to stand dismissed in toto. A copy of this judgment is to be sent to the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bhiwani for compliance.

No broader implications or new precedent were stated in the opinion.

Show all summary ...

A.N Jindal, J

Challenge in this petition is to the judgment dated 10.3.2003 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Bhiwani, dismissing the appeal filed by the accused-petitioner Mukesh (herein referred as ‘the petitioner’) against the judgment dated 18/24.5.2001 passed by the Sub Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Loharu, convicting and sentencing the petitioner to undergo rigorous imprisonment for three months under Section 279 IPC; rigorous imprisonment for six months under Section 337 IPC; and further to undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year and to pay fine of Rs. 500/- under Section 304-A IPC.

The brief resume of facts is that on 14.8.1997 at about 8.30 p.m Shish Ram complainant (herein referred as ‘the complainant’) was returning to village Pahari from Dighawa in his tractor bearing registration No. HYO-3038 and when he reached near Manphara T-Point near the field of Jai Pal, he saw Mahipal son of Umed Singh coming on scooter. One another person was sitting on the pillion seat. In the meantime one tractor came from the opposite side very rashly and negligently and hit the scooter. Both the occupants of the scooter suffered injuries. Mahipal son of Umed Singh died at the spot, whereas, the other occupant of the scooter was removed to Bhiwani Hospital. On the basis of the aforesaid statement, a case was registered and investigated. Completion of the investigation was followed by a report under Section 173 Cr.P.C

The petitioner was charged for the offence under Sections 279, 337, 304-A IPC to which he pleaded not guilty and opted to contest.

In order to substantiate the charge, the prosecution examined SI/SHO Jagdish Parshad (PW1), Dharam Pal (PW2), Bhagat Singh (PW3), Shish Ram complainant (PW4), Ombir (PW5), Tara Chand (PW6), C. Gian Singh (PW7), ASI Sajjan Singh (PW8), Dr. K.C Kajal (PW9), Dr. Satish Sangwan (PW10) and Satnarain Sharma (PW11).

When examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C he denied all the allegations and pleaded his false implication in the case.

Ultimately the trial ended in conviction. The appeal preferred by him also failed.

Arguments heard. Record perused.

At the very out set, learned counsel for the petitioner without assailing the judgment of conviction has urged that the petitioner is a first offender and has suffered agony on account of the protracted proceedings. It has been further urged that since the petitioner has already undergone about 5 months of the substantive sentence, therefore, a lenient view in the matter be taken.

Having examined the impugned judgment, it appears to have been passed on appreciation of the evidence in the right perspective. No irregularity much less illegality has been pointed out or detected resulting into miscarriage of justice. Consequently, the judgment of conviction is maintained.

As regards the quantum of sentence, it may be observed that the occurrence took place way back in the year 1997 and the petitioner has suffered a lot of agony on account of the protracted proceedings. He has already undergone about five months out of the substantive sentence. No bad antecedents have been brought on record in order to dub the petitioner as habitual offender. Consequently, I deem it a fit case where some leniency could be extended to the petitioner.

Resultantly, the instant petition is dismissed with the modification in the sentence to that of already undergone by him. However, the petitioner is directed to pay a sum of Rs. 20,000/- on account of compensation to the legal heirs of the deceased, within three months from today, failing which the instant petition shall stand dismissed in toto.

Copy of the judgment be sent to the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bhiwani for compliance.